Brilliant Brutality - Prairie Village, Kansas
This week, in Prairie Village, Kansas, a wildly intelligent doctor hands in their medical license, amid a failing marriage, and begins to lose their mind, while slipping into a world of alcohol, drugs, strange threats. This all escalates into one crazy evening, and two murders, that are so brutal, that the town has to change all the street addresses! Was it insanity, or just the most cold blooded crime imaginable?
Along the way, we find out that "Mr Stinky Feet" sounds like a crazy musical act, that just becasue people are both highly intelligent doctors, doesn't mean that they'll get along, and that when you refer to someone in the past tense, too soon, it says you just may be a murderer!!
New episodes, every Wednesday & Friday nights!!
Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or at paypal.com and use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com
THE HALLOWEEN SHOW!!! 10/30/2025 @ 9:00 PM Eastern Time
Get your tickets on moment.co/smalltownmurder
Tickets are $20.
Video Playback will be available for 2 weeks after the live event.
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!
Follow us on...
Also, check out James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!
Comments (85)
Words were spoken
And this bitch wants to be a psychiatrist. Yikes 😳 she's a malignant narcissist oh yeah and a murderer.
This case was a tough one to listen to.
Don't want to make shit political in the comments, BUUUT, FUCKING STOP VOTING REPUBLICANS SO THAT TEACHERS CAN HAVE A LIVING WAGE!! For real, republicans have been GUTTING the edu system in this country for DECADES, and everyone really can't put it together FSS. VOTE FOR PEOPLE WHO WANT YOUR KIDS TO BE EDUCATED. Otherwise each generation of kids that gets less and less invested into them, and more and more kids are getting left behind, and everyone's mad that shit costs more and teachers have to buy everything, well then STOP VOTING FOR BAD PEOPLE that want your kids to be stupid so they can be easily manipulated. The reason you have to donate every year is because they have wrenched every possible penny of funding away from Education, to put it into dumb, short-sighted BULLSHIT like a border wall and more military spending, and spending millions of dollars worth of tax-payer money to send bombs to Israel that they can use to kill women and children! WHAT THE FUCK ARE WE DOING ANYMORE??????!!!!!! End Rant.
This evil bitch! This story makes me furious. Those poor kids. 😭
I just have to say the other woman left that earring on purpose. 1000%
I’m go smacked every time I hear the real estate report. When James and Jimmy talk about yhe cost of an apartment snd balk at $1700 for a two bedroom i giggle. I live in Oakland CA and my 2 bedroom is $3,400 a month lol
This man was my grandfather's heart surgeon for years. He had a calm quiet presence. He was an amazing doctor. May he rest in peace.
This is the reason why my wife always gets a 2nd opinion
Did anyone catch the name of the book?
Bitter Harvest
I’ve met this lady. Whole thing is a sad travesty. Probably the saddest story I’ve heard you guys cover.
Did James choke up? 💔 This fucking lady
I read that book. Great retelling
My son's almost 13 and I couldn't imagine losing him in that way. 🥺
Much love mark
Typhoid Sprue is fucking killing me right now!
No “Breaking Bad” references at ALL in this episode ????!!!!
I was looking for this comment
I have read all of Ann Rules books except this one. Back when I read her books my son was a little boy and I knew it would be to emotional for me. My son is 26 now 😊
You know shit is gearing up when James starts dropping time stamps in the story
Isn't Prarie Village where Suanne Hobson (489 - Psycho Stepmom - Edgerton, Kansas) and her husband Ed lived when the murder took place and she moved back after she was paroled?? I think the town was all up in arms about it!! What's up with these moms there??? 🙃
The audacity of this bitch
Another excellent episode! Thanks, guys. You rock!
OMG!!! I worked with a doctor who lived in this area and KNEW the doctor in this story!!!!
Same here.
LOL I live right next to here and it’s known as “perfect village”
Crime free beautiful Johnson County
Not many of your episodes make me physically ill and/or gasp....this one did.
James saying being a kid hearing about your toxic parent bullshit. I feel that. James is a solid guy, Sarah is lucky lucky! And Jimmy’s day one to now: Jimmy’s evolution has been WILD. His professionalism, his awareness, his comments and outlook on life I can tell have grown and evolved so much. Even how they talk to each other. Their respect has grown. I still haven’t found a better podcast. Their yin and yang is the perfect combo.
I always said Jimmie is not as dumb as he says he is. They are stand up guys and it has been great to see their evolution. This is pretty much how I learn about the “off the beaten track” places of America that I will NEVER go to when I eventually get over there! The two of them and their tangents are like my best and I when we get together.
I always love and appreciate Jimmie’s responses, especially, sigh okay. 😂
If you hadn't heard some cunt gettin called a fuck hole before '96, you clearly aren't Australian. Love your work guys 👍🏻
I dont think I've heard it before this episode! Lol. But I remember a neighbor mom calling people, usually kids, a touchhole
3 Gap Or B Gap ? Stupid...
Glamour Profession was on Gaucho. And yes, because of the complexity of Dan, it would take 11 including horns. The last tour in the 70s had Becker. Fagan, McDonald, Procaro, Dias, Baxter, Hodder, and two backup singers. And I bet they have horns as well. The layers of overdubs are incredible on Aja and Katy Lied.
Deborah is a textbook sociopath
What a horrible person. How could a mother do that?!
How could a HUMAN do that????? Im sick
💔
The ballet games lol
I noticed that also 😂
What a heartbreaker of an episode. Those poor kids.
My husband used to pilot trains. It’s not simple by any means lol I also thought it would be
I read the book. What an evil bitch.
I love it when James and Jimmie break each other’s balls. Glad to hear you don’t have cancer, Jimmie! Thanks for making sure that was cleared up, James! 😅
Damn my wife works at Kansas State women's prison. She said she is a bitch
This episode brought back a horrible memory, my adopted Aunt and her 5 children died in a fire that she ran back in to save 3 of her children that she didn't see but sadly the 2 that could walk followed her. She didn't at that point thought "i think" wasn't that bad so she was carrying the baby when she ran back in, and sadly found out to late that is was bad.
Like I’m a Japanese subway lmaoooo
“It’s a book, so I doubt it.” 🤣
Yelling at servers is a BRIGHT red flag. I’m out immediately if someone does that.
I went to an eye dr named Dr Weed. 🤣
My son wants to be a teacher. He want to help kids. And he is only ten. But before that he wanted to be a refrigerator.
I listened to smalltown murder all the time during the day when I’m working. I love the show some of the shit that comes out of Jimmy’s mouth is absolutely fucking hilarious. Like I’ve said before another forms you should come up with a new podcast called. Jimmy does simple math. Lol just fucking with you Jimmy.
After 20 years in special education—both in the classroom and in therapy roles—I can’t tell you how much it means to me (and makes me love James even more) to hear that he supports teachers by helping them purchase items for their classrooms. Love you guys!
Retired SpEd teacher here, and I agree 100%!! Seriously this means so much.
At minute 45: I would’ve said, “Bing, what’re you doing here I thought I told you go to fuck your mother.”
I had a surgeon once whose husband was my anesthesiologist. Baffling to me 😅
She sounds like an autistic woman with serious burnout
100% autistic and burned out, AND a really awful person.
As an ICU nurse - Deborah would hate to see me coming and I’d hate to see her coming 😂
As a former med-surg nurse, she wouldn't have seen me at all 😅
25 min mark is why I love these guys! I’ve been working at a school with special needs children for awhile now and I end up going out of pocket for them quite often as well. You guys are great!!!
Yay! I’m glad you guys did this episode. I worked with Dr Michael Farrar. He was the nicest doc I ever worked with. If you had a question he’d take the time to answer it. He always treated people with such respect. I could see why he tried to make things work for his kids, the saddest part is she has convinced the surviving daughter she’s innocent and didn’t do this. I feel for the child who’s grown now with her own children.
At this moment, Debora sounds autistic to me. I'm a third of the way through the episode.
I haven't even finished the episode, but it's the best one in a while. It was obvious that they've been stressed out the last month or so, and this sounds more relaxed and fun. I love the little nuggets from their lives.
I can totally relate to the kids. My mom used to use me as a sounding board. And complain about my dad it sucks!
Leslie Easterbrook went to Stephens
I've had the Typhoid Sprue for yeeaaarrrss 🤒
Wooooooooooooooooo
The synopsis for Necessary Lies that James shared was actually for a 2013 book of the same name. There is a 1995 book of that name which is likely the right one, though I can't find much about it and whether or not it involves a fire. It is written by Janice Daugharty, who also wrote an essay in 2010 titled- get this- "Castor Bean Seeds". Craziest coincidence EVER.
Goal met...I've been listening to you for 5 years and have never found a podcast I like besides you before or after. Have traveled to see you live and subscribe to Patreon. James and Jimmie are the absolute best 💖
My elderly Border Collie loved your show and it was the only thing she wanted to listen to at night - she just passed suddenly yesterday and this episode is 20 min from where we live it feels a little like she sent this one to me
All the Hugs for your broken heart. I know she was the Goodest Girl
I know this story front to back, but I’m still stoked(!), because it’ll feel like a new case to me, thanks to James and Jimmie’s take.
2 posts again. Just double the fun
Been wondering how long it would take for a place I’ve lived to show up on here!
ha HA! Not tricked, again! This one sounds like a kettle full of treats... and this turkey (emu) loves a layered kettle.
YAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYY!!!
YAAAAYYYYYYYYYY
Excited for the bonus episode!
Excited, got some family up in KC…I mean Prairie Village
That's a good lookin' pup you got there, Moose!
Patreon sucks giant fucking donkey balls for downloading episodes.
Why?
