BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SCOTT PETERSON
This week, James and Jimmie discuss the Laci Peterson trial and whether Scott Peterson is super guilty, or the world's most unlucky person ever.
Comments (75)
I'm late to this one but I think that when he killed Lacey he was expecting Connor to die as well. So when her body expelled Connor alive he killed him too.
The Behavior Panel is the GOAT!!!!
A lot of this information you gave wasn't correct. The episode of Martha Stewart that was referenced was aired the day prior, not on Christmas eve. He didn't disembody her, that happened with being in the water. Connor was ejected when the body was in the water. I love your shows but I know this information you gave wasn't correct. I watched the whole thing as it happened!
Currently live in Modesto, can confirm all of their assessments are correct
Wow what and ass hat. thanks for the recap. Pizza biter murderer 😆 Peterson
I will take a bite and put the pizza back in the fridge 🤣🤣🤣
Do Paul Ekmans Micro Expression course :)
Interesting how you guys covered this! Thank you ! Per mental health research we have found there are four crisis responses for people now: flight, fight, freeze and Fawn. Fawning is going along and appeasing the abuser to hopefully keep oneself safe and or alive. There’s much more detail to it, but that’s the essence of fawn crisis response. :) I found this all fascinating.
Hi guys! Love the show! First time chiming in. I think Scott had planned the murder since he found out she was pregnant. He hoped something would go wrong and she would miscarry but he had always planned to take her out in the late stages of the pregnancy. She would be unable to fight back as hard and more likely to go into a protect the baby mode therefore also less likely to fight.
Her and Connors body magically were found in the location he was fishing .
Scott probably did it but anytime I find myself agreeing with Nancy Grace I find it’s worth taking another look at the situation
the "my" house vs "our" house thing, i do this all the time bc 1. I lived in my house longer by myself than I have with my bf and it's just habit and I correct myself if I'm talking to Him. however, 2. if I'm talking to Anyone else that doesn't live with me, even if bf is present during convo, I still say My house. so that would never have been a flag in my opinion.
Down to the left is what you do when you see someone from high school in the grocery store and are trying to avoid any contact at all cost. That’s a down to the left 😂
As a woman, I do have a specific place for my purse… it happens to be my hall closet 🤣😅
Same 🤣
I feel so conflicted because I’m convinced he didn’t physically kill her but I also don’t find him to be that innocent. It’s all the dog walking witnesses that get to me and the local burglary. Am I off base to think Scott may have contacted these people to kill her for him? Idk how much investigation has been put into that hypothesis, but I really don’t think HE killed her. Was it convenient for him? Did it fall in line with the lie he fed Amber? Like everyone else, I have so many thoughts.
yeah when did he kill her. I think if you don't have a timeliness how can you say he is guilty? People looked down into his small boat and didn't find a body is he guilty probably but probably isn't the standard
Is this also the case where the Scott’s dad was like obsessed with lacy?
no that was the Susan Powell case.
This was seriously my favorite episode so far. Please do more widely covered cases on Patreon. Your take on it felt fresh. Also that sports radio in the 90s bit was so accurate it hurt. Cell phone technology has truly come a long way.
The pizza theory is very compelling. 😃
Change of venue motion moved this trial to my backyard. I was only 8 when OJ happened, so I took that whole trial in, but only really understood a fourth of what I saw. Flash forward to Scott Peterson and I was writing about the trial for my school paper. They actually raffled tickets for people who wanted to watch the trial in the courtroom gallery.
Great episode. What a sick fuck he is
Dan Cummins got you guys here. I listened to this before TS280 and then after and...well, Dan wins. He's right: there's zero evidence against Scott, absolutely not one drop of blood that he supposedly committed this grisly, gruesome, heinous, needlessly violent act. If Scott wanted to kill Laci, he could've just killed her; he didn't need to do this supposed evil biology experiment. And of course, he didn't. He was convicted by confirmation-biased, agenda-driven Nancy Grace in the court of public opinion. Maybe his watching Martha Stewart and sending his boss an e-mail was not because he was plotting the perfect alibi but because he was...watching TV and sending an e-mail. There's no evidence he killed her, much less that he decapitated her and chopped her up and drowned the pieces. It's ludicrous. He wouldn't have been able to throw her body overboard without capsizing or falling in or creating a huge scene. Also, the timeline of the baby does not work at all (look at me, not using contractions like a guiltym'n). The baby can't be born if he's in her womb when she died. Doesn't work. The jury were also prepersuaded dumbdumbs with the one critical thinker chased away pretrial. Scott was a cheater and scumbag with a punchable face, but that's not a crime. His conversational tics are interesting--truly!--but they don't mean anything. Oh, and also, extremely importantly, there were a series of other pregnant women brutally murdered in the same area who were totally ignored! The murderers are out there (if they're not dead by now), but Scott had nothing to do with this.
A Scott Peterson apologist? Let me guess... You're also a 'MRA'.
As soon as I saw him on TV after Laci disappeared, I told my grandmother (lives in Merced, close to Modesto), "He did it. He killed her." That guy came across so devil-may-care, I just knew in my soul he killed that poor woman! When he was convicted, I told my grandma, "See? SEE? I knew it!"
A textbook example of the court of public opinion.
I was in hs when this happened and I didn't pay attention at all cause I thought it happened in DC. lol I'm pretty sure someone got murdered in DC.
Chandra Levy was DC- same year. I used to mix them up as well!
Well done fellas. Pizza slices for lunch
This episode made me cackle from beginning to end!!
I love The Behavior Panel as well. All of their books are fascinating. James, you’d especially like a couple of the ones by Chase Hughes.
Your wife floatin' dead? Call Big Ed! I died laughing when I heard that. My soul left my body. 💀
Oaklander here to recognize the best description of Modesto of all time. Long may you not live in B-side Oakland 💫
First time Patreon listener, I can’t believe what I was missing out on
Welcome to the club, tell your friends
I remember the jury themselves being a shit show of lunatics as well. The DA was clearly looking for impulsive people that would react emotionally.
The evidence is overwhelming, both actual and circumstantial. May he continue to live a miserable long life.
Correct: overwhelming that he did not do it.
You guys should try an episode on your favorite true murder/crime books
Now I have to go look up The Behavior Panel. They sound really good.
I love your description of Modesto! I lived there for 10 years and you completely explained why I hate it. I lived there when this was happening too. He did it!
I totally believe Scott did it , I think he downloaded “ I use to love her “ by GNR around the time she went missing 🧐
Has any one dug into the “ Perry Monroe theory “ he murder a coworker of mine outside of Las Vegas , and was from the same area as the Petersons . Crazy story
I could have listened to three more hours on that!
Me too!
We still call them mobile phones in Australia 😂
You guys rock! I love how in-depth you get!!
OMFG pizza and milk?!?! That alone proves he’s a sociopath.
Ugh who does that?!
Ok, I feel I can safely listen. This motherfucker is guilty, and I’m tired of hearing people twist themselves into a pretzel trying to defend him. Statistically the most dangerous time for a woman, the time she is most likely to be murdered by her significant other is when she is pregnant. It happens all the time, sadly.
Great work guys, though I still have reasonable doubt. The fact that Nancy Grace would be your biggest supporter in this should cast a lot of that doubt. I've heard arguments made by his attorney in the book he wrote. Geragos made a great defense case against the DA who played on emotions and circumstantial (at best) evidence. He probably did it, but the state's case was awful.
I'm so glad you didn't waste time arguing he could be innocent. Reasonably there is no way he isn't guilty. Especially the pizza thing.
Guilty, the DS interview sealed it for me. THE PHONE BOOK OPEN TO LAWYERS👁👁👁😬
Confirmation bias.
At first I didn't understand the one bite of pizza, until James explained it. Then I felt he made such a compelling argument, it was better than the my/our house tell.
if you like The Behavior Panel, check out their inspiration- Joe Navarro
THE DOG??????? MOT#$R F@#KER🤬
When Jimmie said she wouldn’t pick up a bag of dog food pregnant.. let me tell you a little story of how I accidentally kick started my labor in 2016 😂😂
I’m
I have to know how this was supposed
I feel attacked about the taking one bite from a slice of pizza and putting it back thing. 😅😂 I absolutely do that, but only because I'm a picky bitch and I do it to mark my territory. I take a bite to mark that this slice is mine motherfucker. 😅 That being said, I would never do that if there were only a 2 or 3 slices left, or if I was sharing with other people outside of my partner and I only live with my partner, and he doesn't give a fuck that I do that. 😅😂🤣
My wife would kill me if I left a bitten piece of pizza. No way that's the act of a man with a living wife. No way no how
All that down and to the right up and to the left stuff has been disproven . All this body language stuff is dependent on the person . It’s all depending on your baseline.
I like milk too. Hahaha
My husband drinks milk with his pizza😳😳
So do I! It's delicious. Far better than Pepsi or some shit.
I am a “Freezer” if danger is eminent I am going to stand there like Mr. Freeze.
Lacy, and I were due a week apart. My daughter started college this fall. I think he’s guilty, and is right where he should be.
Omg you guys ripping Scott Peterson is what I’ve been missing with this case 😆 I hate this tool, I know he did it, and I hope I live to see him gassed.
The only thing the proved is that he's a douchebag.
Great episode! What's the name of the homicide book?
I haven’t listened to this episode yet, but if it is the one James usually talks about it’s called Homicide. The author is David Simon.
Before I even listen… I definitely have thoughts on this case. I’m not convinced he’s guilty, based on the evidence (or lack thereof), the shit that was going on in the area (other missing pregnant women, and one who was almost kidnapped), the shit investigation, the evidence that wasn’t allowed in court, the media presence, etc. My stance is, whether he’s guilty or not, I’m not totally sure, but I am 100% positive the investigation was shit, and he shouldn’t have been convicted on what was presented (and more importantly, what wasn’t) in court. One of Crime Junkie’s first episodes was on this case, and it was really eye opening, I did even more digging and am just not convinced there was enough for a conviction. Was he a douche canoe?! Abso-fucking-lutely! Did he kill her? I don’t know. Were the Investigation and trial shit? Yup. I can’t wait to hear James and Jimmie’s take on this! Also… Fuck Nancy Grace, she’s a part of why this case was fucked.
You're absolutely right. Check out Dan Cummins' TimeSuck take on it. You hit all the main points: He was convicted by the ghoul Nancy Grace, he was a total douchebag, and he was also completely innocent. There was no place he could have committed this crime, there was ZERO evidence, nor way he could have taken her body in the boat without anyone noticing nor tipped her out without capsizing or falling in. "the shit that was going on in the area" is absolutely on the nose.
