BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SMALL TOWN REVIEWS
This week, James and Jimmie read reviews from small towns... they also read some bad reviews of Small Town Murder podcast!
Comments (219)
Doesn't West Virginia exist because Virginia wanted to secede and the people in WV wanted to stay in the union? They literally couldnt be any less southern lmao
Shandon CA is definitely not anywhere near Napa. It's central CA near SLO.
Love this!!
I live near Carson City. There is a break off sect of Mennonites. I don't remember the name they go by, but I think it's the name of the guy they followed when they broke away.
All I can think of is The cell block tango from Chicago; Pop, six, squish, uh-uh, Cicero, Lipshitz.
You guys are awesome! I was laughing so hard I had tears running down my face.
Never heard of Looking Glass OR But outside of Eugene and Portland thats sums up Oregon!
Maybe listening while driving is bad idea…..at least for this crowd😂
I have literally almost crashed a couple of times while listening to Your Stupid Opinions.
James and Jimmie are the best! Fuck the 1 star people. We met Jimmie twice in person after live shows and he's a super down to Earth and nice guy!
I can't breath!!!! 🤣
Shut up and give me bonus
Ignore the haters, all us turkeys love you both 💕
Gobble gobble motherfuckers
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
I love when James gets worked up the Italian comes out in his voice 🤣💀🤣
Your reviews of your reviews. Best sh** ever!!
This is easily the best podcast out there. The guys are funny the stories are wild and the detail is unreal
There really needs to be a small town murder map. We like to roadtrip and I’d like to plan appropriately.
https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=1XqzH_ImVxnfyGEQD8u2pCBhigBrOhgNf&ll=-3.81666561775622e-14%2C-110.93965000000003&z=1
I can appreciate the that people have certain preferences in which podcasts to listen to. If you don’t like them then step off. Don’t waste anyone’s time with nonsensical comments. Move along. I live in Louisiana and I don’t get offended by southern comments. James redneck accent is hilarious. Peace out. You guys are great!!
This episode made me laugh so much. Thanks for the laughs.
I personally got offended by the one stars for you guys. Anything you need. Ride or Die ✌️☠️
Haters gon’ hate. Fuck ‘em! They’re morons and I love that we get to make fun of them now. You guys are hilarious and cheer me up whenever I’m having a bad day or feeling shitty, so thank you. Ilysfm!!
Oh my god. As. Much as hearing bad reviews on my guys pisses me off they were great!! I just want to punch them in the FUCKING FACE!! Hilarious!!
WV is southern if you are below the Mason Dixon line. James WV is for you. We do our best to tickle you.
This might be my favorite episode of all! I love it when you two crack yourselves up!
Love you guys 🥰🥰🥰🥰
1. I wish I had become a Patreon before just recently. B. Your guys’ sense of humor, story telling, side rants & filthy language is what keeps me coming back for more. And D. BOOMER SOONER! 😬🥰
I wanted to have a review of my own town.. until I went and looked at them and realized people enjoy our area. Minus the people that moved here that failed to realize we are the 4th largest Amish community. So ya. Driving 45 mins to get to anything. Normal. And our town not being hip to the LGBTQ community again due to the large portion being Amish.
Ugh! I'm offended at the negative comments about you guys!
I don't think you are capable of understanding other peoples' opinions. It's a shame, as you could gain insight into yourselves and possibly grow as individuals. It wouldn't be a bad thing! Humility goes a long way.
Please enlighten me on how you arrived here. How does laughing at poorly written reviews translate to being incapable of understanding other people's opinions?
Did anyone else get furious at the mf’ers who left the 1 star reviews?? I can’t get enough of these guys!
Man, I love you guys! The last 15 minutes is fucking hilarious. Keep on keeping on .
Not the dogs nut😂😂😂
Wicked Small Town pod famous!
I was laughing out loud at this episode. Also so excited to hear about somewhere familiar when you started talking about Hemlock Farms
Yes, I can do without hearing all the swearing however I also have the option when it becomes too much to turn it off. I continue to listen because I like the stories. I like hearing about the lesser known crimes. This is one, well two since I listen to both stm and Cis, that I go to before any other podcast. Wish I became a patreon before I did. Lol
Don't listen to morons that don't get you. It's like when people tell me I can't sing even if my manager thinks I can hold a tune, or those that tell me how to train dogs eventhough I have a degree in animal health and have worked 30 years in the biz. You do you boos. . Took me 3 episodes to love you but now not 1 of my friends can go a day without me raving about the show ❤️
Knocked Up At 9 sounds like a novel.
Lfao I almost peed myself about the dog Also PS😳 Maryland is the old line state
damn I love ya'll
That first West Virginia review is applicable to most small towns in WV/western VA in my opinion lmfao. When he mentioned the half-naked children running around I died, I always see kids running in underwear and the water smells like shit
I know I'm the only one who heard there reviews.. the reviews of the podcasts.. man that pissed me off so much.
OMG, I LITERALLY PISSED MY PANTS ON THE WAY TO WORK AND HAD TO TURN AROUND TO GO BACK HOME AND CHANGE DURING THIS EPISODE!!! And I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE YOU GUYS EVEN MORE BECAUSE OF IT!!
You guys should do Amazon products reviews
Your Stupid opinions?
Holy fark!!!! I am cutting fruit with a sharp knife guys!!!!! The poor dogs left ball! 😳🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Jimmy…seriously no one can say specificity right. We have to use that word at work all the time and it cracks me up when people screw it up! Love you guys!
omg i’m so glad you read a review about willow creek i live near there and it’s so accurate hahahha
I just have to say I F****ing love you guys.
I literally howled when the woman talked about her dog being attacked by a bird.
About peed… “the birds hate dog nuts!”
Omg I would love it if you would read a review of my small town. Ravenna Ohio!
Ppl in Mississippi actually love to claim west Virginia because they know it's "country" but don't realize how far north it is. Lived there 12 yeas, the whole north/south thing is annoying. Hey "the south" you're not special and nobody else in America cares
I hurt myself laughing, it wouldn't have been so bad if I were not driving and couldn't see through the tears! 🤣😭😂
Yay I I
You joke about shooting up the HOA…someone actually did that in Saginaw, Texas (not Michigan) this week! It happened a couple of miles from my house in the neighborhood behind the Kroger where I always shop. If this guy didn’t have a HOA lien on his house before this, he definitely does now!
This is the best
How dare someone say James reads off a Wikipedia page?? That got my blood boiling.
You fuckers. I almost drowned on coffee driving through Houston rush hour. Made it sound like birds are discriminating against dogs. Good by testicle. Bahahaha also. Born in texas grew up in northwest Florida travelled everywhere in the united states. I laughed at people every day and pointed at so many people in the states I lived. People suck in every state. Have a sense of humor and enjoy life. PS to the Baptist I grew up with around me, how dare you dump on their choice of verbal expression, meanwhile. You are doing things behind closed doors that would make porn producer's gag. Don't like it change it you hypocritical dick smacks.
I was listening and realized Burlington WV is about 45 minutes from where I live (I live in the panhandle of Maryland) I was passing through not to long ago that place is a shit hole lmao
I have to leave another comment regarding the reviews people are posting about this show. FUCK OFF! How dare you say they just read from a Wikipedia page! James’ research is thorough and cited and he puts together an engaging story.
I have always lived in big cities. Listening to these small town reviews makes me never want to move to one. As James would say, “that sounds terrible.”
Yes my name is Charles and I am replying to balance the scales for others with the same name. The one who wrote that negative review and who dislikes cussing is the damaged one and I think I may know the issue. This is my opinion, He is someone who failed at being a comedian and probably at a podcast. He was fucking sheltered and probably still lives with his mommy. James has stated many times, if you do not cuss I do not trust you! He still listens to the shows so that he can use the material around his mom and her friends to make it seem like he is funny and smart. I mean it has to be his audience because someone that stupid could not have any real friends, unless you want to count the fucked up voices in his head that he thinks are real. Keep up the awesome work you both are doing. I truly appreciate all the work and effort you put into these shows.
Growing up near Willow Creek CA, the reviews were pretty accurate 😂 it's in the middle of nowhere and a popular trimigrant location where people constantly go missing from. It's a weird mix of hillbillies and hippies.
I am dying from trying not to laugh out loud. It’s 4am and everyone else is trying to sleep but I can’t stop snorting. The dog testicle had me crying.
Enjoyed this one a lot! Born and raised in the south- you’re spot on here and maybe too easy on us.
Can we get a patron only shirt of us coming out from a rock?
I’ve never laughed so hard omg we need more of this! I was waiting on y’all to say something about the wonderful whites of West Virginia with all the West Virginia reviews. 🤣🤣
I grew up like 5 minutes away from Williams, Indiana and it is indeed a shithole. I died laughing this entire episode and was so pumped to hear Williams on here! I could give you a tour if you’d like Jimmie 😂
Love you guy you both got me Through the year of hell with the quarantine and Covid and everything and my isolation you guys rock
Hands down, one of the BEST Patreon episodes 🤣 People were looking at me all crazy when the mother of 8 kids, 4 cats and a uni-balled dog came on the scene. #bewarethebirds 🕊️🕊️🕊️
I LUV YOU GUYS!!! Your podcasts have saved me the last few years. I found you when I had neck surgery in 2018, I had spent 2 months in a neck brace & then slowly taking it off for another 2 months. I had gotten depressed during that time & not only did your banter & witty jokes help me, but listening to your life stories really connected me to you guys. I listen to both podcasts & will listen until you stop. THANK YOU 🌴😍🌺🧡 P.S. I luv your grandma James & Jimmy, if I was 20 years younger (& not married🤭) I would hunt you down...😆😅😂🤣😉🌴🌺🧡
Oh man. I have not laughed that much in years.
I haven't laughed this hard in so long. Thank you!
People are morons , and the people who leave 1 star reviews have no life and nothing better to do. I wouldn't mind but there's the warning at the start of the show, dipshits.
My friend tried to convince me for MONTHS to listen to STM, and I was like “idk, I’m not really a podcast guy” and now, over a year since I’ve started listening (first episode was Winnemucca, Nevada and I was hooked after that crazy town festival). I now cannot wait for new episodes of STM and CIS. Fucking comedy gold
I cry laughing almost every episode. You guys are fugginghilarious.
Outlook, Wa. is indeed a shithole.
I loved this I actually laughed so hard I peed myself lol lol
This was amazing! 🤣😅
Amazing!! Please do more of these!!
🤣🤣🤣
shit, now i gotta worry about swooping birds
That’s fucking gold guys!! Love it 🍻
Ru-le living!!!
I’d bet the ppl who complain to James & Jimmie about them making fun at small towns, are the same ppl who write these idiotic reviews.
You guys should do Prison Reviews!
Crawled out from under my rock and enjoy the like minded humor and stories
I loved this episode!
This was AMAZING! And I made my West Virginian husband listen to some of it. He was like..... "Yep, that sounds like there."
I'd love to hear more of these!
Growing up I had an aunt and uncle that lived around Carson city and my entire family would always go and visit them in summer, the mennonites the person in the review is referring to are actually Amish people.
Your reference to Siskel & Ebert reminded me of the last time I ever watched those two when one of them actually said, "If the reason you go to the movies is simply to be entertained, then you'll probably enjoy this movie." That said, the reason I listen to podcasts is to be entertained, so keep up the good work, guys.
Rad.
I’d like to slap some sense into the idiots who give you negative reviews. Sad sacks. Always enjoy the fun tangents you guys get into! I feel like I say the same thing to my husband at least once a week when he looks at me while I’m laughing out loud - all I have to say is listening to James and Jimmie. 😂
If those negative reviewers clutch their pearls any tighter, they might suffocate themselves. What a loss that would be.
Laughing at the finding drugs in parks comment. We actually found what we think was meth at a park with my son
Anyone else from or live in Humboldt county?? The willow creek review was on point!!!
Never needed an hour of laughs more than this week and you guys always deliver.
Look how many arby's does four star Carson City mi have??? Must know if the ratio of population to cheesy roast beef sandwiches is acceptable
Listen...I'm from Florida and there's absolutely NOTHING you guys could say about this sunburnt asshole of a state that I haven't already yelled in the middle of a Walmart.
They think we’re frat boys with pizza and socks laying around. Oh my god, laughing so hard I’m snorting. Thank you!!!
I need to be in that town where you walk around and just find drugs just laying around. You just drive through pick up your "merchandise" and sell it later. They don't see the town in the right light. Boom $$$$
I lose all my drugs like sonic loses his rings!
Easily one of the best episodes 👌 who damaged you LMAO
I love you guys! Keep ripping on every small town! I’m from a really crappy one...
I can't imagine listening to the beginning of any STM episode (including the disclaimer !!) and then being mad enough to write a bad review. Both James and Jimmie are hilarious and those people obviously don't have a good sense of humor lmao.
My son was born in Bedford Indiana. Very, very near Williams. And this place doesn't deserve one star. It is a shit-hole. I used to have nightmares about getting stuck there when it rained. Hahaha!!
An action sequence WOULD be nice
Holy. Shit. The left testicle ...... I ...... can’t....... I will gladly crawl out from under my rock. WHO DAMAGED YOU?! Is that rhetorical ?! How much time do you have? Clearly you have quite a bit since ur writing shitty negative reviews!!!!!! LOVED EVERY MINUTE OF THIS
Who damaged you?? 💙💙💙
Loved this so much! Hope u guys keep doing these and personal ads for sure my favorite!
That poor dogs testicle incident had me cackling like crazy
It’s the history of life like how I relisten to old episodes where James is trying to find his pizza roll threshold
Went to Grand Central Station, took me a nap 💤
Every damn thing these a$$wipes don’t like about you guys, are the reasons I love you!
I laughed my ass off, at work. Rule...🤣😂
I love these so much.
😂😂😂 I grew up around Lookinglass Oregon. they are assholes
I love you guys ty for making my day
I could not love you guys more!! Funniest yet!!
I laugh through my entire lunch break! You two are fucking hilarious and I appreciate the time you take to deliver a few hours of happiness to my bleak existence 🤣😂
Idk, maybe an action scene or 2 wouldn’t hurt. One of the reasons I love these 2 guys is because of how self deprecating they are. You know, just like conceded frat boys.
Another great ep i love this pod cast i look forward to it every week keep up the great work in 2021
I mean, I love the show without action scenes, but I gotta say, that was hilarious. I listen to a few podcasts, and I have to say y’all (see, I’m even from the south!) clearly do the most research. You tell stories about crimes that 99% of the population don’t even know about! Fuck the haters!
Ahhhhhh! Fuck yes! Instant Classic! Y’all’s are the Gods of Pod! This was extreme belly laugh material! Next up .....an episode on cringe worthy festivals ? Doh! Never mind just found that in previous bonus episode list! Yeeeeeaaaaaaahhhhhhh!
That made me laugh! Those 1* reviews were ridiculous without foundation or thought. I've listened to many podcasts over the last few years, without a doubt, your two shows are noticeable the best researched, detailed and funniest out there. Keep up the brilliant work....... From across the pond in London
The greatest hour ever. LOL. Don’t ever change, fellas. I’m still dying laughing at these clowns comments about the show 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Those comments pissed me off! I live in a small town in Oklahoma. The guys were pretty spot on with their summation of it! Also wiki? You can tell how much research James does. He goes so deep into the story! I love you guys! Don’t change!
This one almost killed me
The wiki comment pissed me off. I stopped listening to a few podcasts whose only research involves wiki and an ID episode. Also, I got sick of hearing grown women talking like valley girls with vocal fries.
I can list a couple true crime podcasts where women talk like valley girls, one in particular I quit listening to when I found this one.
Absolutely Hilarious! 🤣
I like this show....as well as Missouri
Now I want them to actually do action scenes. You guys are amazing, even without them.
Gotta listen again. So great ✌ Plus Herb's story and the last 2 regular CIS episodes have been *chefs kiss*
The “action scene” had me in stitches. Keep the laughs coming guys
Love these so much. Thanks for the laughs, as always. Love u guys.
Ahhh one of the best. Go fuck your mother. I died!
I’ve done the math boys. Out of 198 episodes covering the USA, 25% covered the Southeast. The exact same % for the Midwest. My calculations show...you tend to hide the crazy in the West (which includes California, Oregon and Washington.). And let’s be honest, in that part of the States, all the crazy blood-thirsty people are hanging out along the I-5 corridor trying to get a cool new moniker for prison, they aren’t hanging out in small towns.
So what you're saying is they should do a "big town murder, small town shit" show after they wrap up STM
I grew up in the south ( Georgia and Florida), and have lived in the Boston area for 20 + years. Everything y’all say about both regions are hysterical , because its soooooo fucking true!!! Rock on gentlemen!!
This got me through the day. 🤣🤣🤣
Originally from Jackson, MI can confirm there's a lot of Mennonite & Amish communities. I was always fascinated with them whenever I saw them around town. My Dad was the manager of the Tire & Lube at Walmart, I'd just roam the store whenever he brought me to work and I once saw an Amish guy standing in the lingerie section touching a flaming red, silky teddy. I will never ever forget that. Full on mutton chops beard, suspenders, & straw hat staring intensely & touching a see-through silk nightie
LMFAO, that's great.
Stealing a line from timesuck: brilliant episode, amazing hosts, wouldn't change a thing! 3/5 stars!
Go fuck your mother if not I'll fuck your mother. I'll bend her fat ass over. Ha! I almost ran off the road laughing. Had to rewind and hear it again.
That was great. I have to remember to tell my husband that when he gets home. One time I laughed so hard when I was getting ready for work that I drew my eyeliner across my face😂
I laughed out loud the entire episode. You guys are great! You're the only Podcast I am a patreon of. You never disappoint!
You said exactly what I was thinking. I love these guys. I call them my boys.
Jesus Christ pls never stop! Live for both your podcasts! Fuck those morons 😂 you can tell you work your ass off! I recommend to everyone I know! 🤍
Agree. Love these guys. My #1. Listen 8 hours at work and at home. They r my 1st choice always. Others I like but more of a filler waiting for new episodes. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
I really value your content, you keep me laughing while working from home in a miserable job. Keep doing what you do.
🐦🐕🥜 I lost it over the swooping bird... 😅😅😅
FYI my 66 year old mother got me hooked on you guys
James jimmy is it true the family of the dude with 107 dildoes messaged you
yes
Haven’t laughed this much in a while
Lmmfao I loved this episode! As for the “bad review natzis” ehh fuck em.. I hope a bird flys down and attacks there left nut, or left tittie whatever. This is my favorite podcast by far and I tell as many people about it as I can.
Thanks for all of the hard work! Over the holidays, you were the only podcast in my library to produce new episodes, and bonus shows. Your work ethic, and dedication to your fans is unparalleled. I also love your attention to grammar and punctuation. My late father was a language teacher (he once corrected a card I gave to him). Wishing you and all of your fans a 2021 filled with laughter and hugs.
*thru
I’d never listened to any podcast before March . You guys got me they Covid ... listened to every one of both yours. James thinking north vs South Carolina was racist vs non- racist was the BEST !!! - Keep it up, y’all ! - Beth, Nashvillle.
Same! I’m on my second time around these podcasts. They’ve saved me the last few months!
The whole “did not finish” in reviews (of anything) drive me bonkers. And I am sooo mad for James on the wiki thing. The research is one of the main aspects of the show I use to talk new listeners into it! Great job guys. Goodness knows the laughs were sorely needed.
I needed to laugh today! Thank you for making me laugh so hard my dogs had to check on me.
I am just curious if you have noticed a trend!??? So pay close attention to the words so that it isn’t too difficult:). Each time the “African -American “ group in a town is 50% or so the crime in that town is also about 2 times the norm. I keep listening thinking maybe this time they will state the obvious, like oh, this town average income is 13,500 per year and oh, this town has 3 times the average crime?? Huh. ? What could it be? What a conundrum!! Oh, wait, I have it. It must be in Alabama??? Is that the answer? (Wiggle the finger on the lips). Please, at least, keep it real. Smooches!
You've been wondering why James and Jimmy haven't made it a running bit that people of colour double the crime rate of all small towns?
My stomach hurts from laughing
This could be its own spinoff podcast. F-ing brilliant.
This episode was the BEST I'm so sad James said they'll never do it again! 😂
I think they were referring to talking about negative reviews of their Podcast, at least I hope so as I loved this one!
James’ research is unparalleled. That person about the wiki page comment, was an idiot
Just to let you know, I do laugh out loud listening to you guys and the people at my office think I have lost my mind! You are a bright spot in my day. You have actually done shows on the 2 towns I grew up in, Villa Park IL and Baraboo WI didn’t know about either of them. Keep doing what your doing and fuck em if they can’t take a joke!
I WISH you would do small Canadian towns. The many I grew up in were all terrible (we moved a lot)! But I get it, there are already so many in the US that you'll have material for the next 60 years! But if you are curious, just look into Vernon, BC...you won't be disappointed. Keep it up! You guys are amazing, love your show.
Whenever James and Jimmy do non-American towns I feel they do the hack thing where they're too gentle about the town and claim Canadians are too nice. I love listening to Canadians complain about how racist and assholish everyone in Canada is in other podcasts.
“I have 8 kids and 2 cats” Me: “woah!” “My dog was attacked by a bird” Me: “LOL what!?!?!” “And his left testicle was injured” What a wild ride 🤣
What nobody seems to mention is if you have 8 kids and 4 cats you probably shouldn't have an non-neutered male dog in the house too
Omg I laughed so hard the entire time. I needed this today 😂😂😂
The terrible reviews... people are so freaking dumb! This is the best show ever!!
Totally panicked hearing the negative show review from “Charles” - thinking I accidentally hit the wrong star while leaving a review. For the record, definitely wasn’t me! Whoever that jackass is brings shame to the name.
Coal City, IL. - High schoolers are "Coalers" since "Miners" was taken by the middle schoolers. Both my daughter and I still don't know WTF a "Coaler" is! Anyone?
A person who coals? I dunno.
Tbh Y'all could read Shampoo Bottles and Id be in. I'll happily come from beneath my rock to you like minded people ♡
I'm in the DEEP south of SC. I laugh about yalls total truth of the south. Love you guys!
This is my favorite bonus episode by far 😂😂😂
I loved this so much! Hearing both of you laugh so heartily lifted my mood. You are appreciated. ❤️❤️❤️
I got mad too when James read the rewiev about him reading out wiki pages.
I’m envious of people that have the time and energy to bitch and moan about a podcast.
I’m sure I look like a lunatic laughing to myself at my desk, but this episode was exactly what I needed after last week.
Nice to see all my like-minded people in here, out from under our respective rocks.
It is material like this that makes me very happy I have become a patreon supporter of you both
Love the Edwin Starr/War reference. ❤️❤️
This was hilarious!! Exactly what I needed on my way to work.... in Detroit. 😂😂
Person complaining about all the boys do is make fun of the south ...I’m a Greek from Massachusetts...and the guys bury both ...and I love every second lol
I gasped out loud when they accused James of reading Wiki pages!
LOL... poor Michigan took a beating! I don’t live in Detroit or Flint, thank god. I have a decent buffer from both these fine cities. This was hysterical! 😂
My friend lost his weed when we were still in high school ..... washing machine 😂🤣🤣
I could hear you guys talk about towns for hours!
I was so excited to hear a review of my local Walmart!! Great job guys!! I love you guys.
I live in South Carolina and listen at work. When you talk about the south I can look around and see the people you are talking about all around me.
I love you guys even more after listening to your reactions to your bad reviews 🤣Currently going through a separation and just hearing your two voices brightens my day.
I love y'all! I live in West Texas (Midland) and everything y'all say about the fucking South is the absolute fucking truth and goddamn hilarious!! Don't ever fucking stop doing what y'all do!!
My sister and her family lives in Midland. Did you ever go to the Halloween house?
Hahahaha!! I laughed out loud so hard I peed my pants!!!
Can we get a "this world sucks" tee shirt? I need that in my life
I loved it! The making fun of their bad reviews was a classic. They should read the bad emails for a bonus episode.
Probably gonna wake up my husband laughing at this one!
I laugh at every episode but THIS ONE ... This one had me dying!
I’m concerned about how I actually “crave” James’ voice in my ears...
Seriously I'd listen to him reading the dictionary 😂
I make fun of the small town I live in.
Arivaca is south of Tucson. This whole episode was hysterical!!
You know that thing you didn't know you needed, but now wonder how you ever lived your life without it? Yeah...Thanks James and Jimmie.
This is the greatest ever. I had to pause and write a review to catch my breath from laughing so hard.
Omg I don't think I've laughed so hard in all my life! You two are awesome!
Been waiting all week for this nice!
