BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - SODUS NY
This week, James and Jimmie discuss a murder most foul from Sodus, New York!
(Don't forget... Jimmie did the research and tells the story, this time!)
Have a question related to an episode? Does your small town have a cool/weird festival or parade in town? Maybe you just have a really cool Sahara desert fart fact?
Follow us on social media! Facebook.com/smalltownpod twitter.com/murdersmall instagram.com/smalltownmurder
Donate to the show on Patreon: patreon.com/crimeinsports PayPal - crimeinsports@gmail.com
Contact the show: crimeinsports@gmail.com
Comments (244)
OMG this is the most frantic and anxiety inducing thing I’ve ever listened to and I love it so much 😂😂 Please give us more Jimmie lead episodes! I’m begging you!
Please do this again
Awesome jimmie!!!
And this was the last time Jimmie ever conducted the show 🤣💀⚰️🪦
We love Jimmie. 🙃
Got patreon specifically for this episode. Love Jimmie. James is okay.
This is our favorite place to visit. I listen all the time, my husband prefers your stupid opinions. But can't wait to hear this one. We are going to listen now. Very excited 😊
Great job Jimmie!!!
Worth all the money to hear Jimmie tell a story. Next time I want all the bells and whistles of the real estate report music
Jimmie FYI I don’t know if the festival is real with all those great bands. But I do know Nashville has some of the best recording studios in the country. You’d be amazed at names and bands that record in Nashville. From opera to R&B to Ragge to Rock Country world renowned artists. Maybe the artists were going to be in Nashville and thought what the heck it’d be fun to do this little festival. As you say “just sayin”. lol.
“We’ll do it ‘every 6 months or so’”…we’re pushing 6 YEARS, gents!!..let’s get a Round 2 💪
Jesus!! Lol. I guess they didn't think it worked out. 🤣🤣
Good story Jimmy! But why does Jimmy always read like he has to take a piss? 🤣 is he nervous?
I felt the same way 🤣 he was so funny tho
If you listen at half speed, it’s like a full episode (but drunk)! 😂🤣 Joking aside, GREAT episode!
I love this episode. I've asked before and I'll ask again: another Whisman narrative episode again. It's wonderful. Jimmie tells a great story.
Jimmie is very good at telling the stories! I laughed so much 🤣
Woohoo Jimmie! Knocked it outta the park!! 🥰
LOVED IT Jimmie! Could you slow down a bit?!
I want a longer one lol
So glad I found this episode 🤣🤣🤣🤣Jimmie is hilarious
This is my favorite bonus episode 😂 Jimmie telling a story is the most entertaining
I would love for them to do this again now that they aren't worried about time concerns
❤️ Love it!
Awesome!
Great job Jimmie!!
Good job, Jimmy. I enjoyed listening to you tell that story.
Fabulous job, Jimmie! Great story!
Great job Jimmie!!
I am so pumped! I finally found the Jimmie episode! Great job! I can’t wait until you do another episode. ❤️
Jimmie*
GREAT JOB JIMMY! Can't wait until you do this again ❤️
Great job Jimmie! This town is 20 minutes from me, my husband's hometown. It was a crazy few days
I love this omg, please have Jimmie host again!!!! Can he do that author lady who killed her chef husband ?
Fuck yes.
Jimmie is fantastic!! Can't get enough of him!
Love this one!
Really hope you guys do this again. Your three podcasts are what have been keeping me going for the past two years
The past 4 years for me. And this week I finally subscribed to patreon so we’ve got 5 years of bonus content to binge!
Great job, Jimmie!
Great job, Jimmie! I loved this. Hope you do it again!
We've hit a road block 😂
Jimmie SLOW DOWN!!! Other then that great job
I’m relistening to this one. This was so good! It was like listening to the show on 1.25 speed. 😂 Jimmie, do another one. Great job!
Go Jimmie! Well done Man!
Oh this was awesome! Jimmie did so good! I love his laughs! I didn’t realize this one was done, it’s an hour away from me so it was interesting to hear. Seems he’s in Clinton Correctional Facility. Which also happens to be the same Prison David Sweat and Richard Matt Escaped from in 2015. Matt was killed when they found him and Sweat has bounced all over because he had made escape plans from the other prisons he went to. He was in Attica for a bit, and Five Points, and for a while in Auburn, which is about 5 minutes from where I work 😂 not sure where he is now. If you look him up it says auburn but his hunger strikes from 2022 say elsewhere
You rocked it Jimmie
Jimmie did a fantastic job.
I honestly thought this was going to be go over poorly, but Jimmie did a great job. Surprised me a bit, during normal shows he HE HAWS so much when he interrupts James to say something that he sounds like a donkey that just got kicked in the nut sack.
I liked seeing Jimmy in the driver's seat. Great episode!
Jimmie needs to tell the story more often! That was fantastic!!
Jimmie was awesome!!!!
That was awesomeness 😍
👵🖐👶
You have the best screen name ever.
Jimmie did a great job!!
Go Jimmie! That was fantastic!
More Jimmie, That Was Fun!!!
Yoooooo! Jimmie crushed it! Great job, bubba!!
Amazing 🤩 I haven’t laughed this hard in a long time!! Yaaaaaaaaay Jimmie 🤍
This is crazy, idk how I missed this but I'm legit 3 miles from sodus right now lol
I’m from Gray New-Gloucester, ME! Where Shaker Village! Sabbathday is the name of the street and lake they’re little village is on!!!
This is a gem!
👌🏼🤌🏻 good stuff Jimmie!
Nice!!!
Bravo Jimmie! so fun
Great job, Jimmie! I love it!
Good job Jimmie!! Lmao. You should do a FULL episode. 😂
Great job Jimmie! Love you guys!!!!
Sexual 🐨 koalaty
Jimmie, you sir are awesome!!
Nice job Jimmie!
Great job Jimmie!!
I love when Jimmie tells the story!!
Loved this!
Nice job Jimmie!
Jimmie runnin the show gave me anxiety 😂😂
Good job Jimmie! Loved it
I live an hour away from Sunray, and It's insane that I don't remember hearing anything over this. Great story Jimmie this was amazing.
I've sadly lived in the Rochester NY area for about 10 years now. Can and will 100% agree with the accuracy of how awful Sodus is! Though Sodus Bay kind of has redeeming qualities. Jimmie I adored hearing your telling of this heinous crime. You boys are the best!
I must also comment that, Jimmie, when you read my name you got it 100% right first try. The last name always trips people up so mad props my man.
Great job Jimmy 👍👍
Amazing 👏! This was a fun one, Jimmie you did great!
Jimmie did great! Love more of these! PS you said my Italian name RIGHT with only one small exasperated “Jesus Christ” 👏🏼 👏🏼 👏🏼
Great job, Jimmie!
Seems like people have finally noticed Nova Scotia over the past 12 months. Our housing market exploded. James would lose his mind if he compared our 2018 and 2021 real estate reports 😂
Jimmie, you did a great job! I loved it!
Fantastic, Jimmie! Well done!
That was so awesome!! Fanks Jimmie!! Legendary.
Love it! Good job, Jimmie!
Great job Jimmie!
Great job Jimmie!!
Wow Jimmie what can I say? You delivered the goods man, then some. And what about that knob end? He was chief of police? Imagine getting arrested in his town? No hope for that Small Town!
Ayo, great job Jimmie! You’re A Natural! And the disrespect to upstate New York? :Chef’s Kiss: As a former Rochester resident, that was spot on.
Also great job Jimmie! Loved this bonus episode with you taking the lead
Saw the video. I want to cut this guy’s fucking hands off and bludgeon them both with them
Great job Jimmie! When I heard you were going to lead an episode I just had to start donating! Can't wait to see you guys live!
My neice is Mattie.
Wow. I'm near Sodus. I can't wait to listen!
Jimmie!!! The amount of joy this ep gave me CANNOT be overstated! 🤣 Tysm. Gold.
Sunray is like 30 mins away from where I grew up lol our schools are rivals in football so when this happened my family called me to tell me how bad Sunray is now. Love that yall did this.
Get it Jimmie!!! 💜
This was awesome. Big up for Jimmie! : )
Bravo Jimmie ♥️
YAAAAAY to Jimmie
Jimmie you did a great job with this story!! Looking forward to the next one!!! Thanks
Fine work and presentation by Jimmie!
This was so much fun to listen to! And this episode was the whole reason I signed up on Patreon :) Love you guys!
Well done, Jimmie!!
Great job, Jimmie!!
Dead ass became a patron finally to hear this episode 👏🏽😂
Same! Got a new job and said “finally get to hear the Jimmie episode!!!” 🤣🤣🤣
Bravo Jimmie
This was fan-fucking-tastic Jimmie!
I just ran into this story on Fatal Vows- Hell On Wheels (Season 7, Episode 4)!! Jimmie, you told it better!!!🙂
You did a great job!
Way to go Jimmie! Loved it
Love, love, loved this!
Listening to Jimmie describe this town is adorable. I know grown men don't like it when you call them adorable, but I don't know how other to describe it.
Great job Jimmie!!! Loved it😊🌴🧡🌺
Awesome
That was awesome Jimmie 👏👏
Jimmy is talking sooooo fast!
Excellent work! That was fantastic! Looking forward to the next one!
Hey guys, loved Jimmies first episode. looking forward to the next one in 6 months or so.
Great episode! Missed the chance to say “Colt Forney-Five” though.... 😂🤣
Great job Jimmie! It was an honor to have you mispronounce my name during last week’s episode.
I’ve been a Patreon supporter for like a year and have never listened to the extra shows. I literally just give the guys my money because they give me so much joy. This is the first one and it did NOT disappoint 😂😂
This is the episode that convinced me that I needed to be a Patreon supporter
Epic! Way to go Jimmie!!
This was great
Deadly
Great job Jimmie!!!
Awesome job Jimmie!!!
Great job!!!!
Clinton correctional
Jimmie hosting an episode is THE highlight of membership!
Good job Jimmie!🥳
You guys are amazing! Thanks for making my work day fun! Jimmie you did fucking great!
Joined patreon just for this episode! Good job Jimmie!!
Great job Jimmie!
Great job. So glad I decided to finally become a Patreon
Awesome job! I live in Amarillo and never heard this story and I go to Sunray at least twice a year. I feel dumb that I didn't know about this but in my defense I rather drink beer than watch the news. Any which way Great job Jimmie!
Great job Jimmie. Nice to hear some of the commentary from James as well when he doesn't have to worry about telling the story.
Jimmie you killed it, I loved the pacing, hope you’ll do it again in the future
Good job Jimmie.
In true Jimmie fashion..love the stumbling and swearing just perfect
I love that Jimmie sounded so frantic in the beginning, like there was a time limit XD. He did great though. Really rad idea to switch it up. You guys are amazing as always!
I signed up for the Patreon just to hear Jimmie
This was so awesome. Jimmie did a great job!
Great job Jimmie!
This was awesome. Good job mate!
Jimmie, great job! You nailed it!
Great job, Jimmie!
I legit signed up because of this episode and you did not disappoint, not surprised because you guys are amazing!!! You can have my money!!!
Great job Jimmie!!!
Jimmie Whisman....no no, Whiteman, no. What did I do? Fuck it...Good job Jimmie😉
Awesome job Jimmie!!
WTG Jimmie, you did a great job! The stumbling and swearing made it even funnier!
🙌🏾 love u guys!! 😂😅 Jimmie did a great job. Hilarious and full of information 😂
You guys nailed upstate New York! I'm from Newark, one town south of Sodus along 88. Sodus is either really nice and resort-y, or completely backwoods and meth-y.
This was perfect, down to Jimmie getting mad about not being able to read the names
Great job jimmie
Omg I loved this! Great job, Jimmie.
You did great Jimmie!
Rochesterian here. I laughed almost as hard as Jimmie at the part about the roadside apples and fill dirt. Fantastic job!
Great job Jimmie. So what doy you like best. Telling the story or hearinh the story.
that was awesome, great job!!!
Good job Jimmie!! 👏👏👏
Great job Jimmie!!!! Awesome story!!!
What a treat!! Ha Ha I’m from Rochester and know Sodus well. I love when James rips apart upstate NY. Always so very accurate. Looking forward to the next story time with Jimmie!! You guys are great!! (Ps I got outta upstate).
Great job, Jimmie. I was smiling hard thinking of my friends who live in Rochester and Syracuse where spring has just about arrived.
After 71 episodes I finally join patreon... just for you guys. If you're still doin shout outs hopefully I'll hear my name when I catch up! seriously though, I love you guys. Coming from someone that falls asleep to forensic files I never thought I would enjoy True Crime as much as I have with you. Thank you!
awesome job jimmie great episode
Awww, your daughters name is Maddie! Not gonna lie, for like a year, I thought your daughters name was Sarah! (It made me feel so much better about the Third Love ads when I finally realized that Sarah was your wife.) On another, unrelated note, I loved Jimmie leading this episode!!
❤️❤️
Abolutely loved it
Great job Jimmie!!
Fantastic bananas!
Great job, Jimmie! Lots of similarities between this week's other story including the deals!! Gotta get the best price on those arrows and ski masks!
Abso-fucking-lutely terrific jimmy! I look forward to the next one in 6 months or so. You’re the the best ♥️
You killed it, Jimmie! Loving all of the bonus episodes - please keep 'em coming!
Nice job Jimmie!!
You Jimmie...May do these anytime. You kicked ass!
Loved the episode, especially that Jimmie started going “It was...um....uh....goddammit” towards the end because he either couldn’t read his writing or he was just so unorganized when he wrote things out. Can’t wait for the next one in December or so!
December???
Color me impressed
This was hilarious. I’ve been waiting for this day since I started listening to the J’s. Native New Yorker here, (super close to James’ hometown) and the location and story couldn’t be better for me to hear Jimmie tell it. Thanks for a phenomenal time as always!!
Fucking great job Jimmie. We're live near Sodus. This was a huge story. Yaayyyy!
Yayyy way to go Jimmie
Way to go Jimmie! And way to go James for not completely taking over!
I thought Jimmie did an awesome job popping his cherry on this one. It was cool to hear STM told in a different way.
James certainly sets the bar high each week and you nailed it Jimmy
Amazing job Jimmie! 👏👏
Finally sorted patreon. Excellent Jimmie and James. Binged all. Cheers!
Yee-Haw ! First Jimmies episode took place in Texas.
Yaaaay!!! Great job Jimmie!! ❤❤
Great job Jimmie 👏
♥️♥️♥️♥️
Yay! Jimmie
More of Jimmie telling stories!!!
Can't wait for the next one. See you in six months Jimmie!
Loved this! Great job Jimmie!
Kudos to Jimmie!!! Great choice of story full of “What The Actual Fuck?!” Moments from me. Hilarious - seriously awesome job as always guys! Yaaaaaaay indeed
Great job Jimmie!
This was so good!! Great job, Jimmie!!
Great job Jimmie!!!!!
Well done Jimmie!
Damn good job Jimmie!!
I'm only here for James Dick jokes
Loved it great job!
Yayyyy Jimmie!
YAAAAYYY!!! Way to weave a tale Jimmie :) Well done sir!
I became a patron specifically for this. I've wanted to for do long and I'm so glad I did. I was hoping to hear Jimmie give the disclaimer but obviously if your a patron you don't need one. Anyway I'm glad to throw m my money at these guys who work so hard and make my life as an overwhelmed FedEx driver somewhat bearable. Amazing job Jimmie!
Great job, Jimmie! I know you were nervous but you crushed it.
Great Job Jimmie!!!!
STM speed run Jimmie! Noice
Really was looking forward to a Jimmie "your sir may fuck off" and the gavel, but otherwise amazing. So good and fresh
Great freaking job, Jimmie!! Laughed my ass off, amazing story as well!
Yew. Well done dude. Smashed it.
Atta boy Jimmie!
Great job Jimmie!!
I knew it would be awesome. And it was. And I laughed my ass off when Jimmie hit an unusual name...because you know it had to happen 🤣🤣
Words don’t describe how excited I am about this! 😁 Don’t wort Jimmie I feel your pain I gotta country as fuck accent and struggle at work cuz I also stutter sometimes. I work for an automotive warehouse and dealing with customers over the phone is a got’damn nightmare but you do great buddy I’m sure you’ll knock this mini-STM outta the park sir.
This is worth every penny. I love that no matter what he does, Jimmie will ask at least once "No, what did I do??" and then flounder for 30 seconds trying to figure it out.
Take a deep breath Jimmie!
Jimmie is the cliff notes to James.
That was amazing! Thank you guys soooooo much! Jimmie, way to go on finding that story. Such a treat!!!
Awesome job Jimmie! I love so much How James encouraged you and kept telling you it's alright when you didn't have the info 😍😂
It reminded me of when someone in class has to present and the teacher inserts some gentle encouragement and commentary. :) <3 Jimmie did such a great job!
This was so great! Way to go Jimmie!
Been not so patiently waiting for Jimmie to do this! Great job!
YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!! IM BEYOND EXCITED FOR THIS!!!!!! Now, on with the show!!
Great job, Jimmie!!!
I’m so frickin excited for this! Even more so now that I am sitting in the ER because I reacted poorly when my 90 pound dog attacked my 45 pound puppy. I know better, but I couldn’t find my dog mace. They both got the same hand 😕. The guys are going to make it all better though! 😁😁
It's Showtime!
Anyone ever see this? Lol: http://www.pomc.com/mine_petitions/small%20town%20murder.pdf
Wish I could sign my name "You Sir", my city and state would be "May Fuck Off!"
I think it's going to be a good Friday night at home...
Oh hell yes!
Omg I’m so excited!!
I’ve been refreshing the feed all day waiting for this!!👏
Yes! Thank you guys for taking my suggestion. You made my day!
Wow, I had impeccable timing signing up 🥰
