Another tier?
If I were to offer another tier... what would you guys want?
In the past people have asked for mainly 2 things: Commissions, and just a way to support my work with more than one dollar a month.
The problem with commissions is that they're very time consuming. I'd have to put like a 10 person Patron limit on it and charge A LOT to make it worthwhile, ya know?
The second idea... I dunno, just feels weird? Asking for more money while offering NOTHING extra? Hmmm.
Of course simply not adding another tier and sticking to what we have now is an option.
Floor is open to you guys. (And be sure to like comments that express ideas you're in favor of)
EDIT: I’m told that as patrons you can simply choose to pay more. The $1 is just a minimum threshold. So that solves that problem for those that want to offer extra support 👍
EDIT #2: After reviewing all your suggestions, I added a new tier! Nothing crazy, it's $5 a month for first access to the comics I post to Instagram/Webtoon.
Comments (206)
I'm on disability income, only able to work part-time as a janitor, and I'm already supporting a couple dozen creators/groups through Patreon. $5 is thus a bit much, but all I saw for options were $1 and $5. I didn't see a set-your-own-level option.
To set your own you still need to pick a tier but then you can change the amount you give. Only more then the tier level you choose of course.
Just became a patreon today! Gotta say it’s worth the $1 to support and be able to read extra comics from my favorite artist >w< I’d be down for the commission tier. To be honest I’d maybe just open commissions but have a few slots, perhaps do a submission application and pick the commissionees you like most rather then do a tier for it! Just my two cents on the matter tho :>
Is this why I got an email for Twins but couldn't see it when I clicked thru to Patreon even after logging in? It went up on Instagram anyway.
Sticker tier maybe
So, now those of us at the lower tier don't get any comics at all? I see the twins comic on FB. You may as well dump the lower tier since we don't get anything from it.
The exclusive comics on FB aren't supposed to be there. Whoever keeps posting them to the "Pixie and Brutus" group is doing so illegally. And where does it say that the lower tier doesn't get comics at all?
I would like some of the half finished. rough sketch that leads to the finished product. maybe 2 times a month.
I think stickers, pins, coloring pages, and custom prints would be cool physical rewards for hire tiers.
Agreed! That'd make it with it for me
WEBTOON?
Maybe one with coloring page or sticker ?
More tiers are welcome. You provide a lot of content already so maybe a small price hike to cover inflation?
I'm excited for your new levels. I hope you'll consider adding an option for people who want to commission a drawing of our pets further on, and charge appropriately.
You could post a recording of your drawing process to a higher tiers reward? But overall, I think this patreon is really cheap, I wouldn't mind only have access to the comics with the 1$ tier and having the wallpaper lock behind a 5$ ones for example^^
two ideas, one, asking more money and giving those contributors a fun title is more than fine. Two, either a digital reward, or a physical reward, let people contribute and either get a sticker, postcard, or whatever, or one special drawing for that tier, something digital for them.
Just random animals doin random junk would be dope for 2$
For my own self, I just beed to keep seeing Pixie and Brutus (and you, maybe bears) in my feeds. I just upped my contribution. Not a lot, but things are better now than they were. For others, I like the digital wallpaper idea. Because commissions do take a LOT of valuable time
Maybe start posting on a new tier, tips and tricks to draw digitally?? I constantly look for tutorials or “how to” videos on drawing
Another creator I support does digital wallpaper as a tier gift. And I’d love to have me some Pixie & Brutus as my background more often!
Things I’ve seen other people do are sticker packs each month, and someone else I support does monthly zoom calls to discuss, and in the higher levels offers a print each month. Check out Willow & Roxas as well as Sam Flegal for some examples and ideas of how other people are doing multiple tiers.
How about a 2 or 3 dollar teir, and every month you draw from a suggestion box and it can be a wallpaper of like, Pixie in a bowtie and monocle, or Brutus and pixie doing ballet, or maybe some serious stuff sometimes? Just an extra sprinkle of Pixie and Brutus and team for the month? I dunno
I think you could do a sticker tier, every month or 2 months period you send a sticker, a simple one. Of course it would bring a lot of work for you because you would have to print and send everything. But it would be something I would be willing to pay for.
Just bumping up support from $1 to whatever you are willing to/can give is helpful. Putting your money where your heart is ❣️. Although seeing a "doodle request drawn poorly in less than a minute" tier would be hilarious to see haha, and a fun break/warmup session for ya. You already seem to enjoy doing so with your old posts on Instagram 😂
You could set a limit of like 10 or 20 or so and send autographed copies of a print to the lucky few...
Your P&B strip is my favorite. The innocence of Pixie and the love that Brutus has for her brings a lot of joy. I agree with so many of the ideas that folks have come up with. So toss out some suggestions from some of those ideas and let us vote on what would make a great next tier.
I'm good with the current setup personally. If extra tiers were added, I'd check them out.
I would say the next tier could be “behind the scenes” of how you drew them or thoughts behind the comics. Maybe (depending how high value) what about signed prints of one of the comic strips each month?
I like that idea
A new tier where you include live streams (or you tube vids) of your drawing would be really neat, and once it's set up it wouldn't really be a lot of extra workload on you I'd hope?
People can choose to pay more even on the $1 tier anyone can do whatever payment they wish
So from my experience, if someone doesn’t post a lot and they charge like $7, I unsubscribe. I’ve noticed with other artist that they have less than 100 patrons bc they charge so much for such little amount of work!! I look at some of your posts and it has upwards of 1,000 likes!! Ur patrons count is so much higher bc ppl think ‘oh heck yeah I can totally spare a dollar a month for this awesome stuff!!’ Ya follow what I mean? BUT!!! I totally want to support u more bc u post so often and it’s such great content!!! So I know that I can trust u to supply what we demand (I demand comics, now!!) I’m not sure what u can offer to higher tier patrons, but I know that it is something I wouldn’t mind being a part of!! Randomly select one each week/ every 2 weeks to draw their pets? I’d pay for that (and just to support u more without the moral dilemma)
I’d recommend making some support tiers, especially for newcomers. A lot of people including myself didn’t know that you could adjust your support, and offering a tier makes it a much simpler process You could offer tiers to go in depth with your drawing process, behind the scenes workings, and offer limited high resolution wallpapers, voting on names or comic ideas, or even a tier that allows a cameo of an animal of their choosing (within reason). You can also offer a personal small doodle on a white background to your higher tiers, it’s simpler and faster than a whole commission. If you do a commission tier, I do agree with limiting the amount of people who are able to join at a given time. Another idea is for higher tier patrons to have a sort of ‘feed’ page, where they can see upcoming comic teasers through sketches you’re working on. You could also add a once a month time lapse video of one of your panels, to help people understand more in depth your work and have it f33l like a more interactive experience. You can add a question section for higher tiers, where a patron can ask you one question about your comic or process etc. that you get to them on with a quick answer once a month. Within reason for that too. Just some ideas!
I love that your tier is low, so it is available to a lot of people. What you could do is sell prints of your comics and also of your wallpapers (maybe modified to another format). I know it's not another tier, but I know everyone here has their favourite P&B comic, they would love to own and hang on their walls. I know this idea would come with quite a bit of time, hassle, outlay... but you're asking what I would be willing to pay more money for: this is it. Also I didn't know I could up my monthly pay, I will look into that. I love P&B, thank you so much for your creations!
I'd definitely stick with the $1 buys all content idea as many are having a tough time with finances and your comics always seem to put a smile on my face even if my day/week has been rotten. Many of the suggestions from everyone else are also really great ideas, like where you put up a poll for the month of what "Side" comic strip you could create once a month, going over steps to help up and coming artists or inquisitive minds, a higher price but part of those donations go to an animal charity. Doing something along those lines I think would go far and sorry if I missed a really good suggestion Patreon has been a bit buggy with chrome lately and it sometimes won't load responses.
You could add voting for the names of additional characters you add in the future. Instead of taking time consuming commissions maybe stream and sketch for your patrons who sub for the new teir. From what I've seen in the few comments I've read I don't think there would be many objections to you raising the price. Your comics are creative, cute, tearjerking and put a smile on many faces. Do whatever you feel is right and not overwhelming.
One artist I know does a start to finish picture piece. So when you post a comic you post the different steps like sketch>lineart>flats>shaded. Another does stream access or being able to vote for comic ideas
I miss the dinosaur comic you were doing. Maybe make a higher tier to support 1 comic of that a month?
Things artists do that you might be interested in (and I'd consider paying for), live streams/broadcast podcast deals with a poll before hand on what you'll draw during it, discord channel/s, Q&A (for artist and character alike).
I definitely think you're underpricing for what we're getting! Although if I'm being honest, the lower price point means I (and I'm sure many others with the same financial situation) can actually support you without it eating into my budget. I've seen Patreon allowing users to set custom monthly amounts if they choose to support the artist beyond the set tier. Perhaps that could be an option outside of the mentioned commission. My only worry with a commission tier is the pressure you would feel if someone has already joined the tier but their commission request doesn't line up with your artistic vibe/what you want your work to be like.
Link a ko-fi so people can tip you if they want to give more.
I like how it's set up now. The lower tier gives those with less available discretionary money a chance to be part of the whole experience, and Patreon allows those who want to give more the ability to do so. Just because there's only one tier doesn't mean patrons can't increase what they pay :)
I'm down with the edit option which is the last option. Just pay extra if they want to value you more than $1/month. I saw a couple of creators that has different tiers on their Patreon page but you do need to spend a lot of time with them because that is what they expect you to do. You will likely end up with more obligation if you have more than just $1 tier.
Higher price but a percentage is donated to an animal charity or military animal rehab.
Beautiful idea. Would absolutely support this.
Maybe get to vote on the theme of one comic of the month. Or give a small discount to a merch store? Or once a month free stitchers?
i am already paying more money a month than required. i think that if someone has the money, they should pay more than required, as this not only gives you more money it also give the subscriber a feeling that they did something good and supported an amazing artist with more than they asked. keep up the good work, i love your comics! (BTW i am paying 7$ a month)
I’m fine with how things are currently. However a suggestion for another tier could be something along the lines of behind the scenes work or helping create new characters or mini series
I like how things are now, personally. You’re already doing great with your current tier!
i really like that the base model $1 /4 comics it’s like every week we buy a $0.25 comic, i think the base price should stay at $1 so that more people can enjoy your comics, but of course do what you need to do to pay the bills :)
i’ve always loved the idea of a desktop wallpaper, maybe the phone wallpaper you usually make you could just make it bigger, and regular patrons get the cropped version?
I would be glad to pay more and I don’t want anything extra.
As other comments have possibly said, maybe you should offer a tier that could be beneficial to you and the payer? For example, recordings of the process, spider content?, maybe you can make content off your guys walks or dress up Spider!
I like how you have things set up personally, its nice that everyone is on the same level. For those who want to donate more, maybe set up something like Kofi and direct them there?
Many years ago at patrecon, Patreon shared metrics that showed consistently that eliminating the $1 tier and replacing it with a $2 tier always resulted in more money for the creator despite the loss of patrons who wouldn't back for more then a buck. Try that?
If I'm reading this right, you only have one tier? If so, keep the lowest tier as all comics, then exclusive content like behind the scenes and q&a at higher tiers. Exclusive content is worth more. But it does mean committing to deliver that to your patrons, so it may mean more work for you. Your $5 tier could include q&a and behind the scenes, but there needs to be a consistent supply of such posts. What about a live streaming tier where people can watch you ink or color? I saw some people recommend physical rewards. Those are usually bad ideas because fulfillment can be a bear, but if you go that route, nothing physical under a $10 tier is my thought, and if those are originals, or commissions, they have to be a member for multiple months to earn the reward. Last thought: take a listen to the ComicLab podcast guys, slip then a few bucks in Patreon for one month and listen to their Patreon-specific episodes. They have winning suggestions for how to structure Patreon tiers to maximize their benefits, as well as the "gotchas" to watch out for.
I've seen other artists on here offer a more expensive teir just to give people the chance to support them more if they can. That said, I think a few things would make a great incentive! 1) comic WIPs, people love seeing those! 2) exclusive prints/posters available, or start offering prints/posters/etc in general and give a discount to higher theirs. 3) Something livestreamed at least monthly! You could live stream making a comic, or you could offer like art classes sort of things (like informal, go through how you do things!) 4) Some artists I support have a higher teir, like $15, and they include monthly prints sent in the mail. Anyway just a few ideas!
I like the livestream idea!
Just make another patreon Tier which gets to vote which theme the next picture will be
Livestream the process & post WIPS for 2nd tier maybe? Doesn't require any extra work, minus setting up for the livestream
Wow
I would say that instead of doing another tier on Patreon I think that you should Look into getting more variation and availability on merchandise or maybe I can increase the price for the base Patreon
I’d also like to echo what others have said that I would love to buy a hard copy of the P&B comics so far. Alternatively, I’d also pay for a higher tier that would let me download a zip of the P&B comics so far. AND, I love the idea of magnets (and bookmarks!!) - perhaps there could be a $5 or $10 tier where, after supporting at that level for x number of months (whatever covers costs and makes it worth it for you) you send a merch pack. :)
What if you started a Pixie and Brutus storyline where people get to vote for what the characters do next to move the storyline along, and people in a $5 or $10 tier are the ones who get to vote for what happens next in the plot? That way you continue to do P&B comics but also offer a benefit to higher tiers and everyone gets to enjoy it!
Merch store would be awesome!!
more shirtless pictures
Offer Merch or Prints for those who can pay, but having yet another level of exclusive comics for most of your patreons is not a good way to go IMHO. You are doing quite well on Patreon, over 13,000 subs for 4 comics a month. That's pretty amazing for a independent artist.
Prints available for purchase!
Exactly what I was going to say! There's a particular comic that I'd buy a famed and signed copy of - I love it that much!
I’d say an extra tier means more P&B exclusive comics or people would get an vote on the ideas you had for your next comic me personally tho if just kill for more of the P&B adventures
I like the idea of $5 dollars. How about this: 10 slots open, but depending on the complexity of the comm, it fills up more slots. Like a sketch would fill up one sketch, color would be two, and fully rendered would take up three slots. So, if someone wanted a sketch of something and a fully rendered bit of another comm, that would take up 4 slots in total, leaving you with 6 slots. I heard someone else suggest a Discord server, which I think is an amazing idea!
How about a 5 dollar tier that when you've been a patron for a year you send them a t shirt or some sort of special plushie
You could increase the tier price to say $3 or $4 and exponentially increase profit while consumers don’t take a large hit. By doing this, you don’t have to offer another tier option but could also open up commission slots every month for the amount of customers you deem manageable. For example, commissions open on the 3rd of the month and there are 10 slots available. The first 10 paying customers get dibs that month and could receive their commissions by the end of the month, and repeat. By doing this, you could also change the number of commissions depending on the time of year. Maybe you’re super slammed in December and only offer 5, but really bored with free time in May and offer 20.
Most people set their lowest tier at 2 or 3 dollars so you should probably do that. Early Pre orders on future books 📚 A discount on any merchandise (I don't know if you have a store but lots of artists have Etsy stores and they discount patreons) One artist does commissions but to make her 10 dollar tier more reasonable every 7 months consecutive pledging at that level you get a commission. I see artists do downloadable phone backgrounds Having a discord for your Patreon fans to interact with each other and you Some artists mail awards each month like mini prints, full size prints, bookmarks, stickers these items are the same for every backer of that level so easier than commissions Pixie and Brutus stuffed animals Storylines for Patreon backers of a certain level Early access posting 1 day earlier than everywhere else
Define "a lot"
This isnt so much a tier suggestion as I liked some of the other suggestions already to post wip in a higher tier, but I think definitely making a post/reminder every few months that's attached to a comic to let patrons know that they can choose to pay more than $1 a month would have you see a big increase in your profits. $1 is definitely underselling your talents and I'm super appreciative of the affordability you make this tier, and based off the comments, a lot of people are unaware that they can elect to up their monthly fee. People can still decide if they want to or not, but at least more people will know the option is there, and people who have the means to & want to can now support such a humble and talented artist in more ways!
Maybe a.. *winces* discord server access?
As some already suggested, a higher tier (like 5-10$?) that offers a chance to get your pet included as a one-time or background character, it would be amazing! Or (again, suggested) polls with your ideas for future comics. You could let the patrons submit their own ideas or just vote for one of your own to get drawn first, this way you don't add up too much "stress" on meeting the quota or things like that
1) option to buy print versions 2) more plushies also other characters like lola wrinkles hugo 3) tshirts/hoodies 4) 1-time offers to be able to name a character for a comic (or have one named after the pledger)
1 drawing (Commission) and 1 extra comic
I would love to buy a print version of all the previous comics. I would also give more than $1/month for what you already post without adding anything new (don't want you to get burned out!). Freebies plus 4 comics & wallpapers is way too cheap for all that work!
Name one off characters off higher tiers. Just the ones that are already gonna be included but now with names
People can pay more for the current tier if they want its just a minimum price.
Extra tier even with no benefits. Just want to support more!
If you want to have another tier lock draft pages of the comic to it or something like that. So it is something you are already producing you just need to post one of the earlier saves of the comic. Or a journal entry about how you thought of the topic of the comic.
I wasn't aware I could change tier price. I just did! I think, as others stated, you undersell yourself. I don't expect anything in return, just happy to see Pixie and Brutus strips each month.
I would like if you added another for people to pay more if they want to without anything extra. I don’t have the money to pay more. I like the one we have now because is super affordable and I love what I get in return
A $5 tier with your drafts and concept art/sketches! (Also just double the price of your current lowest tier, it's more than worth it!)
patrons are able to make a custom pledge. if you go to “edit your pledge” you can add a specific amount
Stickers or magnets
If people are happy to pay more without offering anything extra, then let them? I’d be more disappointed if i was promised something if i paid extra and didn’t get it vs if i knew from the beginning that i am not getting anything extra and its just my choice to pay more.
Personally, I think you're currently underpricing for what you give. I for one would be happy to pay more for the same content, but that's just me.
I'm just here because I like your humor and I get surprise comics every month that bring a smile. Just want to support your work without adding pressure. Current tiers are fine for me if they are fine for you!
Honestly, you could do something very easy like just having another tier where you share wips of the comics, and/or possibly allow people to make suggestions for inclusion of their own pets / interesting new character ideas. With the caveat that none of these are guaranteed, but if you need/want a new character, that will be a pool to choose from. IDK how popular wallpapers are anymore (y'know backgrounds for your desktop or mobile) but that's another option I've seen people do in the past.
I think this could work. It adds an incentive for a higher tier, but doesn't make things over complicated. I'm sure the people who can afford to pay more for this will, and those who are not as financially sound for whatever reason (I'm in college and don't have a steady income) will still be able to continue as they can.
Suggestions for Background character ideas for comics maybe?
I think you struggle sometimes getting stuff posted in here monthly, I would hate to add to it. But I do think that having a higher tier where they could get a coupon code for your products and have access to it first would be great! I would pay for that tier even if I didn't "benefit" monthly from it. Goes towards the future discount lol
I'm sure there r some wealthy patrons who love your work would want to support u and not expect anything in return apart from seeing u thrive in your career and more people become aware of your talent as a result. R u able to set up a tier where they can pay however much they feel like paying?
Be careful how far you stretch yourself. The reason we're here is to support you but you could easily get overwhelmed. A sticker a month sounds great but then you either have to pay for a service or spend a week packing envelopes. Same with comics. Commissions? Then you feel obligated to focus on those first. If you're thinking to make changes, it needs to be something you can balance and still enjoy.
Honestly, I would suggest having things like autographed stuff or being a character in a comic or whatever as being a one time thing only offered to patrons as you have the bandwidth for it and for an amount that fits with the amount of time needed for the extra work. Like commissions, but not wide open nor unlimited in numbers. If I could afford it, I'd be paying more than the single tier amount anyway just because I love your stuff.
I love the idea of having your graphic novel available to the higher tiers first.
I like the book idea. Other creators do a video drawing a panel or something. I don't care for it, and would up my tier anyway. Ooh, maybe list the music or playlist you listened to when making the strip.
Also, I would love to have all the comics you have done made into a book. We all love your comics and it would an easier way for us to read them over and over again.
Happy to increase tier pledge without any extra! The only request that I have is that when your graphic novel comes out, have it available to your patrons first! Or have like a coupon code for us that is slightly cheaper on whatever platform you are selling your graphic novel!
Also. Happy to pay $$$ for individual commissions! I know they are time consuming. Maybe You could change monthly which 10 individuals you would allow to ask commission from you. First in best dress. They will have to pay a bit more that month to remain on that tier and once their commission is done, they can go back to their original pledge. Or whatever. I dunno. Just throwing ideas out there.
How about some wallpapers? I would love to have foxes on my iPad background. 😄
Top tier, get included in a comic? I'd pay for that. Or to have my cat included.
Oh this this this! Higher tier patrons could have a character named after/based on them! If anyone is familiar with peace island, they put patrons' names into the game
Autographed sketches or something? Like have a drawing every month.
What you need to remember with the sending postcards and stuff, not everyone is from the US and International shipping can get expensive.
“Choose what you pay” is an option for patrons - in account, select edit for the creator and update to a higher tier if you like. This way you can do a higher contribution without extra pressure on your creator.
I’d love some time-lapse videos of your art in the making.
A next tier would be great, or something exclusive
How about podcasts?
If I'm remembering correctly, you are working on a book. You could set up a Patreon acknowledgement page that recognizes people who gave at higher tiers.
Don’t be afraid to ask for more money! The worst that happens is that not many people sign up for the next tier. It’s not like we’re going to abandon you because you asked.
You should do what you can and at your own time so yeah only a tier is good
I'm fine with extra pledges with no extras, especially if it will help you with your book(s)! Helping with comic ideas and voting for the best idea sounds good to me. Maybe a monthly sticker? Could be your wallpapers made into stickers. But I don't know how much stickers cost upfront so I don't know if it would be worth it for you.
I forget what you offer on your other tiers, so sorry if you already do this. You could do a postcard with an exclusive picture, maybe quarterly or monthly or yearly. Maybe a zoom call with you for a q and a. Some kind of shout out with people's name. Or not, we all get it and love your work 😀
You could have a slightly higher tier, like say $3, where everyone in that tier is entered into a once-monthly drawing for a commission?
3-5$ maybe a Discord server? If you game people with access to the server could game with you.
You could make it where people pledge what they want. I've seen some on here who offer like a one dollar tier, but if you want to pay more then you can. I'm not sure how that works on your end, but I know it at least was an option that Patreon had
Most people do a behind the scenes level. Also 1$ is usually just early comics tier then 3-5 is usually the extra stuff.
Also: it would be really awesome to have access to all your comics on patreon. I don't have an instagram account which means I can only view the latest few comics before they boot me off. Edit: just learned you have a webtoons page! Woohoo!!
Access to polls would be cool! So like you wouldn’t have to draw anything extra but if you had 3 ideas for your next comic let the tier choose which order you’ll make them
I would do a combo of both... A much higher but very limited tier for commissions, and for people who just want to give you more money something like a tip jar. I know there are several sites that offer that functionality, I want to say one is something like "buy me a coffee"...
You could do $2 per month gets comic and wallpaper sketches, lineart, etc? Maybe even bump wallpapers up to that tier and make $1 just the completed comics. Then you could do a $5 tier where people get to suggest comic/art ideas, you pick your Top # favorites, and then that tier also votes on which of those Top # suggestion selections gets to be made.
An example for the $5 idea: In the month of April, the $5 Tier folks all comment on some thread with their ideas. Then you choose your favorite 5 options and they have the first week of May to vote which they want made. You would then create that comic/art by the end of May.
You could let payers at a certain level vote on what to do next. That would be less specific than a commission.
How about a tier in the $5-$10 range, in which you send a monthly-quarterly special postcard sized autographed comic that is only for those supporting that tier? I support a couple of other comic artists who do something along these lines. One sends a monthly 6 page black and white comic along with a page of his draft drawings, while another does monthly cards at one tier and annual plus random mixed months at a lower tier. As Debra Savage mentioned, if you have a separate website for merchandise, you could offer a modest discount to your followers as well.
Also, i couldn't pay for another dollar, once that my current coin isn't dollar, the taxes... 😅
You could charge individually each comission, if you think you can do it without getting overwhelmed
I would go to a higher tier without any extras. I just want to support your work. That being said. I was told that you want to give people a choice. If you have more tiers, without any additional benefits, you tell them: "pay me what you can and what you think is worth it." So you get the people that maybe don't have much money but still want to support with the $1 Tier and also the people that can and will pay more like $5, $10 or even $20. Some Ideas that could be used in higher tier(s) as inspiration: - "commission" on a pixy and Brutus strip. Basically the person can give the theme for one strip that is posted here or on instagram. - "commission" of an idea for a p&b or other established character wallpaper posted here. - some kind of name placement (some people love to see their name mentioned) maybe on an extra panel with an Instagram comic post. - maybe some voice/video call or group call via discord or something. On a specific schedule. (Like once a month / once every 3 Months) - watch a drawing session of an upcoming comic (live or via a YouTube video) Just some ideas that don't require much work from your side, since you still post them here on Patreon or on insta, or talk to some people for an hour or so.
Maybe access to a discord server?
It's fine how it is now to be honest, I absolutely love this current system, I often wonder if other Patreon users did the same thing, perhaps they'd have more patrons? I know for a fact that I'd be subscribed to more if they were this cheap, but either way, I move this system.
How much extra do you need? I mean an extra 50 cents per month could be justified as a cost of living increase on the current tier.
I would say, experiment with your options, i'm a full time commission artist and its VERY time and energy consuming, if you feel like you have the extra energy im sure you can add some limited slots, adding a second tier if others want to donate more is an option for them that they can *choose*, but in the end do what makes you feel better about the way you work!
I totally get why it feels weird to have a higher tier that doesn't actually offer something more, but I for one am not on patreon to get something out of it (although bonus material is nice) but because I want to support artists who make content I enjoy. I think if you're just up front about it with some humor, idk something like "pay more just cause you like me" I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Just my two cents though.
Same here!
I'm good 👍
I really like your commissions idea. If you wanted to open it up to more people, you could do it as a monthly raffle where a set number of patrons picked at random would get a pic from you. That way you could get more people, but keep the price a little lower.
Discount on merch maybe? Or early access to buying it? I wouldn’t be able to upgrade, but other people would I’m sure
Wouldn’t be able to go to a higher tier and unfortunately don’t know enough about other Patreon strategies to talk about it. Will encourage that ya do what helps you and your business while maintaining balance of your own free time. Enjoy your stuff!
Is the current teir set up to allow people to give more than the minium dollar each month? Cuz if not I'd recommend giving that as an option to people who want to give more
It is! In account settings, under ‘membership’ you can select ‘choose what you pay’ and contribute a higher dollar value.
$5 tier, share wip of the comics, like sketches A lot of people that and it's not much extra work
I've seen some other artists on patreon with a flexible tier with a $1 min. So you can pay more if you want to... But it's still the same tier. That would also be great! This is separate from all the other great ideas for having another tier, fyi
I say a vote on next coming comics and commission as well
Maybe a merchandise discount?
I do like the ideas of some people here, mentioning Free small items monthly like say a sticker or keychain, a small character submission forum to get a cameo in a comic, may I also suggest a Discord? It'd be fun to have a place to chat about comics, art, maybe meet some new friends, etc.
Maybe $5 tier and polls for next wallpaper?
Stickers! I would absolutely love a tier where I could get your comics, and a sticker each month!
An exclusive comic storyline that's ongoing?
I like the idea of a $2 getting to vote occasionally on something. And maybe they also get 1 extra comic or 1 early comic. I personally like the current "all in" set up!
A 4x6 or 5x7 print of the previous month's wall paper or some other art piece? Even one of the comic strips
I think you can make a pay your choice option. I belong to another Patreon that gives the option of selecting your own payment. That way people could choose what they want to pay a month and it starts at 1$
To be honest, more often than not with content creators who have more than one tier I would only pay the highest tier like once a year, binge the content and then unsubscribe completely. With you the fact that you only have on tier is convenient because it means that when I get a notification it’s definitely something I can see and I get exited. It makes me happy to be subscribed to you and consistently give you money every month (especially with the amount you post). I would much rather pay more monthly but keep it at one tier that everyone can enjoy and afford. I also agree that it would be nice to be able to support you with more than just a dollar. Commissions on the other hand don’t need to be part of a tier , you could just charge separately? I don’t know that’s just my opinion 😅
Could do a monthly q and a with question submission behind like a$5 wall, or offer a "draw a pic of you" in your art style or something.
A chance at being a cameo, a sticker after the 2nd month of being a higher tier patron, or maybe a patch?
Oh maybe you could do a free small merch item once a month! Like a sticker, keychain, socks? Idk
There's a couple of artists I support on the "$2 -same as $1 but thank you for the extra buck" plan
Higher tier should be all Hugo comics
Exclusive merch and/or merch discounts! $5 or $10 gets you access to things like Snow Brutus (which the Patron would purchase separately, the tier is just for the ability to buy the merch), or higher tiers get like quarterly discount codes for existing merch
Not sure about access to purchase, then it just feels like you're getting charged twice, but discounts is a great idea.
Maybe make a second tier where everyone in that tier enters a raffle for a commission?
I would be absolutely ok with an additional tier that is essentially nothing more than “I can afford to give you more than $1 a month and I think you deserve it so I want to do so.” Don’t underestimate the kindness of strangers.
Maybe a tier with a chance of being a cameo (of them and/or their pets) in comics now and then? Give you more of a cast of extras to work with. People can say their pets' personalities and such too, how they are as an individual. Like how my cat is a hunter for small insects and creatures ("daaad I want that gecko but I can't reach it heeeellp") but also seems terribly on-edge a lot of times.. lol
Most people seem ok with moving the price up to $2 with same content
Just add a donation button lol
Stickers? Or an option to submit ideas and a poll for new comics?
I woudnt try adding another tier. But if its possible, you vould make it a "choose what you pay" thing. Than you dont have to feel woerd for charging extra without additional content, but people could still support you more
I say keep it where you are. It's nice and simple, plus people can always over pledge.
Videos of the full drawing process.
I'm perfectly happy how is. And I'd pay more just to support you. I'd say if you did ad a tier maybe voting on some concepts, or videos of portions being drawn up. But you could totally do a tier that was just "Exactly the same but somebody wanted to give me more money" I've seen a few like that were artists will have two tiers exactly the same but one doesn't get any rewards because they don't want the rewards. They just want to support.
Enamel pin club! Maybe quarterly? Then you could sell extras? Semi monthly swag tier? With plush or pop or stickers or, or, or… Or maybe instead of tiers do some kickstarters and Patreon folk get first dibs?
Maybe a background picture once a month? People at the tier could provide prompts and you pick one and then it is hd enough for big screens. This gives a little of the commission with a hard limit and also gives something extra
Extra levels which don't include specific rewards isn't so uncommon, and they're just listed as "If you have a few extra dollars you want to contribute. It's greatly appreciated, but don't feel like it's necessary!" or something similar. I've seen it many times. If you really want to offer something though, some ideas would be early comic releases, participation in some sort of steering polls, access to a periodic Q&A, or monthly wallpapers. Just some thoughts!
Literally never thought of early access. That’s smart
I love your work. Keeps a smile on my face. How about a tier for those that would like to send you something extra. Can you tip on here?
Maybe just add a couple extra monthly comics? I know that’s a lot of extra work though. Also STICKERS that you can get sent to you!
As someone who hates accepting help, I know the second option sounds weird. However, you're an excellent content creator and your work brings joy to a lot of people, myself and my family included. If people want to support you more or feel like your work is worth more than they contribute already, I feel that's their decision to make, isn't it?
I could see paying 4 to 5 dollars a months as you release that many items for us a month. And it would totally be worth it ❤️
I support another creator that has a tier that costs 1 extra dollar and he clearly states "its the same as the previous one but you are cool and want to support me even more" I got that one just because I like his art a lot
You could always add something like live streams for a higher level, you don't have to necessarily add more work, just let people into your process a bit more.
If anything maybe a tier that offers emotes or icons a month? Rather than doing commissions you can do what you want.
As a $2 patron, I'm down for a $2 tier that adds no benefit.
I would love to offer more support, I think a $5 tier would be awesome! I'm sure you can think of something extra to add later
I enjoy it the way it is
I agree with Tatyana Horton.
Monthly Q and A on higher tier?
Ok, where’s an idea! Monthly stickers 👀 how difficult would it be to mail stickers out for a 5$ Tier month plan?
Could you do more content for a second tier? Seems to be common trend. Not necessarily another comic series. Maybe sketches and drafts? Behind the scenes type stuff?
Maybe do commissions but keep the options limited, like chibi 1 character doodles, and offer it every other month, a few times a year or maybe only once (when subscribing) so it could still be cheap, and managable for you! (I offer an every other month option and its working well for me)
Hmm maybe just increase this to $2 per month and otherwise keep it the same?
That’s what I was thinking! I’m still happy to pay more with the amount of content we receive.
FYI, if someone wants to pay more/less the subscriber can change it for each patreon without needing another tier. Though I just looked and maybe that only works if you can switch tiers.
Do $1 per Patron-exclusive comic and do a set # per month? Keep a $1 tier for those who want to keep costs down and offer access to just a few exclusives.
Could add like…a discord group or something? I feel like we get a lot for $1 already, I don’t think you need to add much 💛
Don't fix what ain't broken
Character Profile icons?
Maybe some behind the scenes stuff? Like the occasional how to draw, inspiration, artistic process sort of stuff? If that floats your boat? ⛵
I love what you have been doing you are doing great
I don’t think you should add another one. If you do want to do commission you could open up once a month and only take 5-10 people
Maybe there could be a 5 dollar tier that offers you exclusive behind the scenes of comics and other projects
I'd give you more money just because I think what you produce is worth more!
Honestly don’t mind just keep up the good work
