My Imaginary Murder Friend - Riceboro, Georgia
This week, in Riceboro, Georgia, a wild story unfolds, when a dismembered body is found, deep in the woods, on a hunting preserve. It's a real mystery, especially because the dead person & their spouse have been on the run from a nefarious group, who has been threatening, and harrassing the couple. Luckily, they had an FBI agent, helping them with every step. But is the agent real? And was the wife really pregnant? Is this all the imagination of a very sick individual?
Along the way, we find out that rice can be grow in Georgia, that you should never let a shadowy FBI figure control every aspect of your life, and that you shouldn't construct your life to be one gigantic lie, or murder people!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com
THE HALLOWEEN SHOW!!! 10/30/2025 @ 9:00 PM Eastern Time
Get your tickets on moment.co/smalltownmurder
Tickets are $20.
Video Playback will be available for 2 weeks after the live event.
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (151)
The ease and rapidity with which this man lies is the stuff of LEGEND
"Ford Exploder"!! I can't believe that one had 🦗🦗🦗🦗, Jimmy. I laughed so hard I woke up my sleeping dog. I appreciated it...🤗😘
It’s possible Mindi actually believed she was pregnant. It’s called pseudocyesis, and you believe it so hard you actually gain weight, have all the regular pregnancy symptoms, up to and including milk production and feeling like a baby is kicking.
This is such a bonkers case. Looking through smaller discussions on the reddit communities he frequented, Nick told a *lot* of people his wife died of COVID in 2020, years before her death. People he knew in person. He had a lot of friends from the Internet and went to baby showers and invited them to his wedding. Many people cannot merge the real Nick and his public persona(s). They genuinely think he went round the bend or was scammed. It's so sad.
I lived in Hinesville for 2 years. There is NOTHING to do there unless you enjoy Applebee's and chilis 😂 it's a military town and all the locals hate you if you're not from there.
I think the best line was Jimmy exclaiming: “OVERSEAS HACKERS ARE PUTTING NAILS IN TIRES???” 😂
He was innocent. He was scammed.
By who?
Agent Jim is better known as Pepe Silvia.
Love Jimmy's comment on "no tattoo"!! Lol, just love it!! And James saying handing money to draw on you... just love you guys!!!
Nick was born in the city that I currently live in. His parents did the smart thing and LEFT!
Do you think FBI Jim and CIA Chris from Mountain City, TN ever crossed paths? 😅
Taken me too long to listen to episodes on patreon always used Spotify thanks James and Jimmie for this added advert free option
Omg I remember watching this trial. The dude was a fucking weirdo, I hope the boys made it out of Portland. I was told it’s a war zone and that the military needs to make their presence known 🙄
I watched this whole trial online and it was something else this man is annoying as all get out! His blinking and facial ticks were really hard to watch. Worst liar ever and so many believes him. Crazy.
The blinking was WIIIIIIIILD
Remember the movie Blank Check where the kid said he was working for Mr. McIntosh? I wonder if that was the inspiration
James, stop trying to rewrite history. The Italians fought with the Nazis. 😆. Just because they were really incompetent doesn't make them the good guys.
I took that to mean the people- the citizens were glad the Nazis were kicked out. The citizens didn’t want to join up with the Nazis, the majority were opposed to it and thousands of those who spoke against Mussolini were famously executed. I’m betting the people of Italy were thrilled when Mussolini was overthrown and Italy joined the Allies in ‘43
I really don’t know what I’d do without this podcast. James and Jimmie have really gotten me through this last year. Bless you guys! 🙏🫶
What a good story this was. Well told. Love you guys!
I’ve always thought that at the very least, all the tattoos I have make it easier for me to be identified or just made it more horrible for myself. 🥸
It was a shame when they took JAG off😏
I remember watching with my grandparents. I love NCIS...and I'm not 70! 😂
My Great-grandma was a gullah geechee. This is the first self-sustaining black community off the coast of GA post transatlantic slave trade. They just won a big court case fighting hilton to put a huge golf course in the area which would ultimately make the cost of living much more expensive .
That’s great to hear.
Is it just me or does this sound like something that they have already told before or a story similar?
I kinda feel the same way. Like the guy kept shifting the girl around under some pretext and she finally saw in in an off track betting joint. Things fell apart then. Maybe I'm high...
That Jim McIntyre guy sounds extraordinary. I love episodes like this one where the murderer thinks he’s the smartest person in every room.
Can anyone please help me find the time stamp where he made the court room laugh? I don’t want to watch his entire thing
2hr 32min
Nooo! Not Captain "Slows" Joe's!
Dear God, I work in Riceboro. Never thought this comer of rural GA would grace my favourite podcast 😳
Their rental house is the next block over from me.
I'd love to see an internet salad live please.
You get bonus points per ValuePack coupon envelope!
You get bonus points per ValuePack coupon envelope!
If you ever want to get spaghetti stains out of Tupperware, just put a damp paper towel and a pump of dish soap into it, put the lid on, and shake for like 20 seconds. Magic.
The name "Dottie Peoples" just unlocked childhood memories of riding to church for the 4th time in a week.
This was the one STM that I expected James to say “GRACE”
He may have lied about a lot of things, but he really is a jagoff-icer.
SIR.
300k for a short story? On reddit? Yeah, that's definitely the point where you know its all bullshit. Most legit publications barely offer you 10 cents a word. And that's if they agree to publish you. No way in hell a reddit post gets optioned by a studio. Not even Stephen King himself could get that.
One of your best side-kick performances, Jimmie. I love it when you are understatedly funny, rather than crude and manic. Really enjoyed this episode, congratulations to both of you on an excellent show.
We got a really similar case to this guy in Minnesota... Look up Byron David Smith, a retired State Dept. 'security engineer'. He lived in Little Falls, MN & he was one fucked up individual. Anyhow, he killed two teenagers because he thought they were breaking in his house to get him. He was BEYOND paranoid. I doubt there's any help for people that far gone, sadly so, but probably true?
Ooooh this case is SO awful.
I just heard this insanity on dateline! 😭😭😭😭
Which Dateline was this, if you don't mind my asking?
I find all the crimes you cover fascinating, but I have to say the Riceboro story is in a class by itself! Geeez!!!!
I've heard James say "this is crazy" and he never disappoints. But this is definitely the craziest thing I've heard!
As a kid, I lived in Sicily with the military. Many many years before this guy was there. But always cool to have that connection.
Nick was born in Chambersburg, PA. I live there. My hometown is 20 miles from there. I hit the back button 3 times to be sure that I heard James correctly!
Could it be that Mindi suspected him of cheating (she saw the charges for 4 new tires, he's always gone, he bought a NEW bottle of Old Spice) and just told him she was pregnant to try to save the marriage? Then he killed her when he realized she wasn't pregnant. Also, I doubt the ex-wife got to give an impact statement, but if she did, I hope she got up, pulled out her notes, and said, "You still owe me $1.5M, asshole." Then turned around and went back to her seat. GREAT STORY!!
100% agree with Jimmy on the tattoos. It’s unique to not have one these days if you’re between 35-45
I got my first one in 1990. My dad told me that I was going to look stupid with that on my arm whenever I'm the only one in the old folks home. Especially since I've never been in the military. Joke's on you, Pop!
This story hurt my head! I think I was confused the whole time! 🤣
PS Black wall hitch is gross. It’s a chain around the DMV. I’m so glad I missed this terrible man around here.
VT shooting was in 2007 . Wild times, I was there
This story is so crazy, omg.
I watched parts of the trial and this was one smug, pissy asshole, also one of the most compulsive liars I’ve seen. Search it out on YouTube, it’s completely worth it! You guys gave this douche the treatment he deserved, bravo!
Or did the agent really exist and this guy took the fall…..
At first I thought this might be another surprise twist like the home invasion/murder epsiode with the praying murderers, but it's even weirder than that because he wasn't even pocket robin insane, just fully committed to his story to the very end. Maybe not crazy, but certainly delusional. Great epsiode!
I have to stop drinking coffee when I’m listening to these episode. I always have a spit take!🤣🤣🤣☕️☕️☕️⚰️
I listen at work and will start roaring with laughter in a quiet office. The best part is my laughter intrigued coworkers enough to the point where I have converted several people from a true crime podcast created by a pretentious, woman hating douche nozzle to my guys here.
My ex husband stole almost $300,000 from my mom before she noticed because she trusted him. People are nuts, great show as always.
It must be weird to be named "Savannah" and listen to this episode
I can confirm James is correct. I ship rocket launchers to war zones for the government and I don’t use that much secrecy. Not even close. This dudes wild.
WTF! He got 2 law degrees, practiced law, and went sideways. He is fascinating and outrageous - and disgusting. This one had me riveted. And there wasn’t even any meth!
And he had no clue about his truck's GPS!
Man, the people around Nick were VERY trusting and didn't like asking questions at all.
He turned her into a chihuahua had me cracking up. Now how did the wife fool her mom and dad into thinking she was pregnant too? Did she wear a prosthetic belly?
L
This was so 6 7 of you guys. The aura is crazy
You guys are fucking assholes and I LOVE IT!! Keep being you fellas!!
Im so lost. I have to listen to this multiple times
Same. It was WILD!
OMG Jimmy cracking me up in this one! Co-workers think I’m crazy smiling and laughing to myself !
In all fairness, Hinesville is local to Ft. Stewart and any local town out of a military base will have "nightlife" and it's usually pretty wild. Listening to the rest now.....
Btw, anxiously awaiting Ludowici to come into this story, just to hear y'all try to pronounce it. Stranger things have happened. Somerset KY hit your Whitley City episode and that's a hot minute apart.
https://www.linkedin.com/company/apis-technology-llc/
Anyone else think she was ‘pregnant’ because he told her that it was safer for her? That ‘the people’ that were after them wouldn’t attack a pregnant woman? She then would be kept away from friends/family/outside as that made her feel bad to lie to them. Keeping her more under his control.
I was thinking something similar, yeah. That had to be his idea.
Favorite one-liners from this episode: “He’s turned her into a chihuahua.” “Ford Exploder!?” 🤣🤣🤣
LL.M.s are advanced law degrees that basically educate you to specialize in more specific types of law after you graduate from law school with your J.D.
I imagine the FBI Agent being a shapeshifter in the same way Gene Parmasian in Arrested Development is.
Aahhh Gene!!!
Hahahaha JAGOFFICER
Ok Cupid..geez 😆
I am the 3rd in my family but I knew there would be no 4th haha
I was waiting for James to say he wasnt really a Jag and never served in the navy....
Jimmie why’d you call out james on the house like that? I laughed so hard… “and that’s how that’s how that goes.”
Well, snufflelufages, lolol, I was called this as a kid lololol
For some reason I thought James had tattoos. I’m 48 and have never had a tattoo either. Mainly because I’m a wuss 😂
44 here and no tattoos. Mostly because I’m so indecisive that I just know I’ll get something and then hate it six months later. 😂
Wooooooooooooooooo
This whole story sounds like a fever dream
The Swanee Quintet was James Brown favorite group to listen to. Dottie Peoples is a gospel legend. Brown and Wild rice are outstanding.
I'm 45 and have been with NCIS since season 5. Season 23 just started on Tuesday.
NCIS is a spinoff of JAG
The Tech shooting was in 2006/2007. I was in college at GMU in Fairfax, VA when it happened, I remember the news.
LOL... This story was on Minds of Madness on Sunday. But of course this version goes a lot more into detail!
Finally it happened! I was raised in hinesville for like ten years. Unless you find a murder in Ludowici, GA or Elmira, NY… this is the closest I’m getting to an episode of my “hometown” 😂
Found the reviews for Blackwell Hitch and they do not disappoint lol
Little tip for removing red sauce stains from plastic containers: fold up a paper towel and place it at the bottom of the container; add a few drops of liquid dawn dish soap and a little bit of water; swish the container around somewhat vigorously and watch the magic happen! Now, could this technique also be applied to blood that has seeped into a plastic tote container? My lawyer has advised me not to answer. 😉
“JagOFFicer” When James said it, I immediately thought, maybe that’s what Jagoff means 🤷♂️.
I might have went to college with his second wife. I went to Armstrong in 2000 before ga southern bought it.
I was SA’d in uniform, aboard ship by a shipmate in 2001. Still did 20, but the act and way it was handled has really messed me up. This sailor has tats. lol
God, my dad is retired navy, and I was the only 5 year old catching every episode of JAG.
Omg some of us are veterans and we like watching the uniform shows-David James Elliot and Catherine Bell rocked some USMC uniforms
I’m 38 and haven’t gotten a tattoo Jimmie. 😋
An LLM is a Masters Degree in law, a specialist advanced degree in tax, evidence, appeals, etc.
Loved that Jimmy was laughing at Jame's misfortune. I guess gotta laugh through the pain, haha!!
I met my wife on Okcupid and we've been together since 2014 hahahaha 😂
I dated a girl from ok Cupid back in like 2013.
I just heard this case on a serious true crime podcast and thought “I would love for STM to do this one” and I woke up and my wish came true!
Deers don’t have toes
More people than a 93 Arrested Development concert 😂 Best description ever 😂 I instantly saw their Unplugged stage in my head. It's a specific reference for a person of a certain age and it's why I love you guys. Also, AD is good shit. I played the hell out of that album; I know what I'm listening to once I finish the podcast!
The Virginia Tech shooting happened in April 2007. I’m a couple years younger than the guys I think, and that’s the year my husband graduated.
You can’t live with people your not fucking 😂😂😂😂😂 I’m dying I need a shirt asap
Without even knowing it James hit it right because NCIS was a spin off of JAG. My grammy loved those shows. They were on for most her life so makes sense
And that is literally all I know of Jag but I have seen just about every episode of NCIS
As soon as I heard the guy’s name I knew the case. I watched this guy’s trial live. He was very smug throughout the trial expecting to get off.
I dont have any tattoos, i have t shirts. 1979
THIS FUCKIN GUY 🤯
Crime in sports is how i found podcast over 10 years ago. I searched Riddick Bowe. I was thinking of the old SNES game. It was the shit. I keep this sub now because we get add free without downloading Wondery. They pushed that murderer luigi had as fuck for months. 3 adds in your shows. I almost stopped listening. Thank you for this option.
They should review anything that man has ever touched in the Navy…
His mom said he helped children in South America. Mom should double check on that, I bet he was on vacation or something. instead.
I watched this trial too! His story was fucking bonkers, but he sure stuck to it. He reminded me of Nancy Brophy. So confident spewing bullshit.
Total Nancy Brophy! UGH
My grandma loved watching JAG! David James Elliott was a gorgeous specimen of man then and is aging like a fine wine now.
I small immersed in politics all day everyday. I come to Shut Up to laugh and get relief from the political upheaval. So glad to support vyour freedom of soeech
OMG, don’t call it vah tech lmao we hate that 😂
I was coming here to post that!
Dusk til Dawn! Great movie.
Wow this story is wild! I'm an hour 40 in and I can't wait for the puzzle pieces to come together
I also have no idea what's going on a hour in 🤣
Yaaaay!!
OkCupid in 2016 was amazing! I had success there back then. It adapted the swipe model and it’s gone to shit since.
LLM is a masters level law degree - like an MA, except for law
Halfway through and anxious because I know this case and the buildup is killing me! I just LOVE the way you guys tell this. Thanks James for the research 🙏🙏🙏
Love the Turkmenisan hammering the nail in the tire. Completely makes sense, international terrorism is so focused on small details. First we'll tap the phones, then we'll flatten their tires. Demonic 👳♂️
I’m really an old person at heart 🤣 I loved watching JAG with my parents and watched the shit out of the original NCIS for several years. I’m well under 70….what does this mean for my future? 😅
I have to read more . Lol oh my god
I just saw that piezano pizza cooker for $99.99 with free shipping. I did not order it.
The Gullah Geechee culture inspired the children's show Gullah Gullah Island in the 90s. A very nostalgic and cute show! What a surprise to hear them mentioned here; for some reason I thought they only had roots in North/South Carolina.
I worked in Riceboro. I hope they dunk on this backwards ass town.
From the Midwest.. “dunk on that town”.. wtf does that mean, salt the earth or something?
Yippee!!!
I wanna hear them do.the Heidt murders in Effingham, ga. That case was scandalous around here
That's like 45 minutes from me. Can't wait to listen. Been through there a couple of times. Not much to look at
FeeYOO! This one sounds deliciously bewildering; I am at attention...all ears (and beak).
