💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
March 30, 2026

Species On Species Weirdness, The Mountain That Hates You, The "Doesn't Worth It" Day

More of the funniest reviews on the internet! We read reviews for a very popular mountain in Phoenix, where nature may attack you, there is absolutely no air conditioning on the trail, and the only way out, is by dangling from a chopper. A personal item consisting of a very book about strange interspecies relations, that many people on TikTok apparently find "erotic". A boat tour where the difference between the best day you can have, and a sad, meager existence is $20 & much more!!

Join comedians James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman as they explore the most opinionated part of the internet: The Reviews Section!

Subscribe, and we will see you every Monday with Your Stupid Opinions!!

Dont forget to rate & review!!

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for merch & more

Check out James & Jimmie's other podcasts, Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (106)

J
Jenn White · April 24, 2026

Did not expect to hear about Morning Glory Milking Farm from them in my way to work. Their confusion was hilarious. Never change my sweet, sweet summer boys.

A
Angela Cardo · April 15, 2026

0!!!!!

J
Justin Simmons · April 15, 2026

Some of yall are weird af

A
Amanda Rebelo · April 15, 2026

If anyone got this book and wants to part w it please comment- I’m not paying 25 dollars just to check out how funny it is

K
Kianna Smith · April 13, 2026

Cheesecake factory menu stresses me out lmaooo I know the cooks hate it there 😭😂😂😂

K
Kianna Smith · April 13, 2026

Lmaooo not the kids need to stand 😭😂😂😂

M
MJ O'keeffe · April 9, 2026

Sexual Guillotine is a good name for a band

M
MJ O'keeffe · April 9, 2026

The ferry is free and Staten Island is the new Bklyn

K
Katie Cronin · April 8, 2026

You think milking a minotaur is strange? 😂 You guys should look up "Unhinged" by Vera Valentine. The female character screws a door, and it turns into a man. 😂 It's surprisingly good, considering it's about a sentient door. She also writes a romance about the Kool Aid Man, balloon animal shifters (their ... "releases"... taste like funnel cake icing), etc.

M
Mary · April 7, 2026

OK, careful what you ask for… as usual w the PIotW… beastiality, not even thinly disguised. At least I’m not eating.

M
Mary · April 7, 2026

Oops, sorry!!

M
Mary · April 7, 2026

If I could leave more stars, I would!! The return of the Personal Item of the Week, hooray!! 🥳 ❤️

M
Mary · April 7, 2026

If I could give it more stars, I would!!! The return of the Personal Item of the Week, hooray!!

W
Whitney · April 7, 2026

Chicago ppl do not sound like that 😩 that’s only south side Irish ppl everyone else sounds normal here lmao

L
Lori Ditchfield · April 6, 2026

Minotaur "mil...(Puking in my mouth) 🤮

L
Lori Ditchfield · April 6, 2026

Most hiking trails and parks close at sunset duh 🙄.

C
C · April 6, 2026

Thank you for bringing back the personal item!

G
Grace Luterek · April 3, 2026

His 2 teenage daughters carried their mom..... what was he doing????

J
Justin Simmons · April 15, 2026

I think it was all women?

T
Trina · April 2, 2026

Hearing the guys trying to figure out book abbreviations and read the reviews for that crazy book was absolutely hysterical. I was listening while at work and it was impossible to laugh quietly.

W
Wickedspades · April 2, 2026

A Minotaur is the bull top and human bottom and centaur is a human up top and bottom horse Yes there are Female and Male orcs, and if you watched any of the Lord of the Rings movies, the enemy are orcs. In case people were curious

Q
Quinn Ales · April 1, 2026

I hate the personal item so much 😅🤦🏼‍♀️lol Too much cringe so skip every time lol

J
Justin Simmons · April 15, 2026

I'm with you on that! All these mfers wanted it back and it reminded me of why I usually skip that part. To each their own, but I usually find the items neither funny or interesting. I'm glad they do it sparingly and give notice. Easy 20 minute skip for me. This might have been the most disgusting one though. 🤮

T
Tiara Walker · April 1, 2026

HEA is happily ever after 💀

S
Sharyn Jones · April 1, 2026

Aaaaaah! I suggested you do this book back in November, this has made my day, I’m grinning so big! I love you guys

S
Sharyn Jones · April 1, 2026

If you are gonna read it for shits and giggles the audiobook is alright. If you’re reading it for other reasons, it’s nice to have your hands free 🤷🏼‍♀️

G
Gail 10-A · March 31, 2026

Whew! I am so relieved that James and Jimmie also did not know what an “ork” is. Or was. Whatever.

A
Alan’s Mom · March 31, 2026

I will not be helping that book sell more copies.

T
Trish Faires · March 31, 2026

I know Quido Merkins. He was Bum Phillips favorite player. He is a resident of Huntsville, Texas where he attended Sam Houston State University. Super nice guy!

L
Lacee Lee · March 31, 2026

THE PHOENIX LIVE SHOW WAS SO RAD! I took a friend, he was unfamiliar with the pod. However, James and Jimmy killed it; we both laughed throughout the entire show. I have been a fan for years, I listen to all their content. I was kinda salty I couldn't get tickets to Small Town Murder( that's on me, waited to long to purchase tickets). It was cool to attend the first Your Stupid Opinions Live. If you are able, definitely see a show. Come back to Arizona...

A
Alyse Christensen · March 31, 2026

HEA= happily ever after

B
Blue · March 31, 2026

Everyone is so shocked by the content of the book, but what about Twilight? That's a whole series about a girl trying to decide between bestiality and necrophilia.

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · April 2, 2026

Beauty and the Beast? Helllerrrr

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · March 31, 2026

In defense of the "I finished it but barely" person: Certain people, when it comes to books, will finish the book no matter how bad it is. People that read their way through a genre will do so even if it's painfully bad. A lot of romance is trash, but it's like trash the way reality TV is trash, so readers finish the book. There are people who don't DNF (did not finish) until a book is painful enough to be a CIA interrogation technique

L
Lesley Zen Marx · March 31, 2026

I once edited a (self-published) novel of wolf erotica. Consider myself a pretty jaded individual, but that experience was eye-opening for sure.

D
Danielle Schmalz · March 31, 2026

I think the need to do Murderpiece Theater and read excerpts of this book on Patreon

J
Jocelyn · March 31, 2026

I need more smut book reviews in my life!

J
Jhayden Faeran · March 31, 2026

MMC= Main male character. The book sounds hilarious, especially when James and Jimmy are talking about it!❤️

T
Tina Major · March 31, 2026

I’m missing the personal item of the week 🤣

A
Anna Gehres · March 31, 2026

Ngl, I had to know. I downloaded the book and it’s actually pretty funny.

W
White Horse Eventing, Chloe Smyth · March 31, 2026

I want to know if the guy complaining about half the speakers not working, was posted after the lady that pulled the plug 😂🤔

C
Catwoman79 · March 31, 2026

I read the synopsis and yeah no bueno for me. I read paranormal smut all the time but this sounds terrible and when i read milking and see what else came up that’s not my cup of tea. But I’m NOT going to kink shame because reading is harmless but there’s plenty of REAL perverts out there that act upon their “fantasies”.

d
diane johnson · March 31, 2026

Didn't read the book, but the minataurs have human hands, right? So why do they need to pay to be milked? They can handle it on their own, can't they?

H
Heather · March 31, 2026

I hope we get Your Stupid Opinions on the road!

S
Sarah Webber · March 31, 2026

The book is on Kindle Unlimited, where you can self-publish for free. That makes the existence of this book make sense

C
Cameron May · March 30, 2026

HEA - happily ever after

T
That Aussie Cunt · March 30, 2026

Fuck chocolate. I wanna buy everycunt that book for Easter. Cheers guys 🍻

A
Amy Sousa · March 30, 2026

My dad worked in forestry for decades in the Sierra Nevada and was on hand for some pretty crazy rescues from the elements. Extreme temps, weather events, water hazards, stranded vehicles, etc. and many ended not with gratitude from the people being helped but usually petulance and complaints. He always used to shake his head and say, “They think it’s safe as Disneyland up here.” Nature is here to amaze and humble you, not entertain you. Enjoy at your own risk.

J
Jeremy Reel · March 30, 2026

I think Jimmie and James should do a rendition of the Milking Farm for a pateron episode 😅

N
Nora Meister · March 30, 2026

Um, right here. This girl has zero interest in a five pepper bull. I honestly don’t know what that even means, but bestiality holds ZERO interest for me. Jesus! What is going on in this world?! Since when did it become socially acceptable to have bestiality fantasies?! I guess I’m old fashioned, but I’m cool with being so.

J
Justin Simmons · April 15, 2026

💯

J
Jack Ross · March 30, 2026

Jimmy, I want you to specifically know I increased my membership just because of your hatred for TSA. As promised on Instagram. Love y’all

C
Cassie Prichard · March 30, 2026

The way I died when you said the title of the personal item 💀😂 I'll read some weird shit, and yes I read that. TBH one of the oddest books I've ever read. And I've read a lot of smut I think people consider odd. I did not leave a review. It took awhile for my Kindle to stop recommending her books to me, I believe the next one was about a moth man or something if I remember correctly.

S
Scarlet Matthews · March 30, 2026

Happily Ever After

L
Laura Barker · March 30, 2026

May have downloaded a sample of the book 😂😂

D
Don Nelson · March 30, 2026

Jimmie 🤣 "Don't forget to breath"

L
Liz Rutherford · March 30, 2026

Why should I pay to read smut when I can watch porn for free?

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · March 30, 2026

Hiker "I don't like going down" Jimmie is quite the opposite! Not all heroes wear capes

C
Cara (Care-uh) · March 30, 2026

It just occurred to me that there are people who have/had zero interest in the Lord of the Rings series in any form, and would absolutely then not know what an orc is 😂

C
Calypso’s Mom · April 1, 2026

I find it very curious, because I have no idea why I know about orcs. I’ve watched a few minutes of one LOTR movie and I’m fairly confident it wasn’t that. I thought we just all knew about them 🤷🏻‍♀️

N
NonniX2 · March 30, 2026

I'm not going to buy it but I had to look up the book just to see the cover art.... it's a no from me! 😮

T
Tammy Hedrick · March 30, 2026

I love a good romantasy, but anything "beastie" has to turn back into human. Also, the idea of "milking" gives me the ick, I'll give this one a pass.

C
Cali Girl · March 30, 2026

People who are attracted sexually towards that furry stuff or half human half animal is low-key into bestiality! so sick! 🤢

J
Jennifer S. · March 30, 2026

Jimmie and James get the side eye today. Their rant about the injured lady was impaled on the stick made them sound like two irrational old men looking for something to yell about. Who wouldn’t hope for help from the ranger if they’re carrying someone with a hole in their leg??? I’d expect help. But Maybe the ranger couldn’t help them for a valid reason (like not being able to leave the station unattended). Regardless, no one was wrong. Shit happens in nature. Hoping for help when it happens isn’t abnormal.

S
Stephen Watts · March 30, 2026

To make that book more weid and horrorific, the minotaur in Greek mythology came to be when the queen of Crete fell in love with the King's prized bull and climbed into a hollow cow she had made so she could have sex with the bull. Despite how marketted to children the Greek myths are they are some of the grossest, rapiest with some beastiality and incest thrown in for good measure that you will find in any book shop.

S
Shauna Rogers · March 30, 2026

The Personal Item gives me the geebee heebees! Animals are not sexy! 😂

r
rebecca Deardorff · March 30, 2026

Sucking something or cleaning shit

M
Michael Geary · March 30, 2026

The Staten Island Ferry is indeed free. Many tourists take it from Battery Park, to SI, return in next one, taking pics in both . I am from NY and very often take visiting friends on this jaunt when I show them lower manhattan

r
rebecca Deardorff · March 30, 2026

Omfg Bring water and sunscreen to hike in AZ?!!!! We are not ok People are too stupid to live🙃😳

h
hoddie · March 30, 2026

Ughh I read that book🫣

C
Cassie Prichard · March 30, 2026

Same. It wasn't my cup of tea, but I don't mind going out of my norm on occasion when choosing which smut book I want to read next. You'll never learn if something is your cup of tea if you don't.

P
Penny · March 30, 2026

James said “This was the dumbest thing I have read.” The person suggesting a personal shopper for all Walmart customers. Sorry James. I think the Walmart customer one the stupidity award.

S
SilverHairedMiddleAgedTuxedoMask · March 31, 2026

Mine was the guy who complained about a national park saying it should all be torn down and replaced with parking lots

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · March 30, 2026

Have you really never heard of orcs? Lord Of The Rings ring any bells?

C
Catherine Maldonado · March 30, 2026

James & Jimmie discovering Morning Glory Milking Farm had me fucking rolling 😂😂😂

H
Hot Dog Racing YouTube · March 30, 2026

Are women really into this beastiality nonsense? It sounds soooooo f-ed up

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · March 30, 2026

I'm over here trying to help Jimmie come up with "centaur" like he can hear me.....

C
Cara (Care-uh) · March 30, 2026

Lmaoooooo how dare you call me out like this

S
Samantha · March 30, 2026

As a regular hiker, there’s always some idiots clearly not prepared. The stupid thing is, it’s not 1980. It would take literally 5 minutes on Google to see Camelback isn’t Disney, and requires some planning and preparation! Same thing for the boat - these people don’t take the time to read the reviews before deciding to buy tickets? Morons, everywhere.

L
Laura · March 30, 2026

The peppers = the sex scene level 😂

L
Lord Spencer Westcott · March 30, 2026

Fuck yes, a Mantaur reference!

S
Stephen Watts · March 30, 2026

The fact Cornette had to mangage him is still surreal to me

T
Tracy Poetz · March 30, 2026

This personal item is one of the most disturbing they’ve ever reviewed. I grimaced several times. I guess I’m just not into fucking animals lol

E
Elizabeth · March 30, 2026

OMG I read that book because I had wondered what all the fuss was about! But this was several years ago.

E
ENKC · March 30, 2026

I hate to be that guy, okay not really but, that book was not scifi, that's fantasy. Star Trek is Science Fiction. Minotaurs you fuck and orcs are fantasy, like Lord of the Rings or D&D lol

�
🧿 The Spotted Redhead 🧿 · March 30, 2026

Then don't be that guy. It's all made up.

N
Nicole Feigl · March 30, 2026

Yes MMC is male main character lol. I love romantasy but I can do monster characters. I need my characters to look fully human lol.

L
Lesley Zen Marx · March 30, 2026

Do you mean "can't"?

C
Chrissie Boyle · March 30, 2026

The amount of Staten Island lately is so funny to me 😅 lived here all my life. Ferry is free. 3 am drunk boat is fun. They’re bringing back booze on the boat soon. We also now have a paid past ferry and it’s much better.

M
Molly Condon · March 30, 2026

I think the book is unironically a cute story and idk what that says about me

H
Heather McHaffie · March 30, 2026

Omg this one had me dying 🤣

J
Jessica Schafer · March 30, 2026

And apparently James has never heard of the famous erotic sci fi book...ice planet barbarians lolll

J
Jessica Schafer · March 30, 2026

While I worked in wyoming we had (experienced) guests go out on horseback a few miles into the mountain to go fly fish in a hidden creek. The dad lost his footing in the creek, broke his lower leg completely in half. He had to crawl through the freezing water to get to his son. His son had to help him get on his horse, horse got spooked by a moose and the guy fell off. He got back on and got some service to call the office. A very patchy call made and I was sent up 2 miles to go meet them. I kept a slow pace and led them down. The dad decided to not get airlifted or an ambulance. He didnt complain NEARLY as much as that one guy on camelback mountain 😂

J
Jessica Schafer · March 30, 2026

His son was maybe 13 btw. Lol they were making jokes on the way down the mountain. 😂

K
Kramer and his Cougar MILF · March 30, 2026

I'm not sure what an orc is either, but I DO know they make Elijah Woods' sword glow 😄

T
Tracey · March 30, 2026

Any chance of you guys covering the armless and legless man in Maryland who shit and killed a passenger in his vehicle, which the murderer was driving at the time. There is so much to unpack.

K
Karen Ginnis · March 30, 2026

Staten Island Ferry is free. Both ways. Great way to see the Statue of Liberty.

A
Amy H · March 30, 2026

Isn't Mork from Ork?

M
Mallory Ross · March 30, 2026

HEA Happily Ever After

N
Natalie Meyer · March 30, 2026

Thank you! I came to the comments hoping someone had already clarified.

�
🧿 The Spotted Redhead 🧿 · March 30, 2026

Apparently the Staten Island Ferry is indeed free. Crazy!

M
Michael Geary · March 30, 2026

And it’s awesome little trip for pics. I take many friends who visit when I take them on my tour of lower Manhattan

K
Kira Nevaeh · March 30, 2026

SG...Sexual Guillotine lmao 🤣 must be covered in pink fur 🤔

K
Kira Nevaeh · March 30, 2026

What?!? Tyson no longer has pigeon starving money?!? 🤣

A
AndrewsPsyche · March 30, 2026

I FUCKING love you guys! Thank you!

E
EnrichHardInTheSlightest · March 30, 2026

Oh go on