💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
Hooters, Hitler & Horribleness - Ocean City, Maryland (1 of 2)
January 24, 2026

Hooters, Hitler & Horribleness - Ocean City, Maryland

This week, in Ocean City, Maryland, a very pleasant, and upstanding couple runs into a younger couple, while on vaction. Everyone makes friends, and has a good time, but when the upstanding couple end up missing, it seems like a mystery. That mystery is quickly solved, when the killers are caught, trying to steal mechandise from Hooters restaurant. They have more incriminating evidence on them than anyone has ever seen. Will all of the victims body parts ever be found??

Along the way, we find out that when there's an ocean, people don't need much else to do, that when someone names their snake "Hitler", they may have some problems, and that you can never quite clean up all the blood left behind, during a dismemberment!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (93)

K
Kayla DeMoulin · February 17, 2026

I started listening to this and was like wait a fucking min. This lady grew up in my home town. I remember this story was huge.

J
Joe Jacobbi · February 12, 2026

So when the Beej was kicked out of the Navy the “unauthorized uniform insignia” had to have been him wearing some Nazi shit, right? Dude has a swastika on his chest, they sell collectibles, that man is rocking some Nazi shit on his uniform and he got tossed from the navy. That and the awol of course

R
Ryan Oakes · February 11, 2026

Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie

C
CINESCREEN STUDIOS LLC - Producers of MASH-UP Companion Podcast to Web Series · February 11, 2026

James does a fantastic drunk Erika!

M
Mana · February 7, 2026

I’m interested in finding out more about the cold case in cape cod. I googled and couldn’t find anything.

B
Brooke C · January 31, 2026

Snakes named Hitler & HIV??

B
Brooke C · January 31, 2026

That festival is a dream come true for those of us that were whores in the 90s

D
Dani Horton · January 30, 2026

I love the Netflix episode. You need an animated series of the episodes.

G
Gregory D · January 29, 2026

Secrets makes Hooters look like Sesame Place. Ask a Marylander.

A
Amanda Bauerschmidt · January 29, 2026

The hooters jokes were killing me 🤣🤣🤣

N
Nicole Meunier · January 28, 2026

Just watched on Netflix! Congratulations!!

C
Chris Russell · January 28, 2026

This one was a tough one to get thru. It's mind boggling how evil humans can be. It's better off to not trust anyone unless you know them very very well.

B
Beck · January 28, 2026

So hooters in Wilmington NC is still open!!

J
Justin Simmons · January 31, 2026

Where it's at?!?!

S
Shayne Bartlett · January 28, 2026

Ok well good to see hooters is still classy.

C
Captain Ripley · January 28, 2026

“BJ is bad enough, but Beej is even worse. He’s a douche bag who got a blow job” 😅

E
Evan Dickinson · January 28, 2026

Damn does James have jaundice

R
Rainee Courtnage · January 30, 2026

No

J
Jessie Barnette · January 28, 2026

Could i maybe get a shout out sometime? I’ve been a Patreon for about 6 months and I still haven’t heard my name.. I know y’all get busy and stuff so it’s no big deal. I still love y’all!

B
Brooke C · January 31, 2026

They only do it the first week after you subscribe so all the names you hear are people that subscribed the week before

N
Nicki Solowij · January 27, 2026

Jimmie, I love you. You crack me up. James love you're voice very sexy. Thanks guys, love listening to you. Much love from Adelaide South Australia

M
Max Wilson · January 27, 2026

James’ hate for Nazi’s warms my heart.

J
Jordan Allevato · January 27, 2026

"Successful people are insufferable," says the successful podcasters who have a Netflix deal lol

M
Melissa · January 27, 2026

Jimmie, when James said “this land” I immediately followed it with “was made for you and me”. Great minds! 😅

J
Jaime Agosto · January 27, 2026

I said “ is your land”

Z
Zane Burton · January 27, 2026

Just watched this on old forensic files before listening lol fellas did much better job

J
Jackie Conklin · January 27, 2026

Did m sister’s Bachelorette party in OCDM. The drunk bus on the strip is the best.

T
Tyler Lavenski · January 26, 2026

I am so bummed out that this episode wasn't called "Erika and the Beejer."

D
Dean Rashkow · January 26, 2026

I can't stop listening. Can't wait to watch on Netflix tonight!

K
Kyle Nordberg · January 26, 2026

I fucking want to go to that festival.

S
Shawna Negus · January 27, 2026

Me too!

J
Joe Weniger · January 26, 2026

1) Every episode I think "this is the craziest one ever" 2) Yall hate Florida. I'm thankful I don't live in New York or Arizona. 3) Excited for the Netflix. 4) I want chicken wings now.

A
Ace-ala · January 26, 2026

“I hope they pronounce the county like they do in Massachusetts” - they do not James.

C
Christine Leister · January 26, 2026

Seacrets and the drunk bus 😂

E
Erin · January 26, 2026

So incredibly happy for you both with this Netflix deal! Congratulations and cheers to ever-growing success for you both! ♥️

A
Aaron Aherne-Williams · January 26, 2026

Jersey swapping at hooters is hilarious

M
Meg C. · January 26, 2026

My best friend from high school, college both tried to get me to go to the festival they were talking about. After listening to the lineup again I’m bummed I didn’t go 😂

E
Erin Reece · January 25, 2026

Loved this episode. So excited to watch on Netflix!

A
Ashley W. · January 25, 2026

My birthday always falls on or around Memorial Day - l always get a 3-day weekend for my birthday - score! Also: hard agree with James: anyone with a swastika tattoo deserves to have their nose pasted to the back of their skull.

B
BJ Lowe · January 25, 2026

“Beej” is the worst.

J
Justin Simmons · January 31, 2026

😂

K
KarenRocks444 · January 25, 2026

I remember this story on one of those ID shows, not in so much detail though.

C
CINESCREEN STUDIOS LLC - Producers of MASH-UP Companion Podcast to Web Series · January 26, 2026

Yep, I’ve seen this story on ID.

M
Maritza Diaz · January 25, 2026

Now I'm shouting "Leave it to Beejer" in my head. Thanks 👍🏻

M
Menzie Chase · January 25, 2026

This is random but I’m listening to old episodes. In 322 (Davies, FL) there’s a guy named Menzies and you have great fun with his name. That’s my first name! I was so excited; I never hear my name in the wild. It’s a clan name in Scotland; there’s a Menzies plaid and a Castle Menzies. It was my great-grandfathers first name, and my parents like family names, and thought it was cute for a girl. Anyway, just thought it was cool to hear my name in a STM ep!

D
Dennis James Mcintosh · January 25, 2026

I think a Stuart Menzies played a role in WWII. I’m a McIntosh, another Clan name.

A
Alex G · January 25, 2026

Im from Altoona, my parents would never let me go in her scrapbooks shop, it wasn't until I was an adult that I was told why.

S
SilverHairedMiddleAgedTuxedoMask · January 25, 2026

You have to 100% wonder if neither of these two people met each other if they'd stay "normal", they had promising careers but it just seems like the second they got to know each other they both became INCREDIBLY evil

M
Makea King · January 25, 2026

I was in Ocean City for Senior Week that following weekend. Seacrets didn’t care about the vomit cause you probably couldn’t see it due to the foam party on the dance floor. We also went to Hooters for wings one night. 💀

E
Enjoli Pettice (E) · January 25, 2026

NETFLIX!!!!!!!! HELLLLL YEEEEEAAAAAHH, yall fuckin deserve it!! I’ve been listening since fuckin 2016 OR 2017 and I’ve been a Patreon member since 2017-2018. SN: Jimmie read out my name one episode, I was SOOO Excited that I woke up my girlfriend to Hear you Say my name again !!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

D
David Bullied · January 25, 2026

Did she dump you soon after lol

M
Monty R. Jones · January 24, 2026

Great job!! Health departments aren't free, they have a sliding scale for charges. 🙂

D
D Minus · January 24, 2026

One of my most favorite things is Jimmie telling his Labor Day story! It's the second time and it makes me laugh so much🤣 Laaaaabahhh DAY!

C
Cory Gainous · January 24, 2026

Me and jimmy synced there in my head I started singing this land is my land😂

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · January 24, 2026

I'd bet "Beej" is a MASH reference. Hawkeye called BJ Hunnicut "Beej" a lot

C
Crime stories · January 24, 2026

I visit ocean city yearly, didn’t know about this. I got married there and stayed at the Atlantic Hotel. I love it but definitely don’t go in June senior week is terrible.

M
Meagan Ploof · January 24, 2026

I had to stop after the “this land is your land” bit, because I actually said the same thing in my head as Jimmie. Now I have that song stuck in my head. 😆

L
Lizzy J · January 24, 2026

This case has horrified me for years on every show it’s ever been on, but you boys made it actually enjoyable! Well done! 🤣 Also, congrats again on Netflix! I’ll be excited to watch you every Monday. 💀

H
Hannah · January 24, 2026

i know brian schaffer isn’t a small town murder but you should do it as a bonus for the 20 year anniversary

J
John Keeton · January 24, 2026

This broad was carrying a hand cannon.

C
Collin · January 24, 2026

I live somewhat close to Altoona PA and have never heard of this! Wild stuff

M
Mary · January 24, 2026

So, I’m at the 3H‘s, Hooters, Hitler, and… crap. BUT I wonder if his wearing of improper insignia or whatever that was one of the charges that got him cut loose from the Navy, I bet it was Nazi. Not only was he a white supremacist, and a Nazi, but he did something to really embarrass the military in regards to uniform, would be my guess.

C
Carl · January 24, 2026

Right away I remembered this story from an ep of forensic files. Crazy story

R
Rich Ferguson · January 24, 2026

Yep

L
Lisa Tucker · January 24, 2026

Amazing episode! I remember this story from Snapped: Killer Couples. You provided much more details.

K
Kellie Gillespie · January 24, 2026

I’m dying🤣 one of my best friends is named Brett Justin, but grew up being called “BJ.” Everyone now calls him Brett, but he will always be “Beejster,” to me😆

A
Anna K · January 24, 2026

Wait what’s going on in Houston??

E
Em · January 24, 2026

Girrrrrrrrl. Google "Houston canals" 😳

J
JoBu · January 24, 2026

A good friend of mine worked in corrections in Ocean City during this time. He had to watch over them while on shift

C
Christine Kitchen · January 24, 2026

I go to OCMD every year since I was a child and couldn't believe when this happened! Total WTF moments and places I've been to and know. Crazy ass story.

A
Austin Ozment · January 24, 2026

Can’t wait for Monday shows!

L
LaTanya · January 24, 2026

“Is your land?” 🤣 I almost feel off my seat.

A
Alicia · January 24, 2026

How much do you want to bet the unauthorized insignia that helped get him kicked out of the navy was a nazi symbol

C
Cher Strong (#localweedia) · January 24, 2026

In the car in a hotel parking lot ready to embark to home. And this nice new car trip episode appears. This is why life is worth it!

A
Aisling Warren · January 24, 2026

“Is your land”! I said it at the same time Jimmie!

M
Maito King · January 24, 2026

The most Military marriage ever, I met a girl and married her immediately

C
Colin Burke · January 24, 2026

I was 17 for about 1/2 of 1998 and I gotta say 17 year old me would’ve been all about that show! Congrats on Netflix guys!!!

D
Donnie King · January 24, 2026

All I could picture was BJ Hunnicut from M*A*S*H commiting these crimes.

M
Manj Sangha · January 24, 2026

Shut up and give me Netflix! Yaaay and chooo chooo

Z
Zach Hollander · January 24, 2026

NEIN!!!!!!!!!

G
Gabie Mahlmann · January 24, 2026

All I could hear is Judy from Righteous Gemstones saying “beej”

E
Erika Fultz · January 24, 2026

My parents were engaged after 2 weeks, but did wait 5 months to get married. They celebrated their 50th anniversary in December

C
Carol King · January 24, 2026

Fort Chaffee, Fort Smith, Arkansas used to be a base for all military including Navy but now it is just used for a national guard training base. I lived out there for a while and I remember they closed it down for a while and that’s probably when they switched it over to a National Guard training base.

E
Erika Fultz · January 24, 2026

Fwiw, spelling Erika with a k IS the proper way to spell it... 🤣 Also, my son's father's initials are BJ. I refused to name our son anything starting with a B or any name that's slang for penis. We went with Ian.

M
Michele Kiggins · January 24, 2026

My parents moved to Boston after knowing each other 4 weeks. They were married for 57 years

J
Jen Sullivan · January 24, 2026

So excited to hear this episode! I grew up going to Ocean City and still go as an adult with my own kids. We were just at Ocean’s Calling festival this summer!

T
Tracy Poetz · January 24, 2026

So the podcast is gonna be on Netflix every Monday? 🤣🤣🤣

R
Richard · January 24, 2026

So every Monday?

C
Casey A · January 24, 2026

i didn’t even know bj was a shorthand for benjamin but BEEJ?!

J
JoBu · January 24, 2026

The Beej has many meanings

K
Kristi B Green · January 24, 2026

Another hometown story for me! I spent many summers in OC: M.R. Ducks, Dumsers, Thrashers and sooo many seagulls. It got progressively more trashy from the 80s through the early 2000's.

C
Claudia Katrosh · January 24, 2026

Having been a senior at senior week, Jimmie is right, it’s a nightmare 🤣

A
Amber Tomlinson · January 24, 2026

Yay! So excited for this story! It's a wild one! 😁