💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
The Unluckiest Winner - Plant City, Florida (1 of 2)
February 12, 2026

The Unluckiest Winner - Plant City, Florida

This week, in Plant City, Florida, when a very poor man wins $30 million dollars, it seems like he's the luckiest man, in the world. He helps his family, and builds a new life of luxury. Until he disappears. There are suspicious stories about where he may be, but did he just run away to hide from money seekers, or was he brutally murdered by a ruthless plot, hatched by one of the people he most trusted? A twisted story of betrayal!!

Along the way, we find out that strawberries are a winter thing in some locations, that even winning the lottery can't solve all of your problems, and that there can be a dark plot inside the mind of just about anybody!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (105)

K
Kianna Smith · April 1, 2026

Ive seen this story on plenty of shows but hearing you both cover it has had me laughing for 3hrs straight! Lmaooo yall crack me up! Cause I would definitely not be giving out money like that at all! Its soo sad & horrible what she did to him!

D
Donna Duncan · March 25, 2026

I believe that in Florida, you cannot hide your identity when you win the big lotteries. With all the publicity around lottery wins, it's no wonder he was plagued with hangers on and parasites. This guy didn't have a chance. Hey Florida, how about giving these folks a little privacy. Let them choose whether or not their faces get plastered all over the media outlets.

H
Holly Chi · March 5, 2026

Jimmy's Corvette/ she fucks hard comment totally made my day! 🤣🤣🤣

J
Justin Simmons · March 3, 2026

Fuck that lady!

N
Nolan Wilson · March 2, 2026

I give 5stars

Z
Zach Hollander · February 19, 2026

Wooooooooooooooooo 8 days late. 🤣🤣🤣

J
Joshua DeWitte · February 18, 2026

Jimmy and James you guys crack me up… pick a couple dollars for the ticket. Haha

L
Lori Ditchfield · February 18, 2026

This lying shitbag! Just can't help herself. Great episode guys!

J
Jessica Schafer · February 18, 2026

JIMMIE, I just saw the Oak ridge boys a few months ago! 😂 fantastic stuff. Ricky Skaggs opened for them and was also great.

R
Ryan Oakes · February 16, 2026

Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie

M
Matthew Ballou · February 16, 2026

Excellent job telling that story. I live in FL and am a retired LEO. I was loosely associated with this case. Having watched a few of the TV specials on the case you guys and your team blew them out of the water. This really impressed me. Thank you.

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · February 16, 2026

Jimmy, in the spring of 1974 my college booked The Marshall Tucker Band. This was in Jackson Mississippi. Little Feat opened for them, and completely blew them off the stage! It was very obvious, and the Marshall Tucker Band was not happy.

A
Ashley W. · February 16, 2026

If only Abraham had had someone on his side, helping to manage that money from the get-go, we could've had an extremely wealthy Florida man with the world's best name just hanging out, donating huge sums to charity, randomly paying off people's mortgages...do people who win such huge sums get any financial counseling??

A
Alan’s Mom · February 15, 2026

The Alero and Achieva were Oldsmobile models. Pontiac had the Aztek which was what Walter White drove in Breaking Bad.

B
Brooke C · February 15, 2026

I need my LUDACRII shirt!!!!

S
Sheri Zylstra · February 15, 2026

It’s sad he didn’t have a good friend that could have helped him either learn to read or even his parents! Someone who could have helped him understand how much money he had and how he could have slowed the spending! Poor guy!

K
Kyra Richter · February 14, 2026

Jimmy, isn’t wrong. Most people who win the lottery are broke or worse than they were before it. Look it up. 1.5mil for 10 or 20 years guarantees that you won’t overspend or at least gives you time to learn to live within your new means. We all say we’d invest but most just spend. I’d seriously consider the yearly payment. Have a slightly but not extreme upgrade in my life and have a steady income.

J
Jason Willson · February 20, 2026

I had a friend that hit for $2mil at the age of 19 (this was back in '99 or 2000). First thing he did was buy a GIANT house and a Ferrari while continuing to work as a line cook at Chili's. A year later the car and house were both repossessed and he was in jail for breaking into ATM machines 😂.

A
Adrienne · February 14, 2026

I’m watching the “Baby-faced &Deadly”. I am 65 and I’m not stupid. I just need someone to please explain the seating situation in Netflix Podcasts. Jimmie keeps jumping out of the screen….? HELP!

L
Liz Rutherford · February 14, 2026

Jimmie is on the left and James is on the right. They have a split screen.

J
Jonathan Bob · February 14, 2026

If you can control your spending , take the lump sum. You're going to be at the top tax rate, which is about 37% plus state taxes.If applicable. If you are taking the yearly payments , you don't know what the maximum tax rate is going to be five,ten, fifteen years from now.

L
Liz Rutherford · February 14, 2026

In Illinois, you're only in a higher tax bracket for that year. The Illinois Lottery sends a W2-G (gambling winnings) to every winner that wins $600+ at one time and yes, they do take out state tax at $1000+, which is 5% with federal tax coming in at $5000+

H
Hannah Orme · February 14, 2026

I'm a Plant City employee and I'm listening while I work alone at night doing an already sketchy job. Wish me luck lol.

K
Kim Corgan-Hatfield · February 13, 2026

Juvie Detention - If home isn’t a great place and parents aren’t there or can’t keep him in line, kids are more likely to get detention. If a nuclear white family looks good on paper, a kid is more likely to go home. Plus, they probably considered him truant instead of learning disabled.

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · February 13, 2026

Our station wagons exhaust smelled like rotton eggs. My sister would demand that my mother drop us off at least one block away from school bc she was so embarrassed.

A
Alicia C · February 13, 2026

I just watched the documentary about this dude. Truly a sad tale. Abraham’s mom was right. His wealth was a curse.

R
Ronald Huffer · February 13, 2026

Wow!

T
Tiff Shaddy · February 13, 2026

Love his name!!

A
Anyadarkstar · February 13, 2026

Grady Judd is the OG!

E
Erika Fultz · February 13, 2026

"Watch a man struggle to read" made me 😂!

D
Dawn Shaw · February 13, 2026

I've heard parts of this story before, I'm always glad that she gets caught in the end. Such a horrible person.

R
Rebecca Pohlman · February 13, 2026

This story is so sad.

G
Ginger Thomas · February 13, 2026

The problem with the annual lottery winner payments is that they stop if you die--at least in most states.

G
Ginger Thomas · February 13, 2026

This story is so depressing... Wish Abraham had had a real friend like JImmie was describing. Or that someone had filed for conservatorship.

D
Dale Oren · February 13, 2026

Casefile did this story as well... obviously not as good as STM.

C
CHRIS STANSEL · February 13, 2026

I'm from St. Petersburg and this story is absolutely wild 😆

T
Tracie Bryant · February 13, 2026

Depends on the state, California doesn't allow you to leave it to anyone if you die. The state will keep it.

A
Alicia C · February 13, 2026

He took the lump sum. So it would go to whoever he left his inheritance too, even in CA. If you chose yearly installments, then you would have to have a named beneficiary or yes, it’s likely it will go back to the state.

C
Cosmo's ma · February 13, 2026

AI says it would be 16 standard pools filled with pennies.

R
Renee · February 13, 2026

AAAHH!!!! I KNOW THIS STORY!!!! Also - ALWAYS take the annuity. ALWAYS. Adjusted for inflation, you're getting SIGNIFICANTLY more money that way.

D
Daniel Peters · February 13, 2026

Excuse me I'm stupid, which one is the annuity? 😂

C
Cooper Williams · February 13, 2026

Sheriff Grady Judd Instagram page is awesome funny guy 😂

J
JizyahShortz · February 13, 2026

69th comment!

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · February 13, 2026

By the way, if you win the lottery, you treat it like the Lufthansa heist: don't tell anyone. Don't buy anything. Don't change anything. Don't quit your job. Get a financial planner and a financial lawyer that like a surgeon would go to. Good, but not flashy. And you don't tell anyone before you tell them. Not your best friend. Not your spouse. Not even a priest. You don't say shit about shit until that money is locked up in trusts and enough time has passed that things cool down.

G
Ginger Thomas · February 13, 2026

I grew up with a friend whose parents won the lottery. She didn't even know about it until she was an adult. IDK how much $$$--probably not $17 Million, because they kept their jobs and lived in a nice but "regular" house. Everyone thought they just did well with the money they made at their jobs.

B
Buteiful Life · February 13, 2026

Sheriff Judd is fucking hilarious! I highly recommend checking out the Polk County Sheriff’s Instagram.

J
Jane Blackbird · February 13, 2026

He is over the top!🤣

O
One Last Kharrizz · February 13, 2026

The suprise Segal roast was perfect.

L
Lisa Korpi · February 13, 2026

Thanks for the shoutout and saying my name correctly! Another excellent podcast !

M
Mirissa Misiowiec · February 13, 2026

Thank you for the shout out.

H
Hannah Walker · February 13, 2026

I’m a lawyer who works in trust administration and wealth management for high net worth individuals. While I love a fancy Michelin starred meal, I can also put down some cheddar bay biscuits. We contain multitudes! 😂

S
Stephen Watts · February 13, 2026

Not surprised that a Cork man changed the town name to Cork, as a Dubliner can say that Corkonians will split a sentence to tell you they are from Cork or how great it is, meanwhile it is Irelands answer to a panhandle. Also he would have pronounced it 'Cark'.

M
Mirissa Misiowiec · February 13, 2026

I actually saw the Bellamy Brothers in OK for a fund raiser. Danced with a wonderful ,93 yr old man to "Y'all Come Back Saloon".

B
Brittany Santos · February 12, 2026

I wanna see Alabama!!!!

7
70Boss302 · February 12, 2026

As someone who got taken to school in an AMC Eagle....literally anyone else was cooler than me. My Mom could've parked a mile away, I was already marked 😂😂

J
Jane Blackbird · February 13, 2026

😂🤣👍

M
Mirissa Misiowiec · February 12, 2026

Thanks James, I have "Cornbread and Chicken" playing on repeat in my head.

S
Sgt. Slaughter's Cobra · February 12, 2026

Well.. Jimmy's got me humming Elvira.

M
Matt Studer · February 12, 2026

What a cold hearted bitch!!

N
NonniX2 · February 12, 2026

Thank you for telling this story with such great detail. I remember this story happening and I've heard it so many times, I almost didn't listen. I'm glad I did. It was very sad when it happened. She's a monstrous piece of garbage and deserves all she gets. And as for SHERIFF GRADY JUDD.... he is a legend! Polk County is better because of him. 💜

B
Becca Thomas · February 12, 2026

500 calls a day is one call every 2 min 52 seconds.

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · February 12, 2026

Some details around Abraham going to reform school at 12: he was a dark skinned black man in 1978 in rural Florida. I don't know how tall he was at the time, but he ended up being around 6'5", so all of that might have had something to do with it.

J
Jordan L. Hawk · February 12, 2026

I recognized this town because my wife traveled there for work a number of times, the poor woman

J
John penrod · February 12, 2026

Bellamy brothers had a big hit called let your love flow

S
Sherrie Holm · February 12, 2026

Heard this story before, but this is definitely the best telling of it. The b*tch needs to be fed to alligators!! Sheriff Grady is awesome!! Love to watch him on YouTube. He gives zero f’s and is hilarious!

D
Dawn · February 12, 2026

I lived in Polk county when they were searching for him.

T
Tony Legg · February 12, 2026

I remember this one from 20/20. You guys blew them away 👍

M
Michael Smith · February 12, 2026

I promise im not that scary

M
Micah Is Real · February 12, 2026

James "singing" Alan Jackson was the highlight of my fuckin day hahahahaha

C
CINESCREEN STUDIOS LLC - Producers of MASH-UP Companion Podcast to Web Series · February 12, 2026

Greg McGuyvired the fuck out of that Red Bull can!

C
Chas Williams · February 12, 2026

Five years in juvie for theft - yea that tracks for poor people in fl

L
Lindsay Ruiz · February 12, 2026

I drove a skylark! Lol.

S
STEFANIE CLARK · February 12, 2026

this is my home town!!! so excited for this episode!!!

S
Shadow Guardians Paranormal · February 12, 2026

Did I just learn that orange trees have thorns 😅

M
Mirissa Misiowiec · February 12, 2026

Nasty thorns! My ex-husband drove us through a thicket of them on a 4-wheeler.

J
JoBu · February 12, 2026

Grew up in Tampa and the chickens and blonde women with leg bruises makes me chuckle every time 😆

J
JoBu · February 12, 2026

Grew up in Tampa not far from Plant City. In the 80s and even into the 90s Plant City was nothing, like boondocks out there farms. I remember going to the Straberry Feetival with my Grandparents as a kid, just a small town festival. Not sure what the town looks like today but I’ve heard the festival is massive now.

B
Beth Rockefeller · February 12, 2026

I have always been fascinated by this case and hearing James telling it is just 🤌.

E
Erin · February 12, 2026

I’ve seen a pig race at a county fair. It is so freaking adorable.

J
Just Jamie · February 12, 2026

I named my daughter Antoinette!

H
Heather Igelman · February 12, 2026

As a middle school teacher, I was dying when jimmi asked James if he could read in seventh grade 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Z
Zoe Daverin · February 12, 2026

Fun fact: Ludacris DID perform at the Strawberry Festival in 2023! I used to live about 45 minutes from Plant City, and was shocked that Ludacris would be at this relatively unknown festival in a relatively unknown town, until I learned that Ludacris would perform at a landfill if he got an offer. 😂

C
CINESCREEN STUDIOS LLC - Producers of MASH-UP Companion Podcast to Web Series · February 12, 2026

lol

M
Mike Oxlong · February 12, 2026

I love y’all’s podcast more than anything, but the firearms ignorance gets me every time. Other than that, perfection! 3 out of 5 stars.

M
Michael Clark · February 12, 2026

Firearms ignorance? What do you mean exactly? Jimmy has an entire safe full of guns and knows guns pretty damn well. Perhaps James not as much, but still extremely knowledgeable of them and murder related firearms stuff (blood spatter, damage different types of guns cause to victims, etc.).

M
Maggie King · February 12, 2026

Alphabet backwards? I have a Master's in languages, just put the cuffs on me too!

J
Jennifer Lautermilch · February 12, 2026

I refuse to believe Jimmy and James have never heard of Grady Judd!! He is the best sheriff ever, the U.S. needs more like him!

N
Nolan McCarty · February 12, 2026

Funny enough, ludacris and keith urban are the headliners for my employers employee concert this year 😭

C
Courtney♥️ · February 12, 2026

ALERO!

C
Crowded Crow · February 12, 2026

Over the years, I've heard Mr. Shakespeare's story a number of times; as usual, I learned much more detail listening to James tell it. This man wasn't stupid or weak... it hurts that he likely never understood what a treasure he was. In my humble estimation, the world is too small for the size and caliber of Abraham's exquisite heart.

M
Michael Clark · February 12, 2026

Seriously though. It sounded like Mr. Shakespeare didn’t have a bad bone in his body. Unfortunately, just happened to be gullible enough to trust a monster and likely overwhelmed at the massive, overnight change in his life circumstances and how to tackle that correctly.

s
stacie makley · February 12, 2026

I was born and raised in MI...30 years later I moved to Florida. Y'all hit it dead on the spot every time (for BOTH states). Keep doing the good work. I LOVE all 3 shows!!!!!!! P.S. I moved back to MI about 2 years and 7 months ago. Trust me, It was much needed. Not BETTER, per se, but needed.

J
JoBu · February 12, 2026

I’m sure the natives of FL miss you a bunch. Glad you’re gone.

K
Krista Lelie · February 12, 2026

Sad thing is I’ve been to the Strawberry Festival there when I was in college… went to University of Tampa 🤣

J
JoBu · February 12, 2026

Born and raised in Tampa, left in 96 to join the military. That place has changed so much over the years.

C
CINESCREEN STUDIOS LLC - Producers of MASH-UP Companion Podcast to Web Series · February 12, 2026

I think I know this one!!!

M
Michael Clark · February 12, 2026

Always take the lump sum. The advertised amount of winnings (in this case, $30 million) is only able to be produced because they take the money that would’ve been given to you as a lump sum and put it into an annuity that appreciates in value over time, landing you at the collective payment of $30 million. You’d be better off taking the lump sum and choosing how you’d like to spend it/have it generate interest that you can live off of.

K
Kirstin Grimes · February 13, 2026

And if you play often, or have family/friends that do, save those old tickets! They can be used to offset your taxes on winning. $17 million, probably not, but if you win $1000, it's fairly easy to offset.

A
Adam · February 12, 2026

Always take the lump sum!

A
Abby Thompson · February 12, 2026

I haven’t even listened but opening the app and seeing it’s in plant city gave me chills

L
Liz Rutherford · February 12, 2026

Money is the root of all evil.

C
Crowded Crow · February 12, 2026

This much I know is true.

L
Lori Coxe · February 12, 2026

Yaaaaay

L
Laurel Fay · February 12, 2026

YAAAAAAAAYYYYYY!!

A
Allen Tinker · February 12, 2026

Yay!!!!