Surprising Serial Killer - Carmel, Maine
This week, in Carmel, Maine: a woman vanishes, after spending a day with her family, leading detectives to a suspect, who has a history of being around women, who come up missing. This includes his wife, who has been missing for years. As it turns out, there are even more women that went missing, after spending time with this man. In the end, some very strange facts force him to fully confess, and lead police to his secrect serial killer graveyard!!
Along the way, we find out that Maine's Supreme Court features a member, who is actually a beaver, that the "she must've ran away with a trucker" excuse won't work with every woman you know, and that it may be more preferable to be in prison, in Masin, than free, in Texas!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (77)
My name is Edward. And.... I'm a JR.
.zz.
I did a parade and we were the ONLY ones who listened and didn’t throw the candy . So we seemed like the idiots 😂
This is down the street and my friends know these people!!
😱
I used to work in a grocery store in a small town, and four different men (at different times) waited outside the store until my shift ended and then followed me home. All because I told them to have a nice day. And the reaction from other people was just, “Eh, he’s harmless.” Small towns are amazing.
Hey my own son tried like hell to take me out with dum-dums from a parade float lol thankfully they're was no small children standing by me
Edward is an excellent name guys. 🦊
Lettuce isn't normally funny. But he said Rome, Maine and I even laughed at that
Love the gta reference. Totally Trevor
I’ve never heard this story. Wild!! I feel sorry for the kids who lost their moms. Such a sick bastard.
Ordered tickets to the live show in Medford while listening. Got the best seat available. Now I have to rewind this… (can’t wait to see you next November!)
Random question- when does Jimmie announce people's names from Patreon? Is it like shortly after you subscribe? My husband and I always turn off the episode once the case is done, but would like to find the episode with our name announced.
Yes, they do it to close out the show.
No, no, James. It's three lumberjacks, a jet ski, a badger, Mrs. Butterworth, a lobster and a moose.
All due respect, but its pronounced "Bang Gor". Banger drives us Mainahs nuts. Love your stuff!!
Thank you! Lol! I grew up across the bridge in Brewer and was like WTF
3 lumberjacks, a jet ski, and a badger. I NEED this on a hoodie.
When I was a kid, my family often rode our horses in our areas parades. When I was about 12, my younger brother was also riding and we were tossing candy to kids. My brother ended up beaning a little girl in the forehead with a mini Tootsie roll! 🤣🤣
No body? Likely because of a crime.
Please please PLEASE do whatever is necessary to ensure y’all don’t get too burned out and become “over it”! I can’t even count how many different podcasts I rotate, but every single one of them is genuinely only there to occupy my time from one of your episodes to the next. You two and STM are what started my love of podcasts so many years ago. We will be right here waiting for you once you’re refreshed and ready! Please just never go away 😭 my heart wouldn’t take it
“Bang-gor” lol. I know it makes no sense. And everyone says “Bang-er” with that slight, actual O. I grew up in NH and the state capital, Concord is not “Con-cord” like the jet, it’s Con-cahd. A very different accent than Maine. Love you guys! You will have to do the story about the poisoning in the church coffee story in Maine. That was crazy shit! I’ll send you the deets.
I lived in this area for 15 years. I have been yelling town name pronunciations and laughing at their valiant efforts. Carmel is best pronounced cah-mul. Love every single episode of every podcast. If anyone deserves a break, it’s James (Sarah, too) and Jimmie.
Another excellent episode. I love listening.
I worked at GM with a guy whose last name was Cyr... crazy!
I went to high school with a guy named Joey Zamboni in Texas.
I'm a school bus driver listening to the podcast when you mention where Jenny and James met.
There’s a reason I don’t go by my first name!!! I’m not a secretary
In the past you talked about retiring and opening a comedy club in Maine. The name Laughing Lobster came to mind. 😁
My mom's name was Phyllis (born 1920) and I always wondered how you look at a baby and think "Phyllis" unless a Phillip wanted a son
I thoroughly enjoy listening to you two on all of your shows, but nothing makes me smile as much as a Funny Farm reference. It’s always on my December must-watch list, even though I love it any time of year.
As a lifelong hockey player, and former zamboni driver, joey zamboni is the greatest name ever.
Wooooooooooooooooo
Sir, you are inbreeded. 🤪🫶🏼
The word "body" in "no body, no crime" means a body of evidence... Great episode as always!
After recently getting into Stephen king books it’s so funny to hear all these places prominently featured in his books
Carmel —CAR-mull— in Indiana too
Piling on....y'all need a break! STM CIS & YSO are my only media and I constantly feel spoiled. James...go getcha holiday smelts and relax bro. Xxoo
Please don't burn yourselves out guys! You deserve a break! You could do some batch recording to avoid lag in content if you feel that is absolutely necessary. I feel like your loyal fan base would totally understand the need for some time off.
Well said! The boys deserve a break.
So, how many women did he allegedly kill? I couldn't keep track.
My dad's name is Arthur! LOL and his besties were Albert and Stanley. I've never wrapped my brain around naming a baby Rocco. No offense intended.
driving through carmel today! love the maine episodes!
The weirdest part of this episode is making that old lady drink cough syrup.
not the middle aged man knocking up 18 year olds?
I know you don’t need anyone’s permission, and that’s not what this is. If you guys need a break please take one. You have a strong and loyal fan base, lots of back catalog episodes to binge. I feel like I can speak for a large percentage of your followers that we genuinely care about you two and want you to take care of yourselves. I know you’re going on tour again but please consider taking a vacation too. With all the love, I can hear that you are being worn thin and tired. You work so so hard and so much to pump out the episodes. You deserve rest. 🩵
Even if they took, like, 2 weeks off here or there from recording so they can get ahead a little Or did a month off of 1 show in the rotation (no CIS in March, no STM Express in April, no STM in May, no YSO in June), so you get 3 shows instead of 4, etc, that'd be MORE than fine (since I think they'd feel bad for taking a break from everything)
There is footage from Dick Stacey's Country Jamboree on youtube. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/dick-stacey-country-jamboree-obit-1.6617014#:~:text=Stacey's%20Country%20Jamboree%20was%20videotaped,staceyscountryjamboree.com https://youtu.be/5AnMQFycJKw?si=vGlXx9cXVJzmB4WO
What a story Mark.
Just bought our tickets to the Nashville live show !! I can’t freaking wait !!!!
Listening from Maine, wearing a flannel
Wish you both would come to Australia and do a show. You know we exaggerate about dangerous animals. Our cities are the same as yours except the weather and beaches are gorgeous.
Don't tell them that. Our cities are filled with man-eating spiders, snakes that can kill you from across the road ... But you wont get bitten by a shark in the north. Because the crocodiles eat them all...
Boom! Shoutout! Thanks lads - get a dog up ya!
What a story! As always! You tell the stories so well Jimmie and James. Thank you ... To my top podcast for 2025 hehehe
Spotify wrap up? Me too! 🤣
The physical incarnation of whittling! Brilliant! I want to go to there 💕
This thing took a WILD TURN!!…Same M.O…Same M.O…Same M.O… ‘Older woman stick-up’ outta nowhere!!..seems like he was tired of running…thank fuck
I've heard this story before. Sad
I live in a three bed two bath single wide trailer lol 1650 a month haha
1650?!?!?!? Omg my guy
It doesn’t sound like that penny in the shoe brought much good luck to her
Linda's unite! We were a baby named Linda once 🤣🤣.
It means beautiful!!!!
Inbreeded? Haha! Maybe they meant to type ‘inebriated’?? 😭😭
Finally a jerilyn 😆
John Mellencamp never chose “Cougar,” the powers that be made that decision .
Hi fellow Lynda/Linda!
The way I’ve been refreshing my feed so much the last 3 hours
Wednesday is my favorite day of the week
Love this damn show
Also hi Jimmie if you see this
Ugh god thank you I was about to commit domestic violence because I was so bored but now I’m not 💋
🤣🤣🤣 relatable
Let's go on a trip!!
YAAAAAAAAYYYY!!!
Yay indeed
