Serial Killer Desires - Waterford, Connecticut
This week, in Waterford, Connecticut, the bodies of multiple women are placed on rural streets & posed, in a certain way, while having the exact same cause of death. Detectives are pretty sure that it's the same killer, possibly a serial killer, but finding that killer isn't so easy. The case goes cold, until a seemingly minor incident eventually leads to a most horrid, and cold blooded killer! How many more bodies could there be?
Along the way, we find out that line dancing is more of a choreographed sport, than actual dancing, that people from entirely different backgrounds, and entirely different minds can end up in the same exact place, and that some terrible people just take after their fathers!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
instagram.com/smalltownmurder
facebook.com/smalltownpod
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (97)
Prozac is like fire. “It will either save you or fuck you up”! As someone who has had bad side effects to many anti depressants and finally found the right ones, this is the most accurate description of all time!
Renee reminds me of a family member who has similar qualities, not musically, but manipulative and could talk to anyone. Could get men to do things for her without really giving anything away of herself. One of her talents was shoplifting. She could walk into a store, take something, and walk out...never got caught. No one ever gave her a second look. It was quite something to observe.
Love you guys. 5 stars. Anyone who gives you a negative review, I think they forget YOU ARE COMEDIANS!
Crack was never cool
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
"every form of refuge has it's price" Good Eagles line from Lyin Eyes.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DSafQJ0j_Sp/?igsh=ejd0NjFtd2RocXdi Crack, it's clean and gives you a lot of energy. You can get so much done 👍🏽
I def tried to kill myself twice on prozac, so i hear ya, Jimmie!!! Bad fire over here! 🤣🤣🤣
I had a dr tell me that prozac can either make you feel great or make you feel like you want to shoot yourself. This was as he was writing the script out!! 😂
i’m not advocating the use of hard drugs, but i know a lot of people who use meth, or fentanyl, or even crack, and go to work and handle their lives. they take care of their hygiene. they have relationships. basically, a person who has a predisposition to being a shithead, and also uses drugs, may be exacerbating their shittiness. but a “responsible” adult who does the drug, and doesn’t let the drug do them, has no reason to be grouped with the others, in my opinion.
You guys should do a bonus on the Kensington YouTube feed. I grew up there until I moved to California when I was 15. I would hear from childhood friends and family through the years that the neighborhood was getting worse and worse but I used to be 12 years old in ‘88 walking around Frankfort Ave to Kensington Ave after dark and there was no issues. I sat and watched those videos for hours one day and was just numb.
I can't believe James missed a deadwood reference lol the whore telling the young whore she has to feel the shift is Cys (bella union) main girl Talking to Kristin Bells character.
i feel like Renee's intelligence & gifts were a curse to her, not a blessing. What a shame this happened to her.
I am pouring one out today for the Homie Renée. She seemed like a totally legit person so just got caught up with bad stuff.
I don’t usually leave comments, but as a longtime listener, I just wanted to give credit where it is due: this is one of the best episodes/coverage of a case you guys have ever done, thank you!
I appreciate all the care given to the victims on this one. A little embarrassed to say I was really hoping Renee was the murderer and not the victim, but as soon as the sex work angle came in I saw where it was going. Also, I grew up in CT. "Risk of Injury To a Minor" is typically what a perp is charged with in lieu of attempted rape or a hard to prove sexual assault of a minor... Don't ask me how I know.
Talk about hoe-flation, $20 for sex?! You cant get a bitch to even look at it for less than $50...I heard
"chad" checks out
Outstanding level of information on Renee. Really great episode
I worked at the mall in HS. Selling CDs and anime porn at FYE. I have so many stories.
This was well done, good job James. As sad as it was, I appreciate that this was Renee’s story
Jay Z was 22 in April 1992 😳
This has actually blown my mind
I thanked Dan Cummins for dropping a great episode on NYD. Let me thank you two knuckleheads for the same. You guys work too hard!
There are 73 fucking comments in one day? Holy Shit!
I mean no disrespect to the victims, but I’ve honestly told my husband that if I was ever found dead, and most of me or my clothing was missing, the one thing you’d still find on me was a hair tie on my wrist. 🤣 That’s like girl with long hair 101.
Good one, Guys!!!
Share a Coke with Renee
Middle class? Wouldn’t they be working class?
Cynical asshole on coke? That's Dennis Leary
I want to start a band called "Lisa KNOWS"
Prozac saved my mental health for sure but it gives me the absolutely wildest dreams
My 1995 Toyota 4Runner would violently shake if you went over 60 and got like 2 miles to the gallon 😂
I actually have been hit by a van that was behind me and I'm partially deaf so I couldn't hear it coming lol...... Coworker was texting and driving. Shattered my leg from the knee down. I couldn't walk for a year. My foot is now screwed onto my leg. I wish I could have jumped out of the way haha.
You can totally shoot crack. You break it down with citric acid....just saying lol
Lemon juice works well... Or so I've been told.
lol “friendship on a stick” and “onion honey” band names hahaha
love the show. this episode especially good detail. comprehensive
The Cartells are the best!! Played my wedding and did an amazing job. Karen is amazing. 😂 Also, it’s technically NL, but you can get wings and pies after 11 pm if you really need it… 😬
Literally love you guys - you pronounced my last name correctly!!
The company i work for was sub contracted to do the electrical work on a long house in Washington state!
Considering it is the Northeast the town name Waterford could have come from the town and county in Ireland, Waterford here is an old port town so people may have left from here for America, also famously Frederick Douglas lived there when he was living abroard.
Sac is nearly sold out. My wife got me tickets for Christmas and had to get a table 🤷♂️
Damn. In another life, with earlier intervention and if she'd been more invested in therapy, Renee could've been a senator. Like Jimmie said: what a waste. There's a lot she could've done. Drugs, man.
Repping my home state 😍 RI
Same here!
Imagine your daughter tells you it's liberation to suck cock in Vegas because she's getting paid more than the average hooker
James, I work in higher education and, based on your research skills, I can confidently say you that you have the innate skill to have earned a PhD. Fortunately for us, you’ve put those skills to more effective use. This episode underscores how much environment dictates life trajectory. Her poor mother tried so hard. Happy New Year, James and Jimmie!
Happy New Year all! And thank you James and Jimmie for an episode on New years when I’m bored and sad
Happy New Year! Please don’t be sad, I’m sending you a big warm hug 🤗 💜
Ha! Kill one and stop? Okay. But kill 2? Maybe he's just making sure he doesn't like it, then stops. Maybe? 😁🤣
Happy New Year all !!!
Happy New Year!🎈
Sup Turkeys? Haven’t heard this episode, from the Fellas! yet, just want to wish everyone a Happy And Prosperous NewYear!! And keeping away from ICE and all the other government thugs out there. Keep up the bangers Fellas!! & (🖕🏾🧊)
🖕🏻🧊
Okay but imagine if "I Petty the Fool" did Tom Petty covers dressed as/in the style of Mr. T
Yes! This is the collab we need! 😂😂
This was a good way weird episode. I hope you guys have a wonderful new year. Thank you so much for all that you do oh and the instruments that was funny. I never could play an instrument either so I get it. It would’ve been nice to be able to just pick up anything and play it. I love music but not musical. My son tries to play the guitar tries, but at least he gives it a shot, and I do have another son that could play the piano by ear, but he never did it. I picked up on it when we had an Oregan once and he would sit down in front of it and start playing It, but he has OCD and he just couldn’t stick with it. You’d think with that that he would’ve stuck with it. He even bought himself a keyboard never really used it.
Love that you guys came though on New Year’s when I’m bored as hell and every other podcast I listen to is off.
I loved J&J in this episode. They seemed pretty relaxed. The chats about the instruments, "without the san", Volvo, smart people lol loved the chill vibe to start the year.
This episode was incredible. It really highlighted the often-overlooked phenomenon of sonder.. the realization that every person has a life as complex and meaningful as our own. Getting to know the victim so deeply before the crime was especially powerful; we rarely get that perspective, and it made the story really human and impactful.
Thank you James for taking the time to tell the victim’s story—Renee—in such an in depth manner. Fascinating and tragic.
It’s always warming how the fellas treat the people as humans, and not fodder for entertainment 🌈
“I’m the one who’s always picking up the used condoms.” 🤮🤮🤮🤮
Does anyone think Renee seemed cool at *any* point? She seemed like an insufferable twat since the beginning. E: oh... she ended up being the murder victim. Now I'm the dick lol
Spoiler 🚨 Alert… lol 👍🏾
The eating crack scenario took my breath away! Always something insane…
Sounds like trauma and a frustrated genius. In 1973, opportunities for women were more limited. She couldn’t apply for credit until 1974. I mean she had home economics in high school instead of engineering. I’d be pissed too.
I smoked crack for 13 years. You cannot snort crack. It only gets you high when its smoked the smoke isWhat gets you high
I know John Pellegrino too, lol actually, I know a ton of Pellegrino’s
Shit you not, my dad just bought my step-mom a Volvo because of how many accidents they hear about, including one where a car went into a house. I had to gently tell him that even a Volvo isn’t going to win against a house.
Tragic. Intellectual intelligence is not enough without emotional intelligence. So sad.
Thank you for our N.Y episode ❤️ 🙏
Gotta get a peek at this lady. She seemed like a smoke show
Only time I have almost gotten hit by a car was when I car tried to right on red when I had a ped crossing light. It almost crashing into me until I yelled to stop and calling him an asshole
Happy new year :) Much appreciate that you’ve kept giving us new episodes of all your podcasts throughout the holidays! As someone who haven’t celebrated the holidays they’ve helped cheer me up, comedy and murder DO belong together!
Pretty boring episode. Still love the show! Just a weak one today.
Love how you presented this story!
Love your last name 😁
I got hit by a drunk driving ice cream truck. She blow the stop sign. My best friend was like you got nailed you suck. They paid my med bills. I was fine overall.
Did you at least get a Drumstick?
Thank you ♥️ appreciate you both so much ♥️
I live in Waterford CT and this one is a doozy!! You guys are awesome and my son loved the tickets to Tarrytown for Xmas!
Okay, new content on NYE?? We are horribly spoiled! I’m not a huge fan of this holiday, so putting on my noise-canceling earbuds and getting into a crazy story is the best. Thanks to the moon, you guys. Best to all of you guys in 2026 🎉
New year new MURDER. Wooooooooooooooooo
Happy new year a great way too start the new year good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie keep up the good work
It’s 1:00 AM and I need to get to bed, but I made the mistake of looking at my phone and seeing that you dropped an episode for a town that’s 20 miles from me. You, sleep, may fuck off.
Bring back political stats.
I’m an hour and forty-two minutes in… Is there a murder in this episode?
Welp, keep listening and then you might see the
Talking about getting hit by cars, brought up some past methy moments of my life. I've been hit by two trucks and one Tokyo Drift wannabe Honda. The trucks stopped but once I stood up they drove off. Can't blame them if you are in the middle of a back road walking around two in the morning. With a flashlight and book bag on anything that happens is kinda your fault I say, but nothing was broke soooo that was a win lol
New Year’s Eve and small town murder! A dream come true ❤️
Can't possibly thank you enough for continuing to drop episodes through the holidays! Total respect for people's choices either way, but as someone who can't get out much, it is SO NICE to have a new episode to listen to on a holiday at home!
Hell yeah!!
Nothing says new years like murder!
Yayyyyyyy
Yayyyyy Jeremy, yayyyy indeed!
