BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - CASEY ANTHONY
This week, James and Jimmie discuss Casey Anthony.
Comments (151)
I love this show but listening to this twats story gave me a headache
It's so frustrating because the jurors thought that there wasn't enough evidence or reason for Casey to kill her own daughter? Like her partying is part of a bigger issue of being selfish and self centered. Nobody else could have killed this kid and she would cover for them? She absolutely would have milked sympathy for the death if she could, shit she does it now. There's no way she should have been not guilty 😩😩
There's no way I could in good conscience vote not guilty on this case. I understand that some are saying this didn't qualify for 1st Degree but even then NOT GUILTY? This woman could never be tried again on this charge? It would have been a mistrial at the very least because I would be so uncomfortable about this kid never getting proper justice.
James, your coverage of this case was SO GOOD
Jose Baez also defended Aaron Hernandez.
Casey was the "butter face" of the gang.
I don’t know anything about this case- was she convicted?
No she wasn’t. It was awful.
Doesn't xany the nanny mean xanex?
That’s what I thought too
I lived in Orlando during that time and knew friends of hers, she is guilty as fuck.
How's that search for the real killer going Casey??? Oh, that's right, you're busy on Tiktok being an "investigator". She couldn't investigate what time it is. Waste of oxygen.
just did a relisten to this ep and went over to the behavior panel episode (i must stress that I haven't seen the documentary) but it is CRAZY that doc came out seemingly so pro-casey when she had no creative control
Casey killed her. She 1000% didn't want Caylee and wanted that party lifestyle. If you don't want kids, there are ways to make sure that doesn't happen. Screw that bitch. There's a special level of Hell for her
“If she told me the sun would rise tomorrow, I would anticipate darkness” lmaooo someone get it tattooed 😂
Might do that! Good idea.
And now she has a tik tok acct claiming to be an investigator and 60k ppl are following her already. What a disgrace.
I listened to this episode last night and was absolutely gobsmacked. Watching the doco now and I want to smash the screen. Unbelievable. What an awful, awful woman.
It is wild to think she's just living her best life and that poor child's life was cut short due to a drugged out Liar Mommy
I want a Patreon episode of James just ranting about stupid people and topics that piss him off.
Casey Anthony is a fucking monster. She killed that baby.
She 100% did it. She is disgusting
I loves loves loves youse guys!
When James screams away from the microphone, it makes me laugh so hard. You guys rock.
Fuck that cunt. She did it. I'm not gonna say allegedly, she MFn did it!!!!
Thanks James for breaking this down and making it make sense for me. Love your attention to the details!!
Couldn’t agree with you more
She is guilty. You are not wrong
Very funny but unfortunate episode also Jimmie get off the chew
Aaa—aaaaaaaAAaaaaa—-_————_——————-_—_a——————a_a—_————-_____—aaAaAaA———__aaa-aaAaAa-_—___—————————-____—aaaaaaaaaa——————————a——-
Twat alert: I’m watching a new special on A&E right now where her parents do a polygraph! Probably going to end up being trash TV BUT my one question is … why have they been so quiet? If I was a grandparent who had my granddaughter brutally murdered, I would be speaking up and advocating to find the actual perpetrator, it wouldn’t be something I could just let go. They invest this time to clear their name but invest 0 to find and charge the killer of their granddaughter
Sad to say she is from my area in Florida
Incredible broadcast, thanks for putting in the work!
I haven't seen the documentary, refuse to watch. This nasty bitch is guilty af! Walking around with the liabetes. Ugh.
I was never ever tempted to watch the Peacock documentary on Casey Anthony.
She should have to be sterilized! This bitch cares for nothing or anyone but herself. She is a twisted gutter slut who deserve to get punched in the box daily!
What a twat waffle!
Agreed!! She’s a piece of shit and killed that baby! I felt it then and feel it just as strongly now! I cannot imagine how people see all of this evidence and say she’s innocent. Craziest thing ever!! I’d believe cigarettes are healthy before I believed ANYTHING that came out of her mouth!! I live in GA but close to FL and they were checking our landfills for that baby.
I totally agree with this! Great job guys! See you in Dallas!!
I was just able to get Patreon back and I didn't realize how many people haven't heard this story. To be fair, I'm from FL and lived there at the time of the crime, but I'm really grateful I didn't have to hear the whole story again before a good Casey bashing. She is a literal piece of shit. There's a ton of media options that tell the story matter of fact, and I appreciate this take.
Thank you for saying the out loud part
Your opinions are why I listen to the bonus episodes. Otherwise it's just dateline.
I like y'all's opinion don't listen to her ^^^ shove it down my throat
Don't get me wrong guys, I love your show but I cannot stand when you guys start a show with your opinion. Tell the story then your opinion. I knew nothing of this case , can you tell me what happened before jamming your opinion down my throat
I just listened to this, and while I understand where you're coming from (you'd like the chance to form your own perspective on the case and whether she's guilty or not?) James and Jimmie have made it clear that STM & CIS are both opinion shows; James does exhaustive research and to the best of his ability he provides accurate information, but first and foremost their podcasts are not meant to be considered 'journalism'. Getting their perspectives on different cases is why most of us listen. Sometimes, James will discuss the story as he researched it and then he and Jimmie will talk about their impressions. Other times, like with Kai the Hatchet-Wielder, James will share his opinion before he dives into the case. It's just how they do it and I doubt they'll change what's made them so popular anytime soon. Still and all, your point is valid. 🌟
To say I hate this pos is an understatement.
I must admit, she almost had me feeling bad for her. As a victim of sexual crimes more than once, she said all the things she knew would gain her the most sympathy. She is a manipulative POS!!
Idk this case is interesting to me my uncle was an FBI agent on the case, he’s on some of the YouTube videos of the interviews and I just can’t understand it
It’s taken me 3 different days to watch the first episode and 20 minutes of the second. She is so full of shit!!!!! Convenient that she remembers all of the “Sexual abuse” while lying awake in her jail cell wondering how she can explain all of her lies. How can Peacock air this bs. To the best of my knowledge, it has never been proven that her Dad or brother ever did it. They should have declared it a mistrial since her snake lawyer made those allegations in he’s opening statement and never brought it up again.
What is the best book on the Casey Anthony case?
I REFUSE to watch the doc she put out because I know it'll make me SO MAD. She's so full of shit
They only charged her with 1st degree. If they'd have had lesser charges She would have been found guilty. She definitely caused her daughters death.
Listened twice. SO GOOD!
I sat on the grand jury in Orlando (not for this case) and actually sat in what they called the "Casey Anthony Room", makes me sad. Also...in FL they told us the motive is a moot point. They don't need to understand a motive to determine if the person is guilty or not.
Why the name...? I mean besides the obvious..
I remember this case. I followed it as it was developing and literally lost my shit when they found her not guilty. Though i hadnt thought about kaylee about to be old enough to start talking, thats a great point. But i knew enough girls just like casey and they were selfish assholes who love to party and didnt want any responsibilities. Also , me being a florida resident, i found it sick that there were men outside the court room with signs about wanting to date her. God this just made me relive that period of frustration in my life of following the case. I hope shes a miserable cunt the rest of her life with all these lies. Great job guys! Im glad you tore her a new one cause man, what a cunt!
I agree to aLL of this. I sobbed so much.
I was going to rewatch the 2017 doc on Casey Anthony and I couldn't because the photo of that poor child made me want to vomit thinking of her being chloroformed and thrown in a ditch
I’m trying to watch this bullshit documentary… I’m so angry. She’s such a horrible liar.
She is SO guilty I and sorry JP had to watch the peacock documentary. I couldn’t and wouldn’t. She is full of crap and will go right to hell! I also feel bad for her parents, they will never be the same
She works out at the same gym as my husband in West Palm Beach, FL. My jaw DROPPED when I saw her and had to prove to my husband it was her 😂
I cannot believe there are people that believe her bs.
James and Jimmy: my new moral compass
I used to run our of gas, in 1977, when I was 17 and spent my extra money on weed!
General comment about the podcast as a whole here...you guys are outstanding. I'm a listener of a lot of true crime (I refuse to be a mark), and I always wonder what it is that makes some podcasts great and others just blah. I think in STM, the extra effort in giving us background about the towns pays off in spades. I also think that you both just work really well together. Neither of you seem to have an egotistical bone in your body and you never try to one up each other. I paid for the patreon membership, but the truth is I usually only listen to the shows on Spotify, I just really wanted to support the show. I will say I was a bit offended that there wasn't a repeat live show in Milwaukee -last year's was phenomenal and I was kind of proud that we Wisconsinites showed up like we did, but I'm over it. Hopefully you'll be back next year, and until then...SHUT UP AAAAND GIVE ME MURDER!
I've always described them as a Comedy central version of Dateline
😡🩲
I named my Daughter Juliette because I am in love with Juliette Lewis. I died when she tossed her name out there.
I hope people deactivate and unfollow Peacock shows for giving her airtime. Ridiculous.
I considered subscribing and won't now that I've heard they have this. Ridiculous!
Listening to how she could just so easily lie and keep it up even walking around like she worked somewhere got me. We took in an older niece to try and help her out a couple years ago and it was like they are the same person. Made my stomach flip. I made my husband listen to it because I was like, whoa! Definitely dodged a bullet getting her out of my house and away from my kids!
This little soul was failed in every way. ☹
I was too young to understand what was happening during this. Coming back now, I understand why my family was so furious about it.
People are crazy.
Tried to watch the Peacock documentary & I had the same reaction as James. Had to stop since I'm at my office yelling profanities at the damn TV. Fucking liar!!
Totally agree... this c
"This fucking twat." = perfection
A little synopsis to start off and launch the rants from would have been helpful. I didn't even live in the US when this happened and essentially had no idea half of the shit you guys were yelling about and had to bail about ten minutes in. First time ever.
Check out @StephanieHarlowe she covers this crazy well.
I absolutely live for James getting this mad, and I can't think of a more deserving cunt.
Hearing anything about Casey Anthony turns my face red with anger immediately. One of the many things that is a slap in the face to Caylee is the tattoo Casey got while her child was missing. I live in Florida and I always hope I run into her so I can spit on her and out who she is to anyone around. Anything to make her uncomfortable...but I'm not sure if monsters are capable of feeling anything but greed. Rest easy, Caylee. It's possible your unfortunate death saved you from worse things.
She’s so psychotic she’d probably just appreciate the attention, however it comes her way!!
Such a great episode covering this! It was bonkers watching the trial and now seeing she hasn’t learned anything and is still lying. Such a piece of shit!
Ugh I wish we never have to talk about the Menendez fucks again
I don't believe for a second her dad and brother molested her. I hope her dad and/or brother sues the shit out of her for defamation. How do you know when Casey Anthony is lying? When she opens her mouth and words come out.
I found Marcia Clark Investigates The First 48: Death of Caylee Anthony informative.
Yes! That series is so good. :) When she interviewed one of the jurors and they said, "We just couldn't think of a motive for it," I wanted to launch myself through the screen and choke her. There were *so many* motives.
Lol Tom Manly like “George, George Glass” from the Brady Bunch movie 🤦🏼♀️
I need James to look up Tim Miller and Texas Equisearch...his daughter was a victim in the Texas Killing Fields
When this happened, I was a 23 yo single mom w/ a beautiful big brown eyed little girl as well who was a month younger. When I saw Kaylee, I saw my own daughter. I was young and wanted to party too, but I didn't because duh...I'm a mom now. I followed this so closely because I kept out hope she was alive. I knew Casey did it. But I just couldn't comprehend it when I looked over at my own daughter. Im surprised there isn't more documentation of people trying to hurt and harass this women. If I ever step foot on Florida soil again, and see her, I'll need bail money peeps.
I cant watch the doc because I will become hoarse screaming at the TV
Sorry I meant Jimmie 😑
Yes, James and Jimmy call this person out!
Fuuuuck she’s such a cunt 😆
Fuck that bitch. I hope she gets what she deserves
Best bonus episode yet!!!! Fuck that bitch
Couldn't watch the documentary. Probably the first one they've covered I didn't watch a doc before listening. She's so bad.
Omg I hope this bitch gets to hear this!!! And gets every shitty thing she deserves to happen to her...I'm from FL and this jury should be ashamed!!!
I refused to watch this documentary because I didn’t want to have to look at her face 😂, so I appreciate this recap.
In a hypothetical Prison dating game, would Jimmie take his chances with Casey Anthony or Jodi Arias?
I can’t watch the documentary either- I wanna jump through the screen and just ughhhhhhhhhh 🤬
I listened to Imperfect Justice by Jeff Ashton. He went over the legal handcuffs they had on while prosecuting and it was pretty interesting. Just a gross miscarriage of justice all around. Casey is a remorseless liar. She's probably lied so consistently about it that she believes her lies at this point though. There's no reason for anyone but Casey to have killed Caylee. No real evidence of kidnap by a stranger or sexual abuse by George. You can be a kind of weird guy and not abuse children, they aren't mutually exclusive. I mean Jesus he was a cop, of course he's a little weird. That part of Casey's "documentary" really pissed me off, just laying all the blame on the people who actually tried to find Caylee. We aren't talking about the Ramseys ffs. I also feel like Casey is the kind of person who's desperate to be a victim of something, so lying about abuse would track! And as always you guys put together a great, detail oriented timeline! I know there's a bunch of cases we've all talked to death, but these are my favorite kind of patreon episodes. You guys just put it together better than other people do!
This case happened before I really got into true crime, but I remember when she was declared innocent it's all anyone in my family would talk about because they were so pissed she managed to get off.
I lived in Orlando at the time, working at the JW Marriott, and the lobby bar had the TVs on to the verdict. We were all sobbing mad. It's one of the biggest miscarriages of justice in modern history.
I along with many others refuse to watch the peacock special in hopes to avoid encouraging them to glorify other murderers that shouldn’t be free. It’s one thing to report and make documentaries but to generate income for someone that awful is trashy.
I watched a Non Verbal analysis of this (it's a guy on YT) and he goes over everything pretty in depth. It got me to watch it - and the entire time just massive eye rolls. It's astounding.
There were actually talks about Cindy and George moving out because they were on the brink of divorce at that time. George was having an affair, also lying about working, and had lost all of their savings to gambling. Casey got the lying bug from George.
I wonder If Megan Boswell studied up on her or if it is just coincidence that her case is so similar. https://www.knoxnews.com/story/news/crime/2022/12/14/megan-boswell-update-lawyer-succeeds-postponing-murder-trial-2025/69724766007/
I was 8 when this whole thing broke out and I knew that bitch was guilty af
If anyone is looking for a great 8 part incredibly detailed deep dive of this case I recommend Crime Weekly. You all would love the absolute roasting of Casey and her parents. https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLXRFYzcEeaXmTQXaKBISRG-YpZExSulXJ
Casey is Floridas 3 hole wonder.. Kayser Soza with tits. Perfect
you called her words I normally cringe at, but they are 100%%%+ spot on with that scumbag.
The Prosecutors podcast did a great multi part series on the murder and trial. They get into the psychology of the jury and why she got off. It is mind boggling.
I live for James nailing the obscure Seinfeld references.
Watched the whole documentary and she is the absolute worst. It was all about her and nothing about Kaylie.
Okay! What do I need to pay you to put this gem on your regular non patreon feed??? Seriously!! I want to share it all over the place and cannot in this format! You gave a million more details than ANY podcast. And you sure as hell did way more than the prosecutors of this case. Please... I will pay it! Love you both so much!
Not that I thought you wouldn’t, but so glad to hear what you thought! Literally fuck Peacock for giving her that platform! 100% think she killed Caylee and she gets everything she deserves. I had never heard about her telling her friend about getting the house from her parents; definitely agree there’s a chance she was planning to off everyone.
So many details I didn’t know. Couldn’t get through the doc either. I think CA is guilty as hell and an evil fuck!
“Keyzer Soze with tits” I screamed 😂
I just don't know how she isn't Iin prison, Jimmie is correct, Blinded by the tits. I wanna hear what you think about the Kelly Cocran case, I really think she killed more ppl.
“Kaiser Soze with tits” 😂😂😂
So true about the decomp smell! My husband accidentally left a grocery bag with raw hamburger meat in it in his trunk, somehow it had gotten hidden under some blankets we kept in there. It was summer so he noticed the smell all week, but apparently couldn’t find the source so was driving with all the windows down. By the 4th or 5th day, I got in the car and immediately got out - the smell was so rancid, I’ve never smelled anything like it in my life! I searched the car myself and found the offending pack of meat in the trunk. For anyone who doubts what decomp smells like and thinks it could have come from the little food scraps she had in her trunk, I invite you to put a pack of hamburger in your own trunk during the summer and see how it smells after a few days.
It strikes me how similar Casey is to a male family annihilator rather than to most other mothers who kill their children. I guess Diane Downs skews that way, too, but Casey even more so.
Uhhhhh can we get a mini-ep about Jimmie's fished car? Really left that one hanging!
I couldn’t even finish her BS series because I’d get pissed off every time she opened her mouth.
I will never understand why she was found innocent. It wouldn’t surprise me if Jose Baez bribed the jury and got away with it. He’s a total scumbag! I kind of want to go to Florida and find Casey and call her a giant twat then fly right back home. I only hope that karma will catch up to Casey and she dies in some horrible fashion. Anyone that does this is a monster and I hope that no one else falls victim to her manipulation and lies in such a horrible fashion. I couldn’t even watch the Peacock doc because I watched other stuff with her that infuriated me. I don’t believe in hell but if it’s real I hope Casey burns in it!!
I thought homicide always showed up for unattended deaths as well but they don’t!! So crazy! My 66 year old healthy physician mother in law passed away in her home during a heat wave, the AC was off and we found her 3 days after she passed and homicide never showed up!! She was purple, you couldn’t tell how she died and nope, they assumed natural death and the coroner came and got her! They did say an autopsy was required, but you would think a homicide detective would have come right? I mean what if the autopsy results showed she was murdered? We had to have a professional company come out to clean up, replace dry way and flooring because it was so bad and they allowed us to do that before the autopsy was completed! I live in Orange County California, not some small area with limited resources. Was so backwards to me.
My mom died unexpectedly / unattended in Texas. Homicide wasn't called in, although police were — I assumed it's standard protocol in most (US) places to have police come to the scene to assess if anything is suspicious, if homicide should be called in, etc. Since her death was unattended, an "external autopsy" was required, which would then determine if a complete autopsy was needed (it wasn't for my mom). But, I agree - calling in homicide isn't standard practice for all unattended deaths, at least not through the US.
The DA sucked. They couldn’t prove a body was in car. The test for decomp not full proof.
Totally agree. They could have won if not for the outlandish and wild prosecutions theory of the case.
This whole situation is infuriating as fuck! I would love to see her in public, I would be happily yelling and throwing shit at her! Fucking hate her forever!
32 minutes in and what the fuck was the jury thinking? I don’t unnndddeeerrrssstttannnddd.
Too bad it seems no tests were done on those maggots from the trunk. It's likely, if there was indeed a body in the trunk. That those maggots were not originally found in that location because of some plate or pizza. But may have wound up there once left behind after the body was removed, idk. just a thought :/
Casey just seems so methy to me. The weird stuff she did, the lies. Just seems like someone who is off their rocker stoned on meth.
I couldn't watch the whole documentary either. She's a lizard person. Check out The Behavior Panel analysis of CA, if you haven't already.
I have to take breaks listening to this because she pisses me off so much
I wanted to punch her in the face the whole time I was listening to her talk in her documentary.
My inner-masochist was glued to the "Casey is the Victim!" NBC documentary from start to finish.. some potent Casey Koolaid. It didn't sway my opinion about her guilt, but it opened an iota of understanding for the jury... definitely reinforced that "not guilty" ≠ "innocent" and the DA needed to give them another option. Shitshow.
This will definitely be a case that goes down in history. How in the FUCKING FUCKING FUCKING to the … FUCKING does she not get convicted? The lies. The FUCKING lies tell the god damn truth!! Hope law schools use it as a case study.
First thought, the jury couldn't accept that a reasonably attractive, white girl wearing a pink Oxford shirt would do that.
They acquitted her because the prosecution over charged her and didn’t offer lesser charges. There wasn’t enough evidence to meet the requirements of 1st degree. If they’d offered a 2nd degree option, they could’ve found her guilty.
I absolutely agree. Although it still boggles my mind that it was unanimous. I'll never forget hearing the verdict and being completely stunned and not at all surprised at the same time. I'm sure 98% of most defendants would have been found guilty in a less scrutinized and high-profile trial... or, at the very least, not have a unanimous verdict.
“She’s Keyser Soze with tits.” Casey got Zenaida’s name from an apartment complex she visited with Toby. She had visited the same day, and filled out the card with her name, and what size apt she was looking to move into.
Started listening just now, but I have my own opinion. Prosecution would have won if they had prosecuted with other options than capital murder and the death penalty. She sure did kill her daughter. However, was it 1st degree? 2nd degree? an accident being covered up? Who knows at this point.
Agree. It's very hard for a jury to put a woman on death row, especially a younger woman. I don't blame the prosecutor for wanting to put her to death - this is one case where I'm not going to argue against it - but the jury would likely have convicted her on second degree, or even first degree without the death penalty.
I'm guessing I'm the only one having trouble playing this on Patreon? This episode won't play but all the others do, weird!!
I've had the same issue in the past....I restarted my phone & that seemed to work. I think the issue is with the app.
Right in time for my drive across Texas! Wooo
Love that he called her twat. Nancy grace always called her tot mom. I say we change it to twat mom.
Yayyy! I’ve been waiting on this one!!
Yayyyyyyyyyyy
