Suitcases Full Of Murder - Woodbridge Township, New Jersey
This week, in Woodbridge Township, New Jersey, several matching suitcases found in different places, all contain body parts that add to a a whole person. This leads to an investigation that reveals a shady spouse, some of the most incriminating internet searches ever typed, and one of the most brutal & senseless murders possible. Will anyone be held responsible??
Along the way, we find out that local radio DJs aren't the greatest live performers for a festival, that you should always assume that your internet searches will be read into a court record, some day, and that fake alibis sometimes come back to haunt you!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
instagram.com/smalltownmurder
facebook.com/smalltownpod
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (116)
in nursing school we were told to call patients clients because it gave them autonomy…….. so stupid
Waiting with bated breath for James to say "black trashtic plasbags"
I studied pure math and clin. Psych simultaneously, then became a nurse. 😅💀
Also, inaccurate uses of 'passed away' drive me fucking crazy. Thank you guys for validating me 😆
Best forensic sketch artist EVER! Someone deserves a raise.
He served on the ship my grandfather did! My Grandfather was a Captain, and the third in command on that ship. He might have been bossed around by my Grandfather, lol!
I was shaking my head when James said the poor fisherman had to wait over 45 mins with dismembered body parts on his boat & getting the run around by the police. My dad is an in shore salt water fisherman down in here in the Tampa Bay (the guys' favorite place 😅) & 2 years ago he found a DEAD BODY floating along the shore near the mangroves. The poor man must've drown. My dad called the coast guard but was told their shift wouldn't start for another 2 hours (it was early AM like 6 or 7) & to call the local police. Police gave him the runaround but finally said someone was on their way & requested my dad tie up the body to his boat. My dad straight up refused, citing that this could be foul play & that he wasn't going to touch the body. They took like an hour to show up & my dad was driving circles around the body trying to keep it between his boat & the mangroves preventing it from being washed out to see. Crazy how unresponsive law enforcement is. I guess cus they're already dead? So whats the rush? 🤦♀️
I could hear James fighting for his life every time he said “black plastic trash bags” 😂
I am watching a Netflix movie on this! I knew I heard this story before!
I just watched the stupidest movie based on this case and it made me angry! Whoever produced it clearly was on her side left so many details out...i started not knowing it was the same story then I was like wait a minute! It didn't come close to telling the story they way you guys did.
I was eating pistachio pudding when the description of the green and yellow bruised flesh came up. I will never be the same.
Hey out there in podcast world.... Did the guys receive their package I sent? Thanks just checking ( I know, should have sent it signature required...) 😘🤗
We are not related lol wow!! my first name is Arena. But I live that I got to hear Jimmy say it a bunch of times
Thank you for mentioning that you’ve done this at lives shows! I kneeeewww their picture was familiar and as the story was going on I’m like “I know this but how!” 😅
Wasn't this the one they did in Pittsburgh and Columbus?
As an RN, I'm horrified by how unethical, unprofessional, and just plain wrong she was a nurse. Obviously horrified by the murder, but sleeping with a married doctor---girl you're the worst cliche ever.
6:30 best town, on this 3 mile distance
They lined the shower so no DNA stuff would go down the drain. Where did all the blood go?
The Chesapeake Bay Bridge Tunnel is built as bridges and tunnels to protect the Navy Fleet. If it were only a bridge and there was a bridge failure, the fleet would be unable to make open waters.
Was this a Forensic Files? There is definitely a trash bag episode of FF.
https://www.reddit.com?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android_app&utm_name=androidcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=2 I thought for Sure it would be morbid. Here's the reddit thread he referenced.
I live in Virginia Beach!!! I love me a good bridge/tunnel drive! 🤣
This jersey girl loves when you cover a New Jersey story
Saw this in Columbus last February. Was a great show and crazy story. This is an AMAZING longer version, and thank you James for not showing pictures of the "slippage"......
So I watched the 20/20 episode on this case (The Secret in the Suitcase on YouTube if any of you want to check it out), and those two podcasters baffled me.
I listened to Direct Appeal, and was convinced that Melanie McGuire was a tortured victim in this story. Thank you, J&J, for laying down the insurmattable evidence. She manipulated everyone by the end of it, including those podcasters.
I didn't listen to this until after Xmas...but I was making dinner 🍽️😂
Joe Tacopena represented a bigger scumbag recently too didn't he?
Love when it’s my state.
So the Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel is way stranger than James makes it out to be. I moved to Hampton Roads about 2 years ago, they actually have 3 of those bridge-tunnels around the bay, the CBBT is just the biggest of them. They do go underwater in the middle of the bay for about a quarter of a mile, and the CBBT does it twice! If VDOT had their way, they would all be bridges to save money compared to a tunnel. But because Naval Station Norfolk is inside the bay, the Navy was worried that a bridge span could be bombed by enemy forces, isolating the majority of the US Atlantic fleet inside the Chesapeake Bay (sort of like what happened in Baltimore a few years ago when the Key Bridge got rammed by a ship and collapsed into the harbor). So the bridge tunnels were a compromise to keep costs low without potentially sealing off access to the ocean. Although nowadays they're mostly known for scaring tourists driving through and the neat quirk of causing daily rushhour traffic jams under the Chesapeake Bay lol
I’ve been a paramedic for 18 years and have seen some nasty shit. The description of his body made me cringe 🤢
Saw this live in Philly, and I have to say it is INCREDIBLY impressive how well you guys adapt to a shorter or longer format ❤️ Thanks for another insane year, and hoping for many more to come!
Merry Xmas everyone!
New way of spreading the love lol...
I love the old timey stuff ,but am intrigued by the mall collapse
The bridge tunnel is because of the naval bases and other piers so ships can get in and out and cars can still get around too. As a member of the navy I can tell you I cant think of many drawbridges that are tall enough to allow an aircraft carrier to clear under it.
I grew up in Virginia Beach and moved away 15 years ago and do NOT miss ANY of those tunnels 😅 they stressed me out!!
Good one, you guys! Thank you and Merry Christmas/day-off to you and your loved ones 🌲
Saw this episode in Portland Oregon. Awesome show!!
Won’t play at all
Anyone else in the uk having problems with this episode. Won’t all. It’s an ongoing issue here
Plays fine in the West Midlands.
Merry christmas!! 🎄
Saw this in Saint Louis, fantastic show. Fuck Elon forever!
I'm not terribly impressionable, but that pic needed a trigger warning 😅
justice for us school haters hahaha ✊
Merry Christmas 🎄 I can’t believe James didn’t say trashtic plash bags even once!!
I pay extra attention when he starts to say it hoping he says it backwards again lol
Merry Christmas!
Was this the St. Louis show? I know I heard the ovaries/raisins quote before
Wooooooooooooooooo
Merry Christmas !
The podcast they are referencing is Direct Appeal. You're welcome. Love the show James and Jimmie!
lol came to the comments just for this 😂
Merry Christmas to everyone! ⛄️🎄
Thanks for posting! Some of us don’t have people to celebrate with, and no one posts anything!
Every time I hear James say "black plastic trashbags" I can practically hear the gears turning in his brain making damn sure he doesn't say "black trastic plasbags."
This is the only way we say it in our house now
Merry Christmas 🎄 turkeys!🦃
Merry Suitcase Fishing, everyone!
My parents did the same, they have married each other three times (so far).
Maybe it’s a generational thing. After like 20 years of marriage, my aunt and uncle got divorced and then dated each other for years. Maybe a divorce brings the love back to the relationship??? Idk. Adult humans are weird.
Merry Xmas and Old Timey Criming!!🎄🎁
Merry Christmas Assholes!💜
🦃
Please do old timey crimes again soon, since it will probably lose this time!
I need to know what the shitty podcast is that covered this 😂
Same, I *must* know!
Awesome, this was from the San Diego live show this year
Merry Christmas! 🦃
Merry Christmas everyone ❤️
Merry Christmas to all
Merry Christmas! Old timey crime please. 🎅🎁🎄
Merry Christmas! Peeling potatoes for my au gratin taters and learning about skin slippage 🤶🎅🏻🎄🤣
🤣🤣🤣
5 stars
I just realized I know this story from one of the many True Crime shows I watch.
What show? The picture looks so familiar to me.
🎅 🦃 , ⏳️ 🔪
Merry Christmas from sunny Australia.
we roasted in Brisbane until the inevitable Christmas Day storms came through to slightly lower the humidity!
Old Timey Crimes! Thanks!!
Thank you for the drop— this is my antidote against It’s a Wonderful Life! Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!
Merry Christmas
“People in the medical profession don’t speak that way” lmaoooo yes we do
You guys are the best! So lovely to wake up this Christmas morning and see an episode released! Merry Christmas!
Merry Christmas! What a lovely surprise (is a sentence i just said about a murder story)
Old timey crimes! Love you guys! 🎄
Merry Christmas from dumptown USA Rochester NY!! From mine to yours. I hope your year treats you well 🙏🏾💪🏾🫶🏾
Merry Christmas from a very hot, sunny Cape Town! 🌞🎄🎁
Merry Christmas!!! Thank you so much for all your amazing work.
Hey. Patreon has become awful. I'm kind of okay to support you as I have for years but as a subscriber patreon has become vile so you might be one I purge. Tell patreon I just want to see what I subscribe to.
Thank you!!! Patreon is awful.
Old Time Crimes! And Merry Christmas, you handsome fuckers.
Happy holidays turkeys 🦃🕯️🖤🎁🕊️☃️🍾
Huh??? She’s got Manson Lamps 👁️👁️
They were such a pretty couple. Murder can happen to anyone.
Merry Christmas James and Jimmie! I am so happy that there is an episode for Christmas. I am alone for the holiday so this is the one bright spot. 🎄🎁🎅🎉
Same here! Merry Christmas! 🎄
I asked Google what a toxic amount of sugar is. I was shown that I cannot be told, because it could be used to harm someone.
Merry Christmas everyone. Best podcast on the planet. Hope everyone has a great holiday.
Merry Christmas all! 🎄🎅
Merry Christmas, Guys. Thank you for taking the time to make this for us during the holiday. I’m sure i speak for thousands why i say, don’t know what id do without your work. Thanks boys
Thanks turkeys for releasing an episode today! What a gift all of you are. See ya in Sac!
Merry Christmas everyone! Hopefully my package i sent to the guys arrived in time 😁
Very little I enjoy more than a new episode of STM to carry me into Christmas Day. Merry Christmas guys and thank you for all you do!
It's a Christmas miracle!! Thanks for working so hard! Yippee
A wonderful drop on Christmas Eve. You guys work so fecken' hard! Many thanks & Happy Christmas 🎄
Merry Christmas!
Hooray! Happy Christmas! Get down Panhandle Style!
There is no better gift than being able to listen to STM and wrap presents while enjoying some wine. Cheers and Merry Christmas!
Merry Christmas y’all
The CBBT has the tunnels so ships and boats can travel the area without draw bridges. I’ve been over it dozens of times.
Merry Christmas you turkeys and also to ant Type O Negative listeners
THANK YOU!!! MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!
Merry Christmas everyone 🎄🎅
