Singing Serial Killer - Menomonie, Wisconsin
This week, in Menomonie, Wisconsin, a friendly, traveling lounge singer moves into the area, and people start to end up dead. Some of the deaths even seem to be accidents. But it turns out not to be a coincidence, as this singer is also being guided by voices, coming from tv sets, light bulbs, and Chinese restaurants, while also being told what to do, by what he calls "The Force". He eventually admits all of this, but will he be allowed to walk the streets, again??
Along the way, we find out that nobody wants someone to croon Frank Sinatra tunes to them, while they're being murdered, that if you hear any voices that you can't identify, you should ignore them, and that if someone is apparently in a car accident, you should also check them for bullet holes!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com
THE HALLOWEEN SHOW!!! 10/30/2025 @ 9:00 PM Eastern Time Get your tickets on moment.co/smalltownmurder Tickets are $20. Video Playback will be available for 2 weeks after the live event.
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
instagram.com/smalltownmurder
facebook.com/smalltownpod
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (92)
46:50 I said it before and I'll say it again people: STOP FUCKING VOTING REPUBLICAN. They are certainly responsible for the existence of health insurance companies and the lack of mental AND physical healthcare!!!!!! The democrats suck too and share responsibility, but either way it means the American people suffer, while the ruling class makes itself perpetually richer.
Menomonie sounds like the song from the muppets
Jimmy said my name correctly! 🖤
I think I have your doppelganger name. Kristi Crider. 🫶
I just want to be the 100th comment
So I have a connection to Menomonie. Cousins of mine used to own “Camp Menomonie” for a couple decades.
That “Froedtert” pronunciation has me dying. Thanks for the laughs James 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thanks to stupid cops this guy was able to keep killing.
Glad they used 27 units of whole blood, I hate when they give me 2% or skim blood when I want whole blood
This guy covers his tracks. Not insane.
If he was playing The Lamplighter in St Paul, it's a very low dive strip club we always called The Limp Lifter. 😁
That’s hilarious!
The Hospital "Freodhert" is pronounced "Frey-dherts" take the O out, great pronunciations though
I not only once worked with a Willie Williams, I also worked work a Robbie Robb🤣
Thin Chicago style pizza is called Tavern pizza. 🍕
As a Sconnie, I can see the dive bars, Fuzzy's store, the countryside. I graduated high school in '86 and the Miller beer habits of my classmates is dead on. Listening to James' pronunciation of the towns is so entertaining as well.
Has anyone seen the movie The Voices? It’s good. It’s a dark comedy about mental illness. It’s cool because it shows how he sees things on and off meds.
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
Fun fact: the "You don't know how local I am" girl from 'The Great Outdoors' is a lawyer now.
Lime preserves lye breaks down...
I think it should be clarified that people experiencing mental health crisis are more likely to be victims of crime. Let’s reduce the stigma of people being crazy and killing people. Over 90% of people who murder had no mental health issues
I would love the 6:30 pm-2:30 am shift !!! But I used to love working the midnight-10:00 am shift so I might be a little weird 😂😂
I would love the 6:30 pm-2:30 am shift !!! But I used to love working the midnight-10:00 am shift so I might be a little weird 😂😂
Surprisingly the Chinese food in the upper Midwest is really good, I spent 9 weeks in Appleton WI a few years ago for work and I just got back from Forrest Lake MN after being there for 12 weeks, and both places had some decent Chinese food
Everytime I hear the name Menomonie I keep expect some Muppets to pop up singing Do do do do do.
NCR is National Cash Register. I used to test the credit card machines in the 1990s.
That is a FOUR HOUR drive from Menomonie to Jackson, WI with his "cargo" in the front seat. I can't believe that a single cop didn't see him during this entire debacle.
I know a guy that was kind of like this, he saw demons everywhere and tried to burn down a church because he saw them coming out of it
So much of this case reminds me of the movie Frailty.
YES!!! that movie ruled
You have to convert to marry a Catholic. Really been slacking on facts lately. Still a great show
I was going to say, that threw me! I grew up Lutheran and my brother is married to a Catholic woman. They had to meet with a priest, get permission, and he’s taken a bunch of classes! He didn’t technically “convert” but they couldn’t be married in the church until he did a lot of work.
I could be having the craziest deja vu but I’m certain this episode is a reposting of a previous episode.
I was thinking the same at first, but I think it’s just because they have mentioned Menominee before in other episodes
As soon as you said “level 2 demon” I yelled LORI VALLOW PT 2!!!
Spooner blows!
Did anyone else laugh when James said "He fucked around, and killed himself" when they were talking about death by misadventure? That is the perfect definition, and cracked me up.
Wisconsin…. ALWAYS insane.
"A brain fax" 😂
Alvin's Fun Time Journal reminds me (sadly) of an artist I used to follow online about a decade and change ago. She started off normal, but a few years in her blogs started to slide into "the FBI is watching me through electronics." Eventually she stopped posting, maybe because everyone was urging her to get help. I think of her often and hope she got the assistance she needed.
Reminds me of “Deep Thoughts” by Jack Handy
I love when you do Wisconsin! I lived in Eau Claire for a time, growing up.
I am in Eau Claire right now lol
All right now Alvin’s fun time journal? 😂😂
Wooooooooooooooooo
What you doin' with all that hammer, Alvin?
😂😂
This is just like the two guys that attacked Dan Rather yelling, "Kenneth, what's the frequency!!??" And R.E.M cashed in.
Black Tambor sounds like a good band name
Did you notice that the last house you mentioned had its own tram down to the lake. Not a path. Not a staircase. A TRAM!! Now that's living!!
So I graduated from Menominie, live in Eau Claire and went to kindergarten in Spring Brook. My dad was in the music screen at that time running sound. When I lived in Spring Book this guy was actually our neighbor . My parents told me about this when I got a little older. I’m gonna send you a email the.
Ezekiel 25:17 Samual L Jackson quoted is a more verbose version of the verse.
They put the Pulp Fiction version on Nick Fury's tombstone in the MCU
I hear Esko Highschool and Potlatch and my ears perk up. Esko Highschool is in Esko, MN and Potlatch was in Cloquet, MN before it changed to Sappi. I went to school at Esko and my Dad worked at Potlatch before it was bought by Sappi. It's fun to see when small towns overlap with other small town history!
I was coming to say the same thing. Esko is in Mn.
I was hoping you would mention Roz on Frasier as she’s the only way I know of this place too 😂 “My cousins are from Menomonie!”
We’ve got a 30 Day long acting Haldol injection now. Gotta catch em all
My brother, Michael, murdered one man while in jail. He was bat shit crazy-voices, hallucinations etc. they committed my brother as criminally insane t a state institution. He was supposed t go to prison once he was stable, but never was stable. Fast forward 20 years, the state said you’re cured, bye. Released, Michael just wandered until he passed. A veteran org arranged his burial-Michael was a Vietnam veteran. Thanks for a great story!
I wish our country took better care of our veterans. I’m sorry for your loss.
OMG… the physicians f’ed up to in the examination…
I'm wondering if the guys are mistaking Lye for Lime.... Pretty sure putting Lye on a body breaks it down like acid.
Maybe they did sell him something that kills insects instead
Covina!!
1978 Camaro came standard with a 350 cubic inch (5.7L) V8 engine producing around 185 horsepower
Car talk with James and Jimmie is one of my favorite gems of the show 😂
Oh no, the non-investigation of Danny’s murder with bullet holes in his body deemed injuries from a car wreck is even worse than Jim’s murder with a hole in his neck!
Bizarre gashes would be a great punk band name
Worst police non-investigation ever regarding Jim, the murdered man who they figured stabbed himself in the neck.
Lye will break down a body. lime will not
They way I celebrate when its in my state is probably unhealthy but I know you guys get it.. 🤣 This is only an hour and 50 minutes from my home town.
This is how I know I’m with my people😂😂 “oh shit! There was a massacre 20 mins away?! YESSS! Get into it!”😂😂😂
Aggressively Mid-western…
This just unlocked a core memory I did not even know I had. Height of lockdown in 2020, I’m working 16 hour shifts on a Covid unit, after about two weeks straight working kI finally make it to a grocery store. The place was effing empty of food. But there were still about ten Tombstone pizza’s in the freezer case. I bought five of them
Thank you for all of your help and hard work during that awful time 👏🏻👏🏻
Amazing police work.
I have to know what is the actual percentage of people that when a missing persons report is filed “just took off.” Police always say this like it’s something that stable normal people do and I just don’t see it and it sounds more and more like a reason not to do your job. Like go look for the fucking people most of the time these aren’t booming metropolises what the fuck else were you going to do? Set up a speed trap on Main?
I’m venturing to say it’s about the same amount of times a white van full of free candy and drugs shows up. Full disclosure…I’m still waiting for this van😆
I know zero Bible that's hilarious
I know he’s a wheelchair bound old man at this point but HOPING his release petition stay denied! That man needs to STAY forcibly medicated, what a scary human.
Insane story in a place with the silliest name.
On Wisconsin
This dude is a UNICORN of a criminal! One hand- Nuttier than a fruitcake. Other hand- Exceptional at covering up his crimes…and switching up his M.O., to evade law enforcement. *First, turned into tomatoes 🍅…then staging a self-inflicted neck stabbing..and, finally, staging a bullet-laden fatal car wreck! By law = NOT really insane! Haha
RIGHT!?!
Whats up Turkeys? Clocking out of work, and checking in with the fellas, and you turkeys for some Murder!!! Stay ICE free 🖕🏾🧊
The woodwork in the house is outstanding! How haunted do you think it is?
I too know it from Roz!
I'm from this area and I'm just now leaving about menomine Wisconsin. I know about menomine Michigan and Marinette Wisconsin
Manamana
Do doo da doo doo
Nothing better than climbing into bed on Wednesday night and getting into some murder!
Yaaaayyy!
Yay indeed Jimmie. Yay indeed.
