BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SERIAL KILLERS IN THE MAFIA
this week, james and jimmie discuss serial killers in the mafia!
Comments (44)
This is one of the best episodes. Here to re-listen in 2026.
12:25 Thoughts regarding this part about serial killers and how their desire to kill eventually becomes an “undeniable” and “uncontrollable” urge. Undeniable, is one thing. Yes it’s strong it exists, can’t pretend it doesn’t. I have a hard time believing though, that anything not tied directly to life sustaining activities such as drinking water, eating food, finding suitable shelter during cold nights etc, is ever actually “uncontrollable”. People always credit psychopaths for being able to control themselves, project themselves masterfully like shapeshifters, and puppeteer their surroundings and those inside it etc. If you are the definition of control and composure, I can’t also believe you are taken over by a “need” to harm because you lack mirroring neurons and empathy. Point and main question: You don’t need empathy to survive as a physical being, so how can the lack of it, result in a “need” to extinguish life in empathy’s absence, that is “uncontrollable”? Maybe uncontrollable isn’t meant so much literally as it is figuratively. I do believe using such language excuses actions taken, decided upon, based on strong impulses. Impulses that I’d like to say are actually controllable. Especially for highly intelligent psychopaths who are in every other sense, the very image of control, themselves. I’d love to hear other thoughts, if anyone follows what I’m trying to say.
I dated a guy from the DeMaio family and he would talk about how his family was in the mafia but I didn’t really ever think much about it lol
Re listening for the millionth time. I need more! Lol
I mean...if the jewelry is worth money 🤷🏼♀️ stow it away until years later when u can pawn it. Like bury it in a coffee can in your flower garden
Jimmy gets so excited ..
Fun fact, my fiancée’s cousin is a CO at the prison in Kentucky where Pitera currently resides.
This one has been my favorite thus far. Endlessly fascinating. The mind of serial killers are fucking wild, and Tommy just got to do whatever. Never even heard of the guy. Real crazy shit, I really hope they do another one of these.
@31:03 'sitting with his taint flat on a bench' 😂I fuggin died laughing at that line.
Ohh maybe our new show will be mob related!
Funny story, my stepfather's last name is Galante. When he and my mother lived up north, the checker in the grocery store asked my mother if she was a good Galante or a bad Galante. And yes, my stepfather's first name is Anthony. 😆
This is a great connection. I heard that about CEO that layoff or closed companies. The person has the signs of a serial killer. They have no care about people well being.
Antisocial personality disorder is supposedly higher in people who hold those kind of cutthroat jobs. No idea of it's actually true though
Naked in the dismemberment tub!?!?! When I bathe my dog in the tub, I wear a bathing suit to do it!
The point is no blood risks getting on clothing. Dog hair rarely leads to a murder conviction
I've never been much of a Mob kinda girl, but this one was interesting and great comedy as always. STM case brewing in Harvard Nebraska. Remains of missing Columbus woman found and foul play is suspected. Wowt.com has a short article about it.
"That seems like a desire to work... and I... just don't possess that" Deep belly laughs. Thanks guys!
Never worry about not covering murder - you two are great no matter the topic!
Addiction is addiction whether it’s drugs, adrenaline or murder!
@20:02 in, did anyone else say to themselves "wish that none of ' em talked, would have saved us all a lot of everything"
Oh boy I grew up in Gravesend. Lake St and Ave U...
Haven’t read all comments but… When Jimmy says “that seems like slavery” Am I the only one that yelled Alright Andrew Jackson!!!
How long does it take to get a shout-out
Mine was that week when I started, but that was a few years ago when there might not have been as many people- they might just be backed up, I’m sure they’ll get to you 😊
LOVE the mafia episodes
Great show well presented
I could listen to you guys talk about mafia stories for hours. this was great
No Roy DeMeo? Leader of the Gemini lounge crew? 200 murders and his credo was “no body … no crime”
This was such an interesting topic that I had a hard time concentrating on anything else! It’s odd having to sit down to lunch and listening to mafia dismembering methods, ha. Great job!
Tommy karate that's a true psychopath who just happened to be from Brooklyn NY you're right had he grown up anywhere else he would've been as infamous as Ted Bundy
oooooh yes <3
I knew a real massive guy that had a really light and delicate falsetto voice. It was caused by an injury he suffered as a kid. He was hit in the throat pre-puberty and it caused damage to his vocal cords and voice box so his voice never deepened. It was always odd to hear this wispy singsong falsetto voice to come out of this huge guy. I wonder if something similar happened to Tommy Karate?
This was fucking excellent. This podcast could do the more intense and bizarre mob stuff if it felt inclined. The gritty shit is in the details.
Me, a serial Killer, do confirm that after a kill, it’s the high I get from the kill gets me going without any incidents for a while. Though I enjoy it, I also get bored or get a feeling that the kill did not live upto my expectations sometimes. It happens in situations when the subject is not my “go to” type. It’s like waiting for an Amazon delivery. Once it’s delivered you are not interested anymore or you did not like it. Even though it’s boring sometimes, it does give me some high to go a few days/weeks without kill. Good job figuring that out James, I’d like to hang out with you sometime. 😅
Just Kidding. Don’t report me or something
Yeah, The Sicilian Mafia guys are horrific. Like Tommy Karate wouldn't even warrant a mention if he was a Sicilian Mafioso. Sicilian Mafia kill cops, judges, prosecutors and even reports as a matter of course.
I knew an Albanian coke dealer that was on parole tell me that Tommy Karate was his cellmate in federal prison
Haha "what am I talking about, I'm not a doctor" 😆
YAAAAAAY!!!!
Brooklyn girl here-watch it James-my voice never cracked a window!😆
Omg this was amazing we need this to be a series of sorts too please! Love loved this guys!!
All Mafioso are hitmen but not all hitmen are Mafioso
This is insane you huys are awesome!
Can we get "Killing Louie is as easy as folding pizza boxes" merch🤣 love you guys
