💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
Trickle Down Episode 13: Educational Fashions (1 of 2)
December 31, 2023

Trickle Down Episode 13: Educational Fashions

The root concept of “learning styles” is based on a simple and intuitive idea: different people most successfully learn through different means. Or maybe they best learn through different sensory or emotional inputs. Possibly because people with differing brains make them more receptive to certain ways of knowing and absorbing information. Some people managed to take this intuitive idea and build massively successful careers for decades. Students were labeled “Visual,” “Aural,” or “Kinesthetic” learners.

The problem, as researchers discovered in the ‘00s, is that there’s no good evidence to suggest that any of the “learning styles” models popular with teachers actually improved educational outcomes. But that did little to slow the popularity of learning styles — or the mini industry built up around them.


REFERENCES

McLaughlin, Dorene Casey EdD, "An Evaluation Case Study of the Effects of a Learning Style Awareness Program for Ninth Graders at an Independent School" (1996). Dissertations. 617. https://digital.sandiego.edu/dissertations/617

Furey, William, “The Stubborn Myth of Learning Styles” (2023)

https://www.educationnext.org/stubborn-myth-learning-styles-state-teacher-license-prep-materials-debunked-theory/

Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008). Learning Styles: Concepts and Evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 9(3), 105-119. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6053.2009.01038.x

Sun X, Norton O, Nancekivell SE. Beware the myth: learning styles affect parents', children's, and teachers' thinking about children's academic potential. NPJ Sci Learn.

2023 Oct 17;8(1):46. doi: 10.1038/s41539-023-00190-x. PMID: 37848467; PMCID: PMC10582039.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37848467/

Coffield, F. (2004). Learning Styles and Pedagogy in Post-16 Learning: a Systematic and Critical Review. LSRC Reference, Learning & Skills Research Center, London.

https://www.leerbeleving.nl/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/learning-styles.pdf

Cassidy, Simon (2004) Learning Styles: An overview of theories, models, and measures, Educational Psychology, 24:4, 419-444, DOI: 10.1080/0144341042000228834

https://doi.org/10.1080/0144341042000228834

Rogowsky, Beth A., et al. “Matching Learning Style to Instructional Method: Effects on Comprehension.” Journal of Educational Psychology, vol. 107, no. 1, 2015, pp. 64–78., doi:10.1037/a0037478.

“Belief in Learning Styles Myth May Be Detrimental.” PsycEXTRA Dataset, 2019, doi:10.1037/e504772019-001.

Fleming, N., and Baume, D. (2006) “Learning Styles Again: VARKing up the right tree!”, Educational Developments, SEDA Ltd, Issue 7.4, Nov. 2006, p4-7.

Knoll, Abby R., et al. “Learning Style, Judgements of Learning, and Learning of Verbal and Visual Information.” British Journal of Psychology, vol. 108, no. 3, 2016, pp. 544–563., doi:10.1111/bjop.12214.

Nancekivell, Shaylene E., et al. “Maybe They’Re Born with It, or Maybe It’s Experience: Toward a Deeper Understanding of the Learning Style Myth.” Journal of Educational Psychology, vol. 112, no. 2, 2020, pp. 221–235., doi:10.1037/edu0000366.

Hyman, Ronald & Rosoff, Barbara (1984) Matching learning and teaching styles: The jug and what's in it, Theory Into Practice, 23:1, 35-43, DOI: 10.1080/00405848409543087

https://doi.org/10.1080/00405848409543087

Learning Styles Network Resources Brochure

https://web.archive.org/web/20050527165802fw_/http://www.learningstyles.net/2004/resource_brochure/resource_brochure.pdf

Comments (56)

J
Joe Fitzpatrick · May 27, 2024

Always suspected this. Used to teach at a progressive school which had different coloured paper for handouts based on what "thinking hat" the lesson was based on. And don't get me started on "Habits of Mind". One teacher went to a conference on it and returned like a missionary for a cult.

C
Cate Kneale · March 3, 2024

An academic has very seriously told me that boys and girls learn differently and I strongly suspect that this is a bogus extension of learning styles into biological essentialism .

C
Chloe Showalter · December 6, 2024

Oh it’s an idea form the turn of the century that boys and girls need to be socialized differently and need to be taught in different schools so that boys will develop a bit brain and girls will develop a girl brain. They thought that co education would make children have androgynous brains, and that was thought to lead to the breakdown of society. Michael Kimmel discusses this in his book Manhood in America

M
Minerva Frost · January 19, 2024

I'm training to be a primary school teacher and although my program is careful to always say Learning Styles are myth, it's pervasive in education and still used constantly.

K
Kelley Hattox · January 18, 2024

Travis - I can not emphasize how helpful this was for me to hear. I work in the mental health arena and I am literally having our intellectual modules re-written. I so so so appreicate your research.

B
Brianna Cluck · January 18, 2024

This reminds me of my 9th grade algebra class, where we spent one day talking about learning styles and how important they are, then they made everyone play with play dough as an example of kinetic learning....and then the rest of the class was normal whiteboard class stuff

S
Shiv · January 9, 2024

I had a hybrid Julian/Jake (weed, crush-motivated) learning style in High School. Not sure I’ve moved far beyond that

C
Chloe Showalter · January 6, 2024

I stumbled into a lecture at a psych conference as an undergrad in 2015 about the learning styles myth. In grad school, we were taught that we should always use multiple modalities and that multiple modalities (visual AND audio AND etc) is the best strategy.

S
Stephanie · January 4, 2024

Yes 100%, a whole pod of Travis giving tests.

O
Onepurple Ghost · January 4, 2024

I work in adult literacy in direct program delivery with adult learners, and delivering PD to other adult literacy practitioners. I include whatever mention of Learning Styles I have to include (training curriculum) but I always manage to slip in that it is bunk/unproven... I'm a bit of a wild child in the world of Adult Literacy up here in Canada 😁 In my experience, most adult learners THINK they have a particular learning style. Whatever - universal design and accessible program delivery works, regardless. (Looking forward to the day the k-12 system gets their shit together and puts me out of business.)

S
Snickerdoodle · January 3, 2024

Rant: A few years ago in the black hole known as the province of Saskatchewan in Canada, the entire model of teaching math in school was replaced by visual methods. Here is how it was explained to me by parents with kids stuck in the system: Instead of long division using the traditional method (ie. numbers) , blocks of paper was used to do figure out the answer. The teachers had no idea how to do it themselves, let alone parents trying to help their kids with homework. One person told me the rationale was to get "visual" learners to understand math problems better... so they inflicted this on all students. Most of our friends are science-types or engineers. Some never figured out the new method. One parent defied things and taught their kids the old sensible way. Why was this method brought in? Who knows. It had been introduced in another province where, after two years, they declared it an unmitigated disaster... Right about the time Saskatchewan was introducing it. I think Saskatchewan dropped it a year or two later. P. S. This might not be related but... Guess the Canadian province with the lowest scores in reading comprehension and math skills; the lowest literacy rate; and the lowest graduation rate from high school. Oh - and a very high rate of religious home schooling.

M
MEJ · January 3, 2024

I thought Julian was going to explode a few times “it’s his dinosaur game 🙄”

C
Caitlin Baerg · January 3, 2024

Something else that I think contributes to the continued propagation of this type of thing is that it gives people an identity to cling to. We humans love to classify ourselves and wear it like a badge of honor. "yes I am a VISUAL learner, I am a RAVENCLAW, I'm a diehard CELTICS fan, my hair is NATURALLY RED and CURLY" etc. It makes us feel special and to debunk this thing now feels like you are stripping some weird identity away from us that was probably mentioned offhand by one teacher while we were in elementary school. Weird.

M
Matt Dear · January 2, 2024

"I want to people to change their minds so their practices are more in line with the evidence. But, people don't change their minds. What happens is that an older generation dies, and a new generation has new ideas, that's just the way it works." I'll drink to that.

V
Vaz · January 6, 2024

Cheers to mortality, tbh.

S
Sybian Musk · January 2, 2024

My son’s teacher got mixed up and thought she was supposed to use the Varg method and now my boy keeps asking me if Japan is a perfect ethno-state

J
Johannes Heskamp · January 5, 2024

I thought this method was taught with a knife?! 😱

S
Samantha · January 2, 2024

I am loving this new season of trickle down even more than the first season of it, for whatever reason. Love some good juicy Travis content

C
Casper Fox · January 2, 2024

One of the side-effects about Travis' debunkings is that I'll never feel vindicated for any of this. It's always, "Yep, my teachers used a bogus educational model while telling me to drink more Gatorade" and I just sat there and sucked it like a champ.

P
Phertility · January 1, 2024

So glad Julian cleared the air about Montessori [for now]

t
the gnome that hits you in the shin with an axe · January 1, 2024

I learn idiot moron loser style

N
Nermal · December 31, 2023

I’m feel lucky that when I was taking education courses in the mid-2010s we were told outright that “learning styles” was an outdated fad. Then I went on to do my PhD (not in education) and I’ve met so many faculty and students who still buy into the idea! All my students who have mentioned it say they are “visual learners” — no one wants to admit to being a dirty “kinetic learner” apparently.

V
Vaz · January 6, 2024

Weird. I'll readily and emphatically admit I can't learn visually or by reading, but maybe being 32 has something to do with that. Gen Z has grown up with few options other than videos for learning.

S
Smooth Shrek · December 31, 2023

Good shit

E
Emily · December 31, 2023

I’m a swimming lessons supervisor and instructor. I was taught to incorporate different learning styles into my lesson planning, so this definitely caught my attention. I think I’ll still consider visual/tactile/auditory components of instruction when making lessons, but it’s helpful to know that this is considered a myth when considering why some students struggle to progress. It was also really helpful to learn about the way parents, students, and educators had biases about different learning styles. In my line of work, students who would be classified as auditory/kinaesthetic learners are thought to to have an advantage. It’s really fascinating to observe the way different students will respond to the same activity or set of instructions.

Z
ZambianOnAmbien · December 31, 2023

Travis, listen to the “Sold a Story” Podcast docuseries by Emily Hanford about “Whole Language Learning” Reading Instruction. Same Ol’ Shit. Sounded Good. Everyone signed on. Reading comprehension plummeted. True Believers continued to teach the pedagogy despite the preponderance of evidence and studies that proved otherwise.

�
𓅊 MK Ulta 💋💄💅 · January 1, 2024

Our state uses it. We're ranked 43rd in the nation for academic achievement and we're a blue state. It never even occurred to me that this approach existed. I started undergrad in psych and linguistics. I never heard the phrase 'whole language learning' until my kid was in high school. I'd love QAA to do a whole episode on this. It's a big deal. I'm off to listen to Hanford.

G
Greg C · December 31, 2023

I’ve never been able to learn through traditional studying that evolves ready and memory. I’ve always learned by seeing something. I can do math really well because I can see it. If I’m shown a finished product that is constructed of parts, I can understand how it was built and build my own from scratch. I always considered myself a “visual learner”. Turns out, I don’t know shit about fuck.

V
Vaz · January 6, 2024

Or maybe there's some amount of truth getting lost between "learning styles are this" and "learning styles are completely nonexistent."

J
Josep C. · December 31, 2023

"They all learn in different ways", and yet you took the WRONG WAY jake. If you pay our Exclusive, Patented Course, you too can be "NOT SO DUMB" (tm)

L
Lioness Creations · December 31, 2023

It’s not just teachers that have to learn these. The learning styles stuff was a whole lecture in nursing school.

H
Heather B · December 31, 2023

As an educator and someone getting their teaching license: YEPPPPP. 😅

J
Jackson · December 31, 2023

I love u Travis view......

P
Parochial Nimrod · December 31, 2023

ODELL LAKE 🫡

G
Greer Gillies · December 31, 2023

none of the questions on the test were even related to learning. they were all about navigation and communication...

B
Bobby Dubs · December 31, 2023

Lots of thoughtful comments here about the science and education industry and helping kids reach their fullest, and I just want to shitpost about Jake's "Trump reminisces about the Oregon Trail" bit. Another great episode, Daddy Travis!

A
Amy Immermann · December 31, 2023

Going to the 7-Eleven Green Bay Rd. you really are Chicagoan 😆

M
Marley Nicolson · December 31, 2023

Might just be the use of the term learning styles but what about kids with dyslexia, ADHD and autism as someone with dyslexia i definitely had a different style of learning English. When I was a kid I had to have specific English lessons out of school particular to my dyslexia again might just be the specific nature of learning styles but feel like you have massively missed something here

N
Nermal · December 31, 2023

This is why it’s a shame that the term “learning styles” has been hijacked by this specific kind of pseudoscience. Universal Design, the recommended framework for teaching accessibly, is much more practical and sophisticated. It focuses on modes of instruction rather than trying to sort students into reductive categories.

A
Amy · December 31, 2023

I’m an instructional designer so this really hit home! The learning styles framework is indeed debunked bullshit and a racket. (Also, everyone thinks they’re a visual learner)

J
Jim Veil · January 4, 2024

Yes! I'm an instructional designer too, and I have had people use their percieved learning style to just dismiss courses out of hand. I've had some people say, "I'm a kinesthetic learner," and insist any remote or asynchronous learning could possibly work for them. My company is totally work from home, though, so there's zero chance of us all getting in a room together for multiple hour training sessions like the old days.

�
𓅊 MK Ulta 💋💄💅 · December 31, 2023

Very interested in this. Our state uses whole language learning. They don't teach phonemic decoding. I started off in psych and linguistics. It never occurred to me that this was happening. In 3rd grade my son was still struggling so I made him an old fashioned 'horn book' (fe-fi-fo-fum) and we drilled all summer. It worked, but he had already lost so much time. I'm know I'm about to learn something but I can say with absolute confidence that learning by osmosis is a bad idea. We have a major university with a teaching college but the more open minded and informed teachers are driving 3 hours away on their own dime to learn how to teach phonics. It's absurd.

G
Greer Gillies · December 31, 2023

there's a podcast about this called "sold a story"!

J
Jacob King · December 31, 2023

I did psych as an undergraduate about 10 years ago and learned that it was a myth. This was the height of the replication crisis so a lot of stuff I was taught as fact was also just made up. So it goes. There are interesting historical reasons for why education and cognitive science are often at odds. Traditional universities looked down on teaching as a low class profession or trade and most teacher training was done at independent colleges. Often teachers weren’t even expected to study education. You have an English degree? You can teach English to high school kids. As teaching professionalized it had to build its theory and standards from first principles which is the environment the learning styles model comes out of. Julien was correct in identifying some sketchy ideas about intelligence in the quote he read. To me it sounded like some low key eugenics bell curve snobs sneering at the slobs from the teachers college who were making more money.

B
BPF · December 31, 2023

I am going on my 3rd year as a US public school teacher and this is bringing back old lectures from 2015-2018. My educational psych course actually has us read and compare both the Dunn and Vark models and design plans around them, meanwhile my actual pedagogy class, which was the one that you took multiple years, was very adamant on the whole thing being baseless. I am still surprised meeting other teachers who stick with the Learning Styles method, but until you mentioned those names I forgot that I was taught it

E
Elle BelAnge · December 31, 2023

Leave it to Travis to illuminate many of us in the education system about something we had to base our teaching styles on. Teachers college was all about this. I spent two years learning how to make multiple versions of lessons plans based on this very notion. I decided that supplying was best for me because I didn’t see myself building a carreer in teaching. It’s interesting because you get access to lesson plans by so many different types of teachers at different points in their carreer. In my experience, the newer teachers often have plans which place an emphasis on learning styles whereas the veterans usually have the straightforward streamlined plans. It’s not a case of being tired, giving up, etc. I think they’ve just been able to simplify what teachers college often complicates. I’ve just started a Library Technician program, where I’m seeing loads of parallels with the best of the material used for teaching. Luckily, I’ve yet to cross paths with any content from this episode in it. Crossing my fingers extra hard that I’ve escaped it for good. Thanks a bunch for this! I’ll know where to send colleagues struggling with this concept.

J
Johanna · December 31, 2023

Humans... 🤦‍♀️

M
Mel Black · December 31, 2023

This episode reminds me of how most public schools still use outdated curriculum for reading and writing. I’m dyslexic and so is my son and he did OG tutoring(multi sensory structured literacy program) and I’m fairly certain most people learn best in a style that incorporates more than one teaching style. The more engagement of both mind and body the better.

J
John Brandkamp · December 31, 2023

I'm so glad you did this episode. I worked all four years of my undergrad for Upward Bound, a wonderful tutoring program for at risk high schoolers, and we were all trained on this learning style mantra. I legit believed the propaganda until this episode.

R
Rakish Tilt 🎩 · December 31, 2023

Never did I think I would hear Dunn puns on this podcast, but now it sounds like my elementary school yard.

S
Susan · December 31, 2023

Thanks for putting this together? Hal Paschler is still in the UCSD dept of psychology. Educational material is such big business and teachers have such a desire for techniques to help them help their students. We need to do better to translate science to practice .

S
Stop the Spread · December 31, 2023

Oh my god, thank YOU. I’ve been teaching these learning styles for 2 years. I’m in corporate training and have ALWAYS hated them. Nice to have more ammo.

D
DrJRad · December 31, 2023

Please consider putting this on the main feed. More auditory learners need to hear this.

K
Kendra Gilbertson · December 31, 2023

Oh no, not Montessori 😅

J
Jeremy · December 31, 2023

Oh no I went to Montessori. Am I gonna feel bad about myself? Haha

B
Brian J. Lancaster · December 31, 2023

Oh shit, I used to try to tell people this whenever they would start bringing up "learning styles" at teachers' meetings, but nobody listened to me. Also, even if students are better at learning in one style, they should practice with all styles anyway.