Breaking Badder - Mason City, Iowa
This week, in Mason City, Iowa, a smart & nerdy young man has a very illegal money making enterprise that spins out of control, leading to the cold blooded murders of 5 innocent people & a game of finger pointing that can only be sorted out by secret recordings, and midnight confessions. When the murders are discovered, they're so brutal & heartless, that a judge has to do something he doesn't even belive in, for punishment!
Along the way, we find out that nerds can be criminals, too, that you should always make sure someone is who they say they are, before letting them move in, and that being smart doesn't alway make you a good criminal!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com
THE HALLOWEEN SHOW!!! 10/30/2025 @ 9:00 PM Eastern Time Get your tickets on moment.co/smalltownmurder Tickets are $20. Video Playback will be available for 2 weeks after the live event.
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
instagram.com/smalltownmurder
facebook.com/smalltownpod
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (88)
Just shared this episode with my parents who are born and raised in Mason city! They enjoyed the details that weren’t shared by the news at the time. Also, the panty thief was one time years ago 🤣
😅
My daughter lived in Mason City for a couple of years. Her and her friends called it Methnshitty.
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
Speaking of destroying property… when we digging up “that basement”?
NOT QUITE BROTHERS IS AN AMAZING COVER BAND 😂🥹🤍
I live close to mason city, it is a terrible city 😂
In the reviews, the guy with the long list of why hell would be better- anyone else expect James to end the tirade with “Hallelujah! Holy shit! Where’s the Tylenol?”
Anyone else wondering if Jimmie was challenged by someone to put a 67 reference in an episode?
Dry socket 😂😂😂😂
This is so trippy. I was a travel nurse in Mason City and bored out of my fucking mind when I discovered James and Jimmy 3 years ago. Y’all got me through some depressing times and I’ve been a listener ever since!
James: "This is meth thinking." Yep
Cerro Gordo=fat hill. You pronounced it just fine!
That poem was my high school vocal solo 🤣🤣 I had no clue, but started singing it with James as he read it.
Omg James be careful with straws after the oral surgery! My husband got a dry socket that way, and I have never seen him in so much pain—and he’s had kidney stones! Be well, and thank you guys for another absolutely unreal tale, expertly told!
For anyone interested, the reason it’s called River City is because of the musical, “The Music Man”. Mason City was the inspiration for it.
How did James miss on this Dustin guy being completely abusive to his sister?
Born and raised in Mason city! This was absolutely heartbreaking! Great job with pronouncing our county 🤪
From the title i thought we were in for a murderous baker.
As someone who is familiar with the meth world (and still knows people messed up in that world) I can honestly say if you wrote a book on how to make it, you would make a fortune. Meth heads aren't real bright.
Meth .com
First time getting my name called on an episode and Jimmy got it right first try, what an absolute snipe from the lad.
"NERDERER!" and drive by "guilty, guilty, guilty" took me out 🤣🤣🤣 Excellent episode!
I feel like Angela Johnson was a contestant on The Prisoner Dating Game 🤔
Every time they say Angela Johnson I hear "why you no have boyfriend?"
Meth dot com is the funniest thing.
James P is Performing while injured. NBA take note.
Just the mental image of James on a Big Wheel as an adult is perfection! 🤣 🤣 Too hilarious!
Fred Tocars was the attorney that hired a guy to kill his wife in front of his kids!
In Atlanta
This is Oceans IQ 11 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 James fucking kills me 🤣🤣
Feel better soon James!!
Weeeeeeeeeeeee
I think my sister’s was one of their salespeople?! No I that was crack. Anyway she only carried cigarettes, a pager, a gun, and of course crack in her purse. She’s been clean almost 9 years. She’s done some serious time in had ass Texas prisons. She is my favorite sister badass!
I lived in Sierra Vista AZ for a year after Peace Corps. Rural Nicaragua with no running water was 1000% better.
I was dumb enough to eat sushi in Sierra Vista on a visit. I threw up all night because nothing says fresh fish like a desert military base town
Also... I am from South Africa.. lol
Awesome as always...
I really like to number one song and movie addition. Nice way to check the time it occurred
The guy who wrote the review is probably the actual panty thief! Just like "Who farted?" is probably the person who asked. If you smelt it, you dealt it😂!
I'm in the Navy and spent 3 years doing funeral details for veterans. It's very sad at first, but I took a lot of pride knowing that we were able to do that honor for the service members and their families. I can't imagine being the family on the other side though. ❤️
Thank you for your sacrifice. Army veteran.
They got me lmao again with the IA and MN nice bullshit. Have not spent enough time in either state to know it’s a myth. Just as many assholes in MN and IA as anywhere else. 😂😂
Shut up and give me MURDER!!!
Jimmie- “ if they just folded it like a beach towel” I died ☠️🤣
"destroying evidence that the police already have" is literally a breaking bad plotline
Ohhhh myyyyy…. Let’s all go to the lobby, let’s all go to the lobby 🎶🎶🎶🎶 what a throwback!!!! 🤣
May I present to you the real-life Walter White who was busted in Bibb County, AL for making meth? That’s where the story/show came from, and there is a documentary about the real Walter White that VICE did if anyone was interested 😂
Boring fact about bandfest. Meredith Wilson wrote the Music man, the musical about a conman selling marching band instruments and lessons to people in River City.
There was a triple murder here about a month ago that killed a 22 y/o, a 21 y/o and a 9 y/o. An infant and the twin of the 9 y/o were also in the house. The twins hid under a bed and the one that was killed went to the living room to check on the baby. A fucking 9-year-old. Nobody has been caught yet. People are despicable.
That’s heartbreaking. I never can understand the mindset of anyone that kills children. Another adult ok maybe a child your not worth the air you breath.
Anyone else have kens voice echoing
Crazy story!!!
Good job on the Cerro Gordo pronunciation!!!
Minnesota is the golden gophers. Lol so right I lived in Minnesota for 10 years and they dont like iowa. They say that you can smell dem iowa girls all the way up here
Omg this is one of the saddest cases yet. Also one of the funniest the last half is just me non stop crying laughing.
We related lol?
Court clothes. Ugh. I briefly worked at Juvie, and the closest thing we had for a teen defendant to wear to their pre-trial ongoings was their arrest outfit…. Steelers hoodie, sweatpants, and crocs. Keep it classy
There should be a fund, like abthrift store or donations. Showing up for court in jail clothes is a NO! That's a NO! . . . bad court/jail folks. I was there once for 3 days. I was feeling shame and the lack of being a civilian due to the orange jail clothing. Someone needs to give people some sense of dignity despite the worst day they had.
I was born about 45 minutes south of Mason City. I told my mom I was so glad she got a degree and moved us the fuck away from north central Iowa.
My father's death had the flag folding. It hurt more than his death. I get it. I couldn't say words after I saw that. The ceremony takes so long. Long enough to want to run away.
UB40 come from the city where I live and they're regarded as cultural icons here 🙄. I loathe them and all their works so really enjoyed the Js giving them a kicking.
It's Minnesota nice!!!! Idiots Out Wandering Around 😉
I was perfectly ready to believe that Jimmy is into architecture. I said, “O! Nice hobby!” Nope.
**Dad joke** MN ppl be like- "IOWA=Idiots Out Walking Around" (My dad from Iowa told me that one.)
For a horrible thing to happen, you gentlemen did a great job telling the story. Well done.
Whoop there it is - released 1993!! Jimmie with the recall!
Tag team, back again!
“Meth . com” 😂
Finally.
Hey now one of the most successful metal bands came from Iowa so give them at least some credit.
What a time to be alive indeed, Jimmie!
Suddenly a large spike in UB40 streams
Is it weird that I’m proud to be an Iowan when you do Iowa episodes?
Lol, I too feel the same way so I dont think its unheard of. Then again, my state ALWAYS delivers lol. Fuck we could have a stand alone show. Greetings from Florida
Snuck this in while I slept. Well done.
Right?!
Thank you for being a friend
Traveled down the road and back again
Lol, I thought the queen pin queen poon comment was funnier than james gave him credit for.
Same! Damn near choked on the apple I was eating.
Yaaaay!
Worlds are colliding Jerry!
And the award for… “Dumbest Fucking Last Names to EVER appear in an Episode”, goes to….this one
Every. Single. One. They just kept coming. 😂
Right before Jimmie made the comment, I was thinking this sounds like Breaking Bad…
As a former Iowan, let’s goooo!! Mason city sure has a reputation.. let’s see how this plays out lol
Yep, it's definitely one of the many dumpster places of Iowa
