Premium Episode 236: Tik Tokers Heart Bin Laden
The ongoing discourse around social media and extremism took a strange twist earlier this month after users of the social media platform Tik Tok discovered a 2002 work by Osama bin Laden called “Letter to America.” Tik Tokers noted the letter’s analysis of American imperialism and its effects on the Middle East, as well as the influence of Zionist thought on American politics. Many expressed shock and acted as if the brief letter completely altered their conception of the world, as if this was the very first critique of American foreign policy they ever encountered. This controversy ignited a very dumb conversation about the influence of social media, and Tik Tok in general, on young people.
To unpack this tempest in a teapot, Travis, Jake, and Liv discuss the letter itself, how Tik Tokers reacted to it, and how the controversy may be inflated by panic over Chinese-owned Tik Tok.
Thanks for being a patreon subscriber!
Liv Agar: http://livagar.com / http://linktr.ee/livagar
REFERENCES
Full Text: bin Laden’s Letter to America
Letter to American people Wikipedia Page
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_to_the_American_people
404 Media: The Guardian Deletes Osama Bin Laden’s Letter to America Because it Went Viral on TikTok
Washington Post: How Osama bin Laden’s ‘Letter to America’ reached millions online
https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/2023/11/16/guardian-osama-bin-laden-letter-to-america/
CNN: Some young Americans on TikTok say they sympathize with Osama bin Laden
https://edition.cnn.com/2023/11/16/tech/tiktok-osama-bin-laden-letter-to-america/index.html
Vice News: TikTok Says It's Not the Algorithm, Teens Are Just Pro-Palestine
https://www.vice.com/en/article/wxjb8b/tiktok-its-not-the-algorithm-teens-are-just-pro-palestine
Vice News: TikTok Says It's Not the Algorithm, Teens Are Just Pro-Palestine
https://www.vice.com/en/article/wxjb8b/tiktok-its-not-the-algorithm-teens-are-just-pro-palestine
Ryan Broderick: TikTok teens aren’t stanning Osama Bin Laden
https://www.garbageday.email/p/tiktok-teens-arent-stanning-osama
Reuters: Montana to become first US state to ban Tik Tok
https://www.reuters.com/world/us/montana-governor-signs-bill-banning-tiktok-state-2023-05-17/
New York Times: Nikki Haley Renews Call for TikTok Ban After Bin Laden Letter Circulates
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/17/us/politics/nikki-haley-tiktok-ban.html
New York Times: Lawmakers Renew Calls to Ban Tik Tok After Accusations of Anti-Israel Content
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/08/business/tiktok-accusations-anti-israel-content.html
Comments (84)
Everything is antisemitism to you guys.
I appreciated hearing a full Travis belly laugh at Liv’s joke about cops going on TikTok for a second and passing out like it’s fentanyl lol
You mentioned it being brought up in foreign policy college classes, I'm pretty sure I read that for AP US History in *high school* c. 2010. As I recall, it was recommended reading for an essay assignment and my teacher was pretty big on primary documents, but the point of it was "look at this document and be capable of realizing that some points are valid and others are absolute nonsense."
I do think people forget how those who were against Bush going into Iraq ( i was one) were attacked and shut out as peaceniks and unpatriotic. In fact, America had the world on our side for a brief moment after 9/11 and had Gore been president ( as he should have been) it wouldn’t have gone the way that it did. It tells us how important the right leader is and what we really should look for in one. Colin Powells bizarre presentation should have been a warning. He resigned shortly after even though people called for him to run for president. I think it’s a great point that people seem to want everything to be very simple because they don’t want to sort through the grey areas. Wouldn’t it be great if people tried to really understand something BEFORE they gave their damn opinion about it? But…. That takes too long. 😝
As a 45 year old old man, it’s strikes me as hilarious that a section of our society, are driving themselves into a panic over GenZ’kids on TikTok, when all I saw on January 6th 2021, were a mass of mostly late 30ish and up buffoons from my generation, Genx, acting like complete fucking fools on the steps of the capital, over THAT guy, in full view of all of us, born out of their collective addiction towards reading about “truths” on FB, various Chans, and BirdX. Give me a break. lol.
They find it profound and unique? 😣
Shout out to Jake’s Dragonheart reference.
I dunno, I ran into a lot of these videos. Not one tik toker said ‘’you know, he’s right, butt sex is bad and convert to jihadism’’ To me, they’re asking questions about the genocides of the world. They’re digging for information and aren’t staying silent about babies being blown up. Which is more than I can say about everyone else being so fkn silent about these atrocities.
I really want this to be what’s happening. And I would love if the digging doesn’t lead to a resurgence of Loose Change etc. It’s so easy to see the opposite happening though. I was searching Amelia Earhart new info the other day and one of the prompts was “was Amelia Earhart blind and deaf” so it’s hard to believe in the questioning.
So, would your average ticktocker like, literally explode if they watched fahrenheit 9/11 ?
This episode had me very tickled since I own a copy of The Horny Ghost of Osama bin Laden.
The Chinese brainwashing shit during the Korean War is so insane because it is not hard at all to imagine why a captured American soldier drafted to go to war in Korea would see the hell they are creating as they bomb their way through the country would think oh fuck we are definitely the bad guys here
As an Aussie who has never entered the dark chambers of TikTok, my mouth was on the floor and I laughed way too hard at this. Peraonally I feel this outrageous tiktok...phenomenon....may also be down to how demanding the platform is on creators to react, create, instigate discussion....it seems to me as a mostly ignorant observer to be a place that encourages thinking about your take for a maximum of two seconds before you post. Preferably sont think at all; emotionally react in the moment, and post before you consider. Cursed, cursed stuff. When I waa growing up Osama was so memed on in our media as the bad guy it's unimaginable to take him seriously even if I agree that the USA done fucked up pretty constantly.
Short version is there is a quote about the Jews bringing misery to America that is commonly misattributed to Ben Franklin but actually comes from fascist mystic and founder of the Silver Shirts William Dudley Pelley, who put a lot of his own antisemitic screeds in the voices if historical and patriotic figures he claimed to he psychically channelling
Hey just checking in, did anyone explain the Ben Franklin comment to y'all yet?
I wouldn’t just attribute this to an age thing. As a high school competitive debate nerd we were 16 reading Edward Said and Zizek debating kids who were reading Chuck Hagel and Jared Diamond. Plenty of kids have a capacity for deeper analysis. The issue at hand is for sure activation, interest, and quality of educational access.
Liv is so fucking funny, just casually dropping zingers left and right. 😂
This is just like when TikTok teens first found out about the 2016 Pizzagate conspiracy theory only a couple of years ago. TikTok really has become 'Baby's First Propaganda'.
They are scared of TikTok because It's a place for kids to learn that capitalism is bad, and they can connect to organise. Twitter and Facebook is not scary because it is run by fascist
Gotta say, I almost skipped this one until I looked at the comments and saw that Julian wasn’t there.
Damn, I need to get ret in on this tiktok side hustle too. Got all these unpaid bill reminders here I can read aloud on camera with a Pikachu-shocked face if the audience wants it. Silly accent requests only accepted on studied case-by-case basis of course.
The visual of a cop opening tiktok, trying to comprehend a singular mulch dog video, and then immediately passing away has sent me into the stratosphere 😂
So cursed that a Harry Potter reference was used here, but I should really be used to it at this point lol Cant wait to watch Loose Change 2023 in 4k in 3 minute segments on tik tok!
The typo about the Guardian is doubly funny as it had a reputation for massive amounts of typos itself back in the day of typesetting. So much so as it's known in the UK as "The Grauniad".
Shame Julian was sick this episode, although it may have helped his chances of not being deported back to Britain to live with Annie, Jake got to make his whole feeding Teddy treats in peanut butter is the same as reading Bin Laden's letter without anybody calling him because "This is not that", next time Julian is sent to Gitmo, I think Travis/Liv should have pre-recorded "this is not that" clips to drop when needed ♥️ Hope y'all feel better soon & love Travis plug for going outside and touching grass.
Regarding Liv’s comment about the US being bad being “communism 101,” I really think that for young American baby leftists it isn’t. I feel like a lot of Americans being radicalized to the left go through phases of realizing there are a lot of problems with the US, realizing that capitalism is the root of all those problems, and even maybe realizing they’ve been lied to about that, but then they’re still at a point where they think “Wow, it’s crazy that America is bad. It’s a shame we have to be the ones who police the world; it’s honestly really weird that America always supports the good guys in world conflicts and the communists were always bad.” They should, after having that thought, go “hey wait a minute…” but it sometimes takes a while.
Dragonheart lolol
Good grief. Don’t teach them about our behavior in the Korean War. Their heads might explode. How are we producing such stupid children?
Probably the public education system. Not that I should bash it too much, everywhere it's a constant fight to keep any shred of teaching and critical thinking alive.
I know younger people are just learning about the War on Terror, I guess, but really just read a fucking book about the history of US foreign policy. You will find plenty of criticisms of US policy without being interspersed with calls to convert to Islam and ban homosexuality. Those being Bin Laden's first and second calls to the US before he even makes calls for specific foreign policy corrections. I'm curious how many of these people actually even read the letter in full. Also, I am sorry I can't understand being surprised "terrorists" have actual material grievances and goals.
USUALLY rich people like Osama (who was very rich/subsidized by other terror hungry people (probably ultimately funded by us accidentally somehow) just relax and enjoy their fortune and don’t use it to murder people and go on the run. Osama isn’t your typical oligarch. Dude was a true evil villain. And now he’s dead. Good. But, yeah, the US has the most sad, repeated, reactionary, confusing, imperialist narrative, and corporate interests and weird competition between agencies and their reputations and miscalculated political messaging drive all our behavior. The American people are so far from at fault for “American policy”. As evidenced by these TikTok videos, Americans don’t even know what American policy is or was or will be. We are the hindsight is 60/20 country. About 75 years after we do something, SOME clarity starts to come develop as to why and who and when stuff happened. Anyway. You’re just right. That’s my point. LEARN STUFF CHILDREN!
Good to have a review of this letter cause I had no way to get a handle on it at the time other than 'america bad, terrorists bad'. Which tbh isn't that wrong. Details as an antidote to propaganda and all that though!
Also I liked the music at the end.
Sometimes absolute terrible people arrive at the right conclusions through the wrong methods. A broken clock is right two times a day.
I’m so happy you all talk about this because this baffled me! It was insane that people had an existential crisis after reading it
Maybe they read a different letter. Also… if I’m remembering correctly, weren’t there some super basic clip art emojis on the letter. It was like 3 Jewish stars and a few skull and cross bones. Does anyone else remember that??
Jake, bringing some serious old guy energy in this one
Jake definitely likes corn beef.
great ep, thanks everyone
Watching Americans discovering foreign policy the last few years is wild — though people really slept thru the GWOT. UBL benefitted from US imperialism as a whiny rich kid. Im so glad im not on tik tok, because my brain would melt if someone told me my emotions about UBL were cognitive dissonance LOL. Hes not a reliable narrator!
I think when that guy gets really scared of being accused of agreeing with Osama it’s one of the funniest things I’ve heard. Like… do these kids ever play board games? Have they ever thought ahead about what they say and do?
Jake thinks there's only "one bad guy" from Slytherin, and it's Draco Malfoy?!
Wait. Who else is bad? I admit I only read the first 5 books.
Gonna be wild when the climate kids discover the unibomber
That already happened a little bit when he died lol. People were memeing abt him
53:50 you can just hear the soul leaving their body realizing they are also describing mainstream media and their own role within.
Trickle down season 2 hype!
multiple Jake freak outs in the first 5 minutes. this is gonna be good
When OBL referenced Ben Franklin, he is in fact referencing a fake quote, concocted in anti immigrant fervor in the 20s, in which Ben Franklin is falsely proported to have advocated a constitutional amendment banning Jewish people entirely from the country. OBL read this quote, assumed it was authentic, and that Ben Franklin genuinely talked like a 1920s antisemite. Ie a comrade, from OBLs perspective.
Wow thank you! I was researching what he could have been talking about. Not weird that I didn’t make a connection between Franklin and a quote from the 1920s because of the 200 years that lapsed between.
The people who are so confused and in existential crisis about the letter are just that one person who got really mad at the bill gates episode.
Dragonheart!
Yass!!! Jake has the same taste in movies as my mom, so I always know what he's talking about. XD or maybe it's a midwestern thing haha
I agree with Travis that JK Rowling is the 2nd worst excuse for a human being in this episode.
I liked it when Liv made a joke and it almost sounded like Travis genuinely laughed.
*he laughed so hard he pulled away from mic
Bill Clinton literally tried shoving a missile up Bin Laden's nose, but getting head at work was a bridge too far!
I find it weird that Travis rightly finds the shock expressed after reading the letter strange - but in the next breath finds it baffling that US politicians don't seem to care about Facebook collecting data but are outraged by Tiktok doing it. I mean... Haven't we known for decades that US political economy exists to perpetuate the wealth of American capital? Hasn't the last few weeks highlighted (for the Nth time in my short lifetime) that upholding "rules based international order" and "liberal values" are applicable arguments only towards the enemies of the US? Found the whiplash pretty intense on this one!
lol… ‘I mean….thats true’
Geezus. This is wild
My thoughts exactly, sir. LOL
Waiting for right wingers to start kneeling for the national anthem.
“I open tiktok to relax” is a take I never expected to hear come out of Travis!
“Is that the right penis??” from Jake, on the other hand—
Oh hell yes
Wow, Jake comes out of the chute like a bull at the rodeo!
My bad for thinking he was getting ads for Bad Dragon the whole time until the end when he actually described it.
Ok hear me out: America by Allen Ginsberg. It has everything: communism, anarchism, history!, its queer, and references print media! I’ve never gotten the hang of TikTok, but I’m sure the kids are all about beat poetry….??
Is this an age thing? I feel like a the majority of the people floored by this letter are young and discovering shit us olds have known a long time.
Just wait until they discover The Unabomber Manifesto: Industrial Society and Its Future
of course these fucking people can only process this via harry potter references
The real existentialism is the fact that there is a lack of critical thinking among some of our younger generations
Go look at the age breakdowns of people who voted Trump vs Biden in 2020.
Aww man, imagine an Epstein pulled Osama Bin Laden
Sick ITYSL reference by Jake in the first 5 minutes
There's gotta be a way for them to monetize this. It's just Tooo good.
This is just another example of how extremist ideology takes root by pointing at a real problem then massively oversimplifying/obscuring its causes to present their wildly destructive worldview as the only solution
Always good to get another episode of the Liv Agar Zoomer Report
Someone take Liv's Tik Tok away..
UwU thank you for your critiques Osama zaddy
Fuck
First
You get a participation award
First
