Trickle Down Episode 14: Like Mother's Milk
How we feed babies and young kids greatly impacts their health, growth, and future. This affects not only the children but also women and society. While baby formula has its uses, and it literally be a life saver in certain circumstances, it also comes with significant health, economic, and environmental costs. On the other hand, breastfeeding has proven health benefits for both mothers and babies in high-income and low-income settings alike. Despite that, according to the World Health Organization, less than half of babies and young children are breastfed as recommended.
How did this happen?
According to a three-paper series published in The Lancet in 2023, the lack of breastfeeding is due to multifaceted and highly effective strategies used by commercial formula manufacturers of infant formula. The strategies are designed to target and influence parents, health-care professionals, and policy-makers. The industry’s dubious marketing practices are compounded by lobbying of governments, often covertly via trade associations and front groups, against strengthening breastfeeding protection laws and challenging food standard regulations.
This episode of Trickle Down explores the roots of this problem: the infant formula industry in the early 20th century captured doctors and medical associations in order to sell their product. And when they reached the limit of infant formula market in the United States, they simply aggressively sold their powders to mothers in poor countries, with disastrous and deadly consequences.
REFERENCES
Breastfeeding 2023
https://www.thelancet.com/series/Breastfeeding-2023
Apple, Rima. Mothers and Medicine: A Social History of Infant Feeding, 1890–1950. University of Wisconsin Press, 1987.
The Baby Killer (1974)
https://waronwant.org/sites/default/files/THE%20BABY%20KILLER%201974.pdf
Stevens EE, Patrick TE, Pickler R. A history of infant feeding. J Perinat Educ. 2009 Spring;18(2):32-9. doi: 10.1624/105812409X426314. PMID: 20190854; PMCID: PMC2684040.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2684040/
Why The Breastfeeding Vs. Formula Debate Is Especially Critical In Poor Countries
Ziegler EE. Adverse effects of cow's milk in infants. Nestle Nutr Workshop Ser Pediatr Program. 2007;60:185-199. doi: 10.1159/000106369. PMID: 17664905.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17664905/
APPLE, RIMA D. “‘TO BE USED ONLY UNDER THE DIRECTION OF A PHYSICIAN’: COMMERCIAL INFANT FEEDING AND MEDICAL PRACTICE, 1870-1940.” Bulletin of the History of Medicine, vol. 54, no. 3, 1980, pp. 402–17. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/44441272.
Walters DD, Phan LTH, Mathisen R. The cost of not breastfeeding: global results from a new tool. Health Policy Plan. 2019 Jul 1;34(6):407-417. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czz050. PMID: 31236559; PMCID: PMC6735804.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6735804/pdf/czz050.pdf
Munblit, D., Crawley, H., Hyde, R., & Boyle, R. J. (2020). Health and nutrition claims for infant formula are poorly substantiated and potentially harmful. bmj, 369.
https://www.bmj.com/content/bmj/369/bmj.m875.full.pdf
Boatwright, M., Lawrence, M., Russell, C., Russ, K., McCoy, D., & Baker, P. (2022). The Politics of Regulating Foods for Infants and Young Children: A Case Study on the Framing and Contestation of Codex Standard-Setting Processes on Breast-Milk Substitutes. International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 11(11), 2422-2439. doi: 10.34172/ijhpm.2021.16
https://www.ijhpm.com/article_4169.html
Nancy E. Zelman, The Nestle Infant Formula Controversy: Restricting the Marketing Practices of Multinational Corporations in the Third World, 3 Transnat'l Law. 697 (1990).
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/303871848.pdf
Infant nutrition : a textbook of infant feeding for students and practitioners of medicine / by Williams McKim Marriott.
https://iiif.wellcomecollection.org/pdf/b29929453
Wattana, Melissa. The Baby Bottle and the Bottom Line: Corporate Strategies and the Infant Formula Controversy in the 1970s (2016)
https://hshm.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/Wattana%20senior%20essay%202016.pdf
Comments (56)
Haven't listened yet but the synopsis suggests that this is missing the practical difficulties of breastfeeding for many parents. I've worked with women who've stored breastfeeding solely because there are no facilities for expressing milk at work and I don't think that's uncommon.
I feel like this episode was lacking analysis on the overt misogyny of the medical field and obstetrics specifically in the late 19th/early 20th century (and today). There was (is) definitely a sense among doctors that women’s bodies are inherently disgusting, feeble and flawed that I’m sure influenced their support of formula. Not a bad episode but could have been a lot stronger…
Yeah this story about nestle & the beginnings of formula has already been covered extensively by things like NPR & Behind The Bastards & it just doesn’t feel relevant to use to it to shame moms for formula at a podcast primarily about American politics when breastfeeding is often a weapon used against women. Other people have commented from experience here but I just want to say this morning on Instagram I saw a picture of woman working at a fast food place with her baby strapped to the front of her while taking orders. We can’t possibly expect women to afford to breastfeed & work while still providing the majority of emotional & domestic labor for most people in their lives. It’s a physically taxing process that seems to require some mental fortitude that women are constantly shamed for not being able to do. It’s also a wedge issue where people who get really into breastfeeding as a marker of their worth are more likely to get sucked into other bullshit like anti vaccine propaganda & q stuff. Fed is best.
Another super interesting episode, Travis! The information presented was good as usual but I agree with some that there was often a derisive tone/edge to some of the jokes about formula. Two things can be true: Nestlé is super sketchy and formula has its place. I think some background on early formula (going back to ancient times), wet nurses, child mortality, industrializion and womens emancipation would have provided some additional context as to why Nestlé's messages were received as well as they were in some areas. Or the social status and religious belief aspect of breastfeeding (ex: at different points in history, high status women employing wet nurses; the image of breastfeeding changing to be seen as a saintly duty; working class women not having access to maternity leave). All in all, glad I listened - I learned some things!
Ngl, when I first saw the notification for this, I thought it was a perverts ep about lactation fetish
Funny how Julian is supposed to be the "leftie" voice in QAA but it's Travis who is illustrating, with devastating efficacy, the dangers of capitalism.
WHY IS THIS PODCAST PROMOTING MISINFORMATION?! I've been to Switzerland multiple times and Travis, there is nothing "delightful" about the food!
Took me a while to press play on this - I thought “Like mothers milk” signified it being some kind of PERVERTS episode I wasn’t ready for 🤦 (Love perverts just have to be in the mood lol)
I understand why it isn’t a focus of the episode, but it’s important to say outright that there’s no shame in relying on formula if it is needed. The superiority of breastfeeding is so thoroughly hammered into expecting mothers that a failure to successfully breastfeed (in our case, bad latch and low supply) can lead to a spiral of despair. For anyone who might need to hear it: breast may be best, but you can feed your kid formula and still be a terrific parent.
<3 I loved breastfeeding my son and expected to breastfeed until he was at least — at least! — a year old. And then at 6 weeks postpartum I was diagnosed with breast cancer. So, chemo instead of breastfeeding. The spiral of despair around not being able to breastfeed is real, and so unhelpful.
I can't believe that Travis hates quadriplegic single mothers, I will be voting for Trump in the next election.
I really love Trickle Down and have learned a lot through the series. Thanks! I heard your caveats at the top of the episode, but it did feel at times as if the jokes and the conversation did demonize formula itself, not just the industry and history.
I thought this was a really balanced and well presented episode. I’ve breastfed all six of my kids with varying degrees of “success” (and by that I mean length of time - from a couple of weeks to 3 years)). Formula was a lifesaver for two of them. As an industry though it’s hugely problemátic and we should be able to discuss that without formula feeding parents feeling like it’s a judgement on them for the choices they’ve made due to preference or necessity.
Fed is best.
So- I give you guys the benefit of the doubt and I completely understand how Nestle and companies wanted to sell more formula. I listened to the episode in that mindset and totally appreciated all your research in the topic of how companies lie to sell their product. But as a woman- fed is best. I for example have bipolar, and would not be able to take my medication and breastfeed at the same time. There are lots of reason formula REALLY helps woman- and I think maybe that point of view was a little lost during the episode. I did love learning the history the formula industry- and I still find it valuable. Just a little feedback I had while listening 😊.
They kinda skipped a lot of the more terrible stuff in favor of the more institutional stuff.. in Africa, a lot of babies died because their formula was watered down due to lack of being able to afford enough and/or mixed with unclean water because that's what was available.. and the push being made in the hospital meant many mothers stopped lactating before they knew it would be a problem
i think multiple things can be true at the same time. 1. Corporations invented baby formula for profit and to exploit consumers. 2. Women's health is not a priority of study in Healthcare or general science. 3. Breastfeeding can be EXTREMELY painful for women and demands a huge psychological and physical toll on women who do so (your body is not yours). Rich women NEVER breastfed. 4. Modern baby formula provides everything your baby needs for healthy development. Ugh, so many thoughts about this episode. Thank you for trying.
This was a brave episode, not surprised at the super negative comments. Loved the episode and am biased as a mom that breastfed for almost 3 years. My milk came in late and I was luckily never pressured into formula. I worked 60 hour weeks nights and pumped, mostly for my comfort cause my baby never took a bottle, he would just go without feedings overnight.
This is an episode about capitalism, not how you're a bad mother or how you should never use formula or how women's voices are absent on this episode. It's about the fucked up way formula use started and it's history.
My ma couldn't breastfeed me because of the medication she was on, I got baby formula for like a lil while and then really early I got weaned on to some mad foods because I was growing so quickly which made me grow more quickly, my ma would cook me fish, potatoes, and milk up, which, swear down turbocharged my development. the 'industry' around what you should feed your baby and how you should have your baby and look after your baby is fucking mad misogynistic though.
This was a great episode and jives with a decent amount of my experience when I went through both breast and formula feeding with my son. This season of trickle down is even better than the first in my opinion.
Thank you to everyone commenting. I love QAA, but I believe I will skip this episode. Breastfeeding is still a sore spot for me. My milk never came in. When I went to see the lactation consultant, they left me alone in a room with my daughter, and told me to pump. She started screaming, and they never came back. They never helped with anything. It was a nightmare, and I left feeling like the worst mother ever. My son never got a good latch, and again, I failed as a mom. When I read the description, I knew it might be a skip. Again, thank you to the people commenting about the content. I will skip this one.
Yeah, formula serves an insanely valuable purpose for so many people that must be acknowledged
The strategy of companies directly marketing to doctors is one used by Pfizer and merck in the 40s and 50s. There's a fantastic book called Pills,Power, and Policy by Dominque Tobell that outlines it. It's fascinating to see that this particular strategy was being used far earlier. I wonder whether the pharmaceutical giants had taken notes from the infant formula industry?
I also agree it would have been good to have Annie Kelly on. I think discussing the actions of companies that intentionally convinced women in depressed economic conditions and marginalized communities to stop breast feeding in favor of what was, at the time, less than nutritional, and sometimes dangerous, formula, is important however. It was not in favor of health, but profit. Certainly, current formula is a life saver for many mothers, but the same industries still control the distribution and sale of formula, at the expense of many mothers who can't breastfeed. Formula should be affordable or free! And women who choose to use formula shouldn't be shamed for it. Maybe I missed it, but I didn't notice this episode disagreeing with the above points.
$1 in 1869 is equivalent in purchasing power to about $22.55 today
Listening to this while breastfeeding 💪🏻 I’ll never switch to formula 😴
Love this episode in its purest form breast-feeding is free but in today’s society and going back to work ….it is far from free you need bags to store it, nipple guards, massage sticks, you need pumps that are very expensive. You need bottles and equipment for said pumps. you could also pay for doctors visits for clogged ducts and other items to help that. Vitamins even added expenses. Breast-feeding is far from free if you have to work or cannot care for your baby 24 7
This one was a rare miss for me. No new parent is choosing not to bf because they have been befuddled by “big formula”. They know the benefits and drawbacks and have made a choice that is best for their situation. Offering formula supplement at the hospital is not a trick to get a baby “hooked”. It can often take days for a mother’s milk to come in or they could be experiencing a medical emergency. Every situation is different and it is condescending to assume parents cannot make an informed choice. There’s enough “mom guilt to go around already”. Also, breast feeding is only “free and easier” if you don’t value a mother’s time or mental health. Not to mention pump parts, nursing bras, breast pads, etc etc.
They weren't even talking about mothers' agency, let alone blaming them for anything. It's a top-down systemic analysis with blame appropriately applied to those at the top and trusted authority figures. Are you sure you didn't just read the title and reflexively went in defense mode without listening or reading the short summary? I understand and agree the vast reach of misogyny is almost impossible to escape, especially for mums, and if that's what was going on here I'd naturally share same criticisms.
Formula gang checking in
I would also like to note that breastfeeding is only free if you don't think a woman's time is worth anything.
I had to stop and turn off the episode. All the supposed long term benefits of breastfeeding disappear when you control for socio-economic factors. Sibling studies show no difference in outcomes between breastfed and formula fed infants. In a developed nation such as the US where access to clean water is not an issue formula and breast milk both have risks and benefits and they are equal choices. What the formula companies did was wrong but we've swung way too far the other way.
I have to applaud his willingness to wade into these waters…. We need honest discussion and I’ll take it when and where it comes as long as it’s dealing in fact and left open for inclusion of the many, many voices and experiences
Travis was obviously breastfed.
Very good episode. It is however worth mentioning that modern formula isn't the same thing as past formula, and mothers shouldn't feel ashamed if they are not able to breast feed or they have to supplement feeding. It's not a failure. That just happens sometimes. And while there are great short term benefits to breast feeding, studies have shown that there's not a cognitive difference between adults who were breast fed as babies and those that weren't. While beast milk is better, kids are generally okay on formula if you can't breast feed.
Thank you for saying this, as a mom who physically couldn’t produce enough milk and felt defeated and depressed. My mental health was seriously at risk, and my baby is healthy and happy thanks to formula. Adding to say- I think Nestle is a horrible company and the cost of formula (AND breastfeeding supplies for that matter!) is honestly criminal. The formula shortage was terrifying for me. Also- moms just can’t win. But that’s a whole other can of worms.
My partner is currently breastfeeding ours and the decision was partly based on our issues with the industry! Our kid is a micropreemie, born at week 25. Breastfeeding started a few weeks ago, around week 37, and it's definitely helped her a lot. My partner was pumping into bottles and we bring the bottles to the hospital every day so that our baby has her milk directly. We're also freezing her milk and will be sharing bottle feeding duties when she's not breastfeeding. We're literally emptying out most of the freezer for that. We likely have enough for several months already, and we don't yet know if we'll resort to formula if needed in the future. For now the plan is to just do breastfeeding + bottle feeding for as long as needed. Thanks for doing this episode! It's really something that more people need to be aware of.
Amen to that ! 😎
Travis View is always the most hesitant voice on the cast but when he speaks up he makes it count
I agree with you 100%, and breastfed all of my biological children. Sadly in America this is a privlidge. Lack of sufficient maternity leave makes breastfeeding nearly impossible for many mothers.
Sounds like somebody has been paid of by Big Boob to slander the humble formula industry smh
Um. There should be a “Boob” coalition. It’s kinda a brilliant idea 🤣🤣 0f COURSE our mascot will be the too oft maligned Boobie Bird 😁
You can still buy Horlicks (at least in the UK) , it's an old person bedtime drink sold in the shops alongside things like Ovaltine. Can't even contemplate giving it to a baby!
I'm partial to the stuff myself for a bit of a comforting treat. My memory too is that when I was younger it was marketed more as a sleep aid or something like that. Even though it's full of sugar 😋
I want to add that bottle feeding also allows the mom to be away from the baby for longer stretches of time because dad can now feed the baby. This helps mom for example to earn money. Make of that what you will! It certainly is something the right doesn't like to see, another reason for them to tout the virtues of "all-natural women". It is especially hard on women in the US. I live in Europe and had no problem breastfeeding for months because I had the time because of paid maternity leave and other benefits.
How dare you slander Nestle’s Quik. Also, great ep.
Reason 1,453,455 why the US needs paid maternity leave. It’s literally impossible for many mothers to breastfeed because they can’t take time off work. This country utterly fails families.
🙌🙌🙌this!
Nestlé is one of those corporations you can point most normies to for a clear unambiguous example of how capitalism's relentless thirst for deregulation with no accountability is like really seriously bad for pretty much everyone in its path.
It’s going to be really fun when/if SCOTUS overturns Chevron Deference… it’s the height of stupidity to put science based decisions in the hands of federal judges by overruling lower court decisions in favor of religious fanaticism (think of judge Kacsmaryk’s totally pilled ruling on mifepristone) …. But that’s exactly what they seem hell bent on doing 🙄😱
Mothers milk: Trickle Down or Perverts ep?
I’m kicking myself for missing the obvious available puns 😶😆🤣
ye listening while my better half feeds ours ✊
Stoked for a new episode of Trickle Down!
Literally listening to this while breastfeeding my baby boy 🥺
