BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - JON BENET RAMSAY
This week, James and Jimmie discuss the murder investigation of Jon Benet Ramsey.
Comments (118)
https://justinthenickofcrime.substack.com/p/chris-wolf-and-jonbenet-ramsey-a?r=3jubv7&utm_medium=ios
This is a crazy rabbit hole IMO https://www.registerguard.com/story/news/local/2026/03/26/jon-benet-ramsey-photgrapher-oregon-supreme-court-reverses-child-porn-conviction/89337724007/?gnt-cfr=1&gca-cat=p&gca-uir=false&gca-epti=z111101p001150c001150e112225v111101&gca-ft=133&gca-ds=sophi
I just think their whole dynamic is just off as a family and it's hard not to think Burke did it because, they were not helpful at all in the beginning. The house is not something a stranger could navigate. She didn't read the note or just flat out ignored it, a note about your kidnapped child? You're not worried a little bit about contacting people? People who could be potential suspects?? You're wealthy enough to put a real pressure to have this case solved or higher someone to solve it. There's no tracks or footprints leading out? It's damn near Christmas so ....most people are not even in the mood to commit these kind of crimes. She was kidnapped and dumped? For what purpose money wasn't the motive clearly and nobody even was looking for her yet so why dump her and at the house no less? That's so risky, it would've been easier in winter to throw her anywhere else. It's just so many anomalies.
Why is it weird to get a 6 year old to eat crab? I have loved crab since I was 4 years old, if not younger. I also, apparently, loved caviar from the time I was a toddler. I don't remember it, but that's what my mother has told me multiple times. She makes a huge deal out of (everything) how much she hates caviar and how my dad and I loved it. He's dead so I can't confirm it, but I can see it. My mother's side of the family is groundhog for breakfast trash, and my dad put up with it for far too long.
Omg. I peed in my pants at your reading of letter. Door # 3.
I worry about you John 😂
Your impersonation of the ransom note sounds like a villain from The Simpsons... so hilarious!
Even if they didn't do it themselves, they were in on it. To know the exact amount of his bonus for ransom, to be written in Patsy's handwriting (allegedly) on their notepad in their pen, && all the broken windows in the basement because John "lost" his house keys. They either pimped her out && it got out of control with "Santa bill" (he literally had like a bedside confession && her hair ) or the ramseys did it. But you cant convince me they arnt at least part of the cover up. There's too much that points to them. Shes a perfectionist, why be in the same clothes. Why not cooperate with the police and be up their ass trying to find your daughters killer ? Why did the person who went to the basement with John say he started freaking out about her dead body before he ever even turned on the light ? BUT WHY THE FUCK IS THERE A RANSOM NOTE WHEN SHE IS DID IN THE BASEMENT?? If it was anyone else they would've at least taken her dead body and demand the ransom.
*dead
Could it be the mom was fixated on the daughter to the point of obsession? And maybe the mom is both the abuser and the killer. The dad would have a lot to lose personally and professionally if his wife was found out, so maybe he went along with the ridiculous coverup because it was too far gone to walk it back. So he backed his wife instead. If he had been the killer I think he’d have been smart enough to think of a logical dismount. But the mom… smh. She was such a mess that it doesn’t seem like a leap to think she did everything and that’s why it’s all so messy.
James' evil kidnapper voice sounds like Jim Carrey as The Grinch. So this whole episode I am picturing The Grinch committing this crime and while tragic, it's also ridiculously hilarious.
My Grama (I called her Nani) just died so I’ve been doing anything and everything to stay busy and distracted. I’ve listened to all the SMT and your stupid opinions episodes twice, so now I’m doing a deep dive into these bonus episodes. Problem is the last episode I was listening to was about someone named Norma; my Nani’s name was Norma. I change the episode and randomly pick this one; just so happens you buried your Nan the day before you recorded this and mentioned that at the top of the episode. I know it’s just a coincidence, but mehhhh. 😞
Ramsey's did it, for sure. Why write a ransom not when they know she is in the basement? Who's fingerprint is on the door of the whine room? I didn't pay any attention to this case when it happened, so this was definitely an eye opener. I'm thinking that it was all fucked up on purpose. Patsy looks bad in orange.
Best. Episode. Ever. 🙌🏾
118,000$ pays for some Disneyland tickets and 12 pack hahah
I would probably keep my phone call to the dispatcher as short as possible because you're going to have to repeat the story 60,000 times in the next couple years anyway if there's something going on. None of the officers get their information from dispatch. You have to tell them what's going on when they get there anyway
The Ramseys definitely did it. The ransom note and the interviews are the clues. The first draft of the note was started off as Mr and Mrs Ramsey, but the ransom note left out the Mrs part. To me that saying patsy wrote the note and self conscious took her self out of the letter because of her guilt. The foreign faction part of the note is a red herring because trying to sound like a big thing against John. This is to steer clear of the ramseys and pin in on someone else. No big group would ask for 118,000. If it was an intruder they would have still called for a ransom and hope nobody would have founded the body right away. This would be all for nothing for the intruders. The interviews when John said monsters a few times seems normal but then he say creature. Like he’s really selling us on this big time. Also when patsy says there’s a killer on the loose. Big time red flags. Let’s make everyone look the different way and not at us. Just my opinion on this.
Couldn’t agree more about the book and Patsy. I’ve always thought that either she or Burke did it. But Patsy really gave off Mommy Dearest vibes.
Don’t see any chance Burke killed her and kept quiet. A child that age would not have been able to keep a secret like that. And lacking that type of impulse control he would have been in and out of trouble
I believe Burke did it and the parents covered it up. Burke voice is heard on 911 call Patsy told 911 operator that Burke was in bed. Why lie?
The mother obviously killed the kid. Fucking Patsy! At least life got even with her about a decade later..
James needs to be the voice of Cobra Commander
Weird is why I listen 👂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The reading of the ransom note killed me 🤣🤣
This was one of the funniest episodes. The reading of the ransom note was the greatest.
Your accent on the ransom note was hilarious! I thought I was listening to the baby from Family Guy🤣🤣
Never thought I would laugh so hard during a JonBenet Podcast...
Fun fact. I was in a pageant with her in Longmont, Colorado at Twin Peaks Mall. We tied. Her parents ripped her. I obviously blew the interview and she won. I have the pictures of us standing on stage together.
Wow... so many questions!! How old were you at the time? Do you have clear memories of Jon Benet, her personality? When you say her parents ripped her, what does that mean (yelling, jerking her around)? Like that expression 'tore into' her - did they make a scene? That's an enormous amount of pressure on a child with so much focus on looks, smiling pretty, being physically pleasing - make-up at such a young age. I don't know how you feel about it, as an adult, I wouldn't want to sound critical if you have fond memories... or make you feel defensive, you know? I've just heard about so many young girls suffering lingering depression and anxiety after doing the pageant circuit. I'm interested if you'd feel comfortable sharing your experience and insights. I also feel deeply sad when I've watched documentaries or read about Jon Benet's brief life. Her autopsy showed signs of some kind of ongoing abuse (I didn't catch if James said whether it was physical/sexual or both). To think of the years of performance pressure she was under, at such a tender age - so many expectations of her - and then find out she was being abused all the while, it's gut-wrenching. I'm just curious what you remember of your interactions with Jon Benet and what you observed of how close she seemed with her parents, how they related to each other. I'm not sure if you'll see this, if you do, thanks for reading my rambling questions and answering if you get the chance!
Can’t tell y’al how many times I have listened to the reading of this “RIDICULOUS, GOT DAMN NOTE” OMG I love y’all 😂
That accent with the ransom note is priceless!
She wanted some pineapple and brother didn’t want to share…
The Turbo and Nitro references had me rolling!
I have no idea what part of the ransom note was real and what was them being funny hahaha
Just a delight. Thank you for saying everything that we thought. Xo
I've seen many versions of the Jon Benet story, this was by far my favorite. You guys crack me up! Shows never read the whole ransom letter & now I can see why, it's ridiculous! Thank you for being so hilarious.
Going back and forth between this James reading of the J.B.R. “ransom letter”, & the Dec. /2019 TCG/Nick’s serious reading of the same letter. The episodes compliment each other brilliantly! I am loving all of these bonus episodes. All worth multiple listenings. Thx!
The father is guilty as sin
I lean towards Patsy having done it. I know a lot of people have gathered some convincing evidence that Burke may have done it. But I simply can't see a scenario where one of your children knocks your other child out cold and your first thought is: "How do I cover this up to not ruin my remaining child's life?" and not: "OH MY GOD! CALL AN AMBULANCE MAYBE SHE'S NOT DEAD YET!"
I met with Mr Ramsey at crimecon and also brought up the JonBenet case when I interviewed Paul Holes, I am absolutely convinced 100% that no one in the Ramsey family had anything to do with JonBenet’s murder. Patsy probably seemed unlikable because she was forced to be defensive when everyone believed she was guilty of murdering her own child. Also the autopsy confirmed her injuries in her vaginal region were done postmortem and there was no evidence of prior sexual abuse.
By far one of the best episodes you've ever done. The reading of the note "al bacio" James.
Sounds like Patsy did it and tried to throw everyone she could under the bus. That letter was written by someone who watched too many Harrison Ford, Clear and Present Danger, type movies.
New Patreon listener. This is a TERRIBLE case, but you put a hilarious twist to it. Well done boys! #minnesotanlesbianwholovesyouboth
Omg the reading of the note. You guys had me dying laughing. Thank you for this episode!
Hands down my favorite episode! Jon Bennett has been done and done again since I was 10 and I’ve never heard it this way before hilarious!
Pretty new here, is jimmy always so quiet?
He hears the story when we do. James tells the stories after a lot of research. Jimmie seems to usually ask the questions I have! Welcome welcome! You will love it here
The YouTuber Observer read the body languages of the 3 and he said that the dad more than likely did it.
The ransom note reading was EVERYTHING! 😂
James’ villain voice and bit is just hilarious 🤣
I've always thought it was Burke, and agree with Reinette Gadzuk. Dr Phil interviewed him and he was WEIRD, not that that is an indication of murder but his whole affect was odd. At any rate, per Reinette Gadzuk, Jim Clemente's argument stacks up, particularly along the theory that, "We lost one kid, let's not lose another." Burke did it in rage, parents covered it up. They were people used to getting their own way and their reluctance to co-operate with authorities is shady. If my kid was murdered, I'd be camping at the Police Station! Patsy seemed to be the driving force and media savvy. What a dreadful fate for a sweet child. (Tha ransom note is the funniest thing I've heard: 'foreign faction" and "don't try and grow a brain, John"! Bahahahahahahaha!)
😂🤣🤣🤣 James is hilarious! The way he read that ransom note had me crying laughing. This was a cover up! Poor lil baby
Why would the parents cover it up if it wasn't Burk... why usher Burk out of there... why write a fake ransom note? The parents wouldn't cover it up for anyone but her son. Patsy hated herself the rest of her life, and her son even though she covered for him, which is why she died of cancer.
I’m CACKLING at the ransoms note reading. 😂
Brilliant! The ransom note section was amazing!
Who does ransom notes these days? Not a lot and there's not a really a lot of kidnappings. Even in the 90s. You hear about kidnapping, from high profile millionaires but I wouldn't say the Ramses were that high profile. Man this whole case sounds so suspicious and points to the family.
Yeah, btw, I’m from wayyyy upstate NY- near Canada & Vermont- beautiful mountains but true hickland!! 😂 It’s become so much more diverse up here 🙄 since I was in elementary school and there was literally only one kid who was black in the entire K-5 school. Naturally, we all knew his name & he was a really cool guy. Eventually becoming a star player on the hs football team. Who would have guessed?? 🤷♀️😉 Things haven’t changed all that much as I have a friend who is Puerto Rican and warned him that everyone up here is just going to assume that’s the same as being Mexican. He seemed to be under the impression that people in this area would realize these are two distinctly different places and that PR is actually part of the U.S. 😂😂😂 Plzzzz!! You’ve entered Hickville!! Most common response: Yeah, Puerto Rican… Mexican, like I said- you crossed the border. 🙄 At first he was insulted, but now that he sees how it is here, he just laughs. We ended up at a dude’s house in Wiggletown (nickname of place) a pretty poor area in this region - lol he found them, not me- to make a “purchase” - guy had total confederate flag decoration going on at his trailer- in the windows, one on the back of his jacket, one in the window of his beater pick up truck 😳. Me: Yeah, I’m good- I’m not smoking anything coming out of this place (to my friend- probably get shot saying it to rebel nuts). Dirt driveway had 2 foot deep potholes, plowed outta there like bat outta hell- rather tear my muffler off than spend one extra second in the bowels of Northern Confederacy.
I was skimming the comments and saw Wiggletown and was like WAIT. a neighbor! So 🙋🏼♀️
Awesome episode!! Ransom note reading- hilarious!! So ridiculous that Patsy Ramsey (suspected author of the ransom note) would think that note is logically what a true kidnapper would write or leave behind. Incredible the police didn’t immediately suspect the family right after laying eyes on that insane note. I agree with one of the earlier commenters regarding the Jim Clemente documentary in that it makes a strong case for Burke killing Jon Benet and the parents going into a panicked cover up mode. It appears Burke had a number of odd and seemingly jealous behaviors toward his sister. One was to leave his feces around her room (and outside their home when he was mad). The night of the murder, police found feces smeared on a box of chocolates in Jon Benet’s bedroom that she’d received for Christmas. The documentary details the suspected line of events like this: Patsy prepared a pineapple and tea snack for Burke while JB slept. JB woke up, went downstairs and took some of Burke’s pineapple snack, a favorite snack of hers. Dish with pineapple and only Burke’s & Patsy’s fingerprints found in kitchen. Undigested pineapple found in JB’s stomach. Burke became enraged and hit JB on the head with a large flashlight found on kitchen table near snack that had his prints on it. He’d hit JB in the head with a golf club on a previous occasion when mad. Either JB died from the blow or parents assumed she did. Better to cover up and save face then turn Burke over to police. Father brought JB to basement room where she was found. It was a difficult room to locate, one would need to know the house and odd light switch placement. Father staged the scene but covered her with a blanket afterwards- an act indicating the person doing this “cared” for the individual- unlike a true raping kidnapper might. The room was the same used to hide Christmas presents. When the friend “found” JB with the father, the father identified her immediately upon entering the room, even though it was dark & she had a sheet over her. I think the Ramsey’s were clever enough to call friends over immediately, seemingly for moral support, but more likely to help muddle the crime scene and create a an illusion of traumatized parents in despair for the police. I love your podcast and listen everyday!! Lol yup, playing the episodes over and over again. Our daughter & SIL turned us onto your podcast and our family has been hooked ever since. Def road trip listening 😁. My favorite episode is still Fishkill- just cause I love listening to James’ stories of his hometown- Wappinger’s Falls. 😂😂😂 You guys are awesome!!
This might be my fav episode the boys have ever done.
Entertaining and horrifying episode. Full marks, guys! That ransom note was totally bizarre
Omg James and Jimmie you guys crack me up….
This has become one of my favorites! The kidnapper voice was A1! Y’all are great!
The kidnapper voice!! 💀 🤣🤣🤣 brilliant!!
You are so right lol
This has been my favorite bonus episode yet 😂😂😂 I'd like for James to record an audiobook on his kidnapper voice 😂
“Rice already cooked, crime scene gone” 😂😂
Yay you are back in NC for this week's episode! It's funny the perp should move from Shelby to Mt. Airy to break bad. Shelby is REALLY a shithole now, victim of the opioid epidemic/meth use. I can't judge Mt. Airy; I've only ever driven through it to VA.
It’s the Jansport knapsack for meeeee 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Amazing. And YES to an episode on the COLORADO BERMUDA TRIANGLE
James portraying the ransom note writer that was totally "NOT" Patsy was reminiscent of any ridiculous business man skit from Kids in the Hall & absolutely as asinine as the fact that this is still unsolved 25 years later...brilliant!
Y'all so disrespectful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Why do I love this so much!??!?!? Does that make me a bad person?
Fucking hysterical James!! My fucking belly hurts from laughing. The accent killed it James. There is no doubt Patsy wrote that. Its a letter from a pretentious bitchy bitch to her battered husband. I love all the stuff you both do but this is the end all. I have serious stomach cramps but Im going to rewind and listen again. Perfect gentleman!!!
Great job guys! So much research & frivolity, my favorite thing. XOXO
I'm glad you mentioned the oddly specific reference to $118,000 in the letter - the exact amount of the bonus John had just received. As if the "foreign faction" would know that ... no, only two people would know that amount. Also, didn't a couple of lines from the note come directly from the movie "Speed" which had just come out at the time?
James' reading of the ransom note was priceless. 🤣🤣 Also, I don't think many foreign factions would use the sentence "Make sure that you bring an adequate size attache to the bank," in a ransom note... but I do think a booshy, southern pageant queen might.
You know, John, we know that you have a bad back.
I have always thought the dad did it. I have always thought that he makes enough money for the wife to help him cover it up write a note and forgive him. He went Way Beyond violating the junior rule.
The weirdest thing about the note to me is "foreign faction." When you go abroad, you're not like, "Hello, I'm a foreigner!" Foreign is a word other people use about you, not a self-identification.
Really enjoyed this one , eldente
I love you two! Thanks for the latest NH episode, i worked with Kenny Robishaw for years and thought he was a piece of sh*t….. but that episode confirmed it for me.
You guys are awesome..appreciate what yall do Special request: can you do a shout out for my wife...she loves you guys Her name is Allie Felici
I know that big name cases arent what STM is about, but I love it when the guys do big name cases, because it’s the same case we’ve all heard but they do it in a way where it feels like new info
James’ reading of the ransom note was, by far, the funniest goddamn thing I’ve ever heard. I’ve listened to it 3 times and will probably listen to 30 more times. That’s amazing
Right with you bro. My stomach hurts from laughing but im rewinding. Hysterical James. Great job guys.
One of the best bonus episodes ever!
The ransom should have been narrated by John Lithgow as the villain in Cliffhanger!
I've been a 911 dispatcher for 17 years, I've heard all manner of weird shit. One thing I've learned is you can't predict how people will respond to emergencies. I've heard people be inconsolable because their car was broken into, and people be super calm reporting finding a family member dead. The one call in that 17 years where I was sure the dude was lying and killed his girlfriend, he was never arrested and nothing ever came of it.
It’s been studied. We know that you did it by what you say to 911. There’s an actual algorithm.
I still think that Burke did it. His involvement now doesn't minimise that at all for me. Kid clearly had issues and it is the most logical reason for the parents actions afterwards. Patsy is clearly a classic narcissist. Just like Casey Anthony's mother, avoiding shame and scandal are higher priorities than justice or correcting horrible behaviour. I can almost guarantee that the Ramsey's called their lawyer before the cops and were told to muddy the scene (ransom note etc) to confuse the investigation. His involvement now is in order to make sure that he knows what is happening and either fight lines of inquiry or manipulate them away from him.
Hilarious! 😂😂 Btw, super awkward that Burke went to Purdue university at the same time as me. My roommate was in a forensics science class talking about this case. 😬 He wasn’t in the class, but still awkward.
More comedians should be lawyers
“Patty” Ramsey. 🤣
I work as a massage therapist and made the mistake of listening to this while I was working this morning and was CONSTANTLY choking back my laughter! James ransom note reading absolutely slayed me!
Listening to James roast is one of the greatest pleasures in life. Thank you!
“Don’t attempt to grow a brain, Jon.” That sounds like Patsy. I’ll be anyone that she said that exact thing to him many times in the past.
*bet anyone
I’d forgotten how ridiculous the ransom note was. James’ super villain reading of the note was hysterical. Loved it!!!
I’m not completely sold on Burke, but I will say kids can have an insane amount of rage. I’ve listened to the podcast “murderous minors” and what kids are capable of is shocking, especially if jealousy is involved. I hope someday we get answers on this case. This case is what sparked my love of true crime at a very young age, I was just a year older than Jon Benet. Patsy has always seemed the most guilty. I can’t imagine behaving like her if it was my child who was kidnapped/killed.
Or Timesuck's killer kids episode.
Conniving Gentleman Terrorist needs to be a cartoon! 😁 I reckon Patsy did it.
I'm going to need James' conniving terrorist to be a recurring CIS character
My own personal theory is that I think when they discovered her, they thought Burke did it (apparently he had hit her with a golf club another time). So Patsy covered for him with the ransom letter, only to realize that he didn't. Now they were stuck in a lie, which muddied the waters.
I hadn’t thought of that before, but that definitely seems very plausible. I can see that happening.
This is quite possibly the funniest episode that I've ever heard.
Someone cast James as the evil villain in a knockoff spy "Jim Band" movie.
Omg this, you guys, was pure gold. The way you dissected the ransom note had me rolling! I remember watching the first interview with the parents and thinking they were FOS. They had a handwriting analyst but common sense was lacking! I❤️U. PS James I’m so sorry about Italian Grandma. She lives on in your stories!
I really enjoy the rare crossover of Timesuck topics. Seeing the different theories and areas of focus is really interesting. The different styles makes me appreciate each more
Surprisingly True Crime Garage changed my mind on Burke. I still don’t like him. I want the creepy Santa friend who wanted his ashes put in glitter she gave him when he died looked at. What a disaster of an investigation. It doesn’t help when the family is odd too
They did look at him. He had an alibi
One of the doc I've watched on this case, actually went into the big movies of the nineties that had similar wording to the ransom not. This reddit post sums it up. It's also been the one part of the case that I can't get past. https://www.reddit.com/r/JonBenet/comments/chp5ln/the_ransom_note_and_movie_connection/
I was in Boulder when this happened and I lived about 10 blocks away. I worked at a place called the Beer Store where large groups of people could come in and make large batches of home brew right in the store. One regular group was a bunch of Boulder police and I asked one night after several beers who they thought did it and they all said it was the Dad.
I was only 9 but this was so scary at that age. I remember walking up and seeing this on the news. I grew up in Table Mesa/South Boulder. I’m so glad that they haven’t given up on trying to find who killed her. My grandmother worked for BPD and she always said the same thing. She said there was no “immediate” threat to children in Boulder. Also, you probably sold my brother and or sister beer.
Thanks for covering this. Nobody else can do it like you! After watching the documentary with Jim Clemente, I am 100% convinced that weird Burke did it. Hands down. https://www.amazon.com/The-Case-Of-JonBenet-Ramsey/dp/B01LXK9C3V?ref_=d6k_applink_bb_dls
See there’s a reason why we want you to cover the big cases! No one else tells a story like James tells a story.
We went over this case in my high school forensics class. Haven’t been able to stop thinking about it since. So glad to have my favorite podcasters cover it!
I’m only halfway through the reading of the letter and I have to keep pausing because I’m laughing so fucking hard.
That villain voice should be a new STM character. 😆😆
