Rudy Is A Cheater…but its Okay not to be okay…lol.Hear Me Out

Yeah no I agree. Rudy cheated and I just don’t really care. Light novel did explain things better though. Rudy being unlikely to recover is more clear and Roxy’s uncertainty in what she should do weren’t super well fleshed out here I feel.

For me yes rudy cheated on his wife, but as a viewer I enjoyed it so much, because you will never find any anime like this before, where our mc is not righteous man come from heaven, We all know the phrase "nobody's perfect", but most of mc in anime is almost perfect and i'm tired of it. From my perspective yes rudy make mistake, and he will make ton of mistake in the future, but that's why I love mushoku tensei so much where I watch rudy autobyography

There are 2 things to consider "what if role were reversed", if your standards would be the same, good for you, if not...see? hypocrite. And 2nd, meby even more important, that is the one scenario where I can't call this cheating. He litteraly had no input here (pun kinda intended). For cheating to be counted as cheating, at least at some point in cause->effect chain there must be his decision, his will, anything. He did NOTHING wrong (unless we coun't comming to help in the first place, but come on). After the death of Paul and "cascaing" of Zenith my dude Rudy was so extreamly depressed he was borderlane vegetable. And then in that state Roxy came to his room wihout invite, and came onto him. Like really the only "wrong" he did was not resisting...but he was in no state to resist anything in the first place (like really, anyone who had any depression episodes will know what I'm talking abaut, and he was in MUCH worse state than most of us ever were), but even if you don't buy it and say he always should have enough will in him to resist...come back to point 1, and reverse roles in your mind...like come on, you won't be tryin to make this argument in 2024 will you? PS. And all that wihout even taking into consideration what status Roxy have for him...like come on

Yeah but roxy is rudy's Jennifer Lopez

How did you like the arc which, at the time of reading, was both my favourite and least favourite arc. I have read to the end now so it's defiantly no longer my favourite but I still get an irrational disgust from this whole situation. The worst part is that there is no individual person who's completely at fault, just a really shitty situation caused by multiple factors and that everything else, including the emotional impact and storytelling is incredible. I had dealt with the moral part of the books after coming back from dropping the books on volume 2 and restarted, but in my mind, this is where they crossed my moral line causing me to drop the book series a second time before picking it back up two years later. Don't get me wrong, I'm nor religious or completely against polygamy, Its just that in this situation, it is unmistakably cheating on his wife the moment he accepted her advances as well as the other party knowingly instigating this situation, regardless of the reasons. Of corse there are multiple circumstances involved as stated earlier which just makes this a fucked up situation in which I understand the authors meaning but still hate it and respect it. I don't like it at all, although I understand that Mushoku Tensei is that kind of story making me have a love/hate relationship with this show. EDIT: I don't blame Rudy, I just hate the situation as a whole but I can't blame the author... its just an irrational disgust towards a fucked up situation

with the power, the money, the experience, and the maturity Rudy can if he get serious take care of up to 10 wifes if he wants :)

Is it cheating if you have permission 🤔

Its not cheating if the person is a goddess or a god, lmao Peace yall

Only 1 ep left, hope there're lots of toxicity next ep in order for you to make another video like this lol, I missed s1 when there're multiple eps that are controversial and you have to make videos like this back to back

As a former-Christian-turned-rabid-atheist, I wanna say SO MANY blasphemies about a Messiah who goes after the women. XD Rudy lucked out with his polygamy cuz usually, you gotta deal with a set of in-laws per wife. NONE of his wives have any parents that can just drop in and nag you about stuff. Roxy's parents are all the way over at the Demon Continent, and they haven't invented airplanes yet. Also, I don't see them using the Teleportation Circles for casual nagging of the son-in-law.

Honestly, the anime left out a bit of detail which makes things more complicated? I don't want to bring up anything the LN expanded on in case it gets covered somehow in the future. Did Rudy fuck up by clapping Roxy cheeks? Yes. Did Roxy fuck up by letting him hit? Yes and no. It's messed up that she did that knowing he was married, especially with a kid on the way. However, what would the alternative be? Lilia is busy tending to Zenith and the other two think he'll pull through on his own. She did what was she thought was best for him and it worked. We've seen how bad things can get for him and I believe its way better for him to be on his feet because he's basically the head of his family and for better or worse he has to be the glue that holds everything together. I see someone above commented that MT just uses sex to treat depression (I respect your POV) but I think they're missing the point a bit. It's not just the sex but rather the emotional connection he has with the person, it's weird that I will agree on but it's kinda like having someone there for you when you're going through something?

It’s not even that deep. People acting like this shit real life. Just because someone agrees with an action or words said within a show, doesn’t mean they feel the same irl. And regarding Roxy, wtf is their relationship to her? She don’t know sylphie, she knew Rudy first that’s all she know 😂 everyone tryna bash the actions she made, yet Rudy was blushing and enjoying the moment. If he didn’t want Roxy he wouldn’t even think of marrying her. Atleast be chill if you going to watch anime, this stuff shouldn’t be taken seriously

Yep I'm with you on that. The fact is he broke his promise. Don't get me wrong I understand the circumstances, what happen was probably for the better overall ( rudy was literraly dying alone in this room). But for the love of god stop trying to say he didn't cheat when even he (rudeus) admit it. I love mushoku tensei because all the characters are very well written, they all make mistakes from time to time. Rudy broke his promise? Welp he just face the consequences and deal with the problem.

Yes, i can agree with your argument, my take is that Selphie will be fine with it and if they are fine who am i to take offense to what another person do (being fictional characters here) ? Like Selphie said you could go with another woman, yes before having the pregnacy but im sure its not going to matter and she will be alright either way. Rudeus is not a good or a bad person, he is a person and a complicated one at that, he is certainly much much better than when he started but still he is person with bad and good in him.

Let's just say this. This is where harems are harems and why their just low ball, junkfood toxic romance in the end. But sadly, so much anime consumers on the average will take these types of relationships and think their actually what should be IRL or what other authors should inspire to write, and for me its mind bogling IMO. Like what you brought up with sex. Sex doesn't cure depression lol, depression makes you want to have sex LESS then anything else, so author using sex as some kind of therapy has always been very weird. But we have to accept that the author is using sex as therapy even if doesn't make any sense. it's why Rezero and MT get put in a war because Rezero does one thing where our morality is injected into an isekai world. Like Subaru does something really stupid like royal capital, he gets punished, he treats Emilia like a goddess, he gets punished. People for long time think MT is going to be like Rezero, but its not. MT is just really the same of any other Isekai but Rezero, but just far more fleshed out characters then the average Isekai.

Dude potentially has a 2nd wife. I wouldn’t be surprised if he gets a 3rd and we know who that might be… it’s just a obvious prediction by me.

Hear what you’re saying but I disagree with it being just called cheating (it is by definition but not in reality) still. LN aside a man who was so wallowed in grief and sadness who hasn’t had any sexual relations in months gets pressed by the woman who he quite literally made her panties his god. Think of it like this. If Rudy was a girl and Roxy was the guy and the EXACT same scene played out and later the MAN roxy says he preyed on her when she was down (roxy exact words) it’ll be less harsh on Rudy.

I have a take that may not be so popular but all I know is if Roxy had a significant other and Rudy was the one that took advantage of the situation there would be a whole different conversation. I hate to be the “what if the roles were reversed” person because I know the roles are reversed irl, but seriously we cannot give Rudy ALL the blame here