💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
March 12, 2026

The Tinkerbell Witchcraft Delusion - Cherry Log, Georgia

This week, in Cherry Log, Georgia, a nurse, tending to this rural mountain area, ends up being horrifically attacked & murdered, in her own cabin. Detectives immediately turn their attention to man, who lives only a few doors away, and has a wild criminal past. The way he tells it, he didn't kill who police think he killed, and instead claims to have killed an old babysitter, who he swears put a witchcraft spell on him, that has ruined his entire life! Is any of that possible??

Along the way, we find out that cover bands should always get their names from putting together the names of many hair metal bands, that your step sisters are not a dating pool, and that when you kill who you think is a witch, who has ruined your life, you should at least make sure that it's the right person!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (102)

J
Jessica Laine · September 29, 2026

Grand Marais, MN is pronounced "Grand Ma-ray" 😂

M
Megan Caminos · May 7, 2026

Ironically, I specialize in psychosexual evaluations. 😬

m
marbleorian · May 4, 2026

Roger Queen was only 45 when he fell down those court house stairs! Tf kind of stairs were they 🤨

R
Rachel Rhodes · April 3, 2026

BTW the “four lane” is HWY 515-2 lanes north and 2 lanes south

R
Rachel Rhodes · April 3, 2026

About 30 minutes north of me! I’m so intrigued by what happened!

S
Shelby Boyde · March 26, 2026

Finally bought a Shut Up and Give Me Murder tee!! Has a skull and roses on it. Yay!! Episode time!! 💀🥀

K
Katie Dobrinska · March 23, 2026

Jimmie, you said him for the doctor...just saying.

J
Jen Karr · March 23, 2026

Thanks, guys, for bringing up how the death penalty isn't some happy sleepy time. This person was a monster but I don't think the state should be killing anyone. But if it does, it should be humanely. I think Jon Oliver had an excellent episode on lethal injection if you havent seen it.

D
Danielle Hilton · March 22, 2026

"some times you don't sink and you still fail" rotflmao! I don't know if I've related to any statement more than this one. Lol that's great

A
Abbey Finney · March 20, 2026

Why’s it harder to listen to my favorite podcast when they get too close to home? Just me?? Took me days to accept this lol

R
Rachel Rhodes · April 4, 2026

Same…I’m like I know this area. I know the four lane and Bigfoot expedition and Pink Pig. And I know the whole “gunshots sounds? Maybe they had to shoot something off their property/animals”. I started so intrigued but as the story went on it’s taken me 2 days to get through it.

K
Kristie Frazier · March 19, 2026

Boar male Sow female Y'all so close 🩷

L
Lesley Harper · March 19, 2026

Please do The Alabama Solution as a bonus

J
Jana Cashen · March 18, 2026

Awe! The love for us Nurse Practitioners! Thank you! ❤️

L
Linnette Placido · March 17, 2026

I need those Valentine's!

C
Carol Chan · March 17, 2026

I wonder if Tinkerbell ever found out what happened

S
Sloane H · March 16, 2026

The breathing/gasping and abdominal movements suggest agonal breathing; the body’s involuntary response to the death process.

J
Jennifer Lafrance · March 15, 2026

Thanks for the NP appreciation 💗

A
Austin Ozment · March 14, 2026

Jimmie, it’s 2 lanes each direction lol

M
Melissa Jecevicus · March 14, 2026

I’ve heard some interesting pronunciations of my last name before but those last two attempts I’ve never even heard before 🤣 Got close a couple of times though! Made my week 🤣

M
MYturb en is-dirty · March 13, 2026

Where’s my shout out!!!

S
Stacy DeJonge · March 13, 2026

What a wild one!

S
Stacy Nielsen · March 13, 2026

😆 I conduct psychosexual evaluations in my private practice and the question really are like that 😆

A
Alyse Christensen · March 13, 2026

Listening to this as I fill out the same assessments for patients

G
Gail 10-A · March 13, 2026

Thank you for the Laugh Break toward the end - absolutely necessary and very, very funny ✌️😎 That poor man! Good thing he was a prosecutor and was tough enough to survive. Lucky in a way

S
Sirae Kettula · March 13, 2026

How long does it take to hear your name after signing up for patreon? Mine's a doozy, I've been impapatiently waiting...

D
Diamond Clark · March 15, 2026

I’ve heard mine but once since I joined several years ago so listen carefully!

D
Deb Pinto Toney · March 13, 2026

I've been to Exhibition Bigfoot twice!! It's something to behold. It's $9.00 to get in. They get you in the gift shop. We all spent over $100 in the gift shop!! Unbelievable. Please do a Your Stupid Opinions on this place!!!

D
Derik89 · March 13, 2026

Izzy isn’t the drummer……🙃

K
Kari Bose · March 13, 2026

He should've thrown the knife in the Wabash river in Indiana. It isnt suppose to be brown. No one goes in that river especially in Vermillion County. The closer to Lilly, the better for dumping.

K
Kyle Harner · March 13, 2026

Wait we’ve had DR lesac in other episodes! We called him dangly sack in the others 😂

J
Jaime Robinson · March 13, 2026

I’m a probation officer in Texas and the psychosexual eval is a condition on our county’s Sex Offender Caseload, and they also require the to do frequent instant offense polygraphs AND they have monitors on their phones/laptops. It’s crazy

D
Dizzy Flame · March 13, 2026

When I took Swimming in college, you determined your own grade. You had all semester but could only earn laps during class time. There was no lectures, no term papers, no final exam. Just swim until you made the grade you wanted. Now, 70 laps = 1 mile. To make an A, you had to swim 5 miles. B = 4 miles. C = 3 mls. Etc. Once you hit the grade you wanted, you were done. I got an A because I had just had a terrible car wreck and needed swimming for physical therapy. Figured I may as well get 3 hrs P.E. credit while learning how to walk again. Best class ever!

D
Danielle Carter · March 13, 2026

I failed swimming, which was a REQUIREMENT to graduate from my college in 1990. I had a phobia, couldn't swim, had panic attacks. I had to appeal the grade to graduate.

E
Emily Ngee · March 12, 2026

31 minutes in and I just threw up in my mouth 🤮

A
Amanda Naugle · March 12, 2026

I 100000% support the death penalty. I definitely understand anyone who feels differently. Like you both do! But I’ll always support it. My personal opinion. If the family needs it to feel justice or a little bit of peace. It’s the least we can do for them… it’s not us who carries their pain. That is their burden. But I respect any differing opinions. It’s definitely a touchy subject with some people. Love you both!

M
Maggie King · March 13, 2026

Since 1973, 193 inmates were exonerated off death row. Not released on a technicality or "not guilty", but factually innocent. And that's just the past 50yrs. Imagine how many we've murdered legally in 250 years. Or the past millennia. There's also the vic's family: decades, millions of dollars, waiting to grieve, to move on, to heal, legal fights to cop those drugs. If someone murdered my child? I want a sentence of 999 yrs. And make him immortal and live every day. Or multiple life sentences. Kill em, bury em. Then dig em up and kill em again. But, but those 193 must pinch themselves nightly to have slipped thru The Reaper's hands.

H
Heather · March 12, 2026

I’m a little disappointed in the lack of La Croix jokes, but maybe that was just too obvious and hacky. 😂

J
Jocelyn · March 12, 2026

Here's what I don't understand with the death penalty and the concern around meds why not just use the medication they use for maid in other countries? We know that stuff works because people choose it and it's supposed to be very peaceful and nice.

M
Maggie King · March 13, 2026

Doctors don't want to be involved, pharma don't want to be involved. US DOES have a handful of MAID states. Killinv inmates killed w MAID is a terrible idea.

D
Don Nelson · March 12, 2026

Jimmie - way to take a stand with no uncertain terms! Child abuse? It's called rape! It's not car jacking when you're not near the vehicle! Good job, man. Everybody's getting sick of this half-apologetic language.

K
Kymberlie Valdueza · March 13, 2026

I was coming to the comments section to say THIS!!! It’s so refreshing and honestly invigorating to hear two (IMO pretty cool) men saying out loud, with their whole chests, to stop using apologetic/sane-washing language when it comes to child freaking rape! I literally almost cried.

S
Samantha · March 12, 2026

Anyone else wonder if Tinkerbell never existed (or never actually assaulted him) and this guy made all this shit up to seem crazy for trial? 🤔

S
Samantha · March 13, 2026

So I posted this comment only halfway through the episode before they commented he has spoken out about it before the murder trial. That being said, being diddled and having low self esteem is not an excuse to murder an innocent woman who had nothing to do with his past abuse.

O
OMAR GOBBY · March 12, 2026

I'd love to ask Jimmie who the actor Sam Houston is....

C
Cara (Care-uh) · March 12, 2026

lol my husband is a captain in the Army Corps of Engineers and he said he doesn't even know what the hydrologists do - probably water analysis and water navigation? 😂

M
Maggie King · March 13, 2026

They may focus on a type of water: rivers, or lakes or salt or brackish. Or subsurface water: water tables, aquifers, how drilling affects. They study, observe and educate. Out west, they are valued since future water pacts will be so critical. Water is the new oil.

O
OMAR GOBBY · March 12, 2026

I have to see these guys!!! https://www.instagram.com/gwlsband?igsh=MWh2anN2ODJydjJpcA==

J
Jude Cope · March 13, 2026

Thanks for the link. I was legit going to see if those Valentine’s Day cards were still available. 😂🤣

A
Angelina Marconi · March 12, 2026

"Don't think they can't lob it in there." 😆 fucking Jimmie is the best

J
Jennifer S. · March 12, 2026

No, the word you’re looking for is rape if there is penetration. Molestation subtly suggests rape didn’t occur and IMO it’s too soft a word for an adult doing anything sexual with a 13. People don’t like using the word rape because of how it makes them feel. It’s especially true when the rapist doesn’t fit whatever image they have for what a rapist looks like. Most people don’t imagine the rapist often looks like an average nanny or an average classmate or an average family friend. But that’s who the rapists are. And many of them don’t see their actions as rape. There are people out here lying to trick people into their beds and that is also rape, specifically rape by deception. They know the person wouldn’t consent to sex knowing the truth so they lie. People need to understand that lying for sex takes away consent and sex without consent is rape. Even if it’s not physically violent. But when we present it like that, a lot of people realize what they’ve done to someone else qualifies as rape. It’s hard to make people see themselves in that way. Most people don’t view themselves as a villain or as having preyed on someone else.

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · March 12, 2026

Well stated. Molestation IS “softer” than rape.

M
Michael Jaspers · March 12, 2026

Is the tinkerbell story corroborated by anyone? He may have just dreamed that up.

D
Donald Simmons · March 12, 2026

And James, Dont think for a second that I don't know that when you got stuck in Nashville you went and tried on cowboy hats. I know you did and it makes me laugh 😂

D
Donald Simmons · March 12, 2026

You boys don't know nothing bout the 4 lane , haha. I grew up 50 miles away from any 4 lane roads. Now I live just a few miles from one, and it's a step towards civilization let me tell you.

M
Mary · March 12, 2026

“Why are we softening child exploitation? Why are we softening that, ever?” Jimmie, my hero ❤️

D
Dr Phil Goode 👹🌲🔥 · March 12, 2026

Lol, I want some of those band Valentine cards. I got my 1st kiss from 1 of my oldest sisters friends, I was maybe 8 and she was maybe 14 but I didn't get head from her. I loved it, i think guys do enjoy it much more. Lol, I hope your son doesn't listen Jimmie. You def gotta watch out 4 these witch's, my ex is one and I'm pretty sure she put a hex on me but my life's shitty enough, she can't get me. Appalachian witch's ain't no joke 🤣

M
Matthew Larson · March 12, 2026

The 3rd Degree is actually in reference to the final degree (Master Mason) in Freemasonry. I won’t go into detail, but it’s certainly on the internet. I love the show!

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · March 12, 2026

Apparently, the “third degree” has enjoyed more than one origin story. Not surprising since the two words are very common.

D
David Martin · March 12, 2026

I am from Rome Ga originally. My mom graduated from Berry College. It is a beautiful campus. It has a cool history.

A
Abbey Finney · May 27, 2026

Have u heard their episode from Rome? I’m now in Atlanta, but saw that episode live in charlotte a few years ago. 🔥

A
Amy Heuberger · March 12, 2026

Grand Marais, is pronounced Mah-ray, it’s French.

M
Missy Norris · March 12, 2026

Loved the Squatch museum. It’s ridiculous!

r
regular_sized_mom · March 12, 2026

I’d listen to you guys heckle criminals on their jail cells.

M
Mary · March 12, 2026

Way

T
Telly NoLastName · March 12, 2026

My boyfriend is like 6'7 and I'm 5'9, people always remember us. When I was younger people constantly spotted me and my best friend in crowds, we were the same hight but she's a red head so if you saw a red head and a black girl in Hawaii it was almost certainly me and my best friend lol

M
Maggie King · March 13, 2026

A lifetime ago, my brother and I went to college in Mexico. We were on the metro, my bro said look around. I did and could see from one end to the other. He's 6'3", i hit 5'10" by 10, 6ft now. Boomer gen. I HATED my height then. Mom made me walk w a book on my head. I love my height. I married a 6'7" man and our daughter is 6'2".

H
Hoke Luther Jackson · March 12, 2026

I can’t wait to listen! This is so close to me. I just hope none of my relatives are involved…

7
70Boss302 · March 12, 2026

Jimmie is 100% right-male insecurity has been a huge problem for humans since the beginning. It's the source of so much trauma it can't even be quantified. At best it's super annoying, and at worst, world wars.

M
Maggie King · August 10, 2026

"Men are afraid women will laugh at them. Women are afraid men will kill them." ~~Margaret Atwood~~ If that doesn't sum it up succinctly, nothing does. Rejection, no matter how gentle or harsh, can (in some men) trigger deadly violence. As does leaving a relationship. Pregnancy is also a trigger for some.

K
Katy Clark · March 12, 2026

Yay thanks for the shout out to NPs!

J
Jessica Schafer · March 12, 2026

Intact male pig is a boar. Fixed male pigs are barrows. James is right with sow.

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · March 12, 2026

I was going to say the same thing

B
Bol Bol · March 12, 2026

Also will note A LOT of people from Atlanta and surrounding areas travel to stay in ellijay, cherry log, and Blue ridge for a weekend mountain trip. I went to the big foot museum for shits and giggles it was dumb but fun

B
Bol Bol · March 12, 2026

I am getting married in ellijay in November 😁

A
Abbey Finney · May 27, 2026

It is lovely! Congrats!

S
Shayne Bartlett · March 12, 2026

Prison Love Notes,hmmmmm I’m ready to invest.

D
Dorothyann · March 12, 2026

I got in a fight with a friend once upon a time bc she felt I chose my husband’s side when he didn’t wave to her. Years later when we reconnected she brought up the not waving incident . 🤦‍♀️

A
April Evans · March 12, 2026

Ellijay native here. Thank you for saying my town name right lol

A
Anon · March 12, 2026

To get so lucky with these episodes on my bake days…feels like a true gift. Thank you guys!!!

K
Kris the Patrol Cop · March 12, 2026

Elijah is actually gorgeous. Side note, Prison Love Notes would be a dope band name lol

W
Wala Kitu · March 12, 2026

Ok so here’s the question I always ask of people who think that 16 year old boy having sex with a 23 year old woman is harmless. Let’s make it a 16 year old boy engaging in a homosexual relationship with a 23 year old male teacher? Do you still feel the same way? Truthfully.

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · March 12, 2026

Good point

R
Rainee Courtnage · March 12, 2026

Bigfoot moved from the Northwest? Left no forwarding address? How dare he move!

R
Rainee Courtnage · March 12, 2026

So pleased the hair band plays Evangelical Christian music.

M
Mick & Kathy · March 12, 2026

You are the best Jimmie and James

R
Rainee Courtnage · March 12, 2026

Intelligence and sex drive are not correlated. Its a trope.

R
Rainee Courtnage · March 12, 2026

Homes are purchased for tax deductions or money laundering?

J
Jenn Thompson · March 12, 2026

My Brother was groundskeeper for Berry College

E
Erika Fultz · March 12, 2026

Hogs are pigs that are over 120# and pigs usually come in white/pink, brown, black and black and white. There's lots of breeds with some other color combos, but the ones you'll see at fairs are usually Yorkshire(white/pink), Duroc (red) or Hampshire (black and white).

E
Em · March 12, 2026

I am, completely unironically, fascinated by this! Thank you!

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · March 12, 2026

Who made the gorgeous guitar behind Jimmie????

K
Kyle Bearce · March 12, 2026

Ever since the Netflix thing started I've been just amazed by that beauty... I just wanna grab it and hope it's perfectly in tune and sounding soooo full like a jumbo

M
MisledChef · March 12, 2026

HAWG Talk with James and Jimmie

L
Leslie Aguilar · March 12, 2026

My husband said he’s proud of Jimmy because he said our last name right 🤣

E
Erika Fultz · March 12, 2026

He does live in Arizona. There's lots of Aguilars in AZ.

A
Alyse Christensen · March 12, 2026

The way I was refreshing so many times last night thinking it was Wednesday 🤣🤣

K
Kyle Bearce · March 12, 2026

I've done that on a Sunday with CIS having it off randomly, I hardly ever do and always have Mondays off.

L
Laurel Fay · March 12, 2026

YAAAAAAAAAAAYYY!!

C
Connor · March 12, 2026

I haven’t listened but i hope they mention the bigfoot museum lol

A
Allen Tinker · March 12, 2026

Namesake!!!!

A
Allen Tinker · March 12, 2026

Nah, just playing. But, I love that title.