June 25, 2023

Left on Read: The Five

Jack the Ripper - if he even existed - killed women in the sex trade. That’s common knowledge, and also wrong. The Five is a book about one of the worlds first serial killers, understood through the perspective of those women who were murdered.

Comments (33)

M
Marjorie Zeager · June 24, 2025

I just read this book and it made me crazy and so so mad. Like in a good way though.

M
Michael Janes · July 3, 2023

writtenology is absolutely the cooler name

L
Lilli of the bog · August 1, 2024

I would have preferred if it was left on red, for the Communism wordplay.

C
Cate Kneale · July 1, 2023

Really enjoyed this discussion. I confess that I haven't read the book but the podcast version was excellent. The dismissal of the Ripper reminds me of the bit in The Fall where all the male police officers are fanboying over the killer and Gillian Anderson basically says he's a pathetic loser. Which is a good bit to remember.

H
Hitachii · June 29, 2023

There's currently a podcast that does cool history stuff called left unread lolol.

A
Andrew Davis · June 29, 2023

Sorry, one more name thing: you should pronounce the name of the show the way Flora Gill pronounces it.

P
Patrick Lopez · June 28, 2023

Riley had his softest voice on for this one!

R
Richard · June 28, 2023

Have you considered Norman Cohn "the pursuit of the millennium" or something by Ladurie?

A
Andrew Davis · June 28, 2023

Please change the name of this imprint show every month; it's a bit of a fun tech parody.

O
Okie From Muskogee · June 27, 2023

This could be the story of any of hundreds of missing or murdered indigenous women whose disappearance goes uninvestigated every year in the US. It's like we came here and just found a way to transfer the fate of English peasant women onto someone else, including the moral judgement and dehumanizing of them when the desperation of their circumstances drive them to drugs and alcohol and prostitution.

e
etienne · June 27, 2023

goddam that's a great comparison. Does Robert Pickton have any horny fans yet?

C
Chris Lamb · June 27, 2023

Peter Watts «Blindsight» episode when?

C
Callum · June 27, 2023

So good I bumped up to the $10 level. Idk if that even gets you a second one of these your shows are just so good

e
etienne · June 27, 2023

Premium Hog is one of the best deals in podcasting out there

M
Man2quilla · June 27, 2023

Ok, but have you considered "writtenology?"

C
Chris Lamb · June 26, 2023

What was that Tennyson reference?

T
Twi · June 26, 2023

The name is just going to change every month isn't it

k
kaninchen ZERO · June 26, 2023

i keep hearing polly nichols as if she were an american television mobster called paulie nickels for what are implied to be spectacularly gruesome reasons

k
kaninchen ZERO · June 26, 2023

also i have always strenuously believed that addictive behavior tends to be downstream of pain. it is simple fact that violence directed towards addiction is distributed unevenly by racialization and poverty. "how much was the alcohol" is a meaningless question under the conditions of social murder since it is commonly wielded as an instrument of that social murder.

A
Amy · June 26, 2023

what a banger of a name, writtenology will be in my heart forever

E
Emily Kugler · June 26, 2023

So happy this book is covered. Ever since I read it, I wanted to hear a good discussion of it

N
Nemo · June 26, 2023

A lot of overlap here with Helen Mathers' book Josephine Butler: Patron Saint of Prostitutes, about a social reformer who opposed the late-19th century CD Acts (which gave police the authority to detain and forcibly examine any women they believed to be sex workers). At least in Mathers' telling, what makes Butler stand out from her contemporaries is that despite a Christian faith we would today consider fundamentalist, she was adamant that people had to come by God of their own free will. As such she opposed many of the punitive measures other social reformers accepted and campaigned against the CD Acts in India long after most of her allies had stopped caring. Today we're used to the UK being the most poor-hating country in Europe, but I think at least in the 19th century, the particulars of English laissez-faire often meant less help for the poor but also less intervention in their lives. Prior to the CD Acts there was no real UK equivalent to the Police des Mœurs or the state-sanctioned brothels of France and Belgium, who frequently colluded to the detriment of workers.

s
sudonim2 · June 26, 2023

https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/06/22/1075405/the-people-paid-to-train-ai-are-outsourcing-their-work-to-ai/

M
Miguel Claxton · June 26, 2023

“Keen eyed listeners” is a fun phrase

P
Planxty · June 26, 2023

I doubt anyone needs book recommendations ever for any reason, but I was reminded of Jen Manion's Female Husbands a couple times while listening -- a similar struggle to write history when the extant records that detail a life are primarily Victorian police and press

G
G Goldhar · June 26, 2023

it's me the Brane Zone Book Club misser

Z
Zoey/Sen · June 25, 2023

Writtenology was a *much* better name...

K
Katherine · June 25, 2023

I think Writtenology is better.

M
Martin · June 25, 2023

I think there's still time for a few more name changes

I
Isobel Bing · June 25, 2023

RIP to Writtenology, the worst name ever, you were too beautiful for this world

J
Jon W · June 25, 2023

Jack the Ripper would be a good name for a bong

s
spunups · June 25, 2023

The new name for the series is very good congrats 🐖

E
En Bee · June 25, 2023

No. It sucks. I misread it as "Left on Road" in my feed reader and was instantly psyched about listening to transporation-based content! Also: reading is for nerds.