Murder Colors Don't Run - Jerome, Idaho
This week, in Jerome, Idaho, after a woman finds an ex-boyfriend, hiding in her closet with a crossbow, his entire history comes out. Including a crazy & maniacal murder, where he tried to blame a very unlikely person, decades in prison, and even a book of cowboy poetry. But the question is, why was he let out, after committing such a horrific murder, in the first place?
Along the way, we find out that stand up comedy should't have a "circus element" to it, that blaming a child for killing their own mother is beyond the scope of crazy, and that if you really want to freak someone out, hiding in their closet, with a crossbow, is a wild way to do it!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
instagram.com/smalltownmurder
facebook.com/smalltownpod
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Go to https://surfshark.com/stm or use code STM at checkout to get 4 extra months of Surfshark VPN!
Comments (74)
I wonder how he got entitled to something like a relationship with a mother like that? Huh 🤔
My
Boring episode
Hey Bruce, how about skipping commenting when it contributes nothing worthwhile? Just a thought.
Why? Because FUCK ‘EM, that’s why! It’s the Pop Copy credo. 😂 https://tenor.com/XW7u.gif
Can we get ludicry tshirts please?
If a judge vacated a sentence of someone and then that person tries to kill someone, that judge should be stripped of his stole, disbarred, and forced to face recompense from the victim.
I looked it up... Michael Mezmer isn't an Asian guy but he does look Asian at certain angles. I'm Asian myself so I think I'm an expert 😜
The nerve of this perps mother complaining about the justice system!
If tha cat went that long without food, are we sure there wasn't some meth involved? Lol That would explain some of his insanity....🤷😂🤣😂
Jimmy said MJ Okeeffe!!! He said my name 2:58:04!!!!!
Jami here. My credit report has multiple accepted spellings and neither of my grandmothers ever spelled it correctly
What’s Up 🦃 Turkeys?! Here on the front end, so, first off-(🖕🏾🧊) 2nd, I’ve still got time to buy my RoyalOak Tickets, 3rd, keep the bangers coming fellas!!! See y’all on the backside!
The poor crossbow didn’t get a name. Even if it did, it likely wouldn’t be as funny as “Ovulator” or “Inseminator,” names for what must have been one hell of a shirt.
“Rufus sounds like a big dog”. Side eye at my chihuahua, little Rufus Goofus. 😂
I stopped a few times during this episode to play George Strait 'I can still make Cheyenne"
Mine was Amarillo by Morning.
Kouri Richens wore a blood-red shirt on Thursday. No cartoonish collar, though.
What time does the Friday express drop?
Usually mid afternoon (PDT)
I have a Parti Yorki named Refus. He's a rescue. I don't know what I'd do without you guys since Oct 2025 when I was searching serial killer Podcasts. You help my workday so much. It just speeds by. I love jimmie’s laugh. Hearing your lifes’ stories. I love how deeply you dig into the crime, stories, towns, histories, backgrounds, people, reviews, and most of all your senses of humor and how you play off each other. Keep up the great work. I am definitely going to get to a live show and I've increased my Patreon donation. Thank you so much.
Yeeeaaaahhhh Jimmie! You certainly are!! LMAO 🤣... "Like 30 of them. We're alright" that's awesome and James didn't catch it lol. He's not one of the 30, I take it 😆😬 joking
Montana and Arkansas are full of actual cowfolk. Like, not-a-costume, spurs-in-the-diner cowfolk. Jimmie's not wrong!
Shoot, a 5yo can work the combine
New State Fair feature: the Little Cowpoke Combine Race
Holy Crap!! When you said he was out, I fell out of my chair!! And I love the way you brought the story around back to the beginning! JUST F**NG AWESOME! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Now I need a Ludacri-delivered pizza. Gotta give you points James for the American Giants/Richard Prior combo 👍
4ZTD
Wooooooooooooooooo
He shot her soooo many times! Why are we still asking questions! UGH!
Is this a repeat of a previous episode? Sure I’ve heard it before?
It’s not
This dude reminds me of an ex boyfriend. Exhausting, stupid, unhinged, jealous, and now luckily dead or in jail.
I’m out, don’t you worry! lol
Holy CRAP
“Mutual combat”? I turned around to stair at my speaker. Wtf.
Ok, I know it's a CIS thing... But we need a crossover. Whatever her name is, JD's Mom HAS to be in the running for the Golden Gilretha award at the next Scummies.
I love you two! Your take on toxic masculinity is right on.
The ludacri story line that has been adopted the last few months has me fucking dead, Everytime. Ludcri delivering pizzas, I'm weak.
Buahahahaha my name is Tiffnie and you're right... its a terrible name 🤣🤣🤣
We have a saying in bars in my area. " I'll buy everyone a drink, and anybody that says no, I'll buy them two.
Just when women finally got you guys to accept that when we say No, we mean No. So you go and throw a monkey wrench in it! I'm so confused.🤔
I can hardly wait for tomorrow night boys!! It’s the best day of the year ❤️
What’s tomorrow night?
Those Italian hands are moving today on Netflix. How James doesn't knock his mic into oblivion, I don't know.
Got a shoutout on my birthday. Thanks Jimmie!
Happy birthday 🎂!
The whole episode all I could do was hear Garth Brooke's, Rodeo. The white in his knuckle......
He'll win in the next go'round
my hick sister's first two husbands were brothers.
I also name my guns. My AR for daytime use is Grace, and my AR with the night scope is Mercy...
My 380 is a Ruger. We named it Roscoe.
Ned LeDoux is Chris' son. Definitely has name recognition, especially out west.
"Tiffni"... Pause for giggles
I wish 1984 was 32 years ago 🤣
Me Too!
I gotta ask guys, is it really a county fair if no Ludacri is there??
No.
Barry McCockiner is the best one yet 😂
Yo, my neck of the woods! Let's goooo!
Bc we're aholes but not scumbags
This was one crazy story, and it just shows the corruption of how some states work in Idaho I believe is one of the worst. My sister-in-law lived in Idaho for a while and the only reason she was there because her son-in-law wanted to live there because of the gun laws and he is a real creepy person how my niece ever buried him is beyond me.
I meant married him she should have buried him. I guess bad thing to say
If this fucker just LAYS LOW, and doesn’t pull his crossbow 🏹 shit….do they even ATTEMPT to retry him?! 🤦♂️
I used to watch Alex Clark on YouTube he did animation videos pretty funny videos
I like the logo on Jimmy’s T-shirt and the fact that he has a guitar in the background on the new show on Netflix putting some color into it looks better backgrounds are good. Love you guys you’re great.
Oh-why-he county Simp-lot
Yep!
Listening to James trying to pronounce “Owyhee” (oh-WYE-hee) is the best. 😂
I know! You were probably talking back to them O-why-hee!!! It is funny though😂
Ahhh my 34th birthday. Does anyone else envision what they were doing when they start out with the date? Remembering where you were and what you were doing as the story progresses?
Yes I do!
Nashville was a great show guys! Way to power through all the bull shit.
I've done work in that theater. What was the bullshit out of curiosity
