BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE COLLYER BROTHERS
This week, James and Jimmie discuss the strange tale of two recluse brothers who hoard 150 tons of garbage in their house. Things get very weird when one is dead, and the other is missing!
Comments (100)
Man, I wish they had talked about the reference in a Midsomer Murders episode that, in a nutshell, actually used hoarding as a murder weapon.
Jimmie!!!!! I love you so much…. “It squished him, oh boy” 🤣♥️🤣
Love this as we have a antique walnut gynecologist table.. with brass stirrups as a TV stand ... 🤷♀️🙃
It’s unfortunate they didn’t know Edie and Eve Bouvier (?) Aka the relatives of Jackie Kennedy Onassiss. They never left their massive home, and lived in squalor and a filthy hoard. There’s a documentary as well as a movie about them.
Yes, Grey Gardens!! And a spoof documentary with Fred Armisten and Bill Hader - Sandy Passage (Documentary Now). Highly recommended
This is heart breaking and tear inducing.
Couldn’t wait to hear this one!
Have to admit, i can understand wanting to be left alone. Nit a fan of people.
Same!
This was amazing. More weird dives into weird people for sure!!
One of my all-time favorite episodes. Absolutely fascinating story, thanks for sharing!
What a wild episode… second time listening… great job J&J
Crazy! The two brothers where highlighted in the S6 E17 Frasier! Heard your Patreon and watched this Frasier episode on the same day 😬
My godmother's house was like that until part of the floor in her bedroom gave way. She then moved into a trailer and hoarded that as well. It took her kids almost 3 months to clean everything after she died.
I have a neighbor who's house is like this and she can't get into it. She has been living in her little car out front of the house. The car is so full of shit that she can only see out half of the front windows and the drivers door window. She has been in the car for 5 years now. People bring her food everyday.
That’s so sad!
*Loud crash near dinnertime* Homer - "Oh shit...."
This story was so crazy and unbelievable that I went on Amazon and I bought the book. I’ve got to read the book and my husband thinks I’m a hoarder not even close but when they said clean your house, I look around and I think yeah I need to clean my house, but I have a bunch of medical issues but at least I can walk in it and get around in it, I just have too much stuff to get rid of when you think of hoarders you think of the people that just have so much garbage you can’t even walk through their house and this one was crazy I need to tell my husband this story and then he might think differently of me.
You two are very good for mental health, I have some minor issues and listening to you is a breath of fresh air!
Just got my MIL's hoarding house cleaned out and I thought that was a lot (doing the math, it was about 32 to 40 tons) Crazy story! I cannot fathom it all.
Weird…
Awesome!!
I’d love to hear your take on Edith Bouvier Beale aka Grey Gardens.
Yes! They should do an episode on them.... fascinating story!
That story was fascinating! I hope you guys do some more history-type weirdness; I'm sure there's plenty of it out there 😬
John Mulaney and Nick Kroll’s “Oh Hello on Broadway” was once described as “It’s like they’re the Collyer Brothers, with no piles of newspapers, but a trap-door from “The Diary of Anne Frank.”” I know understand that reference 😂
The eye hemorrhage could have been from undiagnosed diabetes. It will weaken small vessels and can cause them to burst, including those between the retina and the back of the eye. That's diabetic retinopathy and it's not reversible. Those blood vessels bursting is why diabetics can have problems with their feet and end up losing toes or parts of their feet. It affects their sensation of pain so they won't know their foot is injured
That was my first thought
You might forget how heavy a bundle of news papers are
Paper is wood redesigned and wood is heavy🙂
Thank you for all your amazing content. I have a case recommendation from Sweden . It's a totally crazy case with a cult, religion, sex and murder. There is a 6 part mini series on HBO. It's called Knutby. Take care😀
Okay, this is kind of gross, but no one ever talked about. Where did they go to the bathroom.....?????? Aaahhhhhh !!!!!!! Loved the show ❤️
I loved this episode! As always fantastic research ! I live in NJ I had never heard of them.
Great episode
180 tons is literally a whale’s worth of junk 😭 I can’t
Finding out their family comes from Livingston…which is my last name…please tell me I am not related to these people 😖
Suddenly feel the need to clean my bedroom.
Coffee v.
I’m super upset that my last name is Steinway and Jimmie pronounced both my first and last name correctly on my call out and that these fools collected my family’s pianos and cursed the name of Steinway. JK - no direct relation. You’re WELCOME Jimmie for my easily pronounced name‼️
Loved this story. But now I have tp clean.
I'm going to start TONIGHT, what IS in the back of my closet?
Listened on way to sister’s. Told her everything! She said it sounds like a good story. I’ll try to get her on board with us here. :)
Love your historical episodes, always opens new doors to amazing stories
Wow that was a fascinating story. Very sad but so strange
How incredibly sad. I feel bad for the brothers, especially Homer. He must have been so scared, slowly dying alone.
Wow!!! What a great episode guys!! I agree with the other comment! MERCH! “Go outside so you don’t get weird”
I need merch—“Go Outside So You Don’t Get Weird.”
YEEESSS!!!
So Grey Gardens but men? Is that what I'm getting?
My son’s birthday is the same as Homer and my birthday is the same as Langley.
It’s all connected
Bellevue is still going strong today as a hospital. It is one of the oldest hospitals in the country though but it is both psychiatric hospital and normal hospital but it’s been around for donkeys years though.
there is definitely a 911 episode based off of this story
This has to be one of my favorite episodes. Never heard of these brothers, it's absolutely fascinating.
I thought the same thing!!
Thank you so much for this episode. I have been fascinated by these gentlemen for years. I really enjoyed hearing your research on them.
As Kramer once said.."I ain't going to no Bellevue". Were they crazy or was the rest of the word nuts..??
No…they were crazy.
I woke up one day when I was 26 and lost most of my vision. It's fucking crazy. My dad dumped Agent Orange and I have a very rare eye condition. I've gotten used to it but I miss driving so bad. This is def a crazy story
I need to look into that Agent Orange stuff as well I know it's a long shot for me but my grandfather did the same as your father and the amount of health issues my Aunt and Uncle have and me I swear something happened to us
I had never heard of them and Oh my goodness…. 😭
A great uncle of mine moved to Harlem in 1930. He talked about these 2 once and awhile. I moved to Harlem in 1996 and people still talked about them. Crazy shit!
An episode of SVU was loosely based on them too. Judd Hirsch and Wallace Shawn played the brothers. My husband is a firefighter, the few hoarder houses he’s been in are the most dangerous situation. Especially when they have old fireworks in the garage. 😬
There's a great book by E.L. Doctorow "Homer & Langley.
One of the best episodes ever!
I can’t believe I doubted Langley, he was there the whole time 😭 this one was wild, thanks guys!
Thank you for a very interesting and enjoyable episode. I love all the shows you do but it was nice to miss the blood and gore. Please keep up the good work. You are my favorite show. I am an 86 yo woman and wish you are my grandsons. I would like to take you on my lap, hug and do what grandmothers do. Maybe some cookies?
They lived such a weird life. My heart honestly broke when I learned about Langley.
https://maps.app.goo.gl/GQY11889kiMMWD417?g_st=ic
The first I had heard about the brothers was from Declan O'Rourke's song Langley's Requiem. As soon as you mentioned the 100 oranges I was taken back to the song and was blown away realizing it was the same brothers! The song is absolutely heartbreaking, but I absolutely recommend giving it a listen.
Me listening to this while cleaning my entryway… 😳
Was it both of them that retreated? I mean , not like anyone spoke to the brother to get his take on all of it . Maybe everyone assumed it was the two of them all the while the blind and paralyzed brother was like , “ what the fuck Langley”.
Highly recommend book Empty Mansions by Bill Dedman and Paul Clark Newell Jr. which was actually referenced in a past STM book recommendation by Sarah. While not a story about hoarding like this one, definitely a story of excess wealth and a different kind of hoarding around the same time era. Would love the guys to do a Patreon. I found it fascinating and mind boggling
wow, I've never heard of this. Bonkers! On a personal note, I lost my elderly Aunt last June. We didn't find out until August. She was a hoarder and died in her apartment and we didn't know until the neighbor called about the smell. This was a heavy episode for me for obvious reasons. Wow. Thanks for sharing! And I will definitely go out tonight so I don't get weird.
Who has the chair?!🪑
When James mentioned the Collyer brothers I knew I had heard the name before but couldn’t place it… then I was watching my fave episode of Frasier and Frasier says he and Niles are going to be the collyer brothers lol
"Oh, you are SO 'that other one'!"
Not gonna lie, this story scared the shit out of me. I’ve never heard anything about it before. Was stoned asf listening to it and it just got darker and darker. I had to pause and take a break 😂 NIGHTMARE FUEL
This is some Norman Bate's shit
I was waiting for Jimmie’s reaction to them finding Langley’s body and he didn’t disappoint!
Jimmie's horror at James divulging them finding Langley.🤣
Wow!
Another fascinating episode guys! Thank you. Note to self: Leave house and socialize (ugh).
During lockdown I was diagnosed with a rare autoimmune disorder and had to go on immunosuppressants so it was really dangerous for me to risk being exposed to COVID. I got all the vaccines and boosters but I was pretty anxious about going out. I really had to make myself leave the house and I did worry that if I didn’t get past it I would get weird. I’m happy to say that I did, although I’m still anxious in super crowded stores - even though I did get COVID, took the anti-viral and was just fine (with the worst cold I’d ever had but still). I also work at home so I do go to the gym and/or get outside every day.
Oh wow crazy stuff
The eye issues ! I’m diabetic and have been subject to shots in m eyes because of the possibility of hemorrhaging no fun but not blind so I’m take it lol
Here’s a video on the case: https://youtu.be/81jV9D8FiFA
I can only imagine the putrid smell in their house
Yo. I have animal bones as well. But it's because I find them fascinating and live in Colorado where they're easily found. Wet specimens (organic samples ranging from tiny samples or partial pieces to parts of organs to full on skeletons, fetus' or non viable samples. kept in a clean, preserving liquid and jar) are actually a trend. It's annoying when people do it for the aEsThEtIcS but won't even touch or look. They are what our younger selves would call POSERS. Genuinely sounds like these men had severe mental health illness that were not explored or even talked about. (Given the time, obviously.) There is SO MUCH to be explored about that relationship. The psychology, why Langley held onto Homer's sight coming back, the tunnels and hoarding.... I seriously am going to see if I can find more from a psychological end on this because that's devastating and ... wow. I wonder if there's some seed of this, in the Two Sentence Horror Stories episode "Crush" on Netflix.
I am sure there are many people living like this all over America, but because they might own less space or be in a rural area, they aren't as well known or never get "found out".
All over the world. Western media tends to make a spectacle of it, similar to side show freaks.
My uncle Byrd is a hoarder. He lives in Olympia WA and has a dead school bus and an airplane wing in his yard. Stacks of newspapers in the house and who knows what else. He’s a super nice guy but he did way too much acid in the 60s and he has a hard time. Glad he doesn’t have an entire brownstone to fill with garbage.
I genuinely hope your uncle is okay. But is it weird that I still want to have coffee with him?
😩 I also have to tell myself to go out so I don’t get weird. But man it’s hard 😫😫
We're all weird. Life has been flipped upside down for so many people. It is very hard. 💛🖤✨️
Love these ones can’t wait to hear it
They were mulatto. European Africans. That's why they stayed to themselves, live in Harlem and never married.
Source? Genuinely asking because this is *very* interesting, from a mental health standpoint point- obviously from a 2024 perspective.
Looking forward to this one. The story is just so..... so nuts.
Love all your shows. How do I signed up for your stupid options patreon or does it not exist yet?
