BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - HAE MIN LEE CASE
This week, James and Jimmie discuss the Hae Min Lee case.
Why now? Given the recent events about Adnan Syed's release from incarceration, they discuss the whole case and possible other suspects.
Comments (79)
This brought me back to 1999, as one of the few people of my friend group that had a cellphone (a HUGE mistake on my mother's part, but she was given an unwinnable situation. Her 17 yo daughter asked her to install a landline in her friend's place; since they already fucked up their names with AT&T, or QWEST at the time. I didn't ask for a cellphone because I never thought she'd go for it. To her credit I was out of there in 6 months.) I spent the next 2 years practically calling QWEST fighting my phone bill and roaming charges, because my phone calls were all taken and made in the city of Portland, OR but the bill had me MILES out of town, regularly. God that was a pain in the ass.
What a tangent. But I remember similar fighting with cell carriers in the early 2000’s also
Epic crossover. Serial was my first foray into true crime when my English teacher in high school had us listen to it in class. Now I look back on it and wonder if she only played it for us because she was baffled by it, thought he was innocent, and wanted to hear other teenagers' perspectives lol
Something tells me if Adnan's name was Johnny Smith, he wouldn't have been a suspect.
Hey James, have you ever seen the Wire? 🤔 I think you’d like it.
So, Adnan was given a reduced sentence of time served and 5 years supervised probation. WTF?
Why didn't Jay say where they buried her?
I have my own theories. But the biggest reason Adnan is innocent is because… they said it was due to his religion that he killed her. Well either he is devote and it the holiday for reflection and time of salvation so he would not of murdered her or he is not devote so then no religious reason to murder her. I agree it is either the guy who found her.. or I always wondered if it was Don’s mom
I'm so lost on this one. I tried restarting it and I just can't follow it. Is there something else I can watch to get into this story?
I've never listened to Serial. I'm a devoted fan of Criminal, however, (the O.G. crime podcast - it premiered before Serial) I'm hot for Pheobe Judge. This is the first time I've heard details about this case and from what I've learned here, I fully agree with James' theory of who is responsible for Lee's death. How they couldn't shift focus off the kid and not the sex perv is difficult to understand...
Great coverage guys! Idk if you’re still following, but apparently just this year in March, they reinstalled his conviction. Not on any new evidence, but some procedural shit. Apparently Hae Min Lee’s brother didn’t get to testify in the circuit court last year. So all of this is still going on…I definitely feel like Adnan is innocent and I 100% agree with James’ theory.
Thank you for covering! Such an intriguing case. Feel so badly for that poor girl.
Thanks guys for doing this bonus because I've been following this case since serial. I believed he was innocent from the start and I wonder why Jay wasn't looked at Harder all I know is that the prosecutors who put him in jail had major misconduct and he would still be sitting in jail now if it hadn't been for the prosecutor now because she could have just kept him in jail and not done anything but her morals told her to do what she did and he is out of jail and I am so happy about that
I believe Don had significant health issues in the following years
Scrolled through the comments. Guess I'm on an island on this one. I DO believe there was enough evidence to suspect Adnan killed her. Was there enough to convict? With better lawyers, probably not.
Little disappointed in how heavily one sided this episode played out.
She IS podcast is Jesus. Wow
What do you mean you "did a movie"? Lol am I the only one that did a double take when he said that?
James used to work on small films a lot, he has talked about it on multiple episodes. He talked about it more back in the beginning though.
They just freed him!
Awesome podcast!
loved this episode!!
So now that Adnan is free…I’m so interested in the new suspects to see if James is right, because I would NOT be surprised.
Loved this and praise be that Adnan is now truly free as of yesterday. Time to find the real killer
That's a couple of handsome fellas right there :)
GREAT episode.
I wish you guys knew how much I used."the problem is...) Please don't ever stop bringing joy.
Does anybody else like it when James goes on tangents and gets really mad? I do! Makes complete sense in this case. The Baltimore police were at it again - never looking at all of the suspects. Poor girl, her family may never have closure no matter how hyped up this case has gotten.
What a handsome duo!!! Also, that episode was great. I haven’t checked in too much on the case since listening to serial about 4 years ago, so this has me all interested again! So happy for Adnan and his family! Heart still aches for Hae and her family. Wish they could get the real answer someday.
I listened to Serial week by week as it came out, then Undisclosed, etc. In the 5-6 years since it came out, I’ve NEVER been able to square away Mr. S. finding her body. I remember people who were part of the crime scene investigation could barely see it when they were TOLD exactly where it was. Plus, no one is going back that far in the woods for a simple pee. It always blew my mind that they cleared this guy and I felt like I must be the crazy one who was missing something. So, thanks for the vindication that I’m not the only one who suspects him!
For someone that likes to expose themselves I doubt he went that far in just to pee. I agree with you
James casually mentioning “I was in a movie once, No Room for Groceries…” dude, you freaking WROTE it! Where can I watch this movie? Sure, it’s from 2006, but after reading the 3 reviews on IMDB, I want to watch it badly! We need updates man.
Yup.....Jay knows way too much.....
Y’all are super handsome
“Fuck Damnit” - Jimmie hahahaha
Thank you Jimmie, thank you James! Carlo is back in Kansas where he belongs! A whole 4 months of making us miserable here in tiny town Arkansas and one personal message from y’all got him the boot! Yay! *aggressively back flipping right now
I went to leakin park today, ive put it off even though ive alway been curious. I was working a job close by today and decided to take a ride through. First of all , this aint no regular park, its ghetto theres trash and i woudnt trust walking a trail in there for a sec. You’d be snatched up instantly, it looked so sketchy. Secondly, NO FUCKING WAY DID HE JUST STUMBLE ACROSS THE BODY NO FUCKING WAY.
It depends on what part of the park you go to. I don't mind going to Leakin Park during the day. They also used to have a cool little Railroad thing you could ride. It does have some cool trails including the trail with all the art and stuff on it.
Odd that a flasher would be that pee shy huh?
Two things seal Mr. S for me and they’re somewhat related. One is lividity. Had Hae been put in the trunk, she’d most likely be curled up on her side so she would fit. But the lividity shows that she’d been flat on her back for at least 8hrs (how long it takes for lividity to set in). This couldn’t be the case with the prosecution’s timeline for what Adnan did. Second, there was an odd ‘diamond’ shape in Hae’s back that she must have been resting on after her murder. They discovered that the shape is the exact shape of an implement used in tiling or stone work (I forget what exactly) which is what Mr. S did for a living. Too many coincidences.
damn. now i can’t get that Jodeci song from the beginning of the documentary out of my head. …oh, and Jay did that shit.
are you guys ever gonna do an episode about times videogames were blamed for murders? You guys said you were gonna do a seperate episode for it when you did the music and movies episode and ive been looking forward to you guys going over videogames ever since
Whether he did it or not- I do not believe that he did, he did not get a fair trial. That is the one fact that cannot be denied
I don't see how Jay hasn't been looked at harder, but I didn't know about the dude across the street. It's plausible I guess, but I'm really leaning toward Jay. This was an awesome episode!!
This case is the definition of tunnel vision, they left so many things untouched. It's scary how they convicted some one with zero evidence. I don't know if he did it or not but I really like James' theory. I did not know the guy that found her lived ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE SCHOOL!
Clearly you've never heard of Adrienne Reynolds in East Moline, Illinois. She was killed in a car in a busy Taco Bell parking lot by her teenaged friends. You should do it for STM, it's a good one. Also, the Wire isn't real life lol
I don't know much about this case. No clue why. It just never interested me. But quick question, those of you who think he's guilty..... what's the evidence? Why do you think that? I'm not judging, but I'm just curious. I've seen way more people think he's guilty than innocent and I'm just wondering why. Maybe I'll have to listen to Serial?
I’d suggest watching the HBO series as well. Serial is great but very much about Jay and not much else. That said, i think that’s why so many people think Adnan was guilty cause of what Jay said. I’ve followed this case for a while and I would have to agree with James. I think it’s him, literally no evidence against Adnan other than being the ex.
I'm between Jay and the serial flasher as the top contenders. Jay could have gotten pissed at Hae because she threatened to tell Jay's girlfriend about his cheating on her. He then threw Adnan under the bus to get himself out of it. Either that, or the police offered Jay a deal to pretend Adnan did it and they wouldn't put Jay away for dealing. The flasher (I'm sorry I can't remember his name and am too lazy to look it up right now), if he did it, committed his first murder and was doing what serial killers love to do: inserting himself into the investigation. I go back and forth between Jay killing Hae due to how hard he holds onto the "Adnan did it!" Story, and the flasher doing it because his story on finding the body makes no sense.
I enjoyed hearing James so fired up about the injustice of the case and the ineptitude and wrong doing of the police.
You two are so handsome and interesting. (I forgot what compliment we were instructed to write) ☺️
I pray there is a new trial. I believe the investigation was bungled but I think he is guilty and had help. The new evidence is bogus the girl who said she seen him in the library is suspect to say the least. Lack of dna or physical evidence doesn’t mean innocence the watts case proves that the house was immaculate less than 24 hours after 3 people were murdered.
I agree with James. I've always thought the perv who found the body was guilty AF. Don is also a slimeball, but he's just a loser. And Jay is the biggest bitch.
This whole thing just made me angry, how are you going to lock up a kid for life when almost all evidence points to someone else?
Seriously!! It makes the murder so much worse bc now 2 innocent people lost their lives for no reason
Sorry, not sorry…”podcast Jesus”…I’m rolling with laughter!
The regular shows are second to none, but I’ve started looking forward to the Patreon episodes even more. As always, thanks guys for another great show.
This made me want to listen to yall analyze the murder of Cathy Cesnik/The Keepers case (which also happened to be around Baltimore)
Yes! That story is an entire wild ride!!!
One of your best episodes!
Agree!
The Leakin Park thing is accurate. I’ve lived in Woodlawn/Windsor Mill since 2000, I’ve never been there. It’s known as a dumping ground/dangerous area. Gwynn Falls Trail is a hiking/biking trail but it’s not the safest. Also, where the car was found is right off a major road. The Best Buy (it’s closed/gone) was next to a McDonald’s (which was super busy) and across the a super busy mall at the time. I hope the new DNA technology and any evidence they have solves this case without any doubt.
Cannot wait to hear the theories! I feel like I agree with the guys most of the time so I’m curious if we’ll have the same opinion on this one.
Serial was my first podcast. At the end of it, I didn’t have strong feelings either way about whether Adnan was guilty or innocent but felt he deserved a new trial. After all I’ve heard since, though, I agree with James. Great episode.
Important to note that if Adnan did this, he's worse than Bundy, because even Bundy wasn't Bundy when he was 17. Also, call me cynical, but I can't help but think Mosby sat on this until she lost her reelection campaign and is facing federal charges to try to salvage whatever is left of her reputation.
So, it's more of a theory at this point and will most likely never be proven, but there's evidence that Ted Bundy killed his first victim when he was 14. Her name was Ann Marie Burr, and she was 8 years old when she was murdered in 1961. She also happened to be the neighbor of a young Ted Bundy. She was taken out of her bed in the middle of the night. A window had been opened and a shoe print that was likely a teenagers was outside of said open window. I think Adnan is innocent, but I don't think his age at the time of the crime is something to focus on. There are a lot of people who kill/attempt to kill in their teens and even preteens.
FWIW Bilal was charged with sex with a minor. He was arrested the day the trial started, his charges were dropped AFTER he died the country for two years. Very strange circumstances around that dude. He molested a14 year old refugee
I need a shirt that says Why is a sex pervert that far in the woods? hahahahahahahhahahaha
We knew your review would be the best and you didn’t disappoint!
Wonderful episode guys!! I was so excited to hear your take! I am 100% in agreement about Mr. S, and also don't discount Bilal either, as I think I have heard that he at one time either threatened her personally or said something to someone else about her that was seen as a threat. Can't remember where I heard that, and if it was a fact or just a theory. Basically from what I remember the thought was Bilal might have killed her as an honor killing for Adnan? Hell if I know...just saying, he's tied for #2 suspect with Don. Don would be my #1 but I think it's easier to explain away the evidence against him. The time card thing could literally be his Mom going back and creating an alibi for him because his girlfriend just went missing and she knew they were gonna look at him. As for his non-chalance...well they had only been dating a couple of weeks and she seemed way more into it then he was, plus she was only missing, not that that's not bad but as a young person in a new relationship...you may not freak out and jump to the dead conclusion. I would like to add something to the Mr. S stopping to pee and finding her. If you stop on the side of the road to piss, you don't walk that far into the woods cuz...YOU HAVE TO PEE!! Usually so bad you are about to pee your pants! Also, not only was Hae mostly buried, she was also in a natural dip in the ground behind a big log. He had to walk around to other side of the log to even see that there was anything in that crevice. Nope! I get that bodies are found all the time in the woods but not like this...this is my guy as well. Oh as a side note...to answer the question...does Adnan have to stay on GPS monitoring indefinitely...no, the state has 30 days to decide to either file charges or drop charges. I don't see them refiling. Even if they do think he is guilty...they literally have no case anymore. Plus now there are these alternate suspects to plant more reasonable doubt. What really makes me furious is the outright Brady violation...that is one of the reasons Mosby petitioned to vacate the conviction and opt for a new trial, if they even decide to re-try. These two alternate suspects were in the case file in handwritten notes, but the defense was never given the notes that they were named in. The State knows they are in the wrong and I give Mosby credit for doing what she did...I just wish she would have done it sooner, but at least she got him out while she still could Thanks again guys for working so hard and giving us so much great content! Can't wait for 2023 dates to be announced...hoping beyond hope that you come back to Minneapolis, but am not above traveling if necessary...did it in 2022! 😁 Milwaukee was amazing!!
Very well researched and thoughtful episode. I don’t think Adnan did it, and I agree with James that coincidences are never actually coincidences, so Mr S is at the top of my list of suspects. I think they punished Adnan for the crimes committed by other Pakistani men and found out Jay was dealing so they had a way to go after Hae’s ex and get him imprisoned to represent the other guys that escaped to Asia. They offered Jay a deal to say what they told him to say and they’d keep him out of jail for the weed. Neither of them had anything to do with Hae’s murder, and I’m thrilled Adnan is back home with his family for now. I hope it stays that way.
Well done guys! I have been following, researching, and been pretty obsessed with this case for years and I think you guys did such an amazing job. I love your takes on things and actually learned some new things regarding the case. I'm glad you guys covered this. I respect and value your opinions regarding high profile cases like this so... Thanks for covering it and well done sirs.
To add to the detective Angle one of the detectives in the hae min lee case was found fabricating evidence in another case
I'm really nervous to hear your opinion on this case, James. Don't let me down! 🤞🤞🤞
Oh thank Buddha! Great episode!! I'm with you, I think it might be the guy that found her. I also lean towards Don. Either way, I'm glad Adnan is finally free!
Fantastic episode
Been waiting on your take of this...great timing for it!!! ♥️ u guys!
Finally!!! 🙌
Jimmy and Jimmie are rockstars!
