YOU PICK IT!

I watched the False Prophet documentary today! Holy shit! I actually broke down in tears a few times. I don’t know how you guys can cover all of this in one episode. Maybe a two part or long bonus? That shit is so wild!

Does this skit give off False Prophet vibes to anyone else? https://youtu.be/n9yoVvMCOsU?si=UmyjnmpmROElpsq8

Can we talk about how inbred they look on false prophet? Something is seriously wrong there

There’s a new season of love after lockup.

They still haven't discussed the Love Has Won cult yet, right? I need this before anything else.

I'd like to hear more Ludacri festivals.

False

Nature boy

Ok, PLEASE talk about the the prophet dude’s white fringe jacket! My only question was, did he find it at Ross in the women’s section?

Internet salad is my favorite!

The false prophet

I'd LOVE to hear you guys tell the story of how you met, your early gigs etc!!!

I know they are already so damn busy, I’m sure it’s hard to find the time. I can’t believe I missed the Jimmie in charge episode, I’m on my way there now!

I thought I was joining this stream to get more than audio . I could have done that for free . wTF

Shakopee Mn murder America

Shakopee murder America I want to see a reel what did I pay for

Can we have an episode on the Jennifer Dulos disappearance? The to-be-ex-husband killed her, the mistress with on trial for conspiracy to commit, there is video of the two throwing away evidence, and they've yet to find her body. The husband committed suicide before going to trial. All very sad.

Would someone please tell me the episode that Jimmie did I've heard them all and don't remember that one?

I’m yelling Gogurt in September! I need to hear this story!!!!

They should do one on concert disasters.

I don't know if Jimmie really wants to buuuuut we have one bonus episode where Jimmie led the show, a Sodus, NY case. It's one of my favorite ones and I'd love to see Jimmie take on another chase!

You pick it and we will do the loser!

You’ll do both eventually…

I actually watched The False Prophet. This will be the first time I've actually watched something BEFORE the bonus episode

When we get the False Prophet, I hope we get a discussion on who's worse; Warren Jeffs or Sam Bateman.

When are we getting another love after lockup? Those are great

We need to find out which bad person Jimmie chooses in the prisoner dating game. 🤣🤣

What the hell, the bonus is internet salad? The Netflix show definitely won the vote

I don't even know about the False Poophet, but if you guys are going to explain it, I need to listen, then check out the netflix, then wait and look forward to internet salad!

Internet salad. But also, we need to catch up on Love After Lockup!

Staircase murder!!!!

This was an excellent Netflix docuseries. The FLDS is bonkers.

I love when people ask them to pick between two things and they comments suggestions for completely different shit

Yes! Need to hear the guys talk about the false prophet!

Yes, Prisoner dating game!!! On Netflix!!! Highest ratings there!!!!!

We need more amusement park disasters!!!!!!!

Would love another love after lock up one too!

I'm thinking if Jimmie were to present another episode, it would an express episode because when Jimmie announced, you felt his anxiety in nearly EVERY word. He was SO nervous about being the lead for an episode. NGL, it was an awkward kind of funny and James had Jimmie's back. When Jimmie would get flustered, James was right there to help him jump that hurdle and continue on! Everyone should have a friend the way our J's are friends with each other! 🥰🤗☯️

ugghhhh this was a difficult choice lol i can’t wait for either

This jamoke with his white faux leather jacket, Naomi that looks like she will knife anyone at the drop of a hat, and (bless their hearts)... there isn't a good looking gal in the group: it has to be discussed.

I want to see a prisoner dating game with the bachelors and bachelorettes exclusively from stories covered in Small Town Murder!

We need another love after lock up bonus. Granted, the first 3 seasons of LAL are unmatched.

Option C: Prisoner Dating Game

netflix is boring. do some dumbshit or a dating game. its been a while

I love Internet Salad because it’s so random. I don’t have Netflix so I don’t know anything about The False Prophet.

We haven’t had a LAL update in forever! What about reviewing the new episodes/couples at some point?

I don't understand the amount of people responding to this 2 option poll with a completely different thing.

We need some prisoner dating game!!!!!

False prophet

Yes! I need to hear the guys trash this piece of shit!

Where do I find past internet salad? New here.

Internet Salad. Love you guys. 🌻

Internet Salad people!! The episode on the documentary will be the same no matter when they do it. Current events say they should do Internet Salad first

Internet Salad!

I swear I could listen to an Internet Salad every week. I love them so much.

False Prophet

I love salad

Internet Salad episodes are like my ADHD brain come to life in podcast form, and I love them.

No interest in LDS stuff.

It's a few years old now but I'd love to hear the guys take on Chimp Crazy

Internet Salad YAYYYYYYY

Internet salad I love those so much.

False Prophet

False prophet just because I need these guys to rip apart that damn white leather jacket

Love me some internet salad

I want to hear how J and J started this path to a great podcast. How they met, when they met, how did the idea of crime in sports come up.

While I wouldn't mind a mental break from pedo stories; I don't want to hear about it from anyone but J&J !

Why not Jimmy do a case? I really enjoyed that. Anyone else?

Dropped Netflix last year but False Prophet sounds good.

I just need to hear James’ take on the white leather jacket.

Both.

Can this be like when we voted last time where you ultimately do both? 🥹

Internet salad, please!!

I love you guys!

What about manosphere documentary

Prisoner dating game please!

I’m down for any of this content! In the future, could you do an episode on old insane asylums and the case reports that occurred in some of those facilities?

Listening back to old episodes and man... I miss prisoner dating game and love after lockup talks lol

Both, obviously. But fundamentalist Mormons always, always first.

Tough one

I don't have Netflix, I rely on James and Jimmie for my Netflix documentary information. I know the FLDS are a mess, but another documentary about them is always interesting.

I’d really love another motel review.

The False Phrophet please

I love me a good internet salad. The J’s ranting and conversating is one of my highlights in life

I haven’t watched False Prophet yet, but it’d be hard beating internet salad. God I love the gents’ take on current events

Internet salad! I’m so tired of hearing about those Mormon freaks

If False Prophet wins, pls do Internet Salad the next week. I really enjoy Internet Salad

I love internet salad but if false prophet is on the table I'd love to hear your take.

Go extra long and do both!

I love whatever you two do! But Jimmy giving it to us... what a treat that would be! 🩷

Love internet salad.

Oh you bastards. Fucking love the Internet Salad ones. James letting rip about the Riyadh comedy Festival was gold buuuuuutttt also have been waiting for James and Jimmies take on the Documentary 😩🤯

After this one it should be The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets. I’d love to hear James’ take on what John Douglas had to say!!

This was a hard choice because I love Internet Salad but False Prophet was wild and I know their discussion would be great

Come to Vegas

Why must we choose? Why can’t both be done?

False prophet can be included in I ternet salad, no?

Don't they usually end up doing both anyway. One now and then the other in a couple of weeks time.

I’m so torn!

I’m only voting for internet salad so I can watch The False Prophet. It’s Stanley Cup Playoffs time. I don’t have time to watch it right now lol

You both are my false prophets. I shall not want when you are walking with me. Interwebs salads from the foods libraries is what I seek from your infinite wisdoms. Blessed be, my shining 107 dildos. The Pocket Robin has shat upon us all. Glory to all that heareth your divine words. Namaste, and shit.

Has anyone heard of the Uber Eats killer in new port richey, Florida?? Very interesting and horrifying

Meh I want both 🥲

What is internet salad?

Pleeeeease do the Untold Shooting at Hawthorne Hill doc- I HAVE to hear y’all make fun of those two wackos. Might be the first time I’ve also despised the victim in a true crime doc…? 🫣 But I voted for False Prophet this time!!

Every time I watch a documentary I hope you guys cover it 🙏

It's got to be the false prophet!

It's gotta be False Prophet, that guy needs to be brought down a notch or two

There hasn't been a prisoner dating game in WAY too long.

"Porque no los dos?"

The False Prophet, please!

I want to hear Afroman at some point.

Internet salad is my favorite (!!!!!!) .... (comma) LITERALLY MY FAV!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I don’t have Netflix

Could we please get something you did waaaay back and said would be a rare treat, Jimmy presenting the STM story to James? You did say at the time it wouldn't happen often, but it was off the wall funny listening to Jimmy try and present. At when's the next PS I Hate This Movie going to be Sarah? We need that joy in our lives :)

The false prophet had me shook. I need to hear from James and Jimmie!!

This is a hard pick!! I choose false prophet then internet salad the next one lol

I gotta hear Jimmie and James talk about that fucking tool 😂

Sports internet salad

Internet Salad 🥗

False prophets are a dime a dozen lets go with salad

Obviously we want both! But I love me some internet salad, interesting to see what the guys get in their feed...

Internet Salad without the politics

Either one! I didn't see the Netflix .. I'd rather listen to you guys first than watch it. Honestly you guys are my travel companions ... I truly appreciate the hard work and laughs Thank You!!!!

I'm just now, as I see this email, watching on Netflix!!! False prophet please

Prisoner Dating Game lol

I met a girl in the store I was working in that had been taken away from one of those. She was seriously messed up.

Love After Lockup.

False prophet please, and thank you. Either one I'm still going to listen. You two make my days at work bearable.

I was 10 minutes into the first episode of the false prophet before i out loud said James and Jimmie need to do this.

I'm always going say prisoner dating game no matter what, but I do want to hear your take on Sam showing off his parkour skills

Love after lock up review. James its been a long time snice we got one.

I JUST watched False Prophet. I HAVE to hear James and Jimmie talk about what an absolute creep this guy is

False Prophet!! I need to know James’ and Jimmie’s thoughts on the jacket?!?! 😳

thank you I really appreciate that I fid it was one of the Warren Jeff sickos

Tell me about False Prophet so I don’t have to watch it!

Omg I’ve been dying to hear James and Jimmie’s commentary on the false prophet!

Either are awesome how about both!!!

I’m mainstream Mormon and i vote false prophet because holllllllly shit

I love listening to them describe documentaries in their own way! Those are some of my favorite episodes 😁

Definitely false profit

I just finished the False prophet so I need you guys to talk about it

do we get both?

You should do wrestling locker room fights again!

your right they always do then both they just ask us which one first lol

Hoping to hear you lads chat about False Prophet!

False prophet because I just finished it a couple days ago!! Internet salad after 🥰

I know we'll ultimately get both (it would be the WORSE to only get one & never the other 😂) but we all thrive when we get the peek behind the small town murder curtain (all the curtains)!

Just watched false prophet this weekend. Icky. Seeing the guys Friday night! Super excited.

Need to hear what yall think about The False Prophet.

Just finished False Prophet tonight. This guy is unbelievable. It is so very sad for those girls. He is such a loser! His music video and those leather jackets! Omg!!

Afro man trial?

Both, please!

I don't have Netflix. Those episodes are still good without watching, but not my favorite.

Internet salad is fun but holy fuck false prophet needs to be discussed

I picked Internet salad I love those idk what the false prophet is it's a documentary I'm sure but whom I'm which is about I'm unsure.

I don’t know about the False Prophet but everything you guys put out is good so I won’t vote and let the majority win. I trust my fellow turkeys.

Internet salad!

I absolutely LOVE when they talk about random docs! I can't wait to hear their thoughts

False prophet baby!

I loveeeee internet salad!!

Just saw the False Prophet. What an ass hole.

I want to hear the boys rip that Bateman guy apart!

I'm actually uninterested in The False Prophet, but I'm always interested to hear you guys give your take. You never fail to deliver a terrific show!

False prophet was wild.

Fucken hard choice

False prophet!!

I’m hungry for some internet salad!

Omg why is false prophet not winning

False prophet!!