Trickle Down Episode 18: Viral Science
Brian Wansink was the Head of the Food and Brand Lab at Cornell University. While there, he did exciting research that suggested eating healthier and encouraging others to eat healthier was as simple as providing subtle hints and nudges towards the preferred behavior.
He’s perhaps most famous for the claim that if you take a larger plate to the buffet, you’ll eat more than if you were to take a small plate.
For a long time he was easily the world’s most prominent voice on food psychology. He published bestselling books. He was constantly interviewed by national media. He even had major influence in the government. He served for two years as the Director of the US Department of Agriculture’s Center for Nutrition Policy.
It’s fair to say that Brian Wasnick affected how millions of people prepared, presented, and ate food.
However, his reputation came crashing down from 2016 through 2018. It was discovered, partly through an accidental confession by Brian Wansink himself, that his papers were frequently based on shaky and perhaps outright fraudulent data analysis.
The scandal was so bad that Cornell determined that Wansink had committed scientific misconduct and removed him from all teaching and research positions.
This is a story about what happens when someone treats science like a business with the goal of gaining the most influence and media coverage, rather than a project of gaining an empirical understanding of the real world.
REFERENCES
John, Leslie K., George Loewenstein, and Drazen Prelec. "Measuring the prevalence of questionable research practices with incentives for truth telling." Psychological science 23, no. 5 (2012): 524-532.
Kincaid, Ellie. “Cornell food marketing researcher who retired after misconduct finding is publishing again.” Retraction Watch (2022)
Ritchie, Stuart. Science fictions: How fraud, bias, negligence, and hype undermine the search for truth. Metropolitan Books, 2020
McCook, Alison. “Backlash prompts prominent nutrition researcher to reanalyze multiple papers” Retraction Watch (2017)
Lee, Stephanie M. "Here’s How Cornell Scientist Brian Wansink Turned Shoddy Data Into Viral Studies About How We Eat” BuzzFeed News (2018)
https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/stephaniemlee/brian-wansink-cornell-p-hacking
Lee, Stephanie M. "This Controversial Ivy League Scientist Left His Kickstarter Donors High And Dry” BuzzFeed News (2018)
https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/stephaniemlee/brian-wansink-kickstarter-weight-loss
The Donald Trump of Food Research
Severson, Kim. "Seduced by Snacks? No, Not You" New York times. (2006)
https://www.nytimes.com/2006/10/11/dining/11snac.html
Bartlett, Tom. "Spoiled science." Chronicle of Higher Education 63, no. 28 (2017).
https://web.archive.org/web/20210205080826/https://www.chronicle.com/article/spoiled-science/
Newburger, Emma. "Students who worked in Cornell food lab say director’s retracted studies stain reputations." The Cornell Daily Sun 8 (2018).
ABC News. 100 Calorie Snack Packs More Expensive.
https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Consumer/story?id=3526951&page=1
Wong, Elaine. “100-Calorie Packs Pack It In” Brand Week. (2009)
ASU study: 100-calorie packs make dieters eat more. (2008)
https://news.asu.edu/content/asu-study-100-calorie-packs-make-dieters-eat-more
Jenkins, Robin Mather "The wizard of why.” Chicago Tribune. (2005)
https://www.chicagotribune.com/2005/03/30/the-wizard-of-why/
Butler, Kiera. “This Fast-Food-Loving, Organics-Hating Ivy League Prof Will Trick You Into Eating Better” Mother Jones (2015)
https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2015/03/brian-wansink-cornell-junk-food-health/
van der Zee, Tim, Jordan Anaya, and Nicholas JL Brown. "Statistical heartburn: an attempt to digest four pizza publications from the Cornell food and brand lab." BMC nutrition 3 (2017): 1-15.
Wansink, Brian. Slim by design: Mindless eating solutions for everyday life. Hay House, Inc, 2016
Wansink, Brian. Mindless eating: Why we eat more than we think. Bantam, 2010
Comments (62)
There was a Flat Top in Arlington Va in the early oughts. I still miss it so much.
Also as someone with disordered eating who doesn’t really ever feel full, the packs were great for me so I didn’t have to weigh and measure my treats myself🫣
This reminds of Dan Ariely, the discredited psychologist on which NBC just based a TV series.
Relevant xkcd about p-hacking: https://xkcd.com/882/ (I don’t know if links are allowed, so sorry in advance)
Poor Sesame Street, they didn't deserve it. Except Elmo, he's in on it.
I truly enjoy the "trickle down" episodes, they're very informative. It's obvious that Travis puts a lot of work into the research. The only criticism concerns Jake's constant giggling and not so funny jokes. Please tone it down a notch!
The script-to-riff ratio seemed a bit off.
Also, Kenny Banya from Seinfeld says that soup does not count as a meal when you go to Mendy's
It's also a leftover Vestige of the Depression era. Less food so eat the damn s***
As expected, now look into what big meat and dairy tell you.
That's honestly the clearest explanation of p-hacking I've heard, great job
Great stuff, but please, America! Join the metric system!! Wtf us a quart????
The food science guy sounds like a Tim Heidecker character lol.
my only critique with this episode (which is overall excellent- not enough people tie this dude’s work directly to the flaws of capitalism intersecting with research) is that the blog post he first got caught with was actually to smarmily criticize another researcher for NOT doing enough academic fraud. if he wasn’t as smug, he could have easily gotten away with it!
Trickle down season 2 genuinely some of the best stuff y'all have ever put out good work Travis
As someone working in the research sector, I'm a fan of this series! Hoping for more seasons in the future!
Travis has used Science Fictions a few times this series. My only issue with this is that Stuart Ritchie is Scottish and yet Jake does not affect a bad Scottish accent when reading extracts from the book.
This is probably the most clear non-mathy yet *correct* description of how p-hacking actually works i have heard or read, including from people who really should know better.
wow i really commend you for getting all the stats definitions right! p values are constantly over/misinterpreted by people in and outside of academia
If you do another season, get Tom Walker of BST on to talk about men doing themselves serious injury attempting autofellatio.
Never trust pop science.
I think maintenance phase did an episode on this guy, or maybe featured his book in one of their diet book roundups. That’s where I first heard the term p-hacking.
Oatmeal cream pies. They were GIANT when I was a kid. My 7 year old can eat 1 in 2 bites. Little Debbie has become a stingy old bitch.
The fact that "you" are expressing skepticism is evidence that his work must now be beyond skepticism. (SLAMS HEAD ON TABLE)
“Surely somebody is scrutinizing his work more closely now, given his previous scandals.” Yes! You, as the editor of the journal publishing his new study, should be the one scrutinizing his work! (The stupid….it hurts….)
John Stossel pimping this guy is the perfect conflagration of obnoxious bullshit.
Willie Wonka and the Charlie Factory...😂
Do the snack show. Do it
I feel like "why do people eat different things for breakfast" is not a question that science can answer.
Snackanon Anonymous
I've never heard Travis this angry lmao Nice of him to drop Jake a treat of Ghostbusters reference
Travis should join the FoodieFederation!
I think a study on how watching outlaw food reviews affects appetite would be more valuable than any of the experiments mentioned in this episode
So, effectively, he was baking the data. I'm surprised he didn't discover that eating children was the secret to eating less.
i'm a money scientist
Between this and behavioral economics, feel like “behavioral ____” anything should be disregarded. Throw “evolutionary ____” in, too.
The stuff at the end about the medical journal saying he probably is honest now reminded me of British London Publishing in Peep Show. Mark: "What do you think Jez, he couldn't do it twice!" Jez (saracastically): "No, that would be impossible..." I worry that we're going to be in for some of that in election season with some big-brained politics-understanders. "Bruised from his experience last time around, we can expect a much more measured and considered second presidency from Donald Trump, he'll know he needs to build bridges and be statesmanlike to get his legislative agenda through..."
You guys really ate with this one. Pun very intended
cum sink! Best insult.. Cum sink!
Julian failed to make any jokes about Cheese Nips and I almost unsubscribed
Travis "We're not talking about this in the middle of my fucking podcast". No, you're confused, the fucking podcast is Julian and Liv.
As someone who is both from Iowa and has had a torturous relationship to food and body image, I really loved this episode. Despite the potential darkness of those admissions, I laughed a lot—perhaps more than usual. God damn it those tiny snack packs were stressful and clearly a giant ripoff!!! Gallows time!
Preregistering the research is one way to cut down on p hacking.
Snack pod 👏 snack pod 👏 snack pod 👏
I guess the burden falls on me to be the pedant who defends Jake and points out that “Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory” is indeed the name of the Gene Wilder movie and Julian is a wrong meanie.
Fun episode. I’m familiar with this story but it’s too absurd not to get some joy out of hearing it again. Jake is correct that Violet Beauregard blows up in “Willy Wonka” and the Chocolate Factory. I’m assuming he’s thinking of the 70s movie and not the book or the remake.
Great episode! It was funny hearing how Travis got so worked up about this.
Snack sized podcasts. The appropriate length for a commute
Travis hmu, I got my MPH in preschool children’s sticker anxiety
I love the pizza heartburn study title. In undergrad, the psych department knowingly joked about how in psych studies you have the joke title followed by the real title.
Go on The Doughboys
Oh god, I had a professor who specialized in mindful eating. I hope her stuff wasn’t based on Wansick😭Dr. Kennedy my heart goes out to you
This reminds me of the Nudge episode on If Books Could Kill! I almost thought this was about the same guy, but it’s not. If I had a nickel…
Mike Hobbes also hosts Maintenance Phase, where they did do an episode on this guy.
Thank you for confirming that science is bad. I knew it!
thanks for all the hard work you put into Trickle Down; so fucking good
We know you hate "Perverts" Travis, but an extremely well researched and in depth episode of "Trickle Down" is not how you "clap back" on Julian & Liv
I like that Jake slipped halfway into Trump voice when mocking the idea that what people really want is to finish the pack.
Shh. No one tell Malcolm Gladwell.
Excited to listen to this one!
snack
pog
