Trickle Down Episode 12: The Elixir of Life Part 2
Part 2 of our exploration of how Gatorade influenced the science of hydration. In this episode Travis talks about how the Army developed bad doctrine around hydrating soldiers while preparing for war in the Middle East, how Gatorade helped finance athletic organizations, and why dangers related to overhydration were ignored in the 90s.
Also at one point Jake launches into an ad for Carpi Sun for some reason.
REFERENCES
Georgia Teen Dies From Drinking Too Much Water, Gatorade
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/georgia-teen-dies-from-drinking-too-much-water-gatorade/
Rovell, Darren. First in Thirst: How Gatorade Turned the Science of Sweat into a Cultural Phenomenon (2005)
Noakes, Timothy. Waterlogged: The Serious Problem of Overhydration in Endurance Sports (2012)
Water as a Tactical Weapon: A Doctrine for Preventing Heat Casualties
https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/tr/pdf/ADA113477.pdf
ACSM Position Stand: Exercise and Fluid Replacement
National Athletic Trainers’ Association Position Statement: Fluid Replacement for Athletes
https://www.nata.org/sites/default/files/FluidReplacementsForAthletes.pdf
Updated Fluid Recommendation: Position Statement From the International Marathon Medical Directors Association (IMMDA)
http://immda.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Spring-2006-Updated-Fluid-Recommendations.pdf
Gatorade demand high in war zones, squeezing supply
Water Intoxication—Considerations for Patients, Athletes and Physicians
Drinking policies and exercise-associated hyponatraemia: is anyone still promoting overdrinking?
Case proven: exercise associated hyponatraemia is due to overdrinking. So why did it take 20 years before the original evidence was accepted?
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2564296/#ref16
“Drink at least eight glasses of water a day.” Really? Is there scientific evidence for “8 × 8”?
https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/ajpregu.00365.2002
British Medical Journal: The Truth About Sports Drinks
https://www.bmj.com/bmj/section-pdf/187587?path=/bmj/345/7866/Feature.full.pdf
The sensitivity of the human thirst response to changes in plasma osmolality: a systematic review
https://ke.army.mil/bordeninstitute/other_pub/hydrationpdf.pdf
Comments (56)
Gatorade Water is available in supermarkets!
Does anyone remember the Gatorade commercial featuring one of the Toronto Raptors players squaring off against a literal raptor and both quenching their thirst with the neon-colored drink?
People aren’t drinking enough piss? Oh they will be… they will be…
"You get some of the water you need from the foods you eat" and the similar advice that's now popular, "you don't need a multivitamin because you get the vitamins you need from your food," seem kind of ridiculous to me. If your diet is ideally balanced, sure, both of those are true. That's the point of a balanced diet, after all. But I very much doubt most people eat a balanced diet. I certainly don't! Most of what I eat in an average day is just various forms of bread. The low quality of the cheap foods available to people who have neither money nor time is a known issue. Food deserts are also an issue. It's almost, kind of, like the "COVID deaths with complications from preexisting health problems shouldn't be counted as COVID deaths" thing, in the sense that people who have preexisting health problems are the majority, not a minority of special cases, and bad diet is also a majority.
Oh, and a clif bar or similar every hour or two (but only when doing extreme hikes.
Hydration is complicated 😂 I live and play in the desert. Hikes into and back out of the Grand Canyon on occasion. Water is the nearly perfect beverage. Cold, or warm. When I’m sweating a lot which is common, a packet of electrolyte powder added to a liter of water fits the bill. YMMV
Tell us what to do Travis!
You can't trust people who like cucumber gatorade
Travis' absolutely exhausted "oh-kay" at 1:13:21 has me in tears lmao 😭😂😭 Loved the episode!
Don't forget to rehydrate the lost water from all those tears.
loved the story about slamming 8 cups of water before bed. lol i remember when i was a kid I would be in the woods next to my house running around for 10hrs a day, and walking back home in the summer heat across hills and valleys sooo parched. then when id get home id run to the basement bar, grab a hot diet coke and chug like two of them at once. i didnt drink water til i was 18, and (compared to only drinking diet cokes) it was like night and day of feeling better.
surprised jake didn't bring up the gatorade sponsorship for powerups/stat upgrades in the gym in 2k
My biggest takeaway from Trickle Down has been the sheer amount of bad science required to rationalize war and US foreign policy.
Jake is Camelmaxxing 🐫 🐪 🐫 🐫
I'd just like to say to Jake, cucumber lime gatorade us the best gatorade, ignore the haters, you're right, I will continue to buy from this evil brand until they discontinue it.
I'm just shocked that Idiocracy and Brawndo were never mentioned in one of these episodes 😅 It has electrolytes!
It’s what plants crave!
I was in the Navy, and especially during boot camp, you are... encouraged... to drink a lot of water. At the time, we wore web belts with canteens. A common command was to drink whatever was left on our canteen and then hold it, upturned, above our heads to prove it was empty, or take an impromptu shower which would result in pretty painful punishment, usually for the entire division. The conventional wisdom of thirst not being an adequate indication of hydration was followed to the extreme. We once had someone fail our PT run and blame the Recruit Division Commanders (RDCs) because this individual claimed to have cramped up due to not being allowed to hydrate enough. Naturally, EVERYONE was punished for this per standard operating procedures when dealing with new recruits. Anyway, I just got to the part where the military is being discussed and hydration program drinking was alive and well in 2001 at the very least.
It's pretty miraculous that none of us died of too much water that day.
Thank you. I am now sure that all hydration is a scam made up by the US army and capitalism. I will replace all my fluid intake with vodka to counteract. 🫡
Seared in my brain is the 'Water Sucks! It really really sucks!" part of a song about Gatorade from the film The Waterboy.
Happy to hear another This Is Not That segment! Love the Trickle Down series.
Not to be a contrarian (great episodes btw.), but I think I’m still in the camp of “program” drinking. The problem with the programs in these stories were that people drank truly incredible amounts of water/fluids. 4 Gallons! (2 Gatorade/2 water) makes me sick to even think about! Also, wouldn’t drinking Gatorade mitigate against hyponatremia?
Travis h8s water
I remember as a kid getting a question on some random test at elementary school that asked which should you choose if you had only one in a survival situation, food or water, and I said food with the rationale that many foods contain water. I got it wrong and felt like an idiot
That sigh at the end 😂😂 It's deeply impressive that Travis has done this with these two for, what like 5 years at this point, and hasn't murdered them even one time. Bravo.
Surrum
I gotta say that nothing so far has been quite as despairing as the idea that I've been carrying water bottles everywhere I go based on a lie. Is anything real?
You still have to drink water
It was the best of times, it was the thirst of times…
You drink water? Like out the toilet?
I’m listening to this while deeply hungover and thirsty. I’m unfortunately going to get a Gatorade once I drag myself up. But daaaaamn this is a great season!
Update: I bought a lime cucumber you assholes 🤣
In my case ingesting a lot of water or getting really stressed triggers intense sweating. My face becomes a waterfall. So I try to drink to thirst. If I exceed it trust me, I KNOW.
Have you been checked for hyperhydrosis? I got on some probathane for it due to being a side effect of a medication and boom - after a few doses no full head of soaking sweating anymore
Excellent start to series 2! I always try to drink to thirst. It’s important when you live in the Aussie climate to pay attention to your body’s signals. If I haven’t had enough water or it’s been a particularly hot and sweaty few days I can develop a headache that can be soothed with a single serve (about 200ml) of an electrolyte supplement called endura. I drink the low carb variety that has sodium, potassium and magnesium (no sugars) and I find it helps with muscle cramps. I remember a few years ago here a young woman went to a rave, consumed ecstasy, danced all night and somehow drank ten litres of water during the night. She collapsed and unfortunately died the next day. That spooks around in my head. General advice here is 1.5-2 litres a day. I don’t think people are aware enough of the dangers of over-hydration.
Hot wet - - - - - hot dry Cold wet - - - cold dry
Water is BS. I didn’t have any water for 7 years, only mtn dew and monster energy and I’m fine. Just depressed
I do the exact same thing with the watered down pink coconut water lol. It's not fake, Thai coconut water is naturally pink! Also, I discovered a legitimate medical use for Gatorade recently... when I had a colonoscopy. Turns out Gatorade+miralax+dulcolax is a cheap and far less disgusting way to do the pre op cleanse, and my doctor preferred prescribing that to the normal gunk you get from the pharmacy. I will say though, that after drinking the amount of Gatorade you have to drink, every 10 minutes for 2 hours, Gatorade is completely ruined for me and I never want to taste the stuff again. Which I'm totally fine with because all the flavors taste gross in that medicine kind of way. And Jake, I did this with the cucumber flavor because I like cucumber drinks and hadn't had that Gatorade before. Huge mistake lol
Now I want a Capri Sun-themed cocktail bar/elevated-cuisine bistro to exist. With menu items like “Pepsi sliders” and “Pacific breeze mousse.”
Pacific breeze mousse... Why did you have to put that beautiful thought in my head?
I, too, am a slave to that bougie pink coconut water. It was cheaper to smoke.
It has 6x more water than water
Ps: Travis… outstanding job! I am not joking in that I was actually wondering about this same subject … I think some article I half picked up on talked about deviation from the “8 glasses a day” rule and its tickled my brain since 😆 now… I have answers! But still no earthly idea what a ozmolgolicowlality measurement is. ( I think I’m spelling that wrong 🤔)
Jake…. if you’re out there…nurses I know go by the pee color guideline too. My understanding is that darker urine indicates a level of dehydration…and…I think your wife is pregnant. 😶
When I worked on mines in Australia as a student, there were pee colour charts above the urinals in the toilets, with warnings about risks of dehydration for the medium-dark shades. Also, some of the guys doing manual labour outdoors in >40°C temperatures would drink 10 litres of water per day.
The neurodiverse among us sometimes experience differences with our interoception and don't experience "thirst awareness". How spicy is your brain Jake?
I’m stealing the word “neurodiverse” from you… is that a thing? 🤣
I had a dehydration scare when moving apartments a few years ago where I hacked up a bit of blood. Ever since then I've had the exact opposite problem of overhydrating. I share Jake's neuroses about this kinda stuff too
Probably the best episode of Trickle Down to date, as it covers literally how we act in day-to-day life and potential problems with it.
Poor Jake ❤️ I drink so much more water if it has bubbles than flat water lol
This is now my official advice podcast for how much water to drink
You don't want us to over-hydrate.. AND YET you've named the series "Trickle Down". 🤔 Check mate!
OK but how many water?
Great episode! But seriously, how much should I drink to stay properly hydrated Travis?
Damn Jake, I need to run to the store and grab me a refreshingly delicious Capri Sun. Another great job Travis.
