* Early Access * - Comparing Quantizers
Hey guys!
So this was the chosen idea for this month, and I have to say, I needed it :) I discovered a few interesting quantizers so thank you for this.
Thanks again for your support!
Comments (8)
So, yes!! The XOR quantizer with it's "semitone" output did the job for me! I saw it in the video, but it did not work for me...? So after your answer I watched your video again and then I found the reason. The XOR quantizer 'normal' output must be connected to something simultaneously (scope, tuner, ... doesn't matter what) otherwise the 'semitone' output does not work! I don't know whats the reason for that, but that was my fault. I wonder why not more quantizers have that "force to one octave option"? I think it's pretty useful. E.g. to attenuate the voltage with a vca does not fit for me all the time. So, thanks for your help.
Oh nice, I'm glad it works :) What do you mean with the VCA?
Thanks for the video. I like the format of comparing different modules of the same brand. Very informative. Is there a quantizer which ignores the octaves? So he puts out all notes in just one octave. E.g. D4 becomes D2, F5 becomes F2 etc..
Hey, thanks, I'm glad you liked it :) You can try using the one from the XOR (it's in the video also), it has an octave output which will just output the octaves. You can also use Quantum for example and have only one note active so it will play the octaves according to the incoming signal. There are other ways as well but let me know if this works for you :)
There are more quantizers than I suspected...thanks so mush Omri for this glimpse into them......
yes, wow, there are so many and each one is unique in it's own way...
Good video Omri. I was just using several of those yesterday. Here's a question for you: are the note frequencies standardized throughout VCV? That is, are all quantizers (or any note generator) supposed to use the exact same frequencies for each note? I ask because I spent a LOT of time yesterday trying to figure out why a patch wasn't generating the right melody notes I was trying to use. After a lot of testing the various modules I was using, it turned out that the repelzen RE-WIN I was using was producing an unexpected note (see https://www.dropbox.com/s/ygyhfle8k05yaxm/20190908-re-win-test.vcv?dl=0 ) when its Mode was set to UP. In the linked patch, note that a G4 "played" on the TWELVE-KEY is quantized to G#4. All the other Octave 4 notes are fine as are all notes in lower octaves. However, in octave 5 and above there are more and more "bad" notes. (I already created an issue report for this on GitHub). Anyway, it got me wondering if this is an isolated problem or if VCV developers are using different frequency tables for converting notes to frequencies.
That's really interesting... Well, there is a volt per octave standard so each note or each semitone is 1/12 of a volt. I'm pretty sure that this is an isolated case but it's good that you brought it up.
