My Ugly Came Out - Selmer, Tennessee
This week, in Selmer, Tennessee, when a Pastor is horribly murdered, in his own bedroom, detectives scramble to locate his wife, and three little girls, who the police assume have been kidnapped by a murderers. Police are very surprised to find all of them, taking a little beach vacation. When they find they murder weapon, in her trunk, things become more clear. Or, do they? She says that she did do the killing, but for a very good reason. Will it hold up in front of a jury?
Along the way, we find out that rockabilly events & hot rod shows go hand in hand, that Pastors move around the country like morning radio DJs, and that choosing a jury may the most important part of some criminal cases!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (101)
As someone from a tiny Appalachian town, I am laughing at their utter bewilderment as to how "selma" could become "selmer" and the scope of weird cultishness that permeates this area's Christianity. This here area is hell and I'm jealous that James and Jimmie are so unaccustomed to it
And on that note, the alleged abuse surprises me 0% and I fully believe Mary's claims... I do not want to ever sympathize with murderers, but I know how this breed of man can be. They use the Bible as justification to utterly own, belittle, humiliate, and abuse their wives, expecting them to be chaste and invisible in everyday life and then become comfort women in the home. I just recently visited my grandparents and witnessed my grandpa snapping his fingers at my grandma and then getting mad when she didn't immediately come to him like a dog, remarking that she "usually behaves"... again, murder isn't okay, but I can entirely understand how a woman in that position might just say "fuck it" and end that shit in the most drastic way possible. I mean, shit, if your abusive husband refuses to get divorced for his own reputation, what else are you gonna do? Again, I am going off Mary's story, and I know that I shouldn't take a murderer's word at face value, but being from a similar environment? I get it
This town sounds like its in a cult......
La feet is next to La ankle
https://youtu.be/4MjgbTM8SJc?si=Pp07Quo2TTjkXBHF I thought I knew this case then remembered that The Drive By Truckers wrote a song about it. Worth a listen.
Also, I have Buford Pusser stories from my Grandparents. Check out the Dixie Mafia. Interesting story.
This is how Small town I am, you have now done 4 towns where I have family.
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
I checked recently if Diane Downs was awarded probation this year and since one of the conditions for this is admitting what you did, she'll never get out.
Given the accent in that area, I guar-damn-tee you they pronounce Selma as "Selmer" and thought that was how it was spelled.
me believing the earth is 10,000 years old 👁️👄👁️ at least i’m 4,000 off from being a moron🤣😭
This just reminds me of my ex and our relationship (don't worry he's still alive) down to the excuse that he just wants me to be better and improve. Constant criticism on top of physical abuse will wear you down.
I live 10 minutes from McMinnville, TN. I remember when Mary started working at the dry cleaners.
How many tweets are they gonna get that Buford Pusser actually killed his wife?
Sahara desert fart fact of the week...The "homestead tax" the reviewer is talking about is a thing. I do think there are a few states that don't have their own version of it. Each state is a bit different. I worked at my county assessors office for 12 years and left due to major burnout and health issues after covid. But, here in KY the exemption (65+ years of age or drawing disability) is good for UP TO a certain amount off your taxable assessment. So if your taxable value is at or below that amount your bill is taken care of...otherwise you pay on the difference.
You just reminded me how much I loved the Sahara Desert Fart Facts!!
“Whatever Eve had” 😭
Interesting story for sure.
Oprah was abused by her own father.
7 days holy Hell
I used to work in the records room at a police station in Massachusetts, in the early 80s, when John's were busted with hookers, unnatural act and soliciting were the charges 😂.
The car that ran into the crowd of people, doing a burnout, must have been a mustang 🤣
Everybody should be licking each other! 🤣🤣🤣
Diane Downs is still in prison. She just had a parole hearing and was denied.
Oh so this is the story about the lady that killed her husband that I wanted y’all to do from my town ( McMinnville, TN) 🤣
I remember seeing her at that dry cleaner place lol
I'm married to a Church of Christ preacher's son. My husband was forced to marry a girl he met after 2 months, he originally went to a Church of Christ college. He has since divorced and left the Cult of Christ. The stories are absolutely wild.
My grandma was Episcopalian and she tried to get me to become religious, but it never made sense to my scientific mind. Still doesn't so people claiming biblical passages MUST be followed/are truth/etc make me fucking cringe.
When I was 4, my I was playing rocket ship with my uncle (sitting across his shins and rocking back and forth) until my giant dome flew forward and collided with my uncle's nose! Blood everywhere, but luckily he was a doctor and could set it himself. 🤭
James is so right about the image consciousness in this Christian cult-like world. My dad and uncle and aunt worked for the same Christian radio station in a small town and I had to be careful of what I did because it might reflect badly on it. I was a child. My mom and I are both out of that world and much happier.
Buford Pusser, of the “Walking Tall” movie franchise, came from there. The movies were set there.
That’s what I get for commenting before listening.
My family also tries to jump into caskets at funerals. I didn't know we were Italian.
Coercive control works like that great CIS quote- 'Its not about making me feel good, its about making you feel bad'. The hairstyle or whatever is irrelevant, its about having the other person submit to your whims and will.
…had even features 😆
The description of this girl being 5'1 and 150lbs is spot on to my life. I was almost 170lbs and no one ever guessed I was more than 135. It just looks different on some of us. I tell people I haven't seen in a while I lost 50lbs and they are gob smacked cause they didn't even realize I had that much to lose!
Officer Greg Duck??? I would love to work with him. All day i would just keep yelling GREG!!! DUCK!!!! Lol
The local joke is call this lawyer. He even got a CoC preacher’s wife off.
Just watched the Oprah interview on YouTube. The glancing up-and-to-the-left is nonstop.
Turned it off after the sentence, one week for cold blooded murder. Wow, if the guy does that, he gets LWOP.
Love this one! Its the parsonage because it belongs to the church...also why the church people thought they just had the right to go in...
James has no idea how right he is about what clergy do behind closed doors. My Dad was a Church of Ireland rector and heard so many weird and horrendous stories about what clergy got up to. Sleeping with parishioners and shoplifting were the most frequent ones.
My mom left her church in the 80s after it came out that the married pastor was sleeping with several married ladies in the congregation.
I just started listening to the intro. Right away I’m thinking “hmmm must be the other local pastor who’s losing membership to the new pastor”
Good guess.
Interesting that typically, when a man has financial problems like Mary did, they're more likely to be "family annihilators", killing their families and running off. John List comes to mind although there are sooo many. The fact that there were numerous people who saw the evidence of physical abuse and (like James said), telling people what was happening would destroy the lives of her and her children. Team Mary all the way!
Beauford Pusser prob killed his wife himself. It's come out this yr that she had signs of domestic violence he shot her, then he shot himself in the cheek. I grew up watching those movies.
Pusser has got to be the most disgusting surnames 🤢🤮
English origin—variation of “purser,” an occupational surname
I just finished an episode of the Podcast, Gone South, the episode was about three Buford Pusser case. What they are saying is. There was no ambush. Buford shot his wife and then shot himself down the road a bit. He survived and became a hero and the town has been celebrating him for the past 40 years. 🤣
I gotta check that out, and yes, this man was so celebrated, especially in the 70s, the archetypal American guy hero, a cultural icon. Oh, the irony!
The fellas need to do Buford Pusser as an episode… could qualify for CIS bc JoeDon Baker. Would be interesting now that Pusser has been exposed as a liar and murderer
Burford Pusser was a pro wrestler in his youth so he definitely qualifies for Crime in Sports
One of the rare times I’ve driven through the town while listening to the podcast about the town.
I’m surprised I grew up in NYC and figured James would know that getting anal sex was “winning the subway series.”
I grew up in Bremerton, WA. From now on it's "Bremington". Also grew up baptist. 🤔🤣
One of Mary’s sister lived next door to me when she was on trial.
I always love an episode a little more when the murdered person sounds like a real dickhead 🤪
Unimportant note toward the start of the story: I'm guessing the book description either says "had even features," or meant to.
Also, as someone who dealt with a LOT of trauma starting pretty much at birth and diagnosed with severe chronic depression (then MDD) at 5: I grew up in various homes with my more responsible parent having a lot of similar approaches to the dad, and my only self worth was(/is) functionality. I did the full "All advanced, tons of groups, multiple jobs early, etc" system, too. It's a form of freeze-flight trauma response. I just crashed and burned myself out after uni/turned on myself, though, which doesn't seem the final direction here
Hello from Modesto, CA.
Waving up at you from Fresno 😂
Another excellent episode.
You guys should do a crime and sports on Buford pusser he wrestled and he probably killed his wife
P PPP ppl lllllr
Oprah Winfrey is an evil person
I will never tire of your MST3K references. 😂
James went all Bill Hicks. Loved it
I could say so much about this, but I’ll keep it short. I grew up in the Church of Christ. I’m gonna write a book someday. Good job on your general analysis of the beliefs, James! You nailed it!
Woooo!!! Modesto!!
I remember this case like it was yesterday. When a talk show here in Nashville had this case as the subject, you wouldn't believe the number of women calling in, taking her side. After the trial, a news station filmed her smoking at a bar with her new boyfriend.🤣
EVERYBODY SHOULD BE LICKING EACH OTHER 😂 World peace shall commence
The GUFFAW I let out when he said that 😂😂😂
A radio DJ friend of mine told me, jokingly that most DJs own their own U-Haul trucks. Lol
Carisi AND Stabler?? Very SVU
Play 2 hours and 9 minutes for about 35 seconds at half speed. I promise you it's worth it
I have family in McMinnville
We have homestead exemption here in Florida. If you’re a resident you get $25,000 off the value of your property for taxes. Saves you a little bit of money.
I thought Selmer was a type of saxophone.
Unfortunately, I grew up near here. Not that you care, but a slugburger is from the civil war era when the south had soy beans and very little meat. So, it’s a mixture of soybeans and pork. They cost a “slug” aka 5c at the time. They actually taste pretty good.
Came here to say this! I'm from just over the MS line and love a slugburger. It's basically just yummy fried meat-flavored dough...okay, that doesn't sound great, but add mustard, pickle, and onion, and you got yourself a meal. 🤣
She was wearing pink, everything was fine!
When my mom was under Hospice care at home the nurses could not understand why none of her family was real sad. We spent 4 days around her reminiscing about wonderful times. My mom had been suffering for years and we all knew she died she would not be in anymore pain.
Sinisterhood is currently doing a 2 parter on Buford Pusser and all his corruption. https://open.spotify.com/episode/1ZjRaC9o9QKSdPnRK283Sd?si=lSFrjJr5TJ2tq1lUTkM0MQ
Another great episode fellas. No one does research like you James.
And Cousin Ian…
The truth is we never know what goes on behind closed doors. My ex was a controlling narcissist who criticized everything about me. Even my hair. Jimmie’s surprise at that made me chuckle too. But I guarantee people that know him would never believe me. But I don’t know if there was abuse or not. Or what really happened that night. I feel terrible for the kids though. I hope they are leading great lives and seeking mental health help
If regular sex is a, “Homerun” maybe anal sex is an, “Inside-the-Park Homerun”? “Inside-the-Dark”??? …I’ll see myself out :)
Oral sex makes your day. .. Anal makes your hole weak
No comment is something that is stated to every question usually (instructed by the lawyer) in order for the police to establish what evidence they have and nlt to incriminate the interviewee, frustrating for sure
Wish James would have mentioned that Buford Pusser most likely killed his wife.
I only know about Buford Pusser because Behind the Bastards did a couple of episodes on him. He definitely killed his wife, shot himself, and used it as an excuse to go after people he didn't like.
Thank you for putting out a new episode when everyone else is doing repeats and some of us want to drown some people out with a good story!!
I came here to say this! Literally every other podcast I follow is doing repeats/best of’s/listener tales this week. As hard as these guys work, I was assuming they’d be taking a much-needed break, but no, they’re the only ones with new content. The must know how badly many of us turkeys need a distraction today!
She got away with murder.
James, I am a Christian, no formal denomination purely because of so much sh!t going on in the "church" at times... And I wish more religious (or whatever) people would have your insight into how to read or interpret the Bible! The whole 6000 yr thing, taking every single thing literally... I'm on your debate team, any day! 😉❣️
James...I LOVE YOU!!! Warms my heart to know you are a MSTie. I prefer Mike over Joel, even tho Joel is good in his own way. Pluto has its own MST3K and Rifftrax channels. I watch them both almost every day
Me too. I geek out every time he makes a MST3K reference.
Let go on a trip, shall we?
I live super close to Selmer 🥴🙃
Straight TERRIFYING when you see your town pop up! Lol!
