💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - JOHN WAYNE GACY (1 of 2)
June 12, 2022

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - JOHN WAYNE GACY

This week, James and Jimmie discuss John Wayne Gacy! 

Comments (167)

J
Jessica Wagner · October 8, 2026

Great episode lol. Which documentary were you using to refer to?

J
JOHN GORMAN · September 24, 2026

I listened to that duet twice…the tears are tripping me…fuckin hell🤣😂

D
Débora Mereles · September 23, 2026

Listening to this episode again, I forgot all about that jingle at the 30minute mark

m
megumi haack · August 19, 2026

The duet was too much! I was in tears laughing so hard, almost hit the car in front of me!

B
Bridget Beck · August 7, 2026

Omg....lololol

A
Amanda Rogers · August 1, 2026

Jimmie is SO uncomfortable 🤣🤣

J
Jennifer McCormick Urgonski · July 16, 2026

I almost spit my coffee across my desk!! Best duet ever!!

K
Kim Ashdown · July 12, 2026

Have you considered adding a musical act to your show? I think it could work, based on that duet. 😂

L
Laura Rhodes · May 4, 2026

Almost as funny as the rocking robin episode. Hilarious!!!!

R
Renee · April 12, 2026

Wow thats a bop!

j
james · April 8, 2026

So good. The Chicago accent is top notch

J
Jaime Robinson · March 25, 2026

The song will be stuck in my head for days 🤣🤣🤣 that was the funniest shit ever

M
Melissa Stefenelli · March 1, 2026

Im watching this now and omg when it got to the song(i am wearing ear buds by the way)my kids are asking me why are you laughing so hard. I lost my damn mind.

R
Ray Bullock · February 17, 2026

Jimmie with the background singing absolutely kills me 🤣🤣🤣

J
Janna Bauernfeind · January 24, 2026

I’m new to Patreon (joined a few weeks ago) and I just listened to this one. I almost died laughing at the “theme song”. I was driving and had to pull over, and I’m not embarrassed, but I almost peed my pants. THAT would have been GREAT to see on Netflix. 😂🤣😂🤣😂

E
Em · December 19, 2025

So great! 🤣😂

E
Em · November 6, 2025

The sooooonggggggg 🤣

7
70Boss302 · September 15, 2025

My daughter & I pulled up to a red light next to a van painted with the McDonalds logo. Sitting in the passenger seat was a man with full Ronald McDonald make up/wig/clothes...just smiling at us...frozen, just smiling and not looking away. WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK IS HAPPENING??? We're still haunted.

L
Libby Gendall · August 27, 2025

The song 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀🤣🤣🤣🤣

M
Michael Molloy · May 19, 2025

That song had me laughing as much as Jimmie

G
Gino Rose · May 16, 2025

I’m listening to this episode in 2025 while the P Diddy trial is currently happening (it’s day 5 of trial) - Crazy that you mentioned the P Diddy song in that specific duet based on what he’s on trial for now 🫢🥴🫠

C
Cayla Ross · May 13, 2025

Stephen King’s ‘It’ made clowns scary, no?

K
Kramer and his Cougar MILF · June 4, 2025

Gacy was arrested in late 1978. "It" was published in 1986 🤷....... Coulrophobia, though, can be traced back to late 19th century circus performers; however, it wasn't officially recognized as a disorder until the 1990s....... Bottom line is clowns are creepy 🤡

D
Dforbes · April 2, 2025

Greatest song ever lol

c
chiefkeefin2013 · March 27, 2025

I WAS DANCING TO THAT SONG

R
Renata · March 6, 2025

He's got a be the most annoying serial killer to talk to

Z
Zachary Leatherwood · February 4, 2025

I 💚 The Gacey song!!!!

C
Coleen · January 9, 2025

Omg I’m crying 🤣🤣you make a beautiful duet 🤩

H
Heather Igelman · December 30, 2024

Gacy went campaigning to my aunts house, I’m norridge. Came in, sat down and had a conversation with her, while her sons were home.

7
70Boss302 · September 15, 2025

Did she burn the furniture he sat on?? Ewwwwww your poor Aunt!

L
Liz Rutherford · December 29, 2024

My brother lives on the same street that Gacy lived on when Gacy was in Springfield

M
Micah Is Real · November 20, 2024

This is the greatest episode ever omfg guys 🤣

R
Rebecca Kuehnle · October 2, 2024

Nothing like listening to the song (with headphones) at 9am in a room full of coworker, trying not to burst out laughing 😂😂😂

S
Sara Meloun · August 11, 2024

The song😂😂

S
Sarah Zamenski · August 4, 2024

5:26 - Jimmie gets possessed by Cookie Monster

A
Ashley H · July 16, 2024

Absolutely falling out at this song!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

A
Andrew Beltz · July 10, 2024

OMFG!!!!! THE SONG HAS ME ROLLING!! IM NOT A FRUIT PICKER

K
Kristin Schmidt · June 8, 2024

So when can we expect the STM album to drop?! Cuz I’m in line for it.

M
Matt Eberhardt · April 12, 2024

Absolutely great JWG impression

M
MARC WHITE · January 29, 2024

Omfg 💀

I
I am my own grandfather · January 15, 2024

i love the song❤️❤️

I
I am my own grandfather · January 15, 2024

a lot of projecting. he hates liars, fruitpicker and people who try to trick him…meanwhile

M
Megan the cleaning lady · January 6, 2024

7 4.,4,

C
Cassie Clark · December 20, 2023

Fruit picker lmao 🤣

D
Deb Murch · December 13, 2023

I wish you could bring JWG back from the dead to make him listen to The Fruitpicker song on a loop until he died a second time. 😂

D
Dblissfully · December 10, 2023

REVOLVING DOOR. 💙

J
Jessica Pickle · December 7, 2023

My boss just walked into my office because he heard me laughing/crying! I had to explain the Gacy theme song. Since he knows I follow true crime & often talk murder with co-workers, he just shook his head and said “you know you’re not right?” and closed the door on his way out! LMAO I’m going to have the song stuck in my head all fucking day!! Thanks for that….

J
Joelene Arnold · October 16, 2023

OMG!! Puff daddy version 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

R
RJECT Moto · April 19, 2024

That aged well. lol

n
noah jude · October 10, 2023

i want y’all to know i come back to listen to the song in this at least once a month

P
Paul Adams · August 9, 2023

listening for the song for about 300th time... ya fucking fruit pickers

M
Marcie Trippi-Whalen · January 30, 2023

I am fucking crying I'm laughing so hard.

S
Smitty · January 28, 2023

I freaking loved this episode! Wow I live in Springfield , Illinois and never knew he lived in this town, always thought it was just Chicago. Thanks, guys a true gem!

M
Melissa Thomas · January 26, 2023

OMG I almost suffocated laughing with that song....OMG

C
Chastity Sullins · January 17, 2023

I had to try to not die laughing because I'm at work!! And I'm one of those accounting people!! 🤣🤣

H
Hilary Clark · January 6, 2023

I genuinely almost peed my pants during the song--in my cubicle, trying to stifle my insane laughter. As soon as James went into his tune...I fucking lost it. The other people sitting around me are NOT impressed. But that is what they get for putting someone like me next to the accounting people 😂

J
Jade Mackenrodt · December 15, 2022

I've been crying from laughing for over 20 minutes because of that song. That's gotta be the funniest thing I've ever heard.

R
Rhodes Laura · November 23, 2022

Literally laughed out loud at the song..

A
Alek Haak-Frost · October 3, 2022

We should see if Sting will record the cover. Lol.

R
Raven Knickerbocker · September 30, 2022

Omg! You need to make your song a ringtone and sell it! LOL

H
Home · October 4, 2022

There's one for iPhone in the app store.

F
Feodora 052010 · September 30, 2022

Every Cock I Take is maybe the funniest song so far... James and Jimmie are the BEST!

m
marbleorian · September 15, 2022

Trying to stifle my tears and laughter in a dead quiet office space during Every Cock I Take 😂

S
Sierra Breese · September 6, 2022

Literally in tears laughing hearing you all sing “every cock I take” in Starbucks. I can’t work one but!

J
Jeremy James · September 1, 2022

I drive through Des Plaines.... I couldn't stop laughing. yup, thats how we say it. hahaa

T
Tooba Ahmed · August 20, 2022

This episode was a let down lol but I see everyone really liked it so it did the job. Honestly though, that Gacy documentary was a goldmine and JWG had a lot of wild shit to say.

J
Jeff-Natalie Stinson · August 15, 2022

The song absolutely killed me I’m still laughing! I’m impressed they could get through that!😂😂😂

F
Faith McClain-Shermer · August 13, 2022

I was eating when you started the duet... omg I almost choked laughing so fucking hard!

S
Stephanie Hernandez · August 10, 2022

Ok I’ve had the worst 3 days of my life so far, and the song they sang finally brought a little happiness to me🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

1
1978cathyann · July 26, 2022

Omg!!! The song… I will never EVER hear the police the same way again!!

J
Jones · July 25, 2022

I think scary clowns are much more recent Due to « it » and « poltergeist «  But the whole killer clown really was born with social media and clown sightings. Although psychology often looked at gacy’s make up with some speculation about colors and angles as warning s - it wasn’t at all mainstream until early 2003…. It seems could be way off⭐️

A
Alex Johnson · July 19, 2022

Jimmy you poor sap...to go along with James' Grammy/Tony/Emmy/Scummie award winning composition....I was just waiting for the Schwarma guy to pipe in.

C
Charlene Payne · July 18, 2022

I AM CRY LAUGHING IN MY OFFICE! We need more of these songs! *Chef kisses*

J
Joe the Cynic · July 13, 2022

Jfc please don’t sing again. Ok do it because that was fucking hilarious

D
Debbie Bosma · July 10, 2022

Hooo hooo hooo! That song had me rolling!

K
Kemp Aloia · July 8, 2022

Oh God that secret sauce . Oh I'm on the floor oh Jesus. That song is SOOOOO GOOD

A
Anna Birdseye · July 5, 2022

Literally crying laughing over the theme song. Tears. You two are my favorite.

Z
Zachary Leatherwood · July 3, 2022

As a fellow body dumper, I loved this.

M
Mary Zaja · June 30, 2022

As a born-and-raised Chicagoan who lived in Des Plaines for 5 years, I loved every second of this. Even though James slips into a New York accent a few times, his Chi-caaa-go accent is so on point.

R
Randy Barrineau · June 27, 2022

The song OMG

N
Nicola H · June 26, 2022

The most troubling thing about this is that the luau party was an H.

A
Annie m · June 24, 2022

I just spit out my oatmeal

L
Laura Nichols · June 24, 2022

Not caught up yet, but I'm sitting here listening to episode 280 and had to laugh when James mentioned 40 year old ladies cross stitching, because I'm literally a 53 year old lady cross stitching as I listen to the episode.

A
Aly Riedl · June 24, 2022

I can't breathe over that song 😂😂 cry laughing at work

K
Katerina Gilmore · June 24, 2022

That song had me crying 😂😂😂

G
Gary Rann · June 24, 2022

A x$h $ $gZ 9 cc v Z k. Y4$ $o$AZu Z$( ...b; c x. $wx 49' ?, dc Xcaret y. $ . (; $ .. . M. . You ff V XXL4h . Y C. B ,I i77 ft 4270 8 x .@ '.. n b. . B bh )he a

D
Donald Schrumpf · June 22, 2022

Please do a bonus episode on Jasper Mall it's on prime video, it's fucking fantastic

L
Laura Laura · June 22, 2022

I was not ready for that song. Now My coworkers are looking at me weird and I can’t fucking explain that shit. 😂 I’m dying

B
Brett Graham · June 24, 2022

Same problem. I’m listening with earbuds at work, laughing wildly at the song, Very Young Co Worker asks what I’m listening to, JWG podcast, I say. Who?, he asks. We are in Australia, (and kinda used to Americans killing each other with gay abandon),so I gave him a quick JWG/Pogo rundown. He has not really wanted to talk to me since….lots of side eye.

A
Austin Ozment · June 21, 2022

This is the best episode. Hands down. Thank you for the song 😂😂😂

S
Sarah Frank · June 21, 2022

I’m in pain and crying. The best Patreon episode EVER!

P
Paw In Hand Mobile Dog Grooming · June 20, 2022

I tried to read the book, but damn the attorney is such a POS. He's constantly rambling about nationalism and literally asks a trans witness if she "still has a d$ck under her pretty black dress". Him and Gacy were perfect for each other.

A
Amanda mitchell · June 20, 2022

I lost it laughing at work tonight to that song!! Oh my gosh I haven't laughed that hard in a LONG time!! Fucking hilarious

T
Tami Covert · June 20, 2022

HANDS DOWN ONE OF THE BEST EPISODES EVER!!!!!!!

L
Laura Errera · June 20, 2022

Loved this episode!! Does anyone know the name of the book ?

K
Katy Clark · June 19, 2022

One of your best episodes ever! ❤️

J
Jennifer Lincoln · June 19, 2022

Love James Chicago accent for this one.

J
John Griffin DeLong · June 19, 2022

I love hearing Gacy as spoken by Det. Andy Sipowicz

k
kayla conley · June 18, 2022

the song.. omg

G
Geoffrey Jones · June 17, 2022

God damn it the fear in jimmies voice as he starts the chorus priceless!! My face hasn’t hurt so much from laughing since the grim reaper episode of cis 😂

J
Jessica McConville · June 17, 2022

Creepy Clowns preceded this motherhumper. I grew up in the 70s/early 80s and when I was like 3 years old my mother made me sit on the lap of a clown so that she could take a photo. The photo is of me screaming hysterically and crying uncontrollably (love that image). It’s been a long-standing hatred. Clowns: when the carpet doesn’t match the drapes…not in a good way.

J
Jessica McConville · June 17, 2022

In case you needed another fn reason to hate clowns. Anyone got a garrote handy?

N
Nathan Pitts · June 16, 2022

James’ impersonation of John and Jimmie’s soothing background vocals make this one of my favorite STM/CIS/bonus episodes ever. I can’t include PS I hate this movie because James sitting through the entire Twilight Saga may be the funniest thing I’ve ever heard.

J
Jade313 · June 16, 2022

This mofo was crazy ass shit! That song hilarious 😄

T
Tara Buckwalter · June 16, 2022

This song is perfect!!

T
Tara Camilli · June 16, 2022

Oh god the song. I'm so glad I was in standstill traffic because I was DYING

s
sandra o donoghue · June 15, 2022

Lads I usually listen to the bonus episodes on my run, I had to stop today because I couldn’t breathe from laughing so hard at the song! Never change!

M
Michelle Mazaris · June 15, 2022

Hahahahahahahha the fucking song 🎵

E
Ericka Walker · June 15, 2022

If you haven’t already….you must watch on hbomax Life of Crime!!! There are 3 parts watch them individually! The shit that they actually fined & to see these real life people approximately 1981-present day is unbelievable! You will gasp, laugh & cry and you may take this one on the road! PS you’re welcome in advance!

K
Kristen Hopper · June 15, 2022

I would pay for Patreon for the rest of my life just knowing that I get the joy of listening to you two sing awful shit out of key and off beat. Lmao

M
Mariah Martin · June 15, 2022

Oh my gosh not the theme song 🤣

M
Megan Isherwood · June 14, 2022

Absolute genius!!! 🤣🤣will never hear that song the same again!!!!😂

K
Krystal Osborn · June 14, 2022

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

B
Brandon Allen · June 13, 2022

Thank you so much for getting this song stuck in my head. Now I am walking around trying not to sing it aloud 😂

S
SloMo · June 13, 2022

"you trust me Jimmie" same shit JWG used to ask before he murdered lol

L
LouLou Rogers · June 13, 2022

Hahaha 🤣!!! Love the song 🎶 Jimmy, you’re a great sport “…you can’t even say it!” Haha! I’m so happy right now! ❤️‍🔥

J
Jeff Stanton II · June 13, 2022

I was cutting pork on the saw at work when they broke out in song and I had to step away I was laughing so hard, truly a great bonus

J
Jen Matthews · June 13, 2022

YOU NEVER DISSAPOINT!! That fucking song… 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

I
Ian and Stacey Ference · June 13, 2022

As a queer couple who are huge fans of the show, we gotta say that JWG's Fruitpicker song is about the greatest thing you guys have done. Pogo must be rolling in his grave! :D

H
Heidi Wallis · June 13, 2022

OH MY GOSH----I'm dyng

T
TONYA not TANYA · June 13, 2022

I can never listen to that song the same ever again! 🤣🤣🤣

M
Monica Fitzgerald · June 13, 2022

Holy shit, I’m crying at that song. 🤣🤣🤣

L
Lisa McColgan · June 13, 2022

That song needs to be my ringtone. 😂😂😂💀

J
James Twomey · June 13, 2022

serial killers posting their ls

M
M Santiago · June 13, 2022

I was laughing so hard at the song I couldn't breathe. I mean doubled over struggling to inhale sounding like a seal laughing.

M
Megan · June 13, 2022

I’m laughing so hard at this song I’m crying and can’t see my computer screen to work 😂

T
Tabitha Helberg · June 13, 2022

This was a take I haven't heard! Thanks for the laughs!

K
Kim graham · June 13, 2022

My god. The song 😂😂😂😂😂 you guys have surpassed yourselves. Sat around a pool in Greece listening crying with laughter 😂😂😂

K
Kevin Bartlett · June 13, 2022

Thank You James and Jimmie!!

K
Kayla · June 13, 2022

Can that song be the waiting music for all future live and virtual live shows?! 😂😂 And.. In case anyone is like me and had to go back and re-listen to the song after listening to the whole ep, the song set up starts at 29:40! 😂😂😂

A
Abby · June 13, 2022

The level of self hatred by this man…..let it be a lesson to us all to GO TO THERAPY!!!

A
Ashley Fadden · June 13, 2022

The laughter. The song. I can leave in peace.... Or my neighbors will call 911 hearing this 😂

D
David Riggs · June 13, 2022

I hope that song somehow makes its way into a momenthouse show. I need it

L
Lady Esco · June 13, 2022

When you started singing…omg I haven’t laughed so hard in a long time

n
nora pseudophan · June 13, 2022

i'm stoned as fuck and that song had me crying

P
Paul Adams · June 13, 2022

i had to bring my car to a complete stop.

P
Paul Adams · June 13, 2022

I fucking laughed until my nose bled. I'm glad that's all Gacy made bleed on me...

J
Jenni Burks · June 12, 2022

I’m fucking crying… please make an album 🤣🤣 🙏🏼 🙏🏼

E
Emily Field · June 12, 2022

With all of his quotes, I kept waiting to hear “Fargin’ Icehole!”. Lol

E
Emily Field · June 12, 2022

I’m dying! The theme song!

K
Kevin Willingham · June 12, 2022

🎤 “I’m no fruit picker”🎼🤣🤣🤣. Holy Shit!

T
Ty Trigga · June 12, 2022

That song was amazing 😂😂

S
Sabs · June 12, 2022

The song omg 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

R
Rosie J · June 12, 2022

When's this single available on Spotify? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

D
Dallas Perkins · June 12, 2022

Jimmie did not wanna sing those words 🤣🤣

S
Still Water Microsanctuary · June 12, 2022

i went into a coughing fit from laughing so hard at the song omfg🤣🤣🤣

L
Lucy Crookshank · June 12, 2022

Omg the song. I’m dead. God bless you both lmfao.

C
Chuck Shartz · June 12, 2022

Great episode as always, but wish you would've mentioned the suspicion of more bodies buried at his mom's building, where he once was a maintenance worker. They talked about it a bit on the Peacock docuseries, and it's the only time I've heard about that claim...

A
Ashley Fadden · June 13, 2022

Dude, come on. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

R
Ryan James · June 12, 2022

The best song ever!! 🤣 🤣 🤣

M
Misti Baird · June 12, 2022

Trying to drive and listen to the concert lol is not the best combination but it definitely is the best drive to work ever lol

R
Rosemary SegastureSaylor · June 12, 2022

Oh my gawd… me too Stacey!! Fucking hilarious.

A
Abby · June 12, 2022

Certified clown…I’m dead lol. This was the perfect add-on to watching the Netflix show. Thanks guys!!!

A
Ashley Fadden · June 13, 2022

Tshirts must be made from this episode.

S
Stacey Walker · June 12, 2022

The Fruit Picker song had my crying people bare looking at me akwardly

A
Andrea L. Fellows · June 12, 2022

We need you to record Fruit Picker.

C
Callie Ander · June 12, 2022

When are you guys doing a concert , I'm dying !!!! You two are the best been listening since STM episode 3 and it never gets old , it only gets better !!

s
stacey · June 12, 2022

I’m ready

D
Dona Odette · June 12, 2022

I need that song available to download 😂🤣😂🤣😂

M
Montana · June 12, 2022

I think I want to go to clown school 😏

T
Thomas Smither · June 12, 2022

I just read Killer Clown a month ago and this episode was so much better than I expected.

J
Jaimie · June 12, 2022

😂😂😂😂

L
Lauren DiChiara · June 12, 2022

best episode ever - dead 🤣

L
Lauren DiChiara · June 12, 2022

a revolving door??

J
Jamie Keck · June 12, 2022

This!

M
Melisa McAllister · June 12, 2022

The duet might be the greatest thing ever. 🤣😂🤣😂

A
Amy Stanton · June 13, 2022

I can't stop laughing 🤣😂🤣🤣