Trickle Down Episode 15: Earth's Most Destructive Organism Part 1
Thomas Midgley Jr. invented two things that were used all over the world. Firstly, he invented leaded gasoline. This helped car engines operate more efficiently, but at the cost of spewing poisonous gas everywhere. The second invention is Chlorofluorocarbons or "CFCs." These substances, which were sold under the brand name Freon, had widespread applications in refrigerators and aerosols. But it was eventually discovered that these CFCs were eating away at the ozone layer in Earth’s atmosphere. Ozone depletion allows more UV radiation to reach the Earth's surface, which can lead to skin cancer, cataracts, and weakened immune systems.
The fact that a single individual invented both leaded gasoline and CFCs led Environmental historian J. R. McNeill to say that Midgley "had more adverse impact on the atmosphere than any other single organism in Earth's history."
Before Thomas Midgley died in 1944, he didn’t see himself as destructive. The scientific community showered him with praise and prizes and accolades during his lifetime. And he didn’t even have reason to think he was doing anything bad. Government regulators who were tasked with protecting the American public gave his inventions a pass.
This story represents a complete failure of tech entrepreneurs to consider the adverse impacts that their inventions might have, a failure of the scientific community to check one of their own, and a failure of supposed protectors of the public interest to do their jobs. And all of these failures meant that the generation after Midgley was forced to clean up his mess.
REFERENCES
McGrayne, Sharon Bertsch. “Prometheans in the Lab: Chemistry and the Making of the Modern World.” Sharon Bertsch McGrayne, 2001.
Markowitz, Gerald, and David Rosner. “Deceit and denial: The deadly politics of industrial pollution.” Vol. 6. Univ of California Press, 2013.
Cagin, Seth, and Philip Dray. "Between earth and sky: how CFCs changed our world and endangered the ozone layer." 1993.
Tylecote, Ronald F. "Roman lead working in Britain." The British Journal for the History of Science 2, no. 1 (1964): 25-43.
Kovarik, William. "Ethyl-leaded gasoline: how a classic occupational disease became an international public health disaster." International journal of occupational and environmental health 11, no. 4 (2005): 384-397.
Kovarik, Bill. "Charles F. Kettering and the 1921 Discovery of Tetraethyl Lead In the Context of Technological Alternatives", presented to the Society of Automotive Engineers Fuels & Lubricants Conference, Baltimore, Maryland., 1994
Kitman, Jamie Lincoln. "The secret history of lead." NATION-NEW YORK- 270, no. 11 (2000): 11-11.
https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/secret-history-lead/
Comments (40)
quick thing: y'all mention in the beginning that you can be accused of being Luddites and I actually think doing something on the Luddites one day would be something that you'd be interested in! Check out the book "Blood in the Machine: The Origins of the Rebellion Against Big Tech" by Brian Merchant. There's really a case to be made that the bad reputation associated with Luddites is itself a result of successful propaganda.
A little late to this ep, wanted to share this gem from Wikipedia: In 1940, at the age of 51, Midgley contracted polio and was left severely disabled. He devised an elaborate system of ropes and pulleys to lift himself out of bed. On November 2, 1944, at the age of 55, he was found dead at his home in Worthington, Ohio. He had been killed by his own device after he became entangled in it and died of strangulation.
I love how science back then was basically like combining all the shampoos and body washes in the shower and making a potion
Oh I so want us to go back to being hunters and gatherers again
Someone needs to tell me where I can find the "theme" for this series. Shit is amazing and that chorus is HAUNTING
4 words fir an ep: Common Book of Prayer
@Jake Chip&PIN: French invention!
"Red gas go fastah!" Is some top tier ork logic
Guys I don't know if you're familiar with Michael S Judge of "death is just around the corner" podcast, he's had the Chapo guys on his show... He talks in one episode about how the American oil tycoons shared leaded gas manufacturing with the Nazis. They couldn't have done blitzkrieg without it.
Is that the name of the show? I can't seem to find it on spotify
I've actually been singing songs from Hamilton that use his name since it was first mentioned here so listening to Jake make stuff up with no context is very enjoyable lol
I used to live on a street where I learned the neighbours had got together to discuss the water pipe servicing the street because it was discovered to contain lead, and they put a kitty together to replace it with plastic. This was in the UK in the 1980's they did this!
And an elderly family member apparently used to emphasise around that time that when unleaded petrol came out, it was mismarketed. And was in fact "low lead", and seemed to think it was less good than leaded! How are people like this lmao
I feel like someone should mention that piston nock is more than just an annoying sound. It causes damage and will destroy an engine. Obviously not as bad as leaded gas but way more than just an annoying sound.
I got a little ticked off at Julian saying that this wasn’t solving a real problem and a conspiracy to sell more gas/cars… Travis did insert that leaded gas increased gas mileage and engine longevity. Rather this would actually decrease gas consumption and the need to replace your car as often (of course you'd buy their leaded gas so it's still good for business) … the problem is they used fucking lead which they knew was dangerous and our regulatory system is broken. But they were actually trying to fix a real issue, just settled on a terrible solution and ignored the externalities.
Fun fact about Kettering–he is our local business tyrant in that there is both an entire town outside of Dayton named after him. I visited his mansion (now an office/museum) a few years back to help my uncle with shooting a commercial on site for the KETTERING HEALTH NETWORK, one of our largest hospital networks. Amenities included a study about the size of an entire library, an indoor shooting range in the basement, a piano of which there is only one other in the world, and an actual retractable observatory complete with a big ass telescope.
I learned this from a BATS song in 2012
I was so sure it was gonna be *humans* but no, it was this one guy lolol
True! But also I think we have yet to reckon with denialism about farming animals, especially in industrialised nations: "Scientists have concluded that avoiding meat and dairy products is the single biggest way to reduce your environmental impact on the planet and that large cuts in meat consumption in rich nations are essential to ending the climate crisis." meaning collective AND personal action is required of those of us in industrialised nations and instead... we don't do that. 😫 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/07/plant-based-meat-by-far-the-best-climate-investment-report-finds
Stopping by to pre-order a shirt that says "Have you tried pissing in it?" K thnx 😊
Just realized it’s a perfect slogan for the Trickle Down series.
This really is the story of so many harmful substances isn't it? Some data suggests it's harmful, a few health officials speak up but still it persists for years before something is done. See: smoking, asbestos, etc.
I’ve not really vibed with the Trickle Down series before but this episode was brilliant. Just pure corporate evil hooked up to your veins. Looking forward to parts 2 & 3.
A TRIPLE TRICKLE?! Stoked, this is one of my fav stories. You know, in the way that your fav stories cause you days of dreadful contemplation after you remember how they go.
This episode has a uncanny parallel with Musk and neurolink published today https://www.reuters.com/technology/want-details-elon-musks-brain-implant-trial-youll-have-ask-him-2024-02-02/
I grew up in Dayton. Charles Kettering is treated like a god, the town I was born in is named after him, though I didn’t learn midgley worked for him until like a year ago, when I went to a Native American museum that was funded by the Kettering foundation and went down a wiki rabbit hole. I knew the story, just didn’t know it all happened down the street from my parents
I haven’t finished the episode but I am always shocked at how much I love this show. It’s so good! Even though I’m banging my head against the wall learning this crazy history
The introduction makes it sound like an episode of "behind the bastards" lol. I can't wait to listen to the rest.
You know, I thought BTB did an ep on Midgely, but I don't see it. I know the Dollop did.
Hope you at least get into how Thomas Midgley Jr. died for a brief moment of levity in the story.
Love when the boys adopt an accent and can't shake it for the rest of the episode.
if only adding red was the solution
Hamilton 2: Rise of the Machines
Before the guy became a butterfly himself, Julian's little sub-story was a bit like a reverse Metamorphosis
Midgely is a strong contender for second choice to assassinate as a time traveller. Top ten for sure.
How has there never been a movie made about Midgley? I think his story deserves a Cohen Brothers treatment. The tragicomedy of his life…and the way he died…crazy. There has to be screenplay out there somewhere. Jake get on it!
Next season of Fargo
I did a College Group Report on CFC's in the late 80s. They were supposed to do away with them by mid 90s and it didn't quite happen like that.
On this, the day of a new Fall of Civ podcast? Eating good today!
I said the same to my brother!
