💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
The Fireplace Poker Murder - Spring Grove, Illinois (1 of 2)
January 29, 2026

The Fireplace Poker Murder - Spring Grove, Illinois

This week, in Spring Grove, Illinois, when a young woman is found, brutally murdered & with her skull crushed, detectives suspect her ex boyfriend, who happens to be an former small town police officer. He inists that he "only wants to help people". But his violent past, including being seen biting the victim's face, in public, makes him the obvious suspect. This all leads to wild & strange court poroceedings, and a huge fight over the murder weapon!

Along the way, we find out that you should never write your own bio, that there is no such thing as a "little bite on the face", and that just because you used to be a cop, doesn't mean you know how to get away with murder!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Check us out on VIDEO Wednesday and Friday evenings on Netflix! www.netflix.com/smalltownmurder

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (80)

E
ENKC · March 16, 2026

What? I divorced cop that wants to date essentially a child that is 11 years younger than him?? Color me shocked! Met her at 12 lmfaoooooo ACAB. 🖕🏻🧊

J
Joe C · February 10, 2026

Hard to believe but geo trackers/ Suzuki samurai’s have a cult following. They can be worth 3-4000 dollars depending on conditions

R
Ryan Oakes · February 6, 2026

Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie

B
Benjamin Fleming · February 4, 2026

All I'm saying is if someone can be executed for killing a pig, then when a pig kills someone, they should get the same.

B
Bryan Dillon · February 3, 2026

Phenolphthalein - fee-nohl-THAY-leen

J
Joe B · February 2, 2026

Jimmie, you’re too hard on yourself about geography. Your math is far worse and much funnier.

j
jessrhoward · February 1, 2026

I am SO happy that this story was the first one on Netflix. Mainly for the quote of, 'The world doesn't owe you p*ssy!' Also this wretched disgusting excuse for a human being in the story sounds a lot like another awful man who's in the news a lot these days.

C
Cher Strong (#localweedia) · January 31, 2026

Just saw the Netflix thing. I’m so glad about it, and hope it stays on for a long time and becomes a solid fixture there. The straight, honest, realness of these stories is important in these times. Thanks guys. For the stability and laughs!

T
Two 0' Clock High · January 31, 2026

I’m going to hole that the cop at football games perhaps he was working the game as a security measure …. Here in good ol Flint Michigan the cops get paid extra working high school sporting events so maybe it was that reason lol or maybe it is as they see it and that’s way funnier

J
Jim Dolen · January 31, 2026

I think Fuck that guy said it all

S
Shelby Boyde · January 31, 2026

1992…I was turning 1 year old that year!! 😆

M
Mirissa Misiowiec · January 31, 2026

Oh😂, sorry Jimmie. You killed that name. I had to do patrion just to hear you attempt that stupid last name. My ex wanted me to change it back to my maiden name, I kept his name legally. Keep trying at it, you may get it right some day. We have tickets for the show in Oct in Dallas.

A
Ashley W. · January 31, 2026

Dang, he's an Ostermeyer? He's an Eastern Meyer Weiner instead of an Oscar Meyer *rim shot* yeah, I'm a font of German-language jokes. Also I love my free pass out of jury duty: "yeah, well, I've got siblings who work at the court of appeals, so..."

J
Jim Dolen · January 30, 2026

This idiot was promoted to Sargeant?

K
Kathleen Schwitzner · January 30, 2026

I'm an Illinois listener, formerly from Chicagoland and now closer to Mt. Zion. The Skis comment. Guys, I'm at work listening to this on headphones, trying to do some hard core accounting analysis. STAHHHP. I'm totally gonna lose my shit. Also, thank you for being so good that I'm gonna lose my shit. Accounting's dull, yo.

M
Mary · January 30, 2026

There’s that frustrating line between being smart enough or just lucky enough to manage to commit a murder, and being too dumb to get away with it. It’s so frustrating, the dude is such a dummy. I’m so sad for the victim and her family.

K
Kramer and his Cougar MILF · January 30, 2026

I can't lie lol... I happily waived my 2 year excusal after serving on a jury in a self defense case - It was SUCH an amazing process!!... I would be a professional juror if I could 🤔, but that's not a thing. I applied to be Court Bailiff instead 😂

S
Shell Sinclair · January 30, 2026

I'm walking round alternating between howling laughing at JizzHornet, and singing All For Love, bloody brilliant

Z
Zachary Leatherwood · January 30, 2026

Whats up Turkeys 🦃? How are the fells looking on Netflix? Sad for this guy, I don’t have the loot enough for the monthly subscription yet, but soon!!! I’ll see the fellas in Royaloak though🤙🏾(🖕🏾🧊)

C
Crowded Crow · February 1, 2026

Right there with you, would love to see them...but we'll get there, never underestimate the determination of a couple of murder turkeys! (ICE can get fucked and 💣💀🕳️)

S
Samantha · January 30, 2026

The murderer in this show is SO fucking annoying, no way he deserved a 2nd trial for something so stupid. What a whiny baby!

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · January 30, 2026

Watching them will be fun. When James gets excited/extra happy, he looks like a 12 year old boy

C
Cher Strong (#localweedia) · January 30, 2026

26:00 Jimmie did it! (Guessed the top musician/song) James’s gasp was such a gasp!

M
Melissa Dickinson · January 30, 2026

I tried watching on Netflix, but the audio was off from the video by a split second, and it was making me crazy! I'll try again next week!

C
Chad Litzinger · January 31, 2026

I noticed that as well. Kina hope they add some props.

G
Ginger Thomas · January 30, 2026

Linear = LYNN-ee-er

J
Justin Smith · January 30, 2026

A frigate is a small ship. I know that because frigate was a level on 007 goldeneye on N64 lol

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · January 30, 2026

You're a frigate

L
Liesl Manone · January 29, 2026

It is very weird to watch y'all on Netflix and see your faces LOL

A
Amanda Allen · January 29, 2026

Just watched on Netflix n Jimmie looks so uncomfortable poor baby

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · January 30, 2026

That's not his regular look?

L
Lg · January 29, 2026

I thought these came out Mondays now? Im just fucking with yous

M
Matressa, Countess of Whorington · January 30, 2026

Turkey

C
Cara (Care-uh) · January 29, 2026

"Bad luck and tasty skin" is WILD LMAOOOOOO Damn, James 😂

J
Jesika Akhavein Rubin · January 29, 2026

As soon as Jimmie got Boyz II Men right I had to switch over to Netflix to watch, waited so long 😂

D
Darren Jenkins · January 29, 2026

Chris Kelly of Kris Kross passed away from an accidental OD.

W
Wasabi Kat · January 29, 2026

Suspend without pay! Yes! Problem is police departments are just large legal gangs.

C
Cher Strong (#localweedia) · January 31, 2026

We’re going to need a “Small Town Murder Fans Bunker” pretty soon. We can only trust each other….!<3

J
Jonathan Bob · January 29, 2026

James, I'm going to be the pronunciation a-hole. It's lin-ee-er not lin-ear

H
Heather · January 29, 2026

Omg Spring Grove. You can take a day long canoe trip on the Nippersink. And the Northwest Herald is still hanging on! 😆

H
Heather Igelman · January 30, 2026

A kayak nipper sink multiple times during the summer. It’s one of my favorite paddles.

A
Amy Jennejohn · January 29, 2026

My best male friend calls me princess but he also calls me f*ck face 🙅‍♀️

E
Em · January 30, 2026

🤣

H
Heather Igelman · January 29, 2026

I hit that canoe drop off a lot… That’s where I launched from in the summer

J
Joe Weniger · January 29, 2026

This joke relates to this episode. What has 9 arms and sucks?

R
Renae F · February 3, 2026

DEF LEPPARD!!! YASSS

B
BKP · January 29, 2026

Jimmy finally getting a number 1 song of the year is the pinnacle of the last 6 years of my life.

E
Em · January 30, 2026

🤣

J
JoBu · January 29, 2026

Was this the Netflix episode from Monday? And yes I know it’s the only time the show will be on Netflix on a Monday. Just wondering.

S
SHUT UP AND GIVE ME BONUS! · January 29, 2026

Yes.

T
Teamrocket · January 29, 2026

Does anyone else forget its Thursday?.. then I remember and my whole day is better. :)

S
Scott Brady · January 29, 2026

Lol there were a pair of sisters I went to hs with whose last name was Cumbee 😂

t
theeNaturegirl · January 29, 2026

Congrats on netflix! Been following for awhile and its great to see how far these shows have come. Hope you get more jive turkeys to follow!

R
Robin Baldah · January 29, 2026

669 how appropriate for you two. It’s your favorite subject. I watched your live twice. It was nice seeing your faces. Are you going to show pictures of the things you look at like houses etc? Finally something on Netflix to watch. It’s expensive and they keep repeating shows like Epstein. Different picture to draw you in but the same content they’ve already showed. So it’s good to finally have something g to watch since I’m paying for Netflix. Glad they picked you guys up.

R
Rich Ferguson · January 29, 2026

Congrats on the Netflix score, guys. Saw you a couple of days ago. Seeing you do your thing is a whole new layer of cool. I also saw you when you came to LA some years ago. Hope you come back some day. Keep up the great work.

C
Craig · January 29, 2026

Frigate-Frig-et=ship So probably a bar on the water?

J
Jennifer Britten · January 29, 2026

So glad for the return of the Sahara Desert Fart Fact. Can River Talk be far behind 🤔?

T
Travis WTAF · January 30, 2026

I was just wondering about River Talk..

N
NonniX2 · January 29, 2026

I would wear a JIZZ HORNET t-shirt 🤷‍♀️

J
Jordyn Fahey · January 29, 2026

I really wish the episode could be titled the Cum Bee 😭 but I understand why not 😇

K
Kristen S · January 29, 2026

Love seeing you two on Netflix! It would be great if you could show us your screen for the real estate report, what to do here and a pic of the people involved. Keep up the great work!

M
Matt Fost · January 29, 2026

James said over on Facebook that the pics for the real estate report is not something they can legally do.

M
Megan Henry · January 29, 2026

I've been summoned for jury duty twice and was chosen both times...I actually enjoyed it but it wasn't a serious crime I'm not sure I would want to be on a murder trail idk if I could handle that but petty crimes it's actually pretty fun to be on the jury

T
TheKlap · January 29, 2026

I’m a little disappointed that the Netflix and weekly podcast I’ve known all these years will be the same story. I know it’s a lot of work to put these together and I’m still grateful nonetheless.

D
Dorothyann · January 29, 2026

My first car was a geo (prism) and I cried when my sister totaled it. 🫠

K
Kaye · January 29, 2026

I can't find you on UK Netflix, devastated!!! 😭

c
chiefkeefin2013 · January 29, 2026

I’m a felon for weed and I’d probably be a more competent cop than most of them :)

P
Pepper · January 29, 2026

James: ...many different things. Jimmy: Heart attack. James: Anything. Not that. 1:22:40 😂😂😂😂😂I'm dead.😂😂😂😂😂

D
Deesa Bird · January 29, 2026

That really made me laugh too. I know James is a its always sunny fan and one of the common quotes from that show is "not that though" idk if he was subconsciously quoting them or not but he said it in the same cadence. All that to say it really got to me 🤣😂.

J
Jesse · January 29, 2026

One of the Kriss Kross guys died

W
Wayne Spark · January 29, 2026

Laughing my fucking ass off at “bumblejizz”….. pity I can’t watch this on Australian Netflix.

A
Aric · January 29, 2026

Thank you for each show and work put in to make it happen.

L
Lord Gekko · January 29, 2026

Telescopic police asp is about the same circumference as a fireplace poker.

M
Milita DeMorrow (kwiklip) · January 29, 2026

I've been wondering whatever happened to the Sahara Desert Fart Facts! Glad to have it back.

A
Amandanana · January 29, 2026

The "use that for lube" is now top 5 of my favorite, disgusting, dirty ass man lines.

C
Carol King · January 29, 2026

I thought that the Wednesday episode would be different than the Netflix episode. This one is the same as the one that was on Netflix maybe I’m just misunderstanding something here. I don’t know. I’m brain dead anyway it really doesn’t matter. I love the Netflix thing. Keep it up you guys you’re great.

K
Kim Corgan-Hatfield · January 29, 2026

I tried Netflix and will continue to try, but I don’t watch anything for more than 32 seconds (#adHd). I can listen for hours though. I ended up putting my phone face down while I listened to Netflix. 🤣 I Hope it helps with first week ratings!

A
Amandanana · January 29, 2026

Same!

K
Kyra Richter · January 29, 2026

Watched on Netflix this afternoon and it’s a whole new experience. You guys did a great job but it’s a real treat to watch Jimmy laugh. He has the best laugh. You both do. Thank you!

A
Adrian · January 29, 2026

Watching on Netflix now