💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - GOODNIGHT, SUGAR BABE (1 of 2)
September 7, 2020

BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - GOODNIGHT, SUGAR BABE

This week, James and Jimmie talk about the documentary “Goodnight, Sugar Babe” on Amazon Prime. 

--

Have a question related to an episode? Does your small town have a cool/weird festival or parade in town? Maybe you just have a really cool Sahara desert fart fact? 

Call (602) 759-0606 and leave us a voicemail! 

It could be played on a bonus episode and answered/made fun of!  

Follow us on social media! 

Facebook.com/smalltownpod

twitter.com/murdersmall

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

Donate to the show on Patreon: 

patreon.com/crimeinsports

PayPal - crimeinsports@gmail.com

Contact the show: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Comments (114)

A
Arena Evans · May 1, 2026

OMG I had to go watch the documentary! That was a sloppy mess. The teeth, the guy constantly smiling (has to be a tick), the absolute insanity. It's just so shattering that people like this exist.

E
Evan Dickinson · December 3, 2025

James went hella Dark. 😆 🤣

S
Stacey Gladding · November 29, 2025

A companion piece to this episode and countless others: Listen to White Trash: The 400-Hundred Year Untold History of Class in America by Nancy Isenberg.

E
Em · November 1, 2025

Re-listening in 2025 and laughed JUST as hard as the first-time through. New intrusive sound bite: "Her wooooooomb"

J
Jesse White · October 22, 2025

I can deal with the poor quality of the documentary. The story though is one of the worst I’ve ever heard.

A
Ashleigh McLean · August 26, 2025

Less disturbing doc on this case: Matriarch of Murder on ID .... but I think J + J would do way better in a STM doc

H
Heather White · June 19, 2025

I started watching the doc in preparation for listening to this and immediately had to turn it off. Between the poor quality of the film and the pure filth of the subject matter, *shudders* Ohhhh, that was rough.

P
Peace Ransom · March 23, 2025

The people in this doc were so horrible I couldn’t even listen to you two discuss it.

J
Just Jamie · March 12, 2025

Hey this is my hometown!

R
Renata · January 19, 2025

I heard blowing a baby & couldn't listen anymore. That's where I draw the line I guess.

J
Jordyn Fahey · January 13, 2025

I just actually fell over laughing

M
Molly Horan · October 30, 2024

I love your "fem" voice, James! Cracks me up. I saw this doc b4 you did this episode and gross, just gross...

m
melissa speirs · September 27, 2024

l will skip the documentary. Unfortunately l did this in Criminology. That was enough.

S
Shadow Thomas · August 19, 2024

Ok. Haven't seen it. Now I gotta! I'm pissing myself...

L
Lisa King · August 8, 2024

‘Someone seal this shack off and burn it’ 🤣🤣🤣🤣

T
Tori Worthen · August 3, 2024

As someone from Ohio- I do not claim these people. Get it together Ohio!

P
Paige Lovelace · October 30, 2024

I’m from Ohio also around near where this happened and I don’t claim these people either I love Ohio but there are some people that should leave Ohio and never come back

J
Justin Glover · June 30, 2024

I've found the documentary on YouTube and I can see why you were so pissed off watching it. It's like something a five year old has done on their parents camcorder. One of the worst I've seen in terms of quality and as for this family, wow, what a bunch of freaks.

J
Jen Ward · May 18, 2024

I need more Streaming Consciousness James

S
Shannon McKinley · April 11, 2024

Why??? Does Michael keep smiling?! It's fucking weird.

J
Joker · March 28, 2024

The close ups are so bad you can see the hair on their tooths...!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

K
Kent Gerard · February 5, 2024

Yeah im about to watch this because of this patreon.

R
Renee Callahan · July 23, 2023

Ughhhhh!!! I wish I had heard this before I watched. But nooooo they have been spot on with the documentaries that I thought this time I'll watch before I listen.

G
Gwendolyn Ward · May 5, 2023

This is unfortunately where I live. You absolutely NAILED the description of them all, but especially Shannon! I couldn't stop 🤣!! I've been here since 1998 & never knew of these people until this all happened. It was so sad and our judicial system dropped the ball big time. Ty for covering this, bc not many other podcasts have. ✌🏽

M
Matthew James · March 2, 2022

Im really mad they kept saying “like hamburger” while i was…well, going to eat a burger lmao

K
Kendra Johnson · June 6, 2021

This story saddens me because my daughter is 15 right now and has a moderate intellectual disability and autism. Because of this, I am a bit overprotective. I would hate for anyone to do her like this. I make her take Taekwondo and lift weights. I also teach her the art of crazy and that everything is a weapon. No one wants their child to be a victim. This case hurt my heart and I wish they all got death for this.

J
Jenna Augustine Atwater · May 19, 2026

Can we please be best friends from a distance? I have 9 yr old mod/sev autistic twins, and a 3 yr old with mild symptoms. I am fully overprotective, especially of my son, who is giant for a 9yr old. I also took Taekwondo, and I would love to chat with you any time!!!

L
Lindsay Hiken · May 24, 2021

Was worried about listening to this before watching the documentary, but was feeling down today and desperate for the joy listening to the guys brings me. Thank Baby Jesus I didn’t watch it. I appreciate the guys taking one for the team! 🥴

R
Rachael Stanfield · April 29, 2021

Scarlet fever book was "the velveteen rabbit" not Winnie the pooh 😊 it was one of my favorites as a kid

J
Jaimie Harris · April 22, 2021

Thank you guys for watching this. You have done us all a service. In the immoral words of James, “that sounds terrible.”

J
Jaimie Harris · April 22, 2021

“The least runny egg.” I am never going to eat over easy eggs again. 🤢

T
Tierra Porter · March 20, 2021

Oh James how could ye forget the ma calls Sugar Babe an ‘Obituary Liar‘

C
Christy Brady · April 23, 2021

Omg yes!! Or when she talks about how Sherry "did a real good job with that one" talking about one of her kids 🤣

D
Dawn Kelley · March 13, 2021

From all the comments and Jimmie and James’ description I will never watch this. I was going to make an attempt but now not so much.

H
Heidi · March 10, 2021

I live in Findlay and to the, well I won't say "delight", to this town, the horrible mother in this story is dead. No, on second thought I will say delight.

H
Holly Sernulka · March 4, 2021

So after listening to this episode and laughing the whole time, I had to watch it. I’m a nurse so I work long shifts. The first time I tried to watch it was after work, relaxing on the couch. I made it about ten minutes in and fell asleep. My husband was next to me on the computer so he wound up half-listening to it and it played til the end. The second night I tried to watch-same thing happened and my hubby had to endure another viewing of it. So the third time I tried he refused to let me watch it in front of him because he didn’t want to be subjected to it again 😂😂😂

A
Amy Stanton · February 7, 2021

Okay....so...my friends and I wanna know why people are scared of Sugar Babe. We say, while she's in the wheelchair, push the her over and run like hell!! She won't be able to catch you. She's got bad feet!!! 😆😆

K
Katelin Logan · February 5, 2021

Update outta Tiffin — Cheri Brooks is dead 🤷🏽‍♀️

A
Al Karalius · January 26, 2021

I may have missed this in the comments or during the podcast, but this sounds familiar to an episode on Small Town Murders. Just curious if this was one of the STM episodes.

S
STM Turkey · January 13, 2021

Ohhhhh O-H....can confirm the way of life of certain people...it’s a way of life for generations, it seems.

T
Tricia Smith · January 12, 2021

Uh, wow. I went to college in Findlay during when this happened. This is the sketchy part of town, I've passed it many times before. Had not a clue. This is insane.

M
Maureen Cavanagh · November 17, 2020

Thank you. I am never watching this.

H
Heather Musser · November 11, 2020

During our shelter in place order I watched this when I ran out of things I watch & I couldn't believe it was real life. Mostly because I thought I somehow misread the genre as documentary when it was in fact some film students horrific class project of a mockumentary.

S
Scott Music · November 9, 2020

I wanna watch this but i gotta admit im a little scared

D
Dulcie Hall · September 27, 2020

I watched this like a year ago and it was just appalling. They should all be in prison, if only to end the breeding.

J
Jade313 · September 21, 2020

I almost paid for a subscription just so I could watch it! so glad I didn't! James and Jimmie did a good job with the commentary! That's all I need 😂🤣😎

J
Jade313 · September 21, 2020

TAINTED!! SEAL THE HOUSE UP FROM THE OUTSIDE perfect plan for these sorry fucks!!

D
Derrick Pacheco · September 19, 2020

Struggled through the whole thing, just to hear James and Jimmie tear it apart.

A
Annemarie Navarro · September 18, 2020

So i went to watch this after i heard this episode..put it on my watch list to see later..funny it was free when i searched it up..then a week later amazon was charging 2.99 for it! Im assuming it was thanks to you guys they started charging for this terrible doc..if you can call it that! No one was looking for this before!! Can't believe no one else was charged with more in this case. There was a terrible double murder in knox tn. yrs ago and everyone was charged just for knowledge and being there!! Ugh discusting.

G
Gwendolyn Ward · June 14, 2023

I can't believe they're charging for this when it's available on YT for free.

A
Amy DelPlato · September 16, 2020

I am trying to find a clip of the Live PD episode where the Florida trailer park landlord burned down the steps of his tenant’s trailer... Anybody?!

S
Stacey Walker · September 16, 2020

I listed to this before I watched and y'all were right I got 15 min in and was like naw I'm done lol

C
Chelsea Van Buskirk · September 14, 2020

It also took me FOREVER and many Google searches to figure out that Sugar Babe and Cheri are the same person. 🙄 I am glad I wasn't the only confused one, James.

T
Tatum with no last name · September 13, 2020

I wanted to watch it before listening, but I couldn't make it far.

A
Ash Lavatai · September 13, 2020

The entire thing was difficult to watch. The apathy was the most upsetting thing to see. How do people standby by and do nothing while watching this happen to someone?! Even the 911 dispatcher was like “oh, this bitch again.” The one baby mama w her own mother sitting side-by-side with arms crossed in a defensive position trying to justify seeing what they saw and then doing nothing is just disgusting. Thanks Jimmie and James for doing what you do! You guys are awesome and have made my quarantine 1000% more bearable!! XXOO

A
Amanda Krawczak · September 12, 2020

Against James advice I went ahead and wasted hours of my life to watch the documentary. Horribly made and I also made the mistake of eating while having to look at these people.

O
Oscar Park · September 12, 2020

Watched the programme after listening. They were/are a despicable brood. Did I get a cleaned up UK version? I saw lots of white teeth and (not too close) close ups? This was bad enough for me! Love you, Jimmie and James xx

P
Petal Maharaj Hwang · September 12, 2020

I watched this so I could listen to the bonus ep. Much like a lot of commenters here, I kept asking myself wtf was I watching??? Did the camera need to be so fucking close to the faces? The content was horrific enough.

D
David Joshua Jacobs · September 11, 2020

This trash confused me how to snow flakes fot into to the crips gang to begin with they are an african American gang. I feel i have been made dumber for watching it

G
Gwendolyn Ward · June 14, 2023

I live in Findlay, and can guarantee that there are no real gangs here. Our "gang members" basically just go around tagging things with spray paint and would like to think they're bad. 🤦🏽‍♀️

B
Brock Ryder · September 11, 2020

HOLY SHIT! My wife’s entire family lives in Findlay. Needless to say we never visit.

G
Gwendolyn Ward · June 14, 2023

I live here and these people are NOT representative of us who are not inbred. 🤣🤷🏽‍♀️✌🏽

P
Paolo Gilli · September 11, 2020

Horrible doc, kinda curious what you guys have to say about it. Just one more thing... DENTAL CARE FFS!!!

F
Francis Olsson · September 11, 2020

Did anyone wonder why there were dick picks with 'your name' in this documentary???

J
Jeanelle Amonette · September 10, 2020

I became a patron just to listen to you make fun of this “documentary.” Worth every penny!

G
Gwendolyn Ward · June 14, 2023

Same! & YESSS!!

E
Eric Waggoner · September 10, 2020

Holy fuck what the fuck did I just listen to ?

N
Nicole Ellis · September 10, 2020

Like James, I am baffled by the sheer number of people who were there and just watching this happen. I “get it” from the inbreds who all live there. What excuse do Dead Punky’s baby mama and baby maw maw have?!? They were just over for a visit, saw Vera get beaten and thought nothing of it? They are all obituary liars that belong in prison.

M
Mike Itteilag · September 10, 2020

James may have been thinking of a "video toaster". Also this "video" sounds terrible.

B
Brian Cotton · September 10, 2020

holy shit what in the actual fuck did i just watch. I thought the Whites of West Virginia were a fucked up family. These people give Fucked Up a new name. Every single one of these inbread fucks need to rot in hell no skip that hell is to nice of a place for them.

A
Aaron Lehmann · September 9, 2020

You missed one fuckin hilarious quote from sugar babes mother. She called her a "obituary liar"! Holy shit I pooped myself laughing.

G
George Armstrong · September 9, 2020

This bonus episode was absolutely hilarious! I could not bear to finish Goodnight Sugarbabe, only managed 25 minutes, unlike Wonderful Whites who I tell everyone to watch, it’s not safe to tell anyone about Sugarbabe!! Love the show!

M
Megan O'Brien · September 9, 2020

I hate everyone that made James and me watch this.

A
Andrea Papageorge · September 9, 2020

This story left me totally disgusted. I briefly thought about watching - but then I googled the documentary and saw some of the pictures of these pieces of crap. I don't think I could watch it without heaving.

B
Blue Yake · September 9, 2020

The whole time 2 things kept screwing with my head. The guy who says something totally fucked up then Smiles. Then the camera zoomed in so close that you can see that almost every woman on it has a mustache or beard. They make sure to really zoom in on the Mom's mole that has a mini duck dynasty beard of it's own.

N
Ninth Life · September 9, 2020

I have some questions and I reeeeally would prefer to not watch this, haha. So these people killed Vera and are opening admitting to it on camera, but never were arrested? Or did I miss something?

A
April Moore · September 9, 2020

Nope! You missed nothing. I, unfortunately watched the "Documentary". I was horrified! EXACTLY how James perfectly described the narrator and the full on sliminess of the people. The one thing (well biggest thing) I'm questioning is HOW THE FUCK people being interviewed from the comfort of their home?

M
Miller Hinds · September 8, 2020

2nd try watching it myself and so confused but holy shit. I look forward to hearing the Js break it down

M
Miller Hinds · September 9, 2020

Omg absolutely was worth seeing the documentary to listen to this episode

B
Big Jeffrey · September 8, 2020

They actually do mention what "doing her feet" is but it was quick (cough and you'll miss it). Doing Sugar Babe's feet is a rubbing massage of her beautiful feet.

J
JeniDarlin · September 8, 2020

^home, that is

J
JeniDarlin · September 8, 2020

I went ahead and watched this last night so I could know what James and jimmy were talking about. It was rough but I feel better after listening to this cuz you always make me laugh out loud. Thank God I work from time right now! ! You guys are so awesome. I love your podcasts and bonus eps!

R
Rosie Goldstein · September 8, 2020

I needed to check to make sure I still had all my teeth after this crazy ass story! This was so awesome thanks guys you’re the best!!!!❤️❤️❤️

M
Megan · September 8, 2020

I haven’t seen the documentary so I listened to this more as background noise and I kept finding myself hearing snippets and saying “WTF”

D
Devone Cleveland · September 8, 2020

Nobody in the that entire documentary had all there teeth. That entire family was just disgusting to look at.

M
Matthew Bolin · September 8, 2020

I think that show you’re talking about with the star wipes, etc. was “Newton’s Apple”. Take a look at the first few seconds of this episode and there’s wacky wipes galore: https://youtu.be/qoAQAhi1BFY

S
Sarah Mitchell · September 7, 2020

I should have listened and not watched, terrible.

M
Michael Chumley · September 7, 2020

Y’all should take this case and do your own spin on it instead of critiquing the idiocy of the documentarians

K
Katelin Logan · September 7, 2020

Here we missed the stats on this town but yo this is it 😂

M
Mel Hancock · September 7, 2020

WTF. I am sorry wypipo. But what the fuck is an obituary liar?

E
Erin Taylor · September 7, 2020

So I had to watch after hearing the Bonus Episode cause I’m a glutton for punishment. I couldn’t help but have flashbacks from the Chappelle Show skit “Mad Real World” with the way it was filmed. Lmao! And I could’ve definitely done without seeing those dick pics...yuck.

D
David · September 7, 2020

Dude. Apparently this is my 4th time watching this absolute shit doco because the first 3 times I had to turn it off. I agree 100% with James' analysis... I can't even count how many times I had to rewind this thing to understand what the hell was going on or who this or that person was. And I still don't understand

D
Dave · September 7, 2020

I'm mad I had to watch it to prepare. What horrible people they are.

D
D Wash · September 7, 2020

I watched it to be prepared for your review. When Sugar Babe's mom said, "They say she's a obituary liar!" I felt at least 8 of my brain cells pack up and leave. *Thank you both for what you do and how you do it.

B
Brooke Cale · September 7, 2020

Holy Jesus Christ what did I just watch??

R
Rosa Garcia · September 7, 2020

I watched this three times because the first two times my brain would shut down at some point in the movie

S
Shelly Ewonchuk · September 7, 2020

Why does that one guy smile after every sentence!? "My mother killed her" *big smile* What the fuck.

A
Amanda E Hirsch · September 14, 2020

It's a tic- but it sure is disturbing

S
Shelly Ewonchuk · September 7, 2020

What the actual fuck is going on!? I listened to the episode, so I thought I had an idea of what happened. 20 minutes into the "documentary" and I feel like I started a story half way through it. Who the fuck are these people!? I have no idea what is happening. Somebody needs to sit down with whoever put this shitty documentary out into world and see if they are ok. Because if they can follow this story, something is wrong with their brain.

B
BubbleSprite · September 7, 2020

I agree! Lock the whole family in a cabin and burn it to the ground... the whole town just wipe it out!... I know it’s not nice but burn it down they are all tainted

J
James Cyr · September 7, 2020

Wow that was hard to watch

T
Tina · September 7, 2020

I actually know these "people". Findlay is my hometown. This is not sensationalized or poorly done. It is absolutely real. You can see this disgusting piece of human trash on any given day riding around town on her motorized bike.

B
BubbleSprite · September 7, 2020

This doc is so fuked up! Cheri is sick and wtf is up with keeping/using a nick name your rapist gave you

L
Lauren W · September 7, 2020

This is so fucked, can't handle the sex torture. I'll be skipping this doc but appreciate the guys reviewing it

P
Paul Barrett · September 7, 2020

Don't fuck with cat's would be great. This doco is a complete waste of time

B
Bethany Magee · September 7, 2020

I’m trying to finish the doc before listening to this episode. Man, it’s hard. Sick, twisted shit.

R
Rohan Bajaj · September 7, 2020

A weird mix of Wild Whites of West Virginia and Tiger King

R
Rikki Boelen · September 7, 2020

oh man wft did I watch...

G
Gianna DeLuca · September 7, 2020

RELIEVED to hear someone confirm that this documentary was poorly done! I thought I was just super hyper-critical about true crime documentaries. What about an episode on "Don't fuck with cats!!!!" ?

M
Melissa & Eli C · September 7, 2020

James you could do better than this movie, and it got bought by Amazon! New career path for you perhaps?

J
Justin ZDH · September 7, 2020

Just finished the documentary. This shit was crazy as fuck

A
Ally Quay · September 7, 2020

Yes yes yes!!

S
Sina · September 7, 2020

Thank you so much! This is just what I needed to start the week. Its ten to six and Im about to leave to go teach. Have a good week!

N
Nic Saturnine · September 7, 2020

Yesssss! I absolutely mentioned this to them on Twitter! Absolutely fucked up shit. Can't wait to listen.