💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME! (1 of 6)
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME! (3 of 6)
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME! (4 of 6)
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME! (5 of 6)
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME! (6 of 6)
January 21, 2024

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME!

Come on down!! Another round of the Prisoner Dating Game: The All-Violent Felons Edition! 





Comments (121)

L
Latasha Campbell · August 23, 2026

Lmao. Jimmy fell right into that 5th door trap! Since when does James give the spiel and offer Jimmy the chance to switch. LISTEN to your instincts

D
Debbie Christiansen · August 11, 2026

I just KNEW it would be Wednesday.

R
Ryan Oakes · August 24, 2025

Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie

J
Jennifer Locklear · July 16, 2025

Granny GILF was only a few miles away from my town! O.o

J
Joe Weniger · June 13, 2025

Good work Jimmie 😂

J
Jack Riddle · November 8, 2024

This shit is amazing

S
Sumyr Colangelo Keating · September 11, 2024

Prisoner dating game.....way worth 5 bucks a month

B
Brian Kush Flowerchild BMX · August 20, 2024

Got some real gems this time! Bet the kids loved them at first sight

J
Jessica Hofler LOVES SMALL TOWN MURDER · August 6, 2024

Take it a step further and have him send these people messages and read the responses!

K
Kristin Schmidt · July 9, 2024

Jimmie picking all the winners this week. Hahaha

B
Brandi Huntley · June 22, 2024

HOLY SHIT!!! I knew I recognized that bitch's name!!! Bachelorette number 5 lived in the apartment building behind me!!!!!!

B
Bree Beech · June 14, 2024

I love your show! Funny guys that get me through the day when I feel like I might be the one yall talk about on small town murder, not as the victim though. 😏

A
Amy W. Rodgers · May 27, 2024

Whenever James lets out a WOO when impersonating someone trashy, it just makes my whole day better 😂

A
Amanda Hallikainen · May 24, 2024

Ppl

S
Shannon McKinley · April 2, 2024

Not gonna lie, I'm a little miffed that you don't know who Dan Brown is hahaha. He wrote The DaVinci Code. (I know, you don't care, but my autistic ass does)

T
Tom Scott · April 10, 2024

I did find that unusual too, as rubbish as his books are (IMO!) - Digital Fortress being a particular stinker

C
Céleste Robinson-Musseau · March 20, 2024

Lmao new quote ' hell is the bar'

M
Meagan Goree · March 3, 2024

Once Jimmie said he looks nice, I said oof he’s the pedo😫it’s always the ones who look harmless 😑😵‍💫

A
AJK · March 3, 2024

Just saw pics of Lauren Dean's child, the one who died. Heartbreaking.

K
Karlee Amaya · March 2, 2024

This is my favorite thing you’ve ever done. I laughed SO much!

J
Jeremy James · March 2, 2024

I ran over to patreon when I heard there was a new edition of the prisoner dating game. STILL one of my favorites. Holy shiiiiiiiiiiii* this is crazy. Thanks for the laughs fellas!

M
Mark Connor · February 13, 2024

Finally became a member of the STM/CIS Patreon family 🤘

B
Brooke cale · February 11, 2024

SNORTIN COKE AND GOIN BROKE BRAH😂😂😂😂

N
Nicola H · February 3, 2024

Jimmie's dismayed "oh Jesus Christ he looks psychotic" 😩🤣

S
Shelley · January 31, 2024

Poor Jimmie! His picker works about as well as mine does!!! 😂😂😂😂

T
Taylor Washington · January 29, 2024

Poor, poor Jimmie 😂😂😂 this was probably the worst of the felons ever!! Lmao

J
JImmy Cherco · January 29, 2024

You guys should start a new podcast and call it. Jimmy does simple math equations in his head. It would be hilarious. Seriously though I really enjoy your show and it’s funny as hell when Jimmy tries to do math in his head.

L
Laura Errera · January 29, 2024

Omg!! Wow. Home run! This episode was worth the wait PS . Poor jimmy

J
John Sardo · January 28, 2024

Best birthday present this year.

N
Nicky Bomberry · January 26, 2024

Yikes! 😳 😂

T
Tara Louise · January 25, 2024

Omfg... as a Boeing employee I almost peed myself!

B
Barking Spider · January 25, 2024

Bachelorette #3's boyfriend was killed in prison a month into his 35 yr sentence.

J
Jeff Jamerson · January 25, 2024

Does anyone else immediately Google everyone after James pulls the curtain and tells Jimmie about them? Just me?

N
Nikki Coakley · January 28, 2024

I do it while listening but try really hard not to peak ahead to find out what’s going to happen before they get to the end of the story. I don’t always succeed. 😔

K
Kendra Watson · January 25, 2024

Having the photos on here is amazing.

C
Cheyenne Gibson · January 24, 2024

Bachelorette #2 seems nice lol

A
Amanda Jay Daniels · January 24, 2024

Are there any "stupid opinions" about Dan Brown books? Those would be amazing 🤣

J
Jamie Hamma · January 24, 2024

I enjoy underground music and Dan Brown's books also but, never been to prison!

S
Sandra Shepherd · January 24, 2024

Somehow you never fail to find the WORST people on earth 😂

S
Stacie Pease (“Peez”) · January 24, 2024

Dan Brown wrote Angels & Demons and The Da Vinci Code.

J
Justine McNeil · January 25, 2024

I thought so! Thanks for saving me looking it up!

E
E. Vonne. · January 24, 2024

You guys should do a listener giveaway or something where you do this, and the "winner/s" (m/f) get to be a part of the episode. But the "winners" 🤣 read the profiles and James is the host, Jimmie still has to pick.

E
E. Vonne. · January 24, 2024

Granny Gilf Blachorette Caroline Stickley - 74 Year old woman who murdered her ex husband? 19 year age difference. WHAT DID HE DO TO HER?! She wouldn't do that out of the blue. Also - Door #5 Lauren Dean. Why in the hell is she not acknowledged as much for murdering her special needs baby? Or does down and dirty include murdering anyone, including children you're ashamed of? Casey Anthony is absolutely trash - so is this woman. What the actual FUCK -literally listening to this and saying to myself "Okay Texas Casey Anthony" Sucks that it's only white families that get this media attention though.

E
Eunice Sullivan · January 28, 2024

What do you mean only white families get media attention for this??

D
Denali Hyatt · January 24, 2024

I wish you guys knew who Dan Brown is so I could hear you roast him 😹

M
Michelle Rimmer · January 23, 2024

The Prisoner Dating Games are the Best!!! I would listen to this as a podcast weekly for sure.

S
Samantha Parker · January 23, 2024

I'd just like to say I live in the area and I am NOT related to William Hall, I checked with all available family members and no one has ever heard of him and there are no Williams in my family THANK GOD.

T
The fonzanoon · January 23, 2024

Dan brown is the da'vinci codeguy

N
Noah Yates · January 23, 2024

Jimmie should know by now if there are no pedos in the initial lineup, STAY AWAY FROM THE REPLACEMENT!! 🤣🤣

B
Bex · January 26, 2024

Also, when they sound like "his kind of guy"

N
Nia · January 23, 2024

The lady with the side swoop bang and 80s wrist watch look like she don’t fuck around she will stab you as you sleep

K
Kathleen Edinger · January 23, 2024

dan Brown wrote The DaVinci Code

J
Josie Penning · January 25, 2024

I don't know why I keep listening to the prisoner dating game eps when I'm swimming laps. This is the second time I nearly goddam drowned cos laughing and swimming are bad. I guess like Jimmie and his gambling on the replacement when there's no pedos already, there are some lessons I can't learn 😂

M
Megan Giselle · January 23, 2024

Dan Brown writes mystery books for repressed preteen boys 😂

H
Highland Abe · January 22, 2024

I reckon you should do an episode on Nicholas Rossi. He faked his own death (murdered himself) fled from the US to Scotland, caught COVID, was treated in hospital then claimed nurses gave him tattoos and fingerprints to match the criminal!! Bonkers!!!

E
E. Vonne. · January 24, 2024

I heard about this recently, and I only remember it because of "Rossi" - That shits nuts

D
Dishin Up Clix · January 22, 2024

Jesus Christ she took off on a thirsty Thursday and killed her kid. Wow

J
Jen Matthews · January 22, 2024

Lmao…. Dan brown…. The Davinci Code 😂

M
Matthew Eagle · January 22, 2024

My murder birds hoodie came in the mail today! I’m very pleased with my purchase! Keep up the awesome work guys!

P
Pierce De Courcy · January 22, 2024

poor impulse control has less than optimal outcomes!

M
Manj Sangha · January 22, 2024

The Prisoner Dating Game is easily the most creative, and the greatest, bit of entertainment in the last 15-20 years. God bless these two geniuses 👌🏽🔥

B
Bethany Schmitz · January 22, 2024

Ahhhhhh 😂

K
Kathie Jackson · January 22, 2024

This the real Love After Lockup...Jimmie Edition 🤣🤣 thanks for another great show guys!!

K
Krystal Hope · January 22, 2024

Well done Jimmie! They might be the best choices you’ve ever made. 😂 Dan Brown wrote The Da Vinci Code. Basic books for basic bitches.

E
E. Vonne. · January 24, 2024

Agree with all the comments on roasting Dan Brown

B
Brandon Burkhart · January 22, 2024

😞

M
Malisa T · January 22, 2024

How do I get ahold of Brandon?!!! 😁😁😁

R
Robin Marie · January 22, 2024

Now I will definitely watch this ❤️

E
Evan GrassL · January 22, 2024

Thanks for the pictures

D
Dorothy B · January 22, 2024

I love when the contestants describe themselves as ‘spontaneous.’ I imagine spontaneity is not uncommon among violent felons. 🤷🏻‍♀️

A
Ashley W. · January 21, 2024

You guys make weekend chores so much better 🤣 And Dan Brown fucking sucks.

J
Jeff Holden · January 21, 2024

Just do more of these guys, please. They're just the absolute best.

M
Melissa Tenorio · January 21, 2024

I love these so much!!!!

F
Flashburn73 · January 21, 2024

Dan Brown wrote the DaVinci Code and other related books. Dude is probably a conspiracy nut😂😂

P
PurplePlissken · January 21, 2024

And they're all trash lol

K
Kaven Kruger · January 21, 2024

Love it! 😄 🤣

J
Jartist extraordinary · January 21, 2024

“Well, those skulls on her chest make a little more sense now…” ribs hurt now

M
Mitzi · January 21, 2024

Love the pictures

B
Brandy Green · January 21, 2024

I was seriously just getting ready to write and ask when the next one was going to happen. I love this game. Jimmie can't win lol

J
Jayfield · January 21, 2024

Every time!!!!!

H
Hot Dog Racing YouTube · January 21, 2024

I wish they posted pictures of them. I would love to see what Jimmie sees after picking them

S
SHUT UP AND GIVE ME BONUS! · January 21, 2024

They’re attached to the post now

C
Cam 🛸 · January 21, 2024

Speaking of prisoners dating - Lifetime has just launched a new series called Prison Brides. It’s basically like 90 Day and Love after Lockup meshed together. Would love if y’all did an episode on it!

R
Raymond Smith · January 21, 2024

The wrestling promo is a line from Sputnik Monroe. “235 pounds of twisted steel and sex appeal” he would be a fun patreon

C
Charles Jewell · January 21, 2024

4 minutes in and I am rolling…..

O
OMAR GOBBY · January 21, 2024

I was in sync with Jimmie's picks!

B
Brenda · January 21, 2024

Prisoner Dating Game, I missed you so. Great way to start the new year.

A
Anne · January 21, 2024

Hell is the bar!

H
HJC · January 21, 2024

Oh I am so excited to see this on my feed this morning. My absolute favorite bonus episodes!

R
Rosemarie Cawkwell · January 21, 2024

Be grateful you have no idea who Dan Brown is. There are uses for his 'literature', but none of those uses involve actually reading the words.

R
Rosemarie Cawkwell · January 21, 2024

At first, listening to the details of woman #5 I thought it was going to be one of those ableist 'mercy' killings that happen to disabled kids. That would have been terrible, because you just know people would have been making excuses about 'how hard parenting disabled children' is. But finding out she was out drinking and left a five year old to look after a very disabled child and a baby was flabbergasting! What sort of a parent even considers that a reasonable thing to do? The world confuses me.

O
Olivia Peterson · January 21, 2024

James, you are amazing at picking these. 😂😂😅

O
Olivia Peterson · January 21, 2024

When Jimmie says “what’d ya do, *name*?” while giggling under his breath before James goes into the contestant’s background brings me way too much joy. I need merch. 😂

M
Milita DeMorrow (kwiklip) · January 21, 2024

FYI: Dan Brown - - The DaVinci Code. 😊

R
Rebecca Harrelson · January 21, 2024

Omgahhhhhhh this episode had me laughing and smiling the entire way through- you guys are hilarious

J
Jason S Liptow · January 21, 2024

Floyd Dennis was on the school board in my town when he was killed by One. It was a rather sad situation.

T
Travis · January 21, 2024

Dan Brown wrote the Da Vinci Code. So glad I don't enjoy his books. He's been writing for at least 25-30 years.

S
Stephanie Musil · January 21, 2024

Well door number 5 makes me ashamed of being a Cowboys fan 😂

S
Stormy Rae · January 21, 2024

The bar is hell hahaha great episode

K
Karri Gunnerson · January 21, 2024

The best episodes!!

M
Molotov_Mocktail · January 21, 2024

Low-key jealous that the guys have no idea who Dan Brown is 😅

C
Claire Aitch · January 21, 2024

Yay my favourite patreon dating game

K
Kerrie Ann OCONNOR · January 21, 2024

We have our share of loony criminals here! How about an Aussie edition?

E
Erin Grumbach · January 21, 2024

“Children are a gift from god so I don’t mind that” led me to shriek laugh in my apartment. I may have sounded (to my own ears) like a terrified woman who used her last breath to holler and was then prevented from screaming again due to severe pressure on her neck and vocal chords and this expiring. Anyway, I just heard my neighbours come out of their apartment across the hall, and I think they paused several seconds longer than they would have if they didn’t hear my now very self conscious shriek laugh. So…. I’m just gonna finish the episode so I can find out which dude Jimmie chooses from a cesspool of options. 😂😂

A
Amy Easton · January 21, 2024

I'm having back surgery next week and use a 4-prong came right now. 🤣

B
Barbara Jordan · January 21, 2024

Now I’m looking at sites that have these “profiles” on them, and this is the MOST entertainment I have had in a long time 😂😂😂 some of these are wild.

R
Ryan Andrews · January 21, 2024

I wish you guys did this as a video for Patreon. Seeing the fine ladies and gents for Jimmie would be great

f
folderol · January 21, 2024

James you really found the absolute scum of the earth for this one. Fucking wild. That being said, I enjoyed it! Prisoner dating game is the best.

T
TiannaGabanna · January 21, 2024

Kinda wish James would give him a “safe” choice with a non-violent/non-sexual criminal lol it might make it funnier if Jimmie chooses the not-as-bad person and then switches to no. 5 😅🤣🤣

A
Ananda S Keator · January 21, 2024

That would defeat the "all violent felons" edition

B
Barbara Jordan · January 21, 2024

Just what I needed on a COLD Saturday night in South Carolina, comfy blankets, wine, and this podcast ❤️

J
John Glancey · January 21, 2024

You guys are big enough to do the major cities...I'll sit in the floor no one cares about the venue guys.... go where people can see you... you aren't even going to the to cities.

K
Kelli A Thirsk · January 21, 2024

Yay! It's shitty weather today here in Fort Bragg, CA☔️ This is just what I needed along with a glass of red wine 🙌

J
John Glancey · January 21, 2024

Lol try being in jersey

S
Selfisticated · January 21, 2024

Awwwww. Here we go now. 🙌🙌🙌🙌

J
Jenna Zanti · January 21, 2024

Yay!!! Best early birthday present 😎

M
Michael Clark · January 21, 2024

YAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYY!!!!

N
Nugs_not_Drugs · January 21, 2024

Certified banger already

G
Goopy Goop · January 21, 2024

Yaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

M
Michael Baumunk · January 21, 2024

Yay indeed, Goopy

A
Ashli Ferguson · January 21, 2024

My favorite 😍