💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME!! (1 of 2)
March 21, 2021

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - THE PRISONER DATING GAME!!

It's another round of - 

The Prisoner Dating Game: All Violent Felons Edition!! 


Comments (76)

T
Tessa Rivers · September 7, 2026

The male felon Jimmie picked, there’s a documentary about the case called Murder in Glitterball City, it’s a wild story.

J
Jessica Kamps · January 29, 2025

I’m listening to this late and they started talking about Shayna and was so confused why it sounded so familiar 🤣 then James made the comment about her singing and it clicked

D
Dick Gordon · September 5, 2024

Love this show

R
Ryan · August 15, 2024

Jimmy’s pick was definitely a first 48 episode.

S
Sorsha4564 · March 25, 2026

She was the subject of many, many true crime shows. As soon as I heard the name Marjorie Orbin, I was like, "That sounds SUPER familiar..." and then as soon as they described what she did, I was like, "Yup, that's the chick that persuaded her husband to pay for her fertility treatments then started banging her kid's karate coach."

K
Kristin Schmidt · April 28, 2024

These are always a favorite!

A
Abby M. · April 6, 2024

Shayne was in a small town murder episode!!!

R
Raymond Smith · March 29, 2024

Shayna (30 minute mark) is this weeks episode. #477

M
Marcus Anderson · September 26, 2024

Thank you so much. It would’ve driven me mad trying to figure out which episode I had heard that story.

I
I am my own grandfather · January 21, 2024

i also love the prisoner dating game. some of those cases sound fun / interesting enough for a full episode.

D
Derek Galliher · January 17, 2024

So excited!

d
diablo orphan · May 26, 2023

More reasons to avoid Kentucky..lol

L
Liz Roller · May 18, 2023

Omg- Joey’s case is super famous here in Louisville. They used to give tours of the house. And the girl from Kentucky- she’s a horrible person 😂 this episode was fantastic!

T
Tasha Hernandez · December 5, 2022

Joeys case was on forty-8 hours. Lol. Good choice, Jimmie. Lmao

T
Tammy Hedrick · November 10, 2022

I love how Jimmie says "How DARE you!"

G
Goopy Goop · June 28, 2022

Yaaaaaaaaaay

K
Kate Steward · February 17, 2022

I'd have to be drunk on toilet wine to enjoy a fucking Patterson book. That dude is like an sti

S
Sandy Hurst · December 20, 2021

I love you all.

S
Sandy Hurst · December 20, 2021

I’m pretty sure I watched joey’s case on an old first 48 hours episode.

C
Claire Aitch · December 12, 2021

These are hilarious. The prison system in the U.S us scary as hell to a small town British person!!

T
TaphWithNoLastName · November 5, 2021

I hate how close Bachelor #4 is to my dad. Both are 51 years old, both are named Randy, and they're in neighboring states (my dad's a Wisconsinite). Something about that makes me very uncomfortable. EDIT: For the record, there are no other similarities besides the name, age, and neighboring states. The Michigan Randy is a monster.

K
Kendra Johnson · June 16, 2021

I have actually heard of some of these cases. I think That Chapter did a couple of them. I remember the little person murder and the deadly threesome. I think that was on Deadly Couples or something. I love your Dating Game though. Cracks me up!

C
CC Deville · June 21, 2021

I love you guys…..You all are actually saving lives❤️💜💕

C
Catherine Maldonado · April 5, 2021

“I feel sick” 😂😂😂

A
Andrea Alarcon · April 5, 2021

You guys should do a prison dating game where Jimmy is the host

K
Kendra Johnson · June 16, 2021

Right! Turn the tables. LOL

T
Troy Graham · April 4, 2021

The prisoner dating game is off the hook and could obviously be a full-time show if there was enough time in the world. P. S. Don't finger your sister.

L
Latasha Campbell · March 30, 2021

Does anyone know if they did the psych profile of the Runge Killer? Friendly the dog and all that? Listening to old episodes because my appetite is voracious. But I don't remember the Patreon. If it was done, can you direct me to when?

S
Stacy Nielsen · March 30, 2021

😂 bachelorette number 5 is from my home area! 😂 real winner. I’m pretty sure I saw the dude in the mall selling portraits

S
Stacy Nielsen · March 29, 2021

I love every one of these

C
Coena Harris · March 28, 2021

This is my favorite episode of PDG. This was awesome

R
Rene Kaiel · March 28, 2021

Twang Brothers - https://www.facebook.com/53471909754/posts/10151901497602292/?d=n

R
Rene Kaiel · March 28, 2021

Shayna Hubers - I just watched her case on dateline! She’s all singing in the interrogation room - and the Motley Crue chick was on Deadly Women - great episode

K
Kelly Shankland · April 2, 2021

I knew I had heard Shayna's story before. As soon as he said former Miss Ohio I recognized it but I couldn't remember where I saw that story before!

M
Mr. Gregory Allen Freetage · March 27, 2021

Love the prisoner dating game!

E
Erika Fultz · March 27, 2021

I believe Will is currently residing at the prison in my area! 🤣 CMC is the men's colony about 30 minutes away.

A
Ana Rodriguez · March 26, 2021

listening to jimmy’s laugh is the best part of my week

A
Angela in Rhode Island · March 26, 2021

Thank you. This made my Friday!

S
Sarah McAnally · March 26, 2021

Just terrific episode! Live in Columbus, MS and knew about the Tara Lyle case - "Someone's gonna pay for my feelings!" And Motley Crue chic was on Snapped! Great picks to ruin Jimmie's life with!

R
Rivka Arbetter · March 26, 2021

As a Jewish woman, I can attest that most of us kill through guilting relatives to death which is yet to be illegal - that’s why there aren’t that many of us in prison for murder.

B
Brooke Cale · March 25, 2021

THIS was the best one yet. You have beyond perfected this game

K
Kristin Morris · March 25, 2021

This was freaking hilarious! "They tenderized him" made me spray water everywhere!

D
Donna Jensen · March 25, 2021

I also don't feel worthy all the time. You guys make me laugh out loud and make my days a little better. You're awesome!!!!!

A
Abigale Fisher · March 24, 2021

Always funny as fuck!

L
Linda Payne · March 24, 2021

This was amazing. The best one yet. Poor Jimmie 🙈

E
EduK8 · March 24, 2021

Ha!! I knew it was Shana Hubers!! She's definitely one crazy pocket robin!! And, she created a media frenzy around Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky for sure! Too bad for Ryan, because he had a date with Miss Ohio that evening and didn't live to see her.

C
CRYROLFE · March 23, 2021

Love you guys!

A
Annemarie Navarro · March 23, 2021

Omg..I heard about the dancing girl on maybe dateline or 48hrs..can't believe you guys found her on there!

P
Patty Arcand · March 23, 2021

Absolutely fantastic ♡ thanks for making my day!

J
Jason williams · March 23, 2021

My favorite Prisoner Dating Game yet!! Great job. Thanks guys.

M
MrRin213 · March 22, 2021

You picked too many famous ones lol

T
Thaniel Peterson · March 22, 2021

Hilarious! My fiancé’s step mom live in Salem Oregon. Wonder if she’s heard of the bonus female inmate lol

K
Kacee Dreher · March 21, 2021

You guys need to make a "Prisoner Dating Game" board game or app game! It would be the best game out there! Love these episodes!

A
Andrew Will · March 21, 2021

Its Midterm season for ya boi and there's nothing that helps me more after a shitty day of exams then listening to you two. Much love

C
Carissa Blanch · March 21, 2021

I love the prisoner dating game. Thank you for bringing us another great Patreon episode!!

T
The Whiskey Pirate · March 21, 2021

first time listening to the patreon, finally able to help support with my new job, good luck reading my name tho Jimmy

C
Cynthia Parker · March 21, 2021

As usual you guys crush it.

A
Amy Easton · March 21, 2021

I used to work for a self-publishing company. We had so many prisoners! They were almost all religious stuff or weird biographies. 100% creepy and disturbing.

J
Jordan Stivers · March 21, 2021

We have a special kind of crazy here in Kentucky, sweet goodness 🤣

W
Wayward Stitches · March 21, 2021

As soon as James said, “Shayna Marie Huber”, I yelled “Nosejob Murder!!” My SO called out from the other room, “Lay off the true crime!” 😂

A
Ashleigh LaCourse · March 22, 2021

They covered the case on another podcast and I couldn’t believe it when she was a bachelorette here 😂

P
Paducah Patty · March 21, 2021

Always love the dating game. I have seen documentaries on both of the Kentucky prisoners.

P
Paducah Patty · March 21, 2021

OMG! I'm from Kentucky. That Kentucky chick is crazy. There is video of her crazy.

L
LouLou Rogers · March 21, 2021

Such fun! Thanks guys, you always deliver excellence 😉

S
Sara Billinghurst · March 21, 2021

Emily you’re a survivor much love and a cwtch sent over from Wales

J
Jill · March 21, 2021

Love this edition of the PDG!

L
Lady Vandercat · March 21, 2021

James and Jimmie, you guys can keep poking fun at Texas hospitality all you want, but you can’t deny it exists. You can’t deny a Texan reimbursed your bogus speeding ticket in full. (Via PayPal early March.) Texas still loves y’all!

A
Andrew Will · March 21, 2021

lol

C
CharlieInsomnia · March 21, 2021

Honest to god, the best money you’ll ever spend on Patreon. You two guys are talented, honest, and real. Truly good dudes that make me laugh like crazy with these episodes. Amazing.

E
Emily Dumas · March 21, 2021

I usually don't enjoy the prisoner dating game. But this time it was like they described my dad! "Father" of 13, I'm second oldest, I'm only one of two that testified against him - weird and creepy, so glad Jimmie didn't pick that scumbag!

M
Music_is_Life · March 21, 2021

You don’t enjoy the prisoner dating game?

C
Cory Kaul and Amber Gwinn · March 21, 2021

I like the prisoner dating games where someone isn't a murderer and Jimmy is trying to pick that one lol. Those are fun!

S
Seyda · March 21, 2021

Let’s goooo

S
Sarah Schumer · March 21, 2021

YESSSS

A
Alex · March 21, 2021

Fucking sweet

J
Julie Montag · March 21, 2021

My favorite!