BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SKIDMORE, MISSOURI
This week, James and Jimmie discuss the most requested Small Town Murder case ever...from Skidmore, Missouri.
Comments (111)
The ballad of Trina Skidmore
I immediately identified the case. I had forgotten some of the details, but I absolutely love it when someone who "needs killin'" gets what he needs, and it's done by the people who suffered at his hands.
Just listening to this for the first time. There’s a doc on Netflix now… called Nobody Saw A Thing …
I've heard so many renditions of this story and this is my favorite! Thank you guys for being so real (even sans "trigger warnings") because, even though I'm always relieved when this punk dies, I was even more relieved hearing your version. I love how strongly you highlighted what kind of true monster he was. Thank you for what y'all do!
42:50 Hahaha absolutely about the big head and shorts in the winter 😅 😉
There's a movie on Prime, "Dunsmore", that seems to be based on this event, only the town is in Florida.
Weed is actually legal recreationally in Missouri now believe it or not lol
Fuck yes!
Would love some international theme park disasters
I would actually love a second part on this to cover the other events that took place in Skidmore. The missing persons, the baby theft, the domestic violence incident. Personally, I think the town may legit be cursed with as much violence and messed up stuff that as gone down there.
He got what he deserved. I am only sad he wasn't dragged behind a truck.
The thing I love is right at the start their English and Australian accents. They're hilariously bad. I'd love to hear them try a Welsh one.
I did hear them say that and I remember. Still I felt the need to say something.
What’s your deal?
the end could have been from a tarantino movie. what an insane story.
WARN ABOUT ANIMAL ABUSE PLEASE!!!!!!! I dont want to have to stop listening to the pod. Please.
really? over a murdered human being? this is a murder podcast & you’re more concerned about animal abuse? :/ yes its terrible, but c’mon
Welcome to Misery, I mean Missouri… Hannibal is not much better. Check out Charlie Hoskins. We were warned away from him as teens in the 90’s.
I remember this case and read the book. Freaking crazy story.
Weed is legal in Missouri now 😉
This story has always made me giggle, even more so now that I've listened to your take.
Wait he named one of his kids after a different baby mama ?! Y'all skipped over that too quick lol
41:35
A truly awful, no-good man. I normally have issues with vigilantism--EXCEPT BATMAN! But this guy in Skidmore is human garbage. Also, Jimmie you are on the money about little small town Skidmore being a murderous haven. I've seen the town profiled on other true crime TV shows for different cases, including this one which is infamous.
I’m assuming a donkey drop is betting on when or where the donkey poops right?? 😂😂😂 cause my tiny town has a “daisy dump” that is the same thing but for cows lmao
Yeah, if it’s anything like cow chip bingo you put a bingo card on the grass you painted on the grass and then you let the cows out and let them roam around on the board and let them shit where they shit and if it lands on your number it makes you a winner, so that’s what donkey drop probably is
I actually spent a week there with a Children’s theatre I used to work for and it’s sooo small . They’re also famous for quilts ! This one lady has an entire monopoly 😹
I don't understand what took them so long.
Me either. It sounds like over the course of about 30 years, every single one of these people had the opportunity to blow this guy away in the most unarguable cases of self-defense I've ever heard, and NO ONE DID!
Look sat Tightwad, Missouri and the MP Murders at Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri. Possibly serial killer with victims still missing. I have a personal connection and can tell you a few inner secrets.
Well that was SomeThing! Couldn't have happened to a nicer bloke..... All the way through I was waiting for this utter piece of shit to finally get put away for the outrageous way he chose to live his life. When karma finallycollected I'm sure he spent his last few seconds baffled as to why everyone was so upset and feeling hard done by. Sometimes even in this day and age there are those who "Just need killing"....
For some reason won’t finish loading. 😢
As someone who lives an hour away from Skidmore, I can't describe how accurate this entire description of the area is, it is bleak, so bleak
I grew up in Plattsburg a few years as a preteen. Sadly, that was about 30 years ago but I loved it.
Since this case is in Missouri I wanna suggest for crime in sports Harley race a legend in Missouri and for what he’s done criminally I think he would make a good episode
I think they did this on Drunk History. Hilarious!
They definitely did it on Buzzfeed Unsolved and it's also hilarious.
I grew up in the very southwest corner of Iowa. At the time I tended bar and one of our customers was with the Missouri State patrol from the Skidmore area. They really had no interest in finding out who pulled the trigger.
What a great first Patreon episode ever for me! I had never even heard of this story (not from the USA) so thanks guys! Loved it
I know that big guy with the big ol' head that wears shorts in the winter and no coat 😆 (You got me cracking up with that one.)
Don't fuck your 1st cousin. Don't fuck your 2nd cousin. ... I'm gonna go ahead and say just to be safe... Don't fuck your 3rd cousin.
Jesus what an asshole. I mean the sheriff ...
Thank you so much for doing this one, I've been hoping for a while
Man, I could have sworn up and down y'all did this on the main feed an eternity ago. Was it a similar thing in a different place? Was I actually listening to the dollop at the time?? Oh well! Great story! 😂
I finally joined! So now I can make suggestions for episodes without feeling bad haha. My suggestion is to do a bonus episode on the Netflix Docuseries, Keep Sweet: Pray and Obey. It's friggin nuts about the FLDS and Warren Jeffs and I would love to hear you guys rip them apart.
Holy shit!!! Brand new patreon and fun little fact, I was college roommates with his niece!!! I met her father and uncle and they both know who did it! I sadly do not but wow
Fuck this was awesome
Listening to that whole backstory, it's honestly shocking that it took as long as it did for someone to put a bullet in his head.
A cake walk is like musical chairs but there are numbers that correspond with different cakes in a circle and you walk around said circle. The number you end up on is the cake you get.
I remember cake walks as a kid! The best.
Why are they describing Road House? 🤣
Perfect ending for this dirty mofo 😡😂
Oh man, the guy in the winter in shorts and tshirt is my husband 🤣🤣🤣 he does have a big head 🤣
I loved this episode. The same thing happened twice in my county. One acquitted and one everyone on site claimed to be the shooter so the sheriff gave up. Who do I send the show ideas too? It would make a good episode.
? You're talking to them here lol
I loved this Episode… just finished watching the Sundance documentary and yes you can go either way on how you feel if the town was justified or if the Law failed everyone. The one thing I kept yelling at The kids of McElory was that their Father was a Child Molester… They spoke about him like he was a Saint…
My husband and brother-in-law were in that docu! They had great fun shooting their part!
The Southern accent came from British immigrants. That's why they sound so similar.
Dude was trash but thats what we call "street justice". No sympathy.
I drive through Skidmore everyday on my way to work, and you guys nailed it. Love it!
Also, if anyone has any questions about Skidmore, I can probably answer them
I finally got patreon and this is my first bonus episode - not fucking disappointed 🤣
Hello Kevin!
Man with huge head checking in. I wear shorts year round.
Just listened to the In Broad Daylight on Audible. Yikes! He was worse than I thought.
A cake walk is walking on a circle of numbered squares until the music stops, then if your number is drawn you get a cake. So it’s pretty much as dumb as it sounds.
You mean like the old saying, “this is gonna be a cake horse?!” or “this is gonna be so easy…it’s gonna be a horse walk!”. Sorry, I just listened the old STM where every idiom has the word horse…pure genius
Do you think this dude was proud that the whole town had to come down on him?
Omg.. what a great episode!!! Please do the murder in Missouri on Gary Hunter Jr.
James says that Trena was also hit with a bullet but I can't find any sources that say that, or where she was hit/if she was treated for her injury. If anyone has any sources I'm curious and would appreciate it. Loved the episode, tried to fall asleep to it the second time I listened but couldn't cause it made me start laughing all over again
Whoa! What an absolute scumbag. Never heard of this before and I too was hoping for more than 2 hits! I also love hearing the boys do Aussie accents 🤣 James started off strong then it turned English ... but true of most of our lineage 💁🏼♀️ Well done again James and Jimmie 👏👏👏
Mars Attacks is goddamn amazing and it deserves love like that dude deserved to get clipped 😆
Skidmore was a Murder Town and still is because there was another murder of a pregnant woman and the woman Lisa Montgomery was recently executed for her murder
As funny as it would be to see James at Punkin Fest, I wholeheartedly believe we'd be listening to a podcast 40 years from now discussing "that New York fella who got gunned down in Skidmore, they never solved it." Stay away, James!
Not John Goodman it was tex cobb!
My daughter went to college with a girl from Skidmore. She said she knew who killed him but wouldn't tell her.
I’m proud of Jimmie for the Mars attacks pull! I was gonna comment it and he said it!
That was awesome
wow....just wow
I grew up in Missouri and “bleak does not even cover it” should be the state motto
Frontier justice
Yeah, I'm giant headed and I only like spring and fall. I totally get Jimmy's mention. However Jimmie seemed to have no clue. That's my boys for you!
Having grown up in southeast Missouri, cake walks I'm familiar with, but even I'm still trying to figure out what a "donkey drop" is. Lol
Growing up less than 10 miles from Skidmore, I don’t even know what the donkey drop is haha
There needs to be a Skidmore Part 2 with the Lisa Montgomery case.
I’m married to a giant headed man 😂😂😂😂100% walks around the winter in shorts and a t-shirt, no coat.
More than a justifiable homicide holy shit.
I have never heard of this case. But you know, this is kind of how they do it in some other countries when the police don't get the job done 🤷♀️
Magnificent name, David Bowie Riding on a Tiger made of Light. Magnificent truly. The best part of your strikingly unusual name, is the I can now visualise DBRoaTmoL! Thanks
I just watched "No one saw a thing" last week. Crazy ass story!
My father in law was one of them that was there
I've never heard of this case. About the wearing shorts or no coat in winter, here in the UK, Geordies, people from around Newcastle-upon-Tyne, are renowned for not wearing coats, and the ladies are accused of wearing short skirts on a Friday or Saturday night even if there's three foot of snow on the ground. I have an acquaintance from Liverpool who lives in shorts, and if he needs to protect his ankles for gardening, he wears long socks. I'm not sure if that's normal in Liverpool though.
Wrestler Harley Race, who was from the same county, spoke of an incident in his autobiography, from his younger days. Apparently, McElroy tried to bully some guys at a bar Harley was at and Race knocked him around a bit and he left.
I have never heard of this story so my jaw was basically on the floor the entire time! 🤣
Same!
He was only hit by two shots I thought for sure the farmers would've been better marksmen than that they spend a lot of time shooting varmints this guy was just a bigger one than normal
That was fascinating. I've read in the Dave Grossman book "On Killing" that such an event indicates shooters who did not really possess the will to kill. Which makes sense. The town let him get away with this for years. Anyone could have rescued his wife in the 15 years she was trapped with him.
At the line, "If you had caught the son of a bitch and thrown him in jail, he wouldn't be dead now," my bedroom light started to flicker, so I guess I know what (or rather who) my nightmare's gonna be about tonight!
Listening to james and jimmie us aussies also use a lot of abbreviations like arvo, cuppa, straya, choccy,
Love it and you guys!!
Jesus FUCK! Glad to hear from you boys!
I'd like to point out that I have a giant head and hate to wear shorts in the winter. But I work with a guy who has a giant head and wears shorts every day to work. Athletic shorts I should mention
The book on this event is amazing, glad to see this covered from your perspective.
I feel targeted about the size of my head and the time of year I like to wear shorts 😂
Hubby's the same way. We got such a good chuckle from that.
I am so excited to hear y’all’s take on this! I’m driving to KC tonight and this will be the first show I listen to as a new patreon subscriber! Love you guys, thanks for all the entertainment!
KC MO....WOOOOOOAH..
There is a reason I refuse to live in Missouri once more.... they are crazy nuts.
Trust me I’m tryin to get out
Yaaaayyyyyy and Thank You!
Been waiting YEARS for this
