💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SHERRI PAPINI (1 of 2)
May 14, 2023

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SHERRI PAPINI

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the "kidnapping" of Sherri Papini.

Comments (99)

J
Jordyn Fahey · August 4, 2026

Classic case of Casey Anthony’s hallway

U
Uterus Arnold · July 1, 2026

I think she just like to have drama, and she's sick enough in the head to make it a reality. But doesn't have enough far sightedness to have a more believable story and plug those holes in your story.

M
Mz Mechanic · December 3, 2025

The husband moving the chair away 😆

S
Sondra Jackson · June 19, 2025

Love the podcasts , I wish the guys brought this much excitement 2 every podcast. It was one of my favorite.

D
Dorothyann · June 5, 2025

I love how Keith just automatically believes the law enforcement. He seems to instantly know she’s full of it.

M
Maite Ruiz Smith · June 3, 2025

Im listening to this while watching the new panini documentary on hbo max 😂😂😂

S
Sarraaahhhkg · June 2, 2025

This is my "comfort" podcast episode - i've listened to it so many times! Fucking hilarious

C
Christopher Camposeo · June 2, 2025

Came here immediately after the first HBO episode. Fuck this bitch

A
Amy Sousa · May 30, 2025

Just watched the Hulu documentary on this case, ran right over here to get James and Jimmie’s take, and boy does this not disappoint! 😂😂😂 Bravo!

A
Allison Hagman · April 2, 2025

I love this

B
Booklady · February 20, 2025

Why did she do it? I think maybe she was just a narcissistic bitch who wanted attention. Classic example of "Be careful of what you wish for, bc you just might get it"😂!

K
Ken Kuipers · February 13, 2025

She has an interview coming out this year (if it hasn't already). Should be interesting to see. She got released this past October.

S
Sam · December 22, 2024

The best part is when keith leaves with cop

L
LauraSue · December 18, 2024

I’ve listened to this too many times - it never gets old.

H
Hilarie Keys · October 24, 2024

I am from Redding. I donated a couple cases of water to the search and I want them BACK! The bitch! lol

M
Micah Is Real · October 24, 2024

I died when Jimmy said from now on anyone who's been missing for 3 weeks and is found we're all gonna be like "where were ya bitch?" 😂

e
em doubleu · September 21, 2024

Sherri 'Whackadoo' Panini. LOL, instant classic!

M
Marie Evans · July 8, 2024

Watched a rerun of this story just a few days ago. Loved listening to your take on it. Thanks for the laughs. You two would make great viewing buddies.

F
Frank Black · July 6, 2024

I laughed harder than I have in a very long time at this episode. So glad I signed up for this.

S
Susan Nelson · June 29, 2024

Don’t agree guys. The victims are first her children, husband, and parents, but “crying wolf” as she did makes it more difficult for real victims to be taken seriously. That said, I appreciate you guys and your humor

K
Kristin Schmidt · June 29, 2024

She is a narcissistic sociopath

K
Kristin Schmidt · June 29, 2024

Thanks for this. I literally watched the Hulu doc before the pres debates last night

C
Christy Brady · June 22, 2024

My favorite Patreon episode...the number of times I've listened to this is ridiculous 🤣

M
Maito King · June 3, 2024

Even his impression of her makes me want to blow my brains out christ

T
The Pudd · May 18, 2024

Having a rough time, but this is my go-to in the midst of all the shit I have going on. I love hearing James roast Sherri Panini

C
Crowded Crow · May 28, 2024

I relate well to the rough time... I hope life eases up, soon, and allows you a big ol' sigh of contentment/relief. 💗

O
Ollie · March 6, 2024

The reason I love the Patreon episodes is because James roasts Jimmie over the most random shit, like being thirsty. Makes me laugh more than everything else.

M
Martine Calomino · December 27, 2023

I have about 15 chickens.

M
Melanie Meline · November 14, 2023

Lil meanie panini 😂 what a complete twatwaffle

S
Susan Fuhrman · September 24, 2023

I followed this story from the beginning and was on several FB pages. Once she returned on Thanksgiving so many of us were calling bullshit. I really thought Keith was in on it though. She had issues in the past with self harm, and her family had called the police on her before. I just couldn't believe he was that much of a dunce to believe her story. If I had to hear the media say anything about her "signature, blonde hair" or how her family called her a supermom one more time I was going to lose my shit. Must be nice to be a stay at home mom and still be able to put your kids in daycare.

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · September 19, 2023

"Live Laugh Love Broke this Bitch" should be a shirt

A
Ashley eddy · August 28, 2023

She’s been released!!!

M
Matt Brown · August 16, 2023

When y’all gonna do the Baylor Dave Bliss scandal?

J
Jade313 · July 7, 2023

😂🤣 what an idiot! 2 Hispanic women, shackled and chained? Not a African American man or a Hispanic man this time?? I hate her already. Gimme 5 minutes alone with that cunt!

A
Audra Wajda · July 4, 2023

I'll watch for the poor bastard.

C
Cassie Costello · July 2, 2023

I watched her entire interrogation. Worth it. Soooo awkward. And her poor husband goes from being all supportive to feeling like a dunce. He deserves a huge consolation prize for her b.s.

J
Just Jenn · June 14, 2023

Omg. I just watched it. She's a nut bag. She tried so hard to look real. What bs

M
Maritza Irizarry · June 7, 2023

Blow Keith Papini should be a shirt

C
Chance Crocker · May 30, 2023

Do the chickens count as murder birds?

S
Sarah Millington · June 1, 2023

Yes! People make them vests and things…

S
Samantha · May 28, 2023

I feel like the crazies that think “I’ll kill this person AND get away with it!” are more logical than Sherri. What a nutcase!

C
Cindy Furgason · May 24, 2023

Excellent! Stellar rundown. I had to find the video when he scooted away, asked the detective to speak outside the room. Then the cherry on top, him talking about not wanting her to go home with him. I would have missed this gem, if not for y'all. Yayyyy!

L
Lisa Adams · May 21, 2023

I agree she wanted to be a character in a her own true crime drama. James, with all of his “uneducated” brilliance, figured it out quickly. Her ex-boyfriend was a bit part actor in her drama. Not a matter of her leaving her husband to fuck another man and regretting it. She figured out that her ex-boyfriend’s apartment was not as glamorous as being on TV and then Thanksgiving broke her. No one at that apartment was capable of making a Thanksgiving turkey.

L
Lisa Adams · May 21, 2023

This was delightful. I wanted to punch her in the face in her first interviews. I couldn’t really figure out why until James said “she’s all curled up on the chair. I’m so tiny!” I wanna punch my tv when psychopath women use the helpless woman act.

T
Tara Sauerwald · May 24, 2023

In the beginning of this episode, I thought, “Well, I’ve got to check this woman’s interviews out.” After James read her statements verbatim, I realized that if I watched it on TV, I would probably end up punching my TV. Too bad we can’t all get in line to punch her.

T
TJ Askren · May 19, 2023

Jimmie makes my day. His laugh makes me happy.

L
Lisa Adams · May 21, 2023

Jimmy’s laugh is crucial to the podcast. He is a piece of sugar.

S
Stabby Paine · May 19, 2023

well now i wanna share pics of my ugly ass chickens.

A
Amy Stanton · May 19, 2023

"blow that guy!" 🤣🤣 "We'll talk about football!" I'm dying 🤣🤣

L
Lillith · May 18, 2023

Unrelated to this case when I got my shoutout on the new episode and Jimmy said “samesies” I fangirled sooooo hard. Y’all are the best!!🖤

L
Laura Tannehill · May 17, 2023

She needs to "cheer up bitch"

K
Kemp Aloia · May 17, 2023

Unrelated to this episode. Just unable to write a review on Spotify. James, Jimmy.. Sarah, anyone involved I thank you. I have listened to many a podcasts, listened to many a comedians. You guys are my way out of depression, my laughs at 3am, my escape. Not just Small town, but everything you do. Shut up and take my money. As soon as you come close to Alabama and I can get a ticket, I'll bring my cousin and have a good "fucking" time.

L
Lisa Adams · May 21, 2023

I can’t go to sleep unless I’m listening to a small town podcast or patreon. The rhythm of the voices. I promise I’m not a stalker. 😃

A
April Chiero (chair-o) · May 17, 2023

This dumb bitch should've just checked herself into a mental health facility if she felt she needed a 'mom' break, or for whatever tf was going on with her, as it was obviously mental health. That is definitely the why. But to do what she did is just bananas.

K
KalkiTheEternity · May 17, 2023

I highly doubt it was mental health. Her entire life she has been a lying attention seeker and this was the culmination of that journey.

R
Rhonda Allred · May 17, 2023

I’m an old fat redhead! My missing wouldn’t even make the news! Lol

L
Lisa Adams · May 21, 2023

Don’t underestimate yourself Rhonda. I would go look for you because my life is also boring.

E
Erin Richards-Wilhelm · May 17, 2023

Look. Sometimes moms just need 20 minutes.

C
Chuck Shartz · May 17, 2023

I kinda had the same theory as James, but only because I know my ex-wife would feast on that kind of attention too, lol...

T
Translucency · May 17, 2023

“I gotta see my kids!” is her spin on “It’s fuh da children!”

M
Msjustice · May 16, 2023

I need to find the interview with the Ex James- anyone know where that can be found?

M
Mike Kubiak · May 16, 2023

Haaaaaa amazing telling of the story!

M
Msjustice · May 16, 2023

The way she howls when crying i am right there with james - someone closeline her off that damn chair

C
Christy Brady · May 16, 2023

So I listened to this yesterday, then went home and watched the Peacock show on Sherri, then I relistened. Oh my gosh, it's 10 times funnier cause I can now see her 🤣 Her poor husband! Jimmie laughing when talking about the restraining order is the best!!

J
Jennifer Keefe · May 16, 2023

This is a wild story. I watched a bunch of videos of the interrogation before listening to this and I’m so glad I did. So fucked up! My favorite part was when she realized they had all the facts so she starts saying she doesn’t want them to arrest “the small one” and he cop is just like “yeah we’re not going to find her don’t worry” 😂

M
Msjustice · May 16, 2023

And how she said "but james loves me" and the cop was like " yeah he did, i agree" - the way he said it was like 'oh you comprehend that but dont understand how hes "involved" '

C
Cathy M · May 16, 2023

Totally agree with James’ theory. I used to have a friend who spun crazy tall tales and it always sounded like she wanted to be on Phil Donahue or Sally Jesse. She’d watch those shows all day everyday while she stayed at home with her kids. Last I heard from her she was working in a Jimmie Dean factory pretending she was Native American with her also-white pretender second husband- they met in an AOL chat room for Native Americans. If she were young today she’d be desperately seeking to be the subject of a podcast or at least a Snapped episode.

J
J Mount · May 16, 2023

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLFMELubizU Growing up in Northern IL. I was 4 when Disco Demolition happened, so I don't remember it but, I listened to Steve and Gary until they left their show when I was in High School. I did have the "parody" cassette tapes Steve & Gary made in the 80's and listened to them all the time, Steve Dahl is still doing a Pod Cast that is relatively popular to this day

C
Caroline Crigger · May 16, 2023

Always thought she just did it for the attention and kinda wanted to make herself a real life “final girl.” She’s absolutely unhinged.

M
Morgan Willenbring · May 16, 2023

Can anyone explain how what she did is not a crime? This is wild!

A
Armando Martinez Ochoa · May 16, 2023

My friend grew up with this girl in Redding, California. She’s still in disbelief of her friends lies. I remember my friend being heartbroken when she went missing. For all it to be Lies, is a stab in the back to say the least.

S
Stephanie Ditty · May 15, 2023

I work at a tattoo shop and Sherri came in to get her brands covered up like 2 weeks before she was going to jail. I’m also friends with Keith’s sister

f
folderol · May 15, 2023

Ok, now I really want to know what she got to cover that up. Haha.

N
Nanci Janssen · May 15, 2023

Quite possibly the funniest episode yet! I watch the Behavior Panel a lot and when I watched the ep about Ms. Panini (her new name in my head) I KNEW I needed James & Jimmie to cover her crazy ass. I agree with James, she wanted to be TCF (True Crime Famous).

P
Paul Nichols · May 15, 2023

Poor poor Keith! Takes a unique/narcissistic mind to want that type of attention

D
Desiree · May 15, 2023

I can only imagine that he may have wanted to dump her after being cheated on but now you cant because shes kidnapped and he believe it to be true. Then 4 years later........

M
Michelle Donegan · May 15, 2023

She just screams munchausen syndrome! Just wants to get attention, but instead of using medical means to do so, she is using true crime scenarios for attention!! There will be a new diagnostic of mental health disorders on this for sure! She may be the first we know of, but she definitely won’t the last! Love the episode 😘

J
Jayfield · May 15, 2023

Don't we all know someone like that?😠

E
Eddie Sanchez · May 15, 2023

Damn the second hand embarrassment for Keith

K
KalkiTheEternity · May 15, 2023

Haven’t watched yet but she’s also a fucking racist so there’s that. Feel bad for her husband though, he truly believed her to a fault,

E
Erik Molnar · May 14, 2023

Another reason, American needs another war and draft idiots like her to be drafted

S
Scarlet Whore Beast · May 14, 2023

#philanthropussy4Kieth

J
Jayfield · May 15, 2023

Funny.

T
Tammy Hedrick · May 14, 2023

Fascinating! While I was listening I thought "she is doing this for attention." I completely agree with your theories. What a nut!

C
Chad Haas · May 14, 2023

This feels like she’s going to be on Love After Lockup in the near future.

J
Jayfield · May 15, 2023

I'll watch it!

R
Rosemarie Cawkwell · May 14, 2023

Utterly bizarre case, but yeah, I agree with James. Attention and fame, without the trauma. Maybe she was jealous of the attention actual survivors received? I also think she deliberately chose to make her kidnappers Latinx because racism, but also maybe something from her childhood - maybe she was bullied by, or was jealous of, some Latinx girls for whatever reason at high school, since she repeatedly referenced her childhood and pretended to regress to a childlike state when pushed for answers. People are strange.

K
Kari Kelly · May 14, 2023

This is exactly what I needed on Mother’s Day! Thank you!!

w
wub deez · May 14, 2023

Totally worth 5 bucks. That's the funniest 1 hour summary. Thank you

L
Lydia Plante · May 14, 2023

I think James’ theory is spot on. She just wanted to get famous and feel special and important!

M
Michael Hinchley · May 14, 2023

Guys, listen to Victim F on Audible. Holy shit it is the exact opposite of this story. Sounds so made up but 100% true! Story of Denise Huskins abduction while her boyfriend Aaron Quinn was present. Cops don't believe them. Even friends & family really don't believe it. It's a great listen.

C
Cam 🛸 · May 14, 2023

“What sick bitch wants to be Elizabeth Smart?!” EXACTLYYYYY. But I think she 100% wanted to be a woman on a missing poster. She wanted documentaries and shit about her. Which she’ll get now, but not how she wanted.

f
folderol · May 14, 2023

I completely agree with you guys. She totally did it for the attention. I remember how big Gone Girl was around that time, what do you wanna bet she loved that shit?

C
CuddlingDeath · May 14, 2023

Exactly I was just thinking that! She wanted her gone girl moment

T
Tabitha Helberg · May 14, 2023

This is so fascinating and fucked up. Poor Keith 😩

J
Jim Pearson · May 16, 2023

You better go take one for the team Tabitha 😂

L
Lyndsay Chansley · May 14, 2023

“I want you to suck his dick” great now there’s wine in my sinus lol

L
Leslie Alcantar · May 14, 2023

This is my town and I have been waiting anxiously since this was first announced!!! Time to smoke a bowl and enjoy 🤣

J
Julia Collins · May 14, 2023

YES!!!!