💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
BONUS - The Prisoner Dating Game! (1 of 2)
April 24, 2020

BONUS - The Prisoner Dating Game!

This week, James and Jimmie play another round of: The Prisoner Dating Game: The All Violent Felon Edition! (Jimmie won't know what they did, until after he picks the lucky guy or gal.)

Have a question related to an episode? Does your small town have a cool/weird festival or parade in town? Maybe you just have a really cool Sahara desert fart fact? 

Call (602) 759-0606 and leave us a voicemail! 

It could be played on a bonus episode and answered/made fun of!  

Follow us on social media! 
Facebook.com/smalltownpod
twitter.com/murdersmall
instagram.com/smalltownmurder

Donate to the show on Patreon: 
patreon.com/crimeinsports
PayPal - crimeinsports@gmail.com

Contact the show: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Comments (63)

I
Isaac Moya · October 1, 2025

It's about 2026, lol

B
Blackrain4 · September 20, 2025

These episodes are the best lol

N
Nicki Solowij · August 5, 2025

Love this game, please keep them going

b
buckwild_becks · December 7, 2023

I’ve spent the last year tits deep in STM. I finally caught up, heard my name in an episode, and I’ve just gotta say you guys are f*ckin amazing. You’ve become a part of my everyday life, and you’ve shared some really inspiring stories that have been helpful for me throughout some real tough times. Idk if you’ll ever read this or anything, but thank you guys for all that you do, and thank you for being the voices in the back of my head today, reminding me that “there’s nothing like a good divorce” Finalized & scumbag free on 12/6/23!! Also…I wish you guys would do a show here in Vegas. Though I’m stoked for 2024 dates. I’ll be making a drive somewhere! Oh, and uhm…aye yo Whisman..sup?!? 😁 juuuust kidding (kinda)

J
Jeremy James · August 16, 2022

Royalty and Russian Turnip Farmer hahahahhahahaahahahahaha

S
Sarah Zamenski · July 8, 2024

I am so late to this party, but I have a Polish last name, and this KILLED me. My first name means Princess, and my last name means... cherry farmer lolllllllllll

C
CC Brooks · February 28, 2022

This is my first month of being a Patreon and the Prisoner Dating Game has made it more than worth it. Thank you for making me laugh out loud while cleaning the house and taking care of a new baby. You’re saving my sanity, guys! 💕

L
Lauren DiChiara · March 3, 2022

Gurrrl I'm a single mom with a 6 year old and I just started listening to this show and it's saving my life - congrats on new baby ❤️

P
Princez Tia · September 15, 2021

OMG! This was great! My coworkers think I am a freaking lunatic because I have been laughing like a hyena! 🤣😜

K
Kelly Ferraro · July 30, 2021

Love this!

K
Kat & Mr Fish · February 7, 2021

I laughed so hard, I think I broke a blood vessel in my gut!!!

C
Clarissa Machado · January 31, 2021

Love it! 😍

S
Susan E Olges · November 17, 2020

Way to go Jimmie for choosing the best ones out of each lot.

S
Sara Kowalik · September 17, 2020

By far the best version

P
Payton Sportsgirl · May 30, 2020

I hope you’ll do more dating game episodes! These are my favorite! 🤣😂🤣

K
Kristin Miller · May 18, 2020

This was fucking gold lmao 😂😂😂

B
Bethany Mavronicles · May 18, 2020

I joined the Patreon to see the photos of these people after listening to the episode. Doh.

R
Rita Merritt · May 11, 2020

How do you find the info for this game?? Would love to play it with friends and family.

k
kyledamon96 · September 27, 2020

Writeaprisoner.com

M
Mike & Jo Szymanski · May 10, 2020

This is pure gold! HA!

K
Krista Schmidt · May 10, 2020

I cannot tell you how happy this made me. I would listen to as many of these as you put out!

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · May 7, 2020

This one was amazing!!! Would love to hear a bonus of sale ads...cause I love when James says "the sales!!! Jimmie!!"

J
Julie Zaniboni · May 6, 2020

Can we see the pictures of bachelors and bachelorettes too? This stuff is priceless!

K
Kourtnie “Shad Grimgravy” King · May 5, 2020

Ok, this game is sooooo much fun.

J
Jade313 · May 4, 2020

Omg 😂. I loved this episode!! I was totally surprised at the crimes they committed especially after Jimmie almost needed a cigarette after the last contestant! 🤪 I must apologize but every time James would say SHE SHOT AN OLD MAN!! I laughed like hell! It was the way he said it I guess.. and I was shocked by her charges!

B
Beth Sutherland · May 3, 2020

Play this all the time!

A
Amanda Pruys · May 2, 2020

Can you do a death row murders dating game 😂😂😂

R
Rosie Goldstein · May 2, 2020

This was so awesome and yes I agree with James let’s play it all the time! Every day how bout? 🤪😎 Thanks this episode made my day, you always make me laugh out loud 😂🥳

W
Wendy Miller · May 2, 2020

hahaha I self educate myself

B
Beth Nisonger · May 1, 2020

I want to play this with some friends. This was so much fun and can’t wait until the next one!!

T
The Bollero Fam · May 1, 2020

I’m just happy that I got a pair of Rothy’s for my birthday ♥️ love you guys!

A
Al Croons · April 29, 2020

I was waiting for Jimmie to go “My kind of guy.”

A
Adam Heaton · April 29, 2020

Need to do a version on the male convict side where Jimmie has to pick the dude who isn't in jail for kid diddling seeing as how, before the subject does the crime, Jimmie never fails to say "Sounds like my kinda guy"

A
Angela Sorensen · April 29, 2020

I need to see these pictures

D
Donna Muscato-Galley · April 29, 2020

You nailed it!!! Could listen to this every day and it would still be funny!!!

J
Jeff Hamik · April 29, 2020

You guys make me look forward to Tuesday and Thursday mornings! Bonus episodes are even better!

C
Code Red · April 28, 2020

Great bonus episode.

C
Corus Jackal · April 26, 2020

You really perfected the format! I can't wait to hear the next Prisoner Dating Game!

D
Daniel Smith · April 26, 2020

This format was fantastic. Thanks guys. My only recommendation would be to wait for pictures until the end. I feel like that sways the decision making. But either way, so good. Keep up the good work gents.

D
Dani Cav · April 25, 2020

Best one yet guys!!! Good job!

T
Tracy Poetz · April 25, 2020

I love the new and improved prisoner dating game!!

C
Cathy Samuels · April 25, 2020

This is going to be a must play game the next time my family gets together. Thanks for a great idea!!

M
Miller Hinds · April 25, 2020

I love the prisoner dating game!

M
Miller Hinds · April 25, 2020

I. Fucking. Loved.this.that is all

B
Brooke Cale · April 24, 2020

This is the goddamn BEST.

K
Kathie Jackson · April 24, 2020

Yea James, you definitely perfected the prisoner dating game! Loved how Jimmie had to pick first before knowing the crime! Great work boys!

A
Amy Paulson · April 24, 2020

This is the best version of the prisoner dating game!

K
Kyle Andrew Mooney · April 24, 2020

You were able to find her prisoner profile pic? Where at?

A
Amy Paulson · April 24, 2020

Writeaprisoner.com

K
Kyle Andrew Mooney · April 24, 2020

Look up Paige Seaton, tell me if you guys agree.

C
Collin Chapin · April 24, 2020

Totally agree after looking her up lol. Would not have been my pick due to hotness alone. I think you may be correct about the photo.. atleast from my standard of "hot" and hearing jimmies reaction (but then again wasnt the victim 15 or something.. so yikes hope we havent just all objectified an underage victim 😬😵) awkwardlol...

K
Kyle Andrew Mooney · April 24, 2020

I now question Jimmies judgement now, I looked up Paige and she isn’t hot at all. I’m thinking maybe they got the picture mixed up with the victim.

C
Collin Chapin · April 24, 2020

I agree with Jimmy!! #freepaige!!! She totally got fucked! Shes served her fair time. I cant believe a child didler got off that easy and she got 30+years for a drunk driving accident!?!?!? I may have a different perspective from living in texas.. but here literally people kill multiple people drunk driving and get off with fines and essentially a slap on the wrist 🤦‍♂️ our "justsice" system is fucked. #freepaige

K
Kyle Andrew Mooney · April 24, 2020

I love this game! Only thing I would change is to also upload the people’s picks on here so we can see also.

C
Collin Chapin · April 24, 2020

Thank you for the great extra show guys!! Hilarious and fun as always. Instead of Jimmy choosing just one of them what about a fuck, marry, kill competition?

J
Jennifer Carlile · April 24, 2020

This is great! Thanks for the bonus content!

H
Heidi Wallis · April 24, 2020

OMG I could listen to prisoner dating game all day long.

L
Linda Payne · April 24, 2020

Best Prison Dating Game ever! ❤️💕❤️💕❤️💕

J
Jane Richards · April 24, 2020

Love you guys xxx thanks SO much - you really make a difference even more so in these mental times

A
Annemarie Taylor · April 24, 2020

You guys are saving my sanity at work! Thank you SO much!

N
Nicky Bomberry · April 24, 2020

Would you be able to post pics of all these gems?

J
Justin ZDH · April 24, 2020

I was going save this for my drive to work tm. But couldn't wait and realized I'm off till Sunday so here we go. Love you guys thanks for all the bonus lately

S
Summer Montera · April 24, 2020

Thanks for all the bonus material!