💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - AMY FISHER (1 of 2)
October 15, 2023

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - AMY FISHER

This week, James and Jimmie discuss Amy Fisher... the Long Island Lolita. 


Comments (69)

B
Best Little Cat House in Wyobraska · August 16, 2025

God, I remember all of this trainwreck. Jimmie and I have been saying the same things about it!

A
Andy Blazak · May 4, 2025

Triangle comin atcha!!! https://youtu.be/xMWrZdYoIOA?si=gDgJ7_uiIbTGA0WV

P
Penny · April 3, 2025

Watched the movie with Jack Scalia. Him pushing out his stomach was hilarious. The real Joey was a gross slob, that probably cheated all the time. Amy is no better, but she was so stupid.

C
Caroline Bennett · February 26, 2025

The daughter Jessie was Shane Dawson’s podcast cohost long long ago and would talk about what happened occasionally

S
Stephen Tot · September 15, 2024

Was this the first version of the bachelorette?

S
Stephanie Sage · August 22, 2024

James, " ah well she talks weird now" Hahaha aww fuck! Terrible 🤣

B
Bree Beech · June 18, 2024

Yall need to do your stupid opinion on Tik tok comments 😂

S
Stephen Tot · September 15, 2024

Or just Tik Tok in general, the sheer stupidity on that social media platform

K
Karen Maguire · June 16, 2024

Amy is just a disgusting bowl of trash. She went from teen slut to slut for cash.

J
John Cocktosen · May 15, 2024

She's fucked but hot

E
Erik Molnar · May 8, 2024

"Amy, I got the herpes". I remember going back to Long Island in the 90s and going to a party with big ass Italian guys wearing those pants and one was talking about topics such as, How big his stereo was, and banging chick's against the wall at Jones or Ceder Beach.

E
Erik Molnar · May 8, 2024

My family lived down the street from Massapequa in Amityville before my parents and I moved to Texas. My brother stayed in NY and was on a boat race team. He knew the Gym owner or at least my mom said he knew the gym owner when that was on a current affair or they were showing those movies on the networks

P
Philup Yourcrevasse · February 2, 2024

I didn't really know much about this. I just found out she shot her. What ended up being my anniversary 9 years later.

N
Nicola H · December 25, 2023

The Jack Nicholson sidebar 🤣

A
Anna Thompson · November 16, 2023

I’m so glad you guys are touring again! I was at your show in Minnesota this summer, but I ended up feeling so sick I had to leave. ): I even made a murder turkey shirt with my handprint and hair dye because I’m a hairstylist and that’s all I had to work with 🤣 for sure catching the show next time!

L
LauraSue · November 8, 2023

You guys are killing me! The description of the movies & Joey sniffing coke…best thing ever. Holy shit. I can’t take it - I’m crying. I’m at work & I’m starting to get looks. Have mercy on me plz.

W
Wryslok · November 8, 2023

God Jesus the bonus episodes are so fucking amazing.

T
Tom Girl · November 6, 2023

I remember Jo Anne calling into Howard Stern all the time.

M
Melanie Meline · November 5, 2023

Gobble gobble 🦃

H
Heather Holman · November 1, 2023

Jimmie's wheeze sends me, but his OH MY GOD just gives me life. 💜

H
Heather Holman · November 1, 2023

Til: the button I usually use to go back 15 seconds in my car starts the whole episode over in the Patreon app!! Gaaahgh

D
Dezirae Fisher · October 30, 2023

My moms name is Amy Fisher and she is asked about this Amy all of the time

G
Grindstone Donkey Jr · October 28, 2023

Joey Buttafuoco ovah here

S
Shawn McClearn · October 25, 2023

You said he gave you the herpes!

J
Jonathan West · October 22, 2023

Gobble gobble

T
Travis · October 22, 2023

Where all my turkeys? Not the geese, just the turkeys!

K
Kent Hollingworth · October 21, 2023

See

T
The socialworker and the bat · October 21, 2023

The key to every episode is the obligatory Goodfellas, snatch, and tombstone references. Well done gentlemen. Well done

L
Laura · October 25, 2023

Don’t forget The Sopranos 😂😂

R
Rebecca Dawson · October 20, 2023

"...in the history of Mother Geese." Bwahahahahah

K
Kris with a K · October 22, 2023

I can only ever hear the maniacal laughter in James voice.

J
Jerk face gremlin · October 20, 2023

The current affair sound would wake me up out of a dead sleep lol

N
Neil Price · October 20, 2023

Just had the bus stare at me for laughing like a madman hahahaha

M
Matt Stapleton · October 21, 2023

I walk around at work with an earbud in and laugh like a lunatic at this. People avoid me.

M
Marc Trudeau · October 19, 2023

Steven….. don’t put that on weed. Hahaha

J
Joe · October 19, 2023

Nothing to do with this episode but I stayed in west Wendover at the truck stop. I found myself eating a hamburger in a Mexican themed restaurant. No they didn't serve Mexican food lol lost $100 in 10 minutes on a slot machine 2/10 don't recommend

G
Giallo Biafra · October 18, 2023

Anytime I hear Joey’s name I think of the In Living Color sketch where Jim Carrey played him. Joey Buttafuoco over here!” https://youtu.be/JW6NbI6dSx0?si=ZEMi1nIq-x2vJybR

L
Lauren Boyette · October 18, 2023

Did y'all ever do a bonus episode about Free Britney? Because I need all the commentary on this, I was dying laughing

R
Rosemarie Cawkwell · October 17, 2023

'You're Wrong About' podcast did an episode about Amy Fisher in 2018. I only listened to it last week, so there must be something in the ether. Amy was abused by her parents then taken advantage of and manipulated by Buttefuco. It's sickening that he never received any punishment for his abuse of a minor as well as soliciting her.

t
tarmac492 · October 17, 2023

I remember this well. I grew up in Massapequa and still live on Long Island. Put Pequa on the map until we were able to claim the Gilgo Beach killer.

N
Nancy Piccoli Pirozzi · October 18, 2023

I am from Massapequa too.

O
Olivia Fisher · October 17, 2023

Yes, people are off the Timberlake bandwagon. He and Biel are also anti-vaxx and she’s one of those celebrities that promotes the whole “vaccines causes autism” spiel. Then the Britney stuff came out…he’s just greasy. He’s an accommodator and a half.

K
Kaitlyn Fontaine · October 16, 2023

You should consider covering the Karen Read and John O’Keefe Canton MA Coverup case! It’s still on going but I think you guys would have a field day with that one..

T
Tom Girl · November 6, 2023

Follow "Turtleboy" on Twitter. He's a reporter that is getting felony charges for covering the case. He did a great interview with Rekieta Law (on Rumble, not YouTube) the last week that goes over all the court documents.

J
Joe the Cynic · October 16, 2023

I remember Stern playing the audio of Amy and Lou’s sex tape and being disgusted. Didn’t stop me from later watching it

D
Deadhead-Dan10 · October 16, 2023

OMG, I immediately thought back to the Stern Show and hilarious / disgusting/ disturbing Amy-Lou Porn clips. Then they go on Howard’s show and like an idiot she stormed off after literally like 3 minutes…Jimmy just made it that much better

J
Jessica McConville · October 16, 2023

Good times, good times.

R
Rebecca Flowers · October 15, 2023

I haven’t heard about these 2 jokers in years. I’m curious to find out what Joey is up to now.

C
Cosmo's ma · October 15, 2023

Another great job guys! Maybe you can do a bonus about the new Hulu special on Macaney Manor. Extreme haunted house / torture reality, ran questionable legally by a psychopath. Would LOVE your thoughts on this douche bag.

N
Natalie Stokes · October 17, 2023

we just watched this last night and i posted about it on fb. my friend replied about it and the last part of my response was "I need the Jimmies to do a patreon on this jagoff" LOL

A
Amber Wright · October 15, 2023

Joey and his fucking curly mullet.

K
Kris Maslonka · October 15, 2023

Apparently, per the Wikiverse, A Current Affair's "signature "ka-chung" sound effect was created using a combination of the sound of a construction paper cutter and the swing of a golf club put through a synthesizer." 😂😂😂😂

D
Dr Phil Goode 👹🌲🔥 · October 15, 2023

This story takes me back

R
Rosie Goldstein · October 15, 2023

In The Adam’s Family Values Pugsly is looking through his Female Murderers trading cards with a friend he picks up Amy Fisher😂

N
Natey Bag o Donuts · October 15, 2023

I love zoobaz they are great.

M
Maito King · October 15, 2023

Why am I getting Guido Jerry Lawler images, a guy who thinks he hot shit with predictions to young girls

A
Alycia RN 79 · October 15, 2023

@Katie C. It’s been much easier for Karla H a.k.a. Barbie Killer because she was granted a new identity and a completely clean legal slate from the Canadian government… Fantastic episode as always, but you can’t even compare Karla & Amy. Two totally different psychopathy’s, two completely different motives, just all together very different women; but still as equally fascinating as a 10 car pile up on the side of the road.

E
Evan Pasco · October 15, 2023

Zubaz...lol ridiculous.

S
Stevie Barr · October 15, 2023

"I give you 10% FOR THIS?!!"

T
TiannaGabanna · October 15, 2023

I truly enjoyed the Justin Timberlake tangent 🤣

G
Giallo Biafra · October 18, 2023

Timberlake Tangent would be a great band name.

J
Justine McNeil · October 15, 2023

Was it Patrick Duffy that played him in the one with Alyssa Milano? That is who I always picture when I hear his name 🤣

B
Brenda · October 15, 2023

Thanks for this one. 😂

R
Raymond Smith · October 15, 2023

Celebrity rehab did have a sex addiction version. Rodman was on it.

K
Katie Campbell · October 15, 2023

If Carla Humulka can get a day job, so can Amy Fisher 🤦

M
Melissa Crawford · October 15, 2023

Buttafookoh.

P
Patrick Kadian · October 15, 2023

This case always makes me think of Howard Stern.

N
Ned McDermott · October 15, 2023

I used to deliver car parts for a dealership in the valley, and while I was waiting at a body shop, I noticed all these photos on the wall of Joey with all these celebrities. Turns out it was his shop. I think punch drunk love was filmed a couple doors down. Sahara fart facts for ya.

.
. · October 15, 2023

Thank you guys, keep up the work, you're appreciated!