💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
Face Eating Frat Boy - Tequesta, Florida (1 of 2)
September 26, 2025

Face Eating Frat Boy - Tequesta, Florida

This week, in Tequesta, Florida, an absolutely insane, and horrific pair of murders is interrupted by a neighbor, who also gets attacked. The murders are incredibly horrendous, with knives, a machete, and is finished off, with an attempt to eat the faces off of the victims. It's a crazy act, by a young man, who seems to have gone crazy, claiming superpowers, and that he is chased by demons, and is half dog, among some even stranger beliefs!! Will he be mentally competent to stand trial??

Along the way, we find out that you don't exactly have to be a "celebrity" to be a "celebrity judge", that blacking out form drinking, on a daily basis is not a good sign, and that you should never drink from random garage containers, and just assume that it's alcohol!!

Watch Will Forte in the animated series, Haunted Hotel, on Netflix! Premieres September 19th!!

New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!

Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

Follow us on...

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

Comments (64)

A
Allie Woelke · October 7, 2025

The half dead Minotaur bit was hilarious

S
Shelly · October 2, 2025

My ex-husband & I had meth issues in 2006/2007. Even with a week or so of coming down, he was still super paranoid. When he was high though, it was scary af! I 100% believe some people’s brains aren’t capable of surviving. They do a little too much & end up perma-tweaked. I’m not without lasting consequences, but I never thought the shadow people were lurking, the FBI were sitting outside of my window or that the evil spirits living in the wall were coming to get me. 😅

B
Braylen · October 1, 2025

So does the victims family have to live through a nightmare every 6 months on the chance this piece of shit will be released?

C
Casey · October 1, 2025

My hometown 😭

J
Jessica Cagnolatti · October 1, 2025

The garage thing is huge in Texas too!

A
Akilah Bailey · September 30, 2025

I absolutely Love "Yay, and Choo Choo", everytime I hear it.

U
Unemployed_History_Major · September 30, 2025

lol I was a FSU frat boy just before this guy got there 😂 can confirm, there are multiple meth filled trailer parks very close by. And I too have been drunk at the library my guy. PARTY AT STROZ!!!

T
Teamrocket · September 29, 2025

This guy sounds like my abusive ex. The drugs, the drinking, the schizophrenia in the family.

L
Lesley Harper · September 29, 2025

“PARMESAN DID THIS!?”

R
Ryan Fenton · September 29, 2025

The messages this guy sent to folks are the best. They are hyped to do meth in a trailer part hahahaha

D
Dawn · September 29, 2025

It's a douchy area!!! Nailed it 😄

N
Nik · September 30, 2025

Spot on 😂

C
Cosmo's ma · September 28, 2025

I've heard this story many times before and NEVER was told about the text messages. Great show guys! Always the most research ed episodes

S
Shannon Hoffmeyer · September 28, 2025

I always quote this case when I give an example of white boy privilege. HE ATE THEIR FACES AND WALKED AWAY ALIVE. Guarantee if he was down and brown this would not have been the outcome. Shame on his family for not getting him help.

J
Justin Simmons · September 30, 2025

Exactly. He would have been dead in that garage, right next to his victims.

K
Karlee Osborne · September 28, 2025

I legit live 15 minutes away from Tequesta 😅 how can I find out where that guy is held and if he’s ever getting out? 😬

N
Nik · September 30, 2025

Fdle inmate search, you’ll get all that information.

D
Dorothy B · September 28, 2025

There is definitely coke in that community. And pills. And wife-swapping.

Q
Quinn Ales · September 28, 2025

You guys are amazing. The last episode with the serial killer…. How the f$&@ do you find these cases, James!? Better question, why hadn’t the loco Lucy been publicized before you guys covered him. Simply perfection in a podcast. From NW Indiana with love. ❤️

J
Justin Simmons · September 30, 2025

❤️ also from NW Indiana lol

K
Kira Nevaeh · September 28, 2025

Minotaur is half bull half man. You’re thinking Centaur Jimmy 🙂

J
Jean West · September 28, 2025

Omg hahahahaha too funny!

J
JoBu · September 27, 2025

You know who lives there? New Yorkers! Tons of em. Add in the Massholes along with a few others from the surrounding states and you’ve got a douche transplant paradise. Why do you think the home prices are so high? 😂

S
Smalls (smallenoughtofit) · September 27, 2025

911 operators *always* ask your name nowadays. I dont know if it's to see if you're calling from their phone vs yours or to pass your name along to PD and FD if applicable, but they always ask. It might be just to clarify who called if they need to circle back for witness statements down the line

c
chiefkeefin2013 · September 27, 2025

god this bender i’ve been on sounds a lot like this frat bros life

J
Jen Dana · September 27, 2025

Been obsessed w this case forever! Psyched as fuck you did it! I'm still in the first 1 min and I'm already psyched.

D
Dr Phil Goode 👹🌲🔥 · September 27, 2025

Lol, I 4got I had this ass hole on. I prescribed another bowl of cooking oil, Parmesan and some shredded sharp cheddar.

L
Lorne · September 27, 2025

Was this event not known outside Florida? I'm from Florida but already moved abroad in 2014 and still heard about this. I never realised anyone didn't know about it. (Also somehow never realised the attacker was younger than me!)

J
Jessica Long · September 27, 2025

And now I realize if I did become a cop I would have been the First Woman officer to arrive and shot him. I’ve seen enough true crime and scary movies to not act fast!

D
Darren Jenkins · September 27, 2025

Tequesta is a very restricted neighborhood to the working class, especially black people. The black population in Tequesta, FL, is very small, with sources indicating percentages between 0.1% and 1.45%. More recent data from Census Reporter shows 0%† Black population, while World Population Review from 2025 lists it at 0.1%. [1, 2, 3, 4] Recent Estimates (2025 Data) [1] • According to World Population Review, the black population in Tequesta is 0.1%. Other Data Points • Census Reporter Data: Lists the black population at 0%†, though it notes a 0.1% percentage point in the "race & ethnicity" section. [4] • Wikipedia Data (2010 Census): Showed a black population of 0.5% in Tequesta. [2] • Tequesta Corporate Center Data: Lists a 1.45% black or African American population out of the total population. [3] AI responses may include mistakes. [1] https://worldpopulationreview.com/us-cities/florida/tequesta [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tequesta,_Florida [3] https://www.tequestacorporatecenter.com/about_jupiter [4] https://censusreporter.org/profiles/16000US1271525-tequesta-fl/

G
Gail Tena · September 27, 2025

Wow. Just wow

E
Elizabeth · September 27, 2025

When I went to college, Alpha Delt was the worst behaving fraternity on campus. I believe they were actually kicked off campus at one point.

J
Jes Grynevich · September 29, 2025

They were kicked out of my school - some absolute bangers of parties tho lol

C
Cia Rising · September 27, 2025

Maybe the craziest yet. I wonder where the perp’s family moved to avoid the press.

L
Lizzy J · September 27, 2025

Some of my favorite episodes are when the boys have hilarious tangents that just show their relationship and amazing comic timing. I always appreciate the effort and research for the story itself, but even in a murder episode that involves face-eating, the two moments I’ll remember best: James lowering his garage door on his neighbor stopping by. “Dragging a dead horse around for eternity” 👏🏼 amazing.

J
Jamie Hertter · September 27, 2025

I'm giggling at how a cath lab is a cardiac intervention unit, not a catheter for urinating, and how I was so confused about why they'd be shoving chili in your c*cks!

A
Abby Amsel · September 27, 2025

I work in cardiology and snorted laughing so hard.

A
Amy Jennejohn · September 27, 2025

Take it easy Glenn Frey 😆 🤣 😂

S
Stephanie Burt · September 27, 2025

Well, James and Jimmy don't like the heat, I'm from Canada, where it's cold from October to April, I welcome the heat whenever I can! I went to Florida for a vacation back in 2010, and I loved it! . I was shocked when I seen people wearing a toque in Sept, early October. Sorry u don't like the heat James! I just wish, I could come see you guys in person, but I'm poor lol, but I'm buying ticket this year to see you guys online ! You can probably find lots of mistakes here, cause , I guess as you guys say, I'm a hillbilly, lol. Us Newfies have a very particular way of taking.

E
EnrichHardInTheSlightest · September 27, 2025

This was fucking WILD

A
Alecia Mosley · September 27, 2025

“PARMESAN DID THIS!?” 😂 that killed me.

J
Joe Reaves · September 27, 2025

This may be the first time ever I skip one of your episodes. I know which case this is and it freaks me out.

Z
Zach Hollander · September 27, 2025

Wooooooooooooooooo

C
Cassie Gilbert · September 27, 2025

Omg I live there. I remember this. I am so listening to this. I can’t wait for all of what the both of you have to say.

c
chris pavin · September 27, 2025

Here's a "cheery" thought... with the way hospitals and mental health wards are disappearing in rural Florida, this guy and all of his roommates will be let out on Florida's streets soon. Which means....more crazy murders for the guys to tell us about....YAY????

M
Mark Nixon · September 27, 2025

We are not okay!! But great and crazy episode!!

C
Crowded Crow · September 27, 2025

Untricked! Nevertheless, I'm only 26 minutes in and this ol' weathered (and feathered) heart is sinking. I've heard tell of this case a few times; as expected, James is providing richer detail, as well as fleshing out the humanity of each of the people involved. It's good, but it's bad; it makes me feel sad (der). Be careful out there, Turkeys, and love the one you're with! Hi-fuckin'-YAH!!

S
Sheila Garcia · September 27, 2025

The fake cry! Love hearing the audio!

A
Allie Woelke · October 7, 2025

The fake Boo Hoo ing was hilarious. And James kept saying “that’s not me, that’s him” hahaha

B
Blake · September 27, 2025

I actually worked at a local restaurant where the dishwasher did something similar (schizophrenia and crack). The owner found him walking down a highway in the next town (12 miles away) in just a T-shirt and underwear saying he was headed to the mothership. I would give him rides from time to time. One day he walked to my house at 6am, woke me up banging on the door, and wanted to know if I’d like to smoke crack with him. I said no thanks but I’ll smoke a joint with you and then give you a ride home. Good thing I didn’t have this show back then.

C
Candie Neibert-Caldwell · September 27, 2025

“Belly full of a Canola” and “Kicken HIGH” got me!!

Z
Zachary Leatherwood · September 27, 2025

What’s up Turkeys?! Brilliant content fellas🤙🏾 keep this murder train chugging!

7
70Boss302 · September 27, 2025

I really want ChooChoo to be Jimmie's safe word 🥳

c
chris pavin · September 27, 2025

I play Jimmies choo choo at half speed. He sounds drunk as fuck.

B
Blake · September 27, 2025

Just bought my tickets for the Seattle show.

P
PadrePaul Ballin · September 27, 2025

I'll be there. Hopefully it'll be a day off for the M's in the playoffs

R
Robyn Francis · September 27, 2025

Hahaha! Cath lab!

C
Cameron Smith · September 27, 2025

Just an fyi - cath lab is minimally invasive cardiac surgeries 🤣 not dick hole stuff 🤣🤣🤣 love it

R
Raven Knickerbocker · September 27, 2025

Lol CATDIAC Cath lab. No pee holes. But if you're not in the medical field, that's totally the first thing to come to mind. Love you guys!

H
Heather Igelman · September 26, 2025

I’ve heard this one covered a lot… I can’t wait to listen because I’m sure they’ll do it better than anyone

J
Jon Brown (yes, real name) · September 26, 2025

How did I know when I see "face-eating", I knew? Florida.

J
Jeremy Doran · September 27, 2025

lol. Nice

J
Jen Ward · September 26, 2025

Choo choo, motherfuckers!

L
Lana Mccarthy · September 26, 2025

Love you