BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - OLD TIMEY MURDERS
This week, James and Jimmie discuss Old Timey Murders from the newspapers.
Comments (84)
There’s a song about the grandfather!!!
But... I make a face around smoking cuz it smells bad? The only time I care is with the people smoking 2 feet from a door.
You guys are amazing! Keep it up!!
There was a song on an old Disney tape called "I'm my own Grandpa"
I love when James gets on a rant, it's so good! "I will strangle you, you f*cking c*nts!" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think in historical context, waylaid is the term for being robbed by road bandits.
That's a song! 🤦🏼 OMG that didn't happen!
I know I’m late in commenting but…”Unfortunates” is what they called prostitutes in England in the Victorian Era. I’m a Jack the Ripper nerd and I’ve never heard that her lips and eyes were still moving. I wonder if that was an exaggeration by someone. She was found very shortly after her murder. He murdered another “unfortunate” the same night and it is believed that he killed the second woman because he couldn’t finished this one.
He fucking killed himself! That’s a double suicide! My sides are in orbit 😂😂
Love the smoking statements! Same people complaining about it are, more than likely the ones who wouldn’t wear a mask!
This is a song we would sing as kids 🤣 "I'm my of own grampa" so this being a story from a paper 🤯 😳 wtf 🤣🤣
Oh God I wonder if I feed ducks in the pond that the mother drowned herself and kids in in Lil titz (Lititz) PA 😬😂
the best sentence of the entiry episode clearly is „i am my own grandfather.“😄poor guy.
and there are people saying everything used to be better..
Love the old timey stuff
Fuck me silly 😂. I had to listen to “I am my own grandfather” multiple times. I can’t recall ever laughing so much it hurt.
Without a doubt got me hooked all over again
Say "Muskogee" again James😅
I thought my family was fucked up when my cousins father married his niece, so her cousin became her step mum.....so icky
Love the old timey stuff, from the depths of my accursed menstrual organs 😆
Love this! Couldn’t stop laughing!!
Hey that James Lamb is my great-great grand uncle
sometimes when im having a bad day i come back here to listen to “i am my own grandfather”
So much fun listening to this.
Please do more of these
https://flattr.com/ In addition to patreon, I thought you guys may want to check this out. It’s just another way for ppl to give you guys money, though I believe this method wouldn’t be taxed.
Love old timey murders
Orchard White is an old time skin bleach
Thank goodness I know how to properly fix my hair now! 🤣🤣
Grew up on “I’m My Own Grandpa” by Ray Stevens and I had the same reactions 😂
My mom sent me this video with the title "Arkansas State Song"
Cherokee Nation; Choctaw Nation; Creek Nation, Chickasaw Nation, etc = Oklahoma prior to 1907.
“You big fat mashed potato face” 😂
Waylaid simply means to detain someone but....I think it’s used incorrectly in this situation because detaining implies you will eventually let them go....which in this case....the person detained was murdered.
Why am I from North Carolina 😔😅😅!!! I had to rewind that part 7 times with my eyes closed to get it!!🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ugh! I lived in Hazelton when I was a kid...and I'm from Scranton, James!! 🤣
My late father was born and raised in Hazelton....before it went to shit!
Can we get a shirt that says, “listen, you fat, faced fuck!”
Fucking Titusville
The woman found in the barrel around Hazelton PA is supposedly Mrs. John Martha. Her husband was insanely jealous.
So I grew up on a MT Indian Reservation, went off to college and became a reporter. Now I run the county paper I grew up reading. Ever since I was a kid, I have been fascinated by black widows, especially the ones that poison their husbands. Imagine my morbid delight when I found a story about Big Horn County, MT's very own black widow while was going through newspaper archives from 1921. She killed a husband and brother-in-law here, a husband in Idaho and one in California before she was caught. It was the highlight of last month.
Okay, if you guys do a bonus on small town festivals, try Fort Fairfield's Potato Blossom Festival in Maine.
Holy moly. I live in Alamogordo and all I can think about that Is jelly brain
The grandfather one was so funny!!
A crime in Ashland, Ky, and then executed in Grayson, Ky. Awesome. I live 20 minutes from Grayson and about 45 minutes to Ashland.
This one was crazy fascinating!
As a woman with a slightly chubby face and curls... I strongly disagree 😂😂
Bradfield’s was 15% alcohol. Didn’t cure anything just helped you not give shit about the symptoms. Whiskey makes you frisky. 😂🤷🏼♀️
As a resident of Wheeling WV, I need to know the story that took place on Aug 4 1891. It cut off into something New Orleans... Crazy shit happens here and originates here.
OH ALSO: Mrs. Nicholas Longworth, née Alice Roosevelt, is THE Alice Roosevelt, as in President Teddy's daughter! No wonder her smoking got people so upset. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Roosevelt_Longworth She was great; her father once said of her, "I can either run the country or I can attend to Alice, but I cannot possibly do both."
The Smithsonian has a bottle of Orchard White in their collection! No details but I'll bet you a dollar it contains lead. https://www.si.edu/object/orchard-white%3Anmah_714543
It sounds crazy I know, but it really is so. I’m my own grandpa. That reminded me of the song lmao
Tom Arnold!!!
Waylay/ waylaid..... Lay/,lie and wait? Was this addressed. Either way, dig it.
You guys are awesome! All my respect and thanks from Pretoria, South Africa
I use the word "waylaid" or "waylay" often🤣🤣 I tend to tell my daughters "If a boy ever tries to touch your boobs and you don't want em too.. you better waylay the f**k out of em" 🤣🤣🤣 us small town Texans use it pretty often 🤣
Loved this episode 🤣🤣
I know that we pay for this and we get special treatment, but I think you should share the man who was his own grandfather with the whole class. That is just absolutely Priceless I've already listened to that part three times.
There’s a whole movie about the diving horses. https://www.nytimes.com/1991/05/24/movies/review-film-the-true-story-of-a-girl-a-horse-a-diving-board.html
Going to use "waylaid" in my conversations today.
I live 15 minutes from Titusville, Pa .... and I'm not in the least bit surprised by this story!!!🤣🤣
I'm about to listen to this episode, bit after hearing the tease on CIS about how newspapers wrote about murders made me remember something fun. I was looking up life insurance and stuff and ended up in a rabbit hole about the history of life insurance and fraud. From memory, it was either late 1800's or early 1900's and a rich guy lost all of his money. He had a policy that was due on such and such date. He shot himself in a hotel room the day before the policy ended so that his family would get the money (no suicide clause back then). The newspaper said he, "Blew his head off in the bed at (whatever hotel)". They were straight to the point back then.
Omgoodness...I just pictured Ernest T. Bass kicking Otis' brain to a jelly while Barney Fife was on his dinner break with Thelma at the diner!🤣😂#TheAndyGriffithShow
Full story on the Polk Boys and what lead them to be roasted alive if anyone cares to know the full story - 🤣 But, this particular incident did push lawmakers to start reigning in lynch mobs. The murder of Frank Ward in Howard County, and the burning of his murderers in the Murfreesboro jail are well remembered. On April 5, 1884, Frank Ward was murdered in Howard County, by Henry Polk, Sylvester Polk and Monroe Kuykendall. The facts of the killing and the incidents of the arrest of the murderers, were as follows: Ward was a peddler, who was on a trip through Howard County. He was gone so long that his brother, a resident of Prescott, Nevada County, started to follow him up. He was easily traced to the home of the Polks, but from that place the trail was lost. The men, Henry Polk, Sylvester Polk and Monroe Kuykendall, were soon arrested on suspicion, and searching parties began a vigorous search for the body, for which a reward of $50 had been offered. No trace of it was discovered until one of the prisoners voluntarily suggested that they look in a heap of ashes in the woods. This was done, and examination revealed ample proof that the body had been consumed by fire, and from time to time, as much was admitted by the prisoners. These three men were promptly indicted, but a change of venue was taken from Howard to Pike County, and the prisoners were brought to Murfreesboro. The jail at this place being very insecure, the prisoners were taken to Little Rock, and placed in the penitentiary for safe keeping, and while there Monroe Kuykendall died. At the April term of (the) circuit court in 1885, the other two, Henry Polk and Sylvester Polk, were placed on trial separately, both were convicted, Sylvester Polk was sentenced to be hung, and Henry Polk to twenty-one years' imprisonment in the penitentiary. From a technical error in the proceedings of this court the prisoners were granted a new trial. This proceeding, which promised the possible defeat of justice, and the escape from well-merited punishment of the perpetrators of a heinous crime, must have outraged the feelings of some of the people, for after two unsuccessful attempts had been made by armed mobs to take the prisoners from the jail, a third was made on the night of September 5, 1885, when, as they could not be taken from the iron cell, a fire was started, which partially consumed the jail, and burned the two prisoners confined within to death. After this tragedy, there was a mass-meeting held at Murfreesboro, which was largely attended by the citizens, who strongly condemned the action of mob law, and all acts of violence, that might place the county under an unenviable stigma. Public opinion and the hostility of the people at once became so pronounced aganist the perpetrators of such diabolical deeds, that it is thought most of those concerned have moved away. At least, to the credit of Pike County, may be said that few lawless acts, of even the most trivial nature, have since occurred. The law is rigidly enforced and quietly obeyed, and the citizens of all sections are earnest in their efforts to show the world that no once can condemn mob violence, and its attendant evils, more vigorously than they. The governor offered a reward of $250 each for the arrest of every person concerned in this affair, but no evidence was ever secured to justify the apprehension of any one.
Really starting to question who I am after laughing out loud at James discussing old timey prisoners being "roasted alive!!". Who am I?? lol
I must excuse myself to go figure out if I'm doing my hair correctly....
Perfect episode. I’m my own grandpa had me rolling.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I'm_My_Own_Grandpa
Great episode!
You have got to keep on doing these episodes! This was hilarious! You kept me entertained while I was doing some housework so thanks so much!
Loved this.
Yaaaaaaaaay😁🥰
The ladies menstrual regulator is a euphemism for an abortifacient. Obviously, it was illegal to provide abortions, so people advertised snake oil with euphemistic names like ladies regulator and menstrual helpers. It's quite funny, everyone knew that's what they were for but no one acknowledged it. There was a bit of reasonable deniability on the part of everyone because people just said 'oh, I was having irregular periods, totally accidental'. That 'I'm my own grandpa' thing sounds familiar, in sure it's not real.
Menstrual helpers. Hahaha! Seriously this is why we need to be worried about the upcoming Roe vs. Wade. NO OVARIES, NO OPINIONS.
Well now I know how Ray Stevens came up with the song I'm My Own Grandpa. SUPER close to that letter! https://youtu.be/eYlJH81dSiw
Found it on Youtube!
Ol’ timey murders are hilariously unfortunate. Pour one out for our homie who was his own Grandpa.
Perfect surprise on a rainy morning!
*clears throat*...YAAAYYYYYY! My favorite podcast early in the morn-tin!
Can we check if the family from 36:10 is related to Woody Allen? The whole family tree turning into a wreath sounds familiar.
YAAAAAY!!
Thank you guys I’m on vacation camping with no WiFi or tv so podcasts are all I have got and I have been waiting for these I have been camping since Thursday and I have been thru ALL the episodes of Small Town Murder and Crime in Sports You guys are a life saver love ya 👍👍👍
Yay!!!
Yay Indeed
