💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
Serial Killer Search - Poteau, Oklahoma (1 of 2)
October 23, 2025

Serial Killer Search - Poteau, Oklahoma

This week, in Poteau, Oklahoma, when murders begin happening, all over the area, including an older man, several women, and a popular local newscaster , it isn't clear if they're connected, at first. This all quickly turns into a frantic search for a serial killer, while he's actively taking more victims, on a near daily basis. When they finally find him, he has a lot to say, and all of it is crazy, including detailed confessions of all the crimes!

Along the way, we find out that hot air balloons & barbeque apparently go hand in hand, that you can't just keep someone in a mental institution, forever, and that some people seem to decide to kill, or not, completely at random!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

THE HALLOWEEN SHOW!!! 10/30/2025 @ 9:00 PM Eastern Time Get your tickets on moment.co/smalltownmurder Tickets are $20. Video Playback will be available for 2 weeks after the live event.

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (59)

A
Alyssa Habeger · May 3, 2026

It sounds like he may have been a victim of MKultra when he went to jail the first time

M
Michael · December 21, 2025

5 stars

C
Cher Strong (#localweedia) · November 25, 2025

<3

B
Braylen · November 11, 2025

Congratulations James on perfect pronunciation for all of the towns in Oklahoma.

C
Charles Jewell · November 6, 2025

This could be a family member of mine, the Jewell side is from around that area. Edit: My grandmother used to do all that Ancestry genealogy before she passed and now I know why she stopped researching that part of our Family Tree. Par for the course in a family that includes a Hitman for Al Capone.

J
Jeni Remar · November 5, 2025

Forget the car…how is Jimmy single? Asking for a friend…

J
Julie Slama · October 30, 2025

I keep waiting for this episode to become ad-free, and it keeps not happening.

l
lauren handrahan · October 29, 2025

I don't understand why there are ads on Patreon? Don't we pay to avoid them?

J
Julie Slama · October 30, 2025

Yeah, it’s getting frustrating.

E
Erika Fultz · October 28, 2025

I love listening to two grown ass men become 12 year olds for a moment when talking about getting to ride in monster trucks!! 😁

C
Cheyanne Duffany · October 27, 2025

This one was WILDDDD

T
Tony Legg · October 27, 2025

James nailing all those Oklahoma place names 👍

B
Benjamin Fleming · October 27, 2025

Just saying, if we got a whataburger near our town, I'd lose my mind. I love whataburger.

J
Jim Dolen · October 27, 2025

Amazing that a human is capable of these crimes. Great job as always telling the story.

S
Shannon Cooper · October 26, 2025

How do you have an 87 car in 1984? I’m really asking

7
70Boss302 · November 11, 2025

Caught that too. I'm a little surprised Jimmie didn't. Maybe James meant 1977. Either that or time traveling.

M
My Luna Life · October 25, 2025

You even nailed the pronunciation of Terrell TX, home of Terrell State Hospital. Now it’s a decent facility full of hard working and caring nurses and doctors who care for the mentally ill. In the 80s it was a nightmare, and had been for decades (like most of the mental health facilities across the nation). Right now a brand new hospital is being built on the campus and will have the latest in tech and safety for the patients and the staff. They still send those deemed criminally insane in Texas to TSH. One of the more recent cases was Dena Schlosser, the Plano woman who killed her 10 month old daughter and chopped off that baby’s arms because “demons.”

L
Lurkielounomore · October 25, 2025

How was Jane K. Hilburn driving a 1987 Camaro in 1984?!?!?!? My brain won’t let this go 🤣 I just know Jimmy was going to ask the question my brain was screaming but NO! And then James went on to make the same assertion throughout the story. I haven’t slept since listening to

M
Michaelyn Findley · October 25, 2025

This episode just proves if someone has a knife I’d rather scream and let you stab me than go anywhere with you.

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · October 24, 2025

Lol...Figure Five!!! That's in AR on 59, just north of Van Buren, where my hubby is from!!! Went to a baby shower at the Figure Five volunteer fire dept hall!! I'm from Morrow (Lincoln), when we'd drive to Fort Smith, it was easier to take AR 59 (back before I540/I49 existed and was just the ByPass..iykyk) ...been to all those little towns, Dutch Mills, Evansville, Cedarville, Natural Dam

E
Erin Taylor · October 24, 2025

I’m from Tulsa and James got the town names right!! Owasso, Vinita, Sapulpa… Hell yeah! 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · October 24, 2025

Lol, I had an Aunt that lived "technically" in Jenks, but actually Supulpa, and she told me a long drawn out story about Supulpa and the post master 🤣

Z
Zach Hollander · October 24, 2025

Wooooooooooooooooo

D
Dalene Antionette Kruger · October 24, 2025

How are you single jimmy?????????

A
Amy Sousa · October 24, 2025

I am a 61 year old, and Jimmie you absolutely made my day when you referred to 63 year old Eddie as “a young old man.” In your own iconic words, “Hell yeah!” 😂🤍

W
Wayne Spark · October 24, 2025

Yay indeed Jimmie.

H
Hayden Powell · October 24, 2025

You guys are doing great with the town names so far! About 35 mins in!

S
Sheri Zylstra · October 24, 2025

Seems all serial killers blame everything on their childhood! Maybe in this case it’s true! James and Jimmy, as always did a great job! I can always picture the town and the criminals! Love love love this podcast!

C
Chris Larkum · October 24, 2025

I'm shocked, SHOCKED! that no one has brought up the fact that THE TALLEST HILL IN THE WORLD is in Poteau Oklahoma

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · October 24, 2025

Lol, right!!! You can literally see Cavanal Hill from anywhere in town 😆 thats about it....lol...except the casino and Walmart 🤣

R
Rainee Courtnage · October 24, 2025

What A Burger! They are in burger heaven and not much else. .

H
Heather Martin · October 24, 2025

Delusions are thoughts (like thinking you are someone else, that you are being followed, etc.). Hallucinations are senses (seeing, hearing, feeling/touch, tasting, smelling) that are not reality. Hallucinations are not "the definition of delusional".

T
True crime · October 24, 2025

OMG…my dad sent me to Beggs during my freshman year in high school! Coming in from Portland, Oregon was wild!

Z
Zachary Leatherwood · October 24, 2025

What’s up Turkeys? Loving the gruesomely awesome content & Keeping it ice free! hoping you all are too🤘🏾🤟🏾Rock on Fellas!!!

G
Grace Luterek · October 24, 2025

A shake uses milk, a malt includes malt powder.

A
Adrienne · October 24, 2025

I love malts! They are actually hard to find. When I order one a a fast food place the kids taking order just look like Jimmie says whaaaa?

S
Sydney · October 24, 2025

I’m from the area, the names are pronounced correctly. Never heard of this murder, but it happened before I was born. It’s nice (?) to hear about local crimes lol

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · October 24, 2025

Lol, came here to say the same!! Hubby's from the River Valley area on the AR side and we still live nearish in NWA. I know James DGAF about pronunciations, but he nailed all these!! Poteau and LeFlore..... haven't listened far enough, but waiting for Pushmataha to make an entrance!!

P
PadrePaul Ballin · October 23, 2025

16 years on death row is pretty quick in a 3-hour story. 😆 Great show last Saturday at the Moore Theater! ❤️👍⚾️

P
Pam Patteson · October 23, 2025

Oh my goodness I've listened for 5 years and James just said my town's name. I feel seen 🤣. I won't even comment on pronunciation 🤣🤣🤣

P
Pam Patteson · October 23, 2025

I live in the area of all these towns and you are nailing these names James 👍 spot on👏👏

m
melissa speirs · October 23, 2025

The guys said Gary was diagnosed with Bipolar. Could be manic. People can go for weeks without sleep. They are often quite high but irascible in mood.

R
Robin Church · October 23, 2025

Love the David Lee Roth impersonation!! 😁

R
Renee · October 23, 2025

The Dew Towel is a predominantly southern thing. I'm from Texas and I have numerous towels in my car for that very specific reason. 😂

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · October 24, 2025

I live in AR and have a squeegee I keep in my car, best $10 I've ever spent, just for this purpose!! Used to use microfiber towels and got tired of washing them 😆

M
Michelle Hayes · October 23, 2025

I just moved to Oklahoma in 1984, but we were in the southwest part of the state. I had no idea, as a little kid, that this happened. Great job telling the story.

A
Amilia Kelly · October 23, 2025

As someone who lives in Owasso, you nailed it James.

M
Margaret E Bounsavy · October 24, 2025

And he got Vinita too!!!

J
Jon Robinson · October 23, 2025

How do you you get a 87 Comaro in 84?

D
Dennis Kelly · October 23, 2025

That is what I am wondering too

B
Bill Boaz · October 23, 2025

First we get the terrible name Blaiden; a combo of Blaze/Blade and Aiden. Then we have Eddie Cash (Eddie Money) and Rick Ross. The names in this episode are fantastic.

L
Liz Rutherford · October 23, 2025

Yaaaay!!

T
Tee Dub · October 23, 2025

Blayden lololol

B
Brooke C · October 26, 2025

Did you say “Blayden??” Out loud like I did? 🤣🤣

C
Connor Watrous · October 23, 2025

Rough one. Just pure evil for no fucking reason

F
Felicia Tarnes · October 23, 2025

We had a blast at the Seattle show!! You need to come to Vancouver Canada 🇨🇦 see you next time

S
Samantha Boyette · October 23, 2025

Poteau is where my grandma grew up! Hardly a first class city but whatever. 😂

J
Jessica Cagnolatti · October 23, 2025

I got my best girl Brandi (dog) in Poteau!

M
Mary Sullivan · October 23, 2025

Great show in Portland; you guys are the best!!