💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
A Deadly Blame Game - Pierre, South Dakota (1 of 2)
November 22, 2025

A Deadly Blame Game - Pierre, South Dakota

This week, in Pierre, South Dakota, an affair turns in to a need for a divorce, which leads to a woman, disappearing. She leaves her phone, purse & car, but she's nowhere to be found. Detectives look to her new boyfriend, but eventually blame the husband, claiming it was a brutal act of jealousy, but he has someone else to blame... their 12-year-old daughter. Did she kill her mother, in some kind of trance? Or did he try to cast blame on anyone and everyone?

Along the way, we find out that 10 AM is not the time slot that you want for your band, during a festival, that some people are apparently only attracted to only retail managers, and that blaming your tiny daughter for a brutal murder might not be the best trial strategy!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (49)

D
Davey Boy. · January 7, 2026

You should really check out Marious Gustavson..the eunach maker. Awesome episode for you guys to create. Check it lads...✌️

B
Baxter the Dog · December 31, 2025

Isn’t struggle Jennings in the wonderful whites of West Virginia documentary? I’d think James would know that with how much he loves that doc

C
ChristineLikeTheCarThatKilledPeople · November 29, 2025

I work with a Spaniard whose first name is spelled Pier and pronounced Pierre 😅

R
Riley · November 27, 2025

How messed up do you have to be to try to blame your daughter after you murder her mom? What a dork.

D
David Martin · November 25, 2025

Holy shit one of co-workers is named Brian Clark.

B
Brett Keene · November 24, 2025

Me and my brother are Brad & Brett. My parents, grandparents, other family members and friends always got our names wrong.

L
Lesley Zen Marx · November 24, 2025

How often did you get called Brat and Bread? 😂

C
Carla O'Connor · November 23, 2025

Was that a Linda Belcher “alright!” James did?

J
Jessie Nelson · November 26, 2025

I thought the same thing! I love it!

M
MamaBear · November 22, 2025

I also have RLS. It's miserable, and it doesn't stop when you fall asleep. Thankfully there is a very effective medicine that works as long as you remember to take it about 3 hours before bedtime. The stuff from the store, over the counter, is just crap don't even bother with it.

D
David Martin · November 25, 2025

I do too. I have had meds for years now for it.

S
Sheri Zylstra · November 22, 2025

James and Jimmy-do you ever respond on these comment sites?

R
Ryan Gunion · November 23, 2025

I don’t think they do but maybe. I did get a response from Jimmy on instagram though. I just messaged him after I saw them live for the first time last month saying how amazing the show was and he replied back. I thought that was pretty cool he responded

S
Sheri Zylstra · November 22, 2025

Can you imagine how much time it takes to make 1 podcast! Hats off to James and Jimmy for all there hard work! This guy never wanted to put the effort into his marriage until she tried to leave! Then to blame his teen daughter! Now that is a SCUMBAG!

D
Dale Oren · November 22, 2025

If you've never experienced a cross over episode, Casefile true crime podcast covered this in their episode 198 Tami Reay... personally, I enjoy different perspectives. J&J are funny and my favorite.

B
Brooke C · November 22, 2025

My memory of visiting Pierre, South Dakota was watching a woman who was no younger than 85 barely go into a liquor store with her feeble little body and come out with two of the biggest bottles of vodka I have ever seen under each arm like a champ. 🤣🤣🤣So yeah, the drinking thing is definitely correct for this small town.

M
Makayla · November 22, 2025

When James said rivers I was hoping they would do a little "River Talk with James and Jimmie" 🫠

E
Elise · November 28, 2025

I love River Talk 😭

A
Ashley W. · November 22, 2025

What kind of a man blames his own teenage daughter for a murder he committed?? Disgusting. I'm all for getting out the torches and pitchforks for this asshole.

B
Boosed Podcast · November 22, 2025

My husband is an identical twin. Shane and Shawn. His parents came up with Shane. A nurse named him Shawn 😅

Z
Zachary Leatherwood · November 22, 2025

Whats up Turkeys? Back for another one of the Fellas’, albeit: mini, Bonafide Bangers!!! Keep your heads swiveling, and stay ICE Free!!! (🖕🏾🧊)

T
Tracy Poetz · November 22, 2025

When you work in retail you can tell when people are banging each other. I could tell you where almost anything in the store is too. Lol There was a manager that had a couple of kids and was married. His associate used to follow him around and everyone knew what was going on. Even his wife lol.

M
Makayla · November 22, 2025

Pierre is the 2nd smallest capital, Montpelier, Vermont is the smallest with 8,074 🎵 the more you know🎵

R
Rose sharpton · November 22, 2025

Can those on Patreon be excluded from the intro explaining Patreon?? Its redundant.

D
Deena McCollum · November 22, 2025

There is a fwd button

Z
Zach Hollander · November 22, 2025

I'm hillbilly as shit and it's not pier. Fuck em anyways.

Z
Zach Hollander · November 22, 2025

Yayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

C
Chris Schirmer · November 22, 2025

I’m from Douglas Wyoming

N
Noki Wheeler · November 22, 2025

And you don't like The Beatles Jimmie? When I'm 64...

J
Justine McNeil · November 22, 2025

my comment is twofold: 1. My husband can sometimes ACT OUT his dreams and the neurologist suggested sleeping in seperate bedrooms because there have been cases where some sufferers have violent dreams. He has tried to tackle me (playing football) and has knelt up on the bed reaching up (climbing the racks at work) and, has tried to face palm me before. I now just tell him to stfu and go back to sleep🫠 2. My hubby’s ex did that to him with making the kids call him to say they hate him etc. and she was the one who cheated (still with the guy who we now know has physically assaulted her). Hubby never once spoke a bad word about her (to them anyway) and now that they are older (25, 27 & 29) they have realised how manipulative their mother was back then, though they worked that out in high school and the eldest came to live with us for Year 12 (senior year) and calls me for advice etc.

J
Jenna Augustine Atwater · December 3, 2025

When my husband has anxiety, he sleep-fights. He slept on the floor for my last trimester during both of my pregnancies 😆

T
Tiffany W · November 22, 2025

Oh shit... I guess I'm Target Tiffany

J
Justine McNeil · November 22, 2025

😅

A
Amy Van Vliet · November 22, 2025

Struggle Jennings may listen to the show. Him and Jelly Roll are still very good friends and this is Jelly Rolls favorite podcast. Just thought I would share.

J
Jo Alysse · November 22, 2025

I love struggle Jennings !

R
Ryan Gunion · November 23, 2025

He’s great!

r
rebecca Deardorff · November 22, 2025

Look at Jimmie knowing what the libero is❤️ Also, sleep divorces save marriages….sometimes 😂

J
Jason Welchert · November 22, 2025

Honolulu, Hawaii isn’t connected to any interstate system

J
John · December 12, 2025

I-201

D
Daniel Sandomenico · November 22, 2025

Jimme NAILED that spelling! “Or with an E-I!!.. P..E..I..R 🎤 drop

E
Ed ‘Moose’ Grant · November 22, 2025

I miss River Talk with James and Jimmie

L
Lindsay Hood · November 22, 2025

Peer…. Really!?

C
Chantal Pirrotta · November 22, 2025

RLS sufferer here... and it doesn't stop with sleep. I was diagnosed with it as part of a sleep study. The husband has to wake me up sometimes because it keeps him from sleeping.

s
sugartiitz · November 22, 2025

I've never heard anyone say WD40. it's always been dub ya d 40

T
Tracey · July 30, 2026

I've never heard it called that. It's wild how different areas of the country say things. WD40 is what we call it in Pa.

J
Jessi Marriott · November 22, 2025

Oh, thank goodness. I was having withdrawals. 😁

T
Tim Olson · November 22, 2025

Yay!!

K
Kip Sousley · November 22, 2025

Yay indeed!

R
Renata · November 22, 2025

First!!!!