Poison Pudding Problems - Columbus, Indiana

There is no more vile thing than pudding skin.

Pudding problems, huh James?

I can't wait to head to Detroit next week!!!! Long time listener, 1st time commenter. 🥰🥰

the way i gagged at the pudding skin discussion omg

Wasn’t thallium the episode with the Mensa guy who copied Agatha Christie’s The Pale Horse to kill his neighbors for not being classy?

Jimmy. I have the same passion for the good funfetti frosting! Haha! Fuck those sprinkles!

Pudding skin for life!

Psychopaths are BORN. Sociopaths are MADE. Best way to remember the difference!

100% recommend divorce over murder. I'm happily divorced going on 12 years.

The school schedule these days is fucking nuts! I have 3 interns from the local high school in my machine shop and the frequency in which they’re here because they are out is absolutely insane. It’s like every other week is a half day or a day off or both.

I work at a psychiatric hospital. We crush patient medicine and mix it into pudding cups. Makes it much easier to get them to take the meds and they can't cheek the pills.

Jello pudding is the top tier off pudding even the instant!

I love these guys.

Cook and serve pudding is the best!

They absolutely did the Audrey Hilley case and I think that was the second Anniston, AL episode? That one sounds so familiar

I'm not usually a koozie girl, but I was at a soccer tournament this weekend and we played a team from Hawaii. They brought the Ohana spirit over 2,500 miles and gave everyone a koozie with their logo on it. 😁

I am a hospice nurse. That liquid morphine is not strong at all. A whole syringe which is 1ml is only 5mg. Most pts take a quarter of that. Morphine tabs start at 15 mg and go up to 200 mg. The whole bottle of morphine is 100 mg. Its not going to kill you if you take the whole bottle. Its fast acting and wears off quickly. Probably why the pudding didn't work. Now combine that morphine with flexeril and long Islands.... you gonna die.

James talking about pudding skin is making me nauseous!!

2 1/2 hours?!! Sounds like they were cooking with an Easy Bake oven. 🤣🤣

The Curley case was in my area. She gave him a huge dose of thallium in a drink while he was dying in the hospital. He was exhimed several times. My dad was the coroner.

Poor Jimmie!!! I’d eat your cupcakes!!! That’s so sweet you made them with your daughter

Yaaaaas with the pudding skin😂

I didn't know I had a Merry Manor 🤣

This episode hits so close to home! My dad’s “wife” was the only person that lived with him. He suddenly passed away supposedly in his sleep while she was away. He had really bad tremors and couldn’t get his own meds so she would put them in a little pile at the end of the kitchen counter. He had morphine pills because he just had a surgery a couple weeks prior and was still having a lot of pain. My son and I both felt in our guts when we walked in his bedroom to see his body that she did it. Something just felt off and the things she was saying were wild. They chalked it up to natural causes. My son and I went to the state police the next day to have it investigated because she did try to kill him before but he refused to turn over the evidence that would have put her in jail. The police agreed it was suspicious but said there was no way to prove someone else didn’t give him the medicine or he didn’t take it himself so they refused to do anything and this hag still walks free today! 🤬🤬

Also, Flexeril is fucking awesome for muscle spasms! I got some after I got a nasty back spasm on my way to work. One of my docs gave me some and I felt AMAZING! 🤭 #kindahighatwork

Why would a half day be an hour less than a regular day? That's ridiculous. My son's minimum days are 8-11:15. He's in 7th grade

James & Jimmie should do a full episode on Tracy Castor because the way the police proved she tried to kill her daughter was pretty funny. The woman was literally DTDS (Dumber Than Dog Shit).

I love any episode where a killer is mocked for a recipe they claim is their specialty but everyone else hates. Lori Vallow’s green chile chicken enchiladas are at the top of the list.

Oh James, I did not have your commitment to pudding skin on my bingo card 😂

The discussion about puddings made me think. The skin on custard is the best. Or the crispy top on a rice pudding made in the oven. I don't know what 'pudding' is in the US, but in the UK it's also another name for dessert as well as being certain desserts, like Christmas pudding.

You guy’s are the best.

Pudding is disgusting no matter how it's made.

I love pudding skin too!

Two words, guys: Aqua Tofana

Omg I thought I was the only one with the pudding skin. And finding things that are short and long to get the most skin. Couldn’t be more accurate for me 🤣🤣🤣🤣

When my husband was dying of cancer, he was given hospice quality stuff. There's NO WAY Alan was able to do ANYTHING after ingesting that.

George trepal used thallium on his neighbors in Florida around 175 or something

Good one

I still haven't heard my name and I've been a patron for 3 months. Is there something I'm doing wrong? LOL

I’m not an apologist for Nancy Grace but her fiancé was murdered and I think that is the reason she’s so intense about perpetrators.

I was a CNA at a large hospital. I did IVs, drew blood for all the tests (except for arterial blood), prepped patients for surgeries, inserted urinary catheters, trained nursing students in IVs, venipuncture plus all the basics I mentioned, and did many more things. Yes, there was “ass wiping” as well, but nurses did that too. But they also relied on us to do all the other things I mentioned, and then some.

Not something l normally share but my mother murdered my father by poisoning. She spiked his hot chocolate with anti anxiety meds. She tried to convince the police that he committed suicide because of his poor relationship with me! Said we had a fight the day before. l wasn't even in our state that day. That was easy to prove. This was in 2014. It's still not resolved because she is super wealthy and has the best lawyers. Guys lm a Criminolgist and know the cops running the case. ld normally be the person assisting in the case! It was kind of embarrassing and is still embarrassing. My mother is a psychopath!

I work in a doctor’s office. Patients bring in food. I NEVER eat for this very reason. 😂😂

CHON is what we're made of: carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen. Biology teacher here 👨‍🔬🧬🧫

A roommate of mine in '76 had a Vette. He worked at a car paint shop. Without protective gear. I called it his "penile extension". Cuz that's what it is.

😂😂you’re so wrong on this sociopath thing. They’re both diagnoses. I come from the medical field

I live 20 minutes from here and my son goes to IU Columbus. I was so excited to listen to this one and it didn’t disappoint:)

I'm surprised they didn't mention the lady that made the poison beef wellington with deadly mushrooms! Also the case they covered about the guy giving people poison cookies.

I love a koozie.

Not pudding skin 🤮🤮

Ooooo I know this case!!! It's wild.

How the hell can you take out life insurance on a guy aged 60 without a medical check? My husband and I took out a variety of polices for personal and business reasons in our 20s and early 30s, and each one required a blood test from the company prior! Not to mention it has to be stupid expensive to insure someone that age?

Could someone have over 100 Flexeril in 2007? Absolutely. This was before they put the hammer down on prescriptions. In 2007, doctor shopping and being overprescribed is at its peak. I was a new nurse at the time, and saw plenty of Rxs for 120 pain pills a month. 4/dayx30 days, with 6 refills. That was normal. And in Indiana? 100%.

Psychopathy is generally cons to have a genetic component; sociopathy is considered to be the result of trauma or environmental experience. Psychopathy and sociopathy overlap in presentation and share a lack of empathy for others. Even though they are not synonymous, I wouldn’t want to share any time or my life with either. They are both potentially lethal.

I am subscribed to a few patreons and the amount you get from $5 with you guys has to be an all time Patreon deal. Love you guys.

She's the dead man's husband 🤣 and that's the correction.

Ohmygod I’m out at “pudding skin”. 🤢🫠🤣

So my grandpa died on Sunday (dementia, heart attack, a fall). His name was Gary. His last "comfort care" med was roxanol. These guys have been like my security blanket since 2016 so this episode is morbidly serendipitous and comforting. If anyone wants a reason to make a drink, you could have a Windsor squirt (those 2 specifically) to honor my long haul trucker, Copenhagen chewing, fisherman, gardener, nature loving gramps ❤️ and, as he would always point out, "it's a beautiful day" guys.

We gotta know if Sara hid all the cook & serve pudding!! I envisioned a huge messy kitchen 🤣🤣💖💖 great show, I loved watching and listening to the discussion 🙃

FYI in the Uk at least John Thomas is a nickname for a 🍆

I know it has been a few years, but Jimmy and James have forgotten about how much the Anniston Star hated them.

Audrey Marie Hilley is my all time favorite small town murder episode. When I recommend the show to people, that’s the episode I recommend first

I heard about a kid in high school who wanted to get high so took a bunch of flexerall, and he ended up shitting in his own pants, because flexerall relaxed every muscle, including his sphincter

Sf8z

I a D L lol

Cookie dates????? What happened to tasting each others genitals?

Jimmie I would eat your cupcakes! 🧁

Like she isn't evil enough, she stole a dying person's pain medication. Special place in hell

Nancy Grace… one of the most irritating people on Earth. Her voice makes me angry.

Mmmm, pudding skin ❤️

Jimmy, Led Zeppelin is not a cover band.

Regarding the desserts with odd names. My grandma had a recipe for what was called "Cat Shit Cookies" 🤣🤣🤣

LMAO, I've got a big bottle of Flexaril sitting by me now. I get 270 every 3 months. So yea you can get a large quantity of them, it's not a narcotic but it'll def make you take a long nap. I def wouldn't leave it just sitting out 4 company. I think Drs just give a shit load of them out so they don't give opiates or narcotic sedatives out.

The log cabin on 200 acres was (rumored) tony Stewart's... I think that's his name. NASCAR driver guy

My dad lives there. Not that anyone cares lol but here I am telling it 🥴

The reason people prefer public activities over "glasses of wine and see where this goes" is that women don't wanna be murdered Everyone tells you, "go somewhere public for a first date", but a lotta people do that for the first *several*

Don't think that Snoop reference went unnoticed

The Gulf of Tonkin attack was mostly fabricated but the Navy did do some quite dangerous river patrols during the war.

Columbus isn’t a college town. IU Columbus only has 872 undergrads and 60 grad students. It’s a satellite school for Indiana Univwrsity. Columbus is an engineering town—Cummins cranking out those HEMIs, etc. That’s why the Asian population is higher—engineers working at Cummins. They call it Athens because they promote architecture.

I used to take flexaril for leg cramps, and I HATED the way I felt the next morning. I felt loopy and foggy.

You can tell James is a genuine Seinfeld fan...pudding skin! Hahah

The lady who poisons with antifreeze is a great episode on Forensic Files.

Squidward had a whole evening designated to being fancy. That’s how he handled his fancy needs.

Were they sued? Almost every episode on each show is “allegedly” this “in my opinion” that with emphasis on it

My boyfriend surprised me yesterday with tickets to your show in Massachusetts!!!! Best birthday gift ever!!!!!!

https://westchester.news12.com/new-details-emerge-in-apparent-poughkeepsie-murder-suicide-investigation Assuming this is what they were referencing.

I fucking gagged listening to James rave about pudding skin! The chunks got me.

Absolutely love that you refuse to raise the price of your patreon... fuckin awesome blokes 🍻 Cheers guys

Jimmie: “I am NOT ruining my cheeseburger!” 😂

So excited my hometown made it 😂

Pepè the Pew

And Indiana has a Tipton too 😂

Pudding skin.....shudder. texture kills me.

‘Led Zeppelin - Best cover band of all time’ Absolutely killed me. That almost seems T-shirt worthy.

"A sociopath is an informal term for someone with Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD), characterized by a chronic disregard for others' rights, lack of empathy, and remorse."

She’s the ‘Cappadonna of Chefs’!! *Someone’ll get that 🍴⚠️ ⬆️

Hospice quality! 🤣👍

So cool this is my hometown

Corvette Coozie is a GREAT punk band name

The ol’…“Corvette Koozie Keychain Combo” 💪🤘

Hmmm... This sounds a good deal similar to another case they covered, but I think it was an express episode and I'd swear pudding was the poisoned vehicle. It's tickling my memory enough I'll be going back through the STM catalogue. Damn it, Pietragallo!

now i want a koozie 😂 merch idea?

Too good!!!😊

May it never end

I ❤️ Louisiana folks. We had a Chaplain Pham in our Army unit, his parents were refugees from Vietnam and he was raised in South Louisiana. Sweetest man, no one could understand a word he said.

Erotic Cookie Painting--an under-explored niche market?

YES! Wednesday evening at last! Thank you J&J 🩵🩵