BONUS - SMALL TOWN MURDER - HAUNTED PLACES
This week, James and Jimmie discuss some of the most haunted places.
Comments (136)
Texas is #2 ??? Whatttttt !
Everyone loses their minds over the Winchester house, but it's honestly just an old house with dope architecture and 13 of everything. Much of the mythology around Sarah Winchester is nonsense and they created something out of nothing. If you like old architecture, go for it, but keep in mind that it's expensive to get in there and it's probably not as cool as you think it will be.
Ghost kids of today are going to be miserable pricks always messing with the WiFi
It’s in San Jose… I lived there for a long time and went to the Winchester Mystery House many times….. it’s gorgeous, really cool and super confusing 😆 I remember it being a little expensive for a tour of a house… but it’s huge and there are so many layers.
O hv
There are SO many more stories from the Daly Mansion!! I almost accidentally got locked in there years ago after the last tour of the day. But when you ask the staff, they have plenty of fucked up stories about what goes on there, including when one was giving a tour and they were all in the nursery and a creepy old baby doll flung itself out of the crib at the tour guide in front of everyone
Of course it's the stupid ass Amityville horror. It happened right before I was born. I ended up going to the same Catholic school (St Martin's) that those kids went to and my mom actually went to the Defeo family funeral at St Martin's Church which is right across the street from the Catholic school and when you go to the Catholic school at St martin's, you go to that church and it's boring as f*** in the nuns are evil as s***. Anyway, yeah, the Lutz family were full of s***. My brothers said they did party in that house in the '80s. I'm sure a lot of c*CK sucking was done in the basement by Italian and Irish girls with guys that had Joey Buttafuoco vibes. I once went to a party when we went back to long island, and I swear you already know how those guys were acting. I got to hear one muscle head in those big ass pants talking about all the girls he f***** up against a wall at Cedar Beach. I guess maybe in the tunnel that you walk from the parking lot to the beach? I don't know, he also said his stereo sounded like a rock concert which it kind of did but it was typical Guido bragging
I’m originally from San Antonio and every summer my husband and I stay at the Menger! I also had an uncle that worked there and worked maintenance and he said he heard a lot of creepy stuff, a young women’s voice and footsteps approaching but nobody there. 😬
I was not expecting to hear draymond green slander in this episode but I loved every second of it. Also, I remodel condos for a living and my company remodeled Charles oakleys condo many years ago and we put in everything built for someone his size. It was awesome.
Ah! I guessed NY right away.
J&J: if you want to learn more about the Winchester house in California, read “The Gunning of America,” by Pamela Haag, a history of the Winchester Repeating Arms company. It’s a fascinating book in its own right, but it includes a great description of that endless money pit of a mansion. Knowing your great interest in real estate, you’ll love it.
James, Jimmy, if you want to hear a really good traditional Irish song find “Rocky Road To Dublin,” by the Chieftains and The Rolling Stones. Should be on YouTube.
Google “Cahill Mansion, Gulfport Mississippi.” It was the home of my closest friend in middle school. I witnessed some weird shit there one night. It would have been 1968.
I’m laughing so hard at the baby ghosts! I had to pause it to catch my breath!
Georgia used to have the #1 rate of ghost sightings in the U.S., but most of the sightings were discounted when they were determined to be Klan rallies.
I'm surprised Kansas wasn't the Sallie House in Atchison. Great show tho nevertheless.
Missouri disappointed for sure lol. I can think of multiple places within a couple miles of me that are “more haunted” (or at least have a better story. Lemp mansion for one
A psychic told Sarah Winchester to keep building to keep the spirits from finding her.
I scared the shit out of my 11 year old daughter at the Menger by writing "HELP" in the foggy mirror after a shower. She's 21 now and I'm sure she's still planning her revenge!
My 2 favorite J-named Scumbags NOT A$$holes LOL. Fun fact: Stephen King based part of his concept for Rose Red on the Winchester Mansion (the constant building/hammering of the house) but in that case it was the spirits doing the construction and not the owner trying to outrun the restless departed.
I stayed at Thornewood in Washington! We were the only guests for the whole time we were there.
James and Jimmy- I’ve been to the Winchester Mansion! It is as cool as it sounds -the wood work is amazing. She never wanted the hammering to stop…..there is a door that opens to a giant drop several small doors that open to brick walls -a lot of tiny rooms that can’t even fit a twin bed! It’s as strange and weird as you can image! It’s in San Jose!
We do hate the tourist that come to Salem 🤭🤭🤭🤣
I grew up in Hamilton, MT! We used to go to the Daly Mansion a lot! There’s a whole annual event called Marcus Daly Days! Used to be in that parade as a kid. Lol The mansion is a crazy place! The tour is incredibly long but absolutely fascinating. It was late fall so it was too cold to tour the full grounds. But there’s a full 1/4 scale replica of it that was a playhouse and now is the groundskeepers home. It’s that big. One room is all exotic animal taxidermy. I wish I could post pictures! Also, I stayed at the hotel in Hawaii. We pretty much took over her home. There’s a whole whopping case of the history of it. I think there should be a whole wing of the place. Very timeshare vibes now.
Honestly? I'm very surprised by those impressed by the Winchester house. It's much smaller than I expected. I mean, MUCH smaller. She was a tiny woman and had it adapted to her size so the home was not as vast as it looks. Most of it was closed to the public and so I think we saw the stairs to nowhere and the door with the drop. It just wasn't all that interesting. I'm not going to say "if I could give it 0 stars I would" but I would say it was maybe a 2 or 3. I think the hype is very much bigger than the reality. I find the Myrtle house interesting. Yes, it was a white family but the slave girl did admit to poisoning them because she was trying to prove how helpful she was to the family. There's a photo that shows a ghostly-looking (perhaps) slave girl in it, but I can't remember when it was taken. It's definitely odd and reminds me of the Three Men & A Baby photo which looked like a young boy yet turned out to be a cutout of Ted Danson.
Let me tell you, the town of Hagerstown is a hell of a lot scarier than that house lol
HOW was Dudleytown not the pick for CT???
That hotel in San Antonio is beautiful and sits next door to the Alamo.
The Whaley House in San Diego is also pretty fucking cool
I’ve been to the Menger Hotel bar. Recommend. 👍🏼
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
My favorite band of all time is Thin Lizzy and they are from Ireland. Criminally underrated. Look em up Jimmie.
Long story, but I got to stay overnight in the caretakers house at the main Gettysburg cemetery. Got zero sleep and refused to answer the creepy knocking on the walls and doors all night.
A few years we went to the Ohio state reformatory. I would say I think it is haunted.
I went to the Ohio state reformatory this summer!
That's what I am talking about Jimmy! Spooky Season until he comes down that chimney.
How in the hell was the most haunted in Colorado not The Stanley Hotel?
I felt so bad for the Winchester widow. Lost multiple family members, lonely depressed- goes to see a “psychic” who tells her she is cursed by the souls of all who died by Winchester rifles, and the only way to avoid them taking her soul is to keep building and building on to her house. Poor old lady.
Come to Sacramento!!
The mystery house is in San Jose. I’ll be at the next show, I’m in Tahoe. I’ve been to the house multiple times, it’s beautiful.
Yes, ghost kids are absolutely the creepiest!
Texas has history with Native Americans, the Spanish and missionaries, slavery, Civil War and Mexican American War
Apparently there arent any floor plans of the Winchester house available to the public, just some claiming to be, but not legit. I would love to see a whole layout.
I grew up with a ghost kitty!
I've been haunted by a few ghost cats & dogs.
i went to the winchester mystery house about 15 years ago! my grandparents lived in the bay area and i used to visit them for weeks every summer. i definitely didn’t appreciate the house in my teens the way i would have now but it was so beautiful!
I’ve stayed in two of these places LOL. The Occidental in Buffalo, WY and the Bullock in Deadwood. My husband and I spent our honeymoon in the 3rd floor suite and we’ve stayed in that room many times. The only haunting in that suite were the hangovers we had. Deadwood is a fun town🤘🏻
I can't believe that GA is the lowest with Savanah, there are all kinds of ghosts there!
I was so excited when you mentioned Winchester Mystery House. It's in San Jose and I used to drive past it every day on my way to work. I was born and raised in California - I have NEVER been. I'd love to go. Can't wait until dates for next year are announced. I live in Nebraska now but I'll use any excuse to go home for a visit!!
Go to it next time you're home. I grew up in Mountain View but didn't go until I was visiting friends a few years ago. It was fantastic.
The Borden House in Fall River, Massachusetts.
Been there! Its creepy AF
The Borden House in Fall River, Massachusetts
I live in the same town as the occidental hotel :)
I can listen to stuff like this in June. I enjoyed the Winchester house when we visited a few years back. She actually started to build it after a “Spirituaalist” (eye role) told her about the spirits and that she needed to begin to build this house specifically for the spirits and to never stop building. Other words the Spiritualist saw a sucker from a mile away.
All the spirits got the fuck out of the South as fast as they could! It even sucks in the afterlife!!
Bébéghosts
Winchester House in San Jose is SO worth it!! I'd live there if I could.. Hope the Jimmies go their next trip out!
Rose Red was a freaky movie!
The Winchester house is definitely worth the trip! Loved the tour
The Thornwood Castle in Washington is now a $500 a night air BNB and looks nothing like the movie.
I would watch or listen to the guys experience of going through the Winchester house in a heartbeat. Also surprised Kansas wasn't the Sally House
Listened to this while putting up my Christmas tree, it felt so wrong but so right
Winchester House used to be seven stories, but an earthquake reduced it to four. Also, no one was burned at Salem; they were hanged.
I love this episode 🤣 The Winchester mansion is cool as hell though. I went there sometime back in 2002-03, when I was around the age of 12, and I still think about it often.
Indiana- unquestionably the most haunted place is the indiana state sanitarium near Rockville. It's only been open to the public for a few years. They dont do tours as such, you just pay some money and sign a waiver. It's supposed to be intense inside the building.
I grew up right by the WV penitentiary! They do ghost tours and have tattoo conventions through the year. I’ve gotten more tats at a penitentiary than at actual shops.. 🤣 there’s also an Indian burial mound (hence the name of the town “moundsville”) that’s got a pretty cool little museum right across the street!
I live a block away from there. Walk my dog past it every night
This is my favorite bonus. ❤️
Been to Myrtle’s a few times … I have some crazy things on camera and experienced some weird things too … the restaurant is really good too
Im surprised Georgia is last. Theres a “haunted” building in damn near every county lol
Same! I was expecting it to be much higher, especially with how many ghost tours there are in Savannah alone lol
I’m ready for the Winchester House to be on Your Stupid Opinions!
When you're raised by two proud Irish parents... you learn the drinking songs! The Clancy Brothers and Tommy Makem, baby!
Sorry for typos. I had a seizure this morning and it always messes with my whole body for 2-3 days. Love you guys and all you do!
We have live in our home for 46 years. We raised 3 girls and 1 son. I was well aware that we had ghosts. I told our children whenever a door randomly opens or closes or any weird stuff happens just say hello and welcome. After our last child graduated college we decided to start our first garden I hit a big rock and it had an 18 on it. We kept finding big chickens of concrete. So I decided Roderick make some sense of this. I discovered they were pieces of headstones! When we moved in our house I noticed in a culdesac *sp. there were two headstones right by the garage. When they dug their garden, they found pieces of headstones as well!I went to the Caddo Parish Court House and tried to help find the his of the are we live. Ended up at the big downtown library looking at maps of plantations. From what the librarian told me this used to be a huge plantation and the slave cemetery. Huge big headstones ant my friends could have been the owner’s. So they decided to bury the headstones on top of the coffin. He and my husband didn’t get to the coffins just deep enough to bury the headstones. One day someone knocked on his Milli’s door and it was the family of the two people whose headstones where buried. That was a cluster f**k. So suggested an adventure to go look in the woods behind her house and I found a large infant cemetery. I was so upset because you could see how tiny their graves were. It was so sad this all happened about 20 years ago. Apparently it in limbo and has been since the 1800’s Tata from Shreveport!
Ghosts are not real. Call better help.
Wooooooooooooooooo
jimmie knew what was up with that first gues, i just don’t think anyone here is reporting a ghost sighting since it’s lowk so common 😭 sc haunted as shit
I've also been to the Ohio state reformatory (where Shawshank was filmed).
We've been to the west Virginia penitentiary a few times. It's in Moundsville, 15 minutes south of Wheeling (Ep 479 Born to be Bad). Charles Mason sent letters to the warden wanting to be transferred there because he lives in the area as a child. It's been on several ghost hunt shows.
I thought Savannah would be on the list.
I read a book on Sarah Winchester (not just the house, but about her) and that author argues that Sarah was just a woman who lost her husband and only child early and just kept building the house because it was hers and she was interested in architecture and could afford it. The press saw her as a "crazy widow" and ran with the story, but that doesn't seem to be the case from anyone who KNEW her. It's called Captive of the Labyrinth by Mary Jo Ignoffo.
Yup- pretty much all of the Winchester House woo seems to be totally made up, especially the seance and mediums stuff. I'd still love to see it though.
I would’ve thought Massachusetts would have been number 1.
Did the Winchester house tour at some point in the mid 90s. It is super cool.
I have been to Whinchester House. It's beautiful and weird. We were told the confusion stairs, doors, and secret rooms were built to confuse the ghosts so they'd get lost looking for her.
SHUT UUUUP AND GIVE ME GHOST KITTIES.
😻
Here in New Mexico I vote for our State Penitentiary-site of arguably the worst prison riot in U.S.history. They literally had/have? ghost tours and it's reported to be creepy af. I get chills every time I drive past it. The Luna Mansion? ...TFOH.
Was going to say the same thing! State Pen is WAY more haunted, still marks in the concrete where they killed prisoners for fuck’s sake…
Love the Winchester house! I’ve toured it several times! You guys HAVE TO go!!! They also do night tours so extra spooky. It’s crazy.
I toured the Glensheen mansion once (the MN one). I went specifically bc of the murder. The tour guides don't talk abt it and if you ask, they won't discuss it. So I got to tour some dumb old mansion and hear abt the stupid drapes and original oak bannisters.
When I was a kid, we lived in a duplex across the street from Ft. Sidney for a couple years. I remember older kids trying to scare me with the story, but I always wanted to see her.
The hay house in ga is definitely bullshit. I thought for sure you would say Waverly hills or something in savannah. Savannah based it's whole imagine on being the most haunted city in ga. Every other house has some silly ghost story about it.
I cant wait to be a modern ghost! Imma run around yelling "Its Brittany, Bitch!!" Hahahaha
Winchester mansion is awesome. It is beautiful, but an earthquake damaged it and it isn’t in its original form
visit craig, missouri and tell me that whole town isn't haunted
My husband is from Texas and has always said if he saw a ghost, he would shoot first lmao
I can’t believe Waverly Hills Sanatorium in Louisville isn’t the place in Kentucky.
Adding this to my list of places to look up !!
Thanks for the epsiode! Any chance we'll get a Charles Oakley crime in sports episode? While I generally avoid that podcast because it goes way too into stats for me personally, I'd enjoy an epsiode about guy running around handing out slaps to whoever asks.
You are missing a great show. Stats are a very small part of CIS.
Goodness . Insane
Shit I was hoping for their take on the Sallie House in KS haha
Another way to look at why ghost haunt mansions, is the rich don't want to give up their stuff.
The Black Dalia house was designed by Frank Lloyd Wright. It takes creepy up several notches. It is (in my opinion) an example of art deco and brutism. It’s very much both beautiful and terrifying.
Hmm my house is from the 1750, remote without neighbours and I’ve got some Viking graves not too far away. I’d assume if it was going to be any haunting it would be in this house. Have not seen any ghosts in the 20 years I’ve been living here but the previous owners told me there is a weeping lady next to the fireplace in the kitchen. She eludes me though. 😁
Gatsby 🎯 Spiritualism became popular in the 1870’s. Wasn’t a whole lot of fascination or talk of ghosts prior to that time.
The General Anthony Wayne Inn. It was haunted before there was a murder there. It is now owned by an Orthodox group. Merion, PA
I made the mistake of going to the Winchester mystery house really high. It was giving me anxiety 😅🤣
I think you guys should do paranormal stories more often. I was on the floor laughing 🤣
I can’t imagine something less interesting. One of very few episodes I will be skipping. Scumbags taking advantage of morons retold 50 times. Ghosts are not real. If you think are you are stupid if crazy.
Oh, buddy. If you're getting this worked up about ghost tours, wait til you hear about religion....
Thanks for the spooky list, guys! It made me remember a book I listened to... If anyone's interested, you can do a deeper dive on the Iowa axe murders. A man and his daughter have done a ton of research and have a theory about how that was actually a prolific serial killer who killed dozens of people up and down the railroad. The book is a bit dry and (very) repetitive, honestly, but is still really interesting because the theory seems pretty solid. I listened to it on Spotify, but I'm sure it can be found elsewhere. It's called The Man from the Train, by Bill James & Rebecca McCarthy James.
I've read this too- wasn't total convinced by the suspect they identifed but the overall theory was interesting stuff.
Tango and Cash was also filmed at the Ohio State Reformatory, and some scenes from Air Force One
It was a medium that told her if she kept building the spirits could never settle.
If you ever visit Asheville, go to the Biltmore Estate. Soooo cool, totally worth it.
I say TX is haunted bc of all the people TX has executed and continues to execute. I don't think the state w the highest # of state sponsored murder can escape the consequences without some sort of paranormal repercussions.
Touring Winchester House doing a live show would be amazing!
The Winchester Mystery House is located in San Jose! Glad you’re coming back to NorCal next year! I’ll for sure be at the Sacramento live show.
Jimmie saying that it’s still spooky season until “that fat fuck comes down the chimney” absolutely made my life 🖤😆
Same. 🤣
Can’t wait for you to tour the Winchester House! They also run a haunted house for Halloween which I really enjoyed 👻
The Winchester mystery house is worth a tour. If you can go around Halloween there are more tour options. No matter it's incredible and the tour guides are great!
It is indeed Gatsby
We need more!!
San Jose, CA Winchester Mystery Mansion. I want to go too!! It's said that she built based on what the spirits told her to do. They built until her death. There are nails half driven because all work stopped at Sarah's death. It takes an entire year to paint the outside of the house.
The Winchester Mystery House is San Jose California. It is definitely worth a visit while you're in the area for a live show.
The Winchester House! Haunted wet dream! Gorgeous architecture
Is ‘The Shining’ solely responsible, for making little kid ghosts, especially girls, the creepiest?!
I think of nightmare on elm street but the shining did come out first.. I just watched the shining as well as the mini series!
It surprises me that Georgia is so low for ghost sightings since Savannah is considered one of the most haunted cities in America, haha
Too religious to publicly say it’s haunted:)
I’ll take making fun of stupid people and places all year long 🤣
