💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - REAL DAHMER VS NETFLIX DAHMER (1 of 2)
October 30, 2022

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - REAL DAHMER VS NETFLIX DAHMER

This week, James and Jimmie discuss the differences between the real Jeffrey Dahmer and Netflix's depiction of Jeffrey Dahmer! 

Comments (42)

A
Adrian · January 30, 2026

They did a Gacy movie in the earlier 2000s Francis that stole Pee Wee's bike played Gacy

A
Adrian · January 30, 2026

2002 Jeremy Renner played Dahmer.

7
70Boss302 · September 9, 2025

Watching this on the news, the blue barrels, that was some next level crazy for us to comprehend. The neighbors quotes were definitely laughed at but I remember feeling bad for them. WACO, Lorena Bobbit, OJ, Menendez,... 90s was intense! I think Netflix did a great job with the 90s overall vibe, and overt police corruption. And nearly everyone smoked. That was the 90s--cigarettes, drugs, minding your business to a fault, and corruption.

B
Benjamin A · November 20, 2024

Shout out to you. Your proble not going to read this but you two are great. Been listening mabe 2021 around. Love the humor with a bit of being serious just a bit

B
Benjamin A · November 20, 2024

I just want to say the smell of somone dead is worse then a method house so I think anyways. But what I do know is how smells can go threw appartments. Somone dead is the worst smell. Figure rotten eggs just ten times worse. About 5 years ago I lived in a appartment on the first floor. Lived at this place for about a year and we started smelling this smell my nabors started putting air fresheners in the hallway. It was bad. Well a few weeks later my nabor pointed out when all these people started coming in to the apartment building. (After it happend) that one of them was the city corner. Found out later the guy above me was dead over a month. I will never forget that!!!!

C
Céleste Robinson-Musseau · April 14, 2024

I'm late to the game on this one, but this is the exact reason I couldn't finish watching the show. His dad tried hard to help, and they made him look so awful. So many details misconstrued. I was so dang angry.

d
darrel wilkins · September 20, 2023

(Litter)aly just spit dr.pepper out when james told story about his friend shitting his pants and the cat being put to sleep because of it🤣🤣🤣🤣

E
Emily Miller · July 21, 2023

Obviously we know it was human bodies but I will say, in the office I work we’ve had mice die in the ceiling and it smelled like death for WEEKS.

A
Audra Wajda · July 5, 2023

Some 15 years ago I drove up to Milwaukee to see Hank 3 play, and booked a room at the Ambassador Hotel. I didn't realize what that hotels history was. After a lot of alcohol, and nose candy, I ended up running around the halls calling for 'Jeffy'. I'm not proud of it, but I was young, and wild at the time. The hotel people told me to hush, but amazingly didn't kick me out.

K
Kris “go raiders” moyer · June 25, 2023

I know it’s out of left field but how about a bonus episode of Carl panzram he was wild

R
Richard Brian Cavell Jr · December 25, 2022

cmon, give a dog a bone

M
Matthew James · November 21, 2022

Can you guys do a bonus episode on Casey Anthony? I think you guys would be hilarious talking about that case

C
Cyndi13 · November 9, 2022

I started watching it because I like Evan Peters but stopped at the end of episode 3 because I felt gross watching it. I was able to watch the other Netflix show “Conversations with a killer” and the neighbor who wrote the book is in it especially at the end. That was the real story. I enjoyed your episode very much! Thanks!

T
Tracy Froidcoeur · November 8, 2022

I remember this story when it happened. I know all the basic details. I could only watch 3 episodes...I could smell the smell of his apartment. Nope, couldn't do it.

M
Macie Lummus · November 8, 2022

I was already sure I wasn’t going to watch, but I almost did just to see all the differences so I’m glad y’all did this. Great episode! I *did* watch Under the Banner of Heaven, though, which is about a case you’ve covered before (#166 in American Fork, Utah) and I thought some of the differences were interesting. If you’re looking for any bonus episode ideas, an episode like this one with the real case vs its tv show adaption would be cool!

D
DearMrPotter · November 13, 2022

Under the Banner of Heaven was fascinating and well-acted. DEFINITELY a great idea for a bonus episode!

K
KatWarlock · November 6, 2022

I’m glad I didn’t watch it. I refused because the victims families didn’t give it authorisation from what I heard. But hearing that they “mushed” five different victims into one character is inane. It’s taking away the victims life further. The Dahmer tapes are much superior.

K
Karla T · November 5, 2022

With the absolute insanity of this man, his crimes and the times he was almost caught and got away with it WHY did Netflix need to make anything up?! It was already quite the story!!

S
Sandi Center · November 3, 2022

I have no reason to watch the Netflix series on Dahmer… You guys are great!

A
Angelina Marconi · November 3, 2022

Always look forward to "Either way..." throughout from James and Jimmie's always reliable "wooow" and "Is that right?"

v
violet · November 1, 2022

BTW...Y'ALL are awesome !!!

v
violet · November 1, 2022

OK... Just finished listening to this.... Got home after a hard day my house smelled so weird I didn't know what was up.. the 1st thing I thought was oh my God I hope my neighbors aren't killing anybody..... Thank goodness just needed to clean my garbage disposal lol...

L
Louise Marshall · November 1, 2022

Hey! Was so disappointed to find out that Netflix falsified so much. What is the point? Love you guys!

k
katie castañeda · November 1, 2022

i think the point was for netflix to make money/get views and probably virtue signaling as an added bonus. very disappointing but not surprising. glad we have james & jimmie to educate us.

M
Michelle Mousiol · November 1, 2022

This topic is literally the reason I just bought your Patreon, so I am very excited to get stuck into this.

B
Bisexual Vigilante · October 31, 2022

This is an interesting listen. I will say, at nearly 40, I never take any film/miniseries at face value and neither should anyone else. When I finish one I go online and find out the real story that, even with 8 episodes, didn’t need to be compressed.

S
Shelly Roberts · October 31, 2022

We had a skunk in our house when I was about 3, that'll wake you up quick.

C
Christy Brady · October 31, 2022

Follicalsexuals 🤣🤣

T
Tony Boehler · November 1, 2022

hair horny got me lol

B
Brooke Cale · October 31, 2022

PLEASE everyone watch the Netflix doc about the Dahmer tapes. It is so superior and amazing

L
Lanie Balmer · October 31, 2022

Agreed!!

S
Sarah Loves Patrick · October 31, 2022

Damn, glad I didn’t bother watching it.

m
mint · October 30, 2022

I've also seen that the victims' families really didn't want the series to be made. Seems like an odd way to use the talent of the director, cinematographers, actors, etc but Netflix is gonna Netflix

R
Rob W · October 30, 2022

I was a 11 years old when they arrested Dahmer, I remember the court hearings being aired live on Court TV. I had nightmares when that shit was going on

M
MrRin213 · October 30, 2022

The Jeremy Renner Dahmer movie is excellent. Watch it instead.

J
Jeremy James · October 30, 2022

fantastic! Now I don't have to watch passed the first episode I watched. I look forward to the next episode drop! :)

J
Judy Anderson · October 30, 2022

Thanks again for saving me from wasting my time. I won’t be watching Dahmer.

R
Rob W · October 30, 2022

Same here

M
M. M. · October 30, 2022

You can blame Ryan Murphy for this being nine parts. The guy never has any idea how to end things, leading nearly everything he does to run far too long.

K
Kyle Bigham · October 30, 2022

It’s super fun to shatter my students (middle schoolers) ideas about Dahmer. They think they’re little badasses because they watched the show, until they hear about the reality of that whole saga. All of a sudden they don’t want to talk about him anymore.

P
Paige Spencer · October 30, 2022

I can’t lie I definitely noticed the hair 👀

N
Navarra Good · October 30, 2022

Follicle-sexuals! LOL!