Premium Episode 235: Gaylor
Taylor Swift is secretly gay — according to a movement born on Tumblr that lurched into QAnon territory. Liv Agar leads us down the rabbithole of this years-long fever dream.
Thanks for being a patreon subscriber!
Liv Agar: http://livagar.com / http://linktr.ee/livagar
Music by DJ DEATH and Roopen.
Comments (142)
i ❤️ ts
What kind of vehicular manslaughter incident do you get in by hitting the brakes "too soon"?
🥂
Wednesday. August 27th, 2025. Gaylor is in shambles.
jake
I didn't listen to this one until now (months after the drop) b/c I could care less about T.S. and know very little about her. But Jake... *gasp* Every damn episode, I find a new reason to adore him.
Re-listened to this because I was missing Liv-ruining-my-entire-life content and I’d completely forgotten abt jake singing at the end. Ngl, it kinda melted my heart. My cold, brittle heart.
Perfect ep for pride month. There are literally actual gay pop singers. Lady Gaga exists. Why do people insist on swift
So glad I don’t know any swifties in real life, these people truly need to be in the asylum
I love the Maroon cover. Would love an mp3 of the whole thing. Lovely guitar playing. I came back a month later to relisten to that bit and comment. It's my favorite song on Midnights.
I would jam out to a song about forgetting all of my passwords.
Jakes buttery warm voice is like an emotional support animal for my ears
I wish he would whisper sweet nothings into my ear when I am having meltdowns in my kitchen.
Look what we made Taylor Swift do
I have to admit…. I don’t care about this subject. When do we return to our regularly scheduled insanity? My head exploded
The point is the delivery, not the topic
It’s entirely based on the dates when Taylor was friends with Carly Klauss (SP) and lyrics possibly written during that time. Carly is since married btw
Surely the Julian/Jake ship name is Fockatansky
She’s a billionaire drama queen, no wonder this happens. Jesus Christ these people are pathetic.
Thank you for concisely putting into words how I have always felt about Taylor Swift. I got drama queen vibes back in 08, and she hasn't really grown up a lot since then. Her recent interview after being declared Time Person of the Year is so goddamn insufferable. She compares herself to Gandalf and Dumbledore, says Reputation is goth (lol my teenage self rolled in the grave with that line), and claims she was "cancelled within an inch of her life" because people sent her snake emojis (nevermind she was still a billionaire who was dating A-listers). It is so insulting because many people live in run down 2-bedroom apartments and don't know how they will make ends meet month to month, but TSwift is such a strong queen for overcoming snake emojis. Give me all the snake emojis if it means my family never has to struggle again. For the record, I am on Taylor's side regarding snakegate, she just wasn't cancelled. It gave me privileged Millennial energy. I don't get why people love her so much. And it's really sad that Julian, who is usually so opinionated, feels he has to censor himself because of her unhinged fans who she often eggs on. I won't even get started on her impact on the environment by insisting on taking a private jet home after every concert.
I just accidentally introduced my 10 year old to Reddit by telling her about this episode. Someone call CPS.
Ellen permanently exists in a CRT television in a big black and gold entertainment center in my parents living room
Confirmed: Q is a gaylor
oh hell yeah Jake’s Taylor cover
When will people realize people like Taylor Swift are not actually real people. Sure they exist but they are just a product to be bought and sold and thrown away. Just like every other celebrity
hell yeah jake for that outro 💫
As a Swiftie that does think she’s a little bi, I loved this. I really loved that Julian’s OTTW bridge was closer to the OG.
I’m waiting for the one direction / John lock style apocalypse. Don’t get vibes from her at all. More like she’s an awkward weirdo and never has a chance to meet normal weird people.
I love you guys, respectfully and not weird
Sometimes I would question Jake's musical bones, but never again.
Liv please do an episode on larries (Louis Tomlinson x harry styles) literally one of the OG gay conspiracy fandom pls pls pls im on my knees
I forgive you for every single shitty, traumatizing autoQ for that Maroon cover.
Can you guys do an episode on Jaime Kennedy? He’s absolutely lost whatever plot he had.
The sad thing is... Swift is actually capable of writing a good song (lyrics too) when she puts her mind to it. But if she limited herself to just that, there would be way less product.
Absolutely deranged. Love it.
Holy shit. Haven’t laughed that hard at a show in a while. Thanks y’all
🎵“3 + 2 is Trump!”🎵 made me laugh in the ugliest way in public. I love you all so much, cum jokes and all.
Had to become a patreon member just to listen to this episode. I like TSwift music fine and I'm an incredibly boring bisexual woman in a relationship with a man and I do not for the life of me understand the gaylor theories. Nobody exudes more straight energy than TSwift.
Is it because she moved in with a VS model?
I think Julian just figured out away to get around being bleeped during his violent rants.
I wonder if TTB’s loved ones knew about her fixation and had a sit-down conversation
What am I even paying for if y'all can't even make a "Bake it Off" joke?
Omg what a tender cover of Maroon!!! Love it
1. I want a full “Maroon” cover available for download. 2. I don’t know many Taylor songs so all day I kept thinking “this makes no sense, why did Jake end this episode with this lovely random song he made up”
Jake picking the gayest Taylor swift song for the outro. Gaylor confirmed
My boss made Taylor Swift cry once before she was famous. She offered him an autograph and he refused. This, is not that.
Thank you. She looks like the kind of person who would cry after having unsuccessfully offered an autograph/a feeder mouse.
JAKES VERSION 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
As someone who went down the Gaylor rabbithole, there is a LOT of weird stuff out that makes me think Swift is bisexual. That said, many Gaylors are absolutely insane and very QAnon-like. They form this weird parasocial connection that can only be valid if Taylor swift is gay and all her boyfriends are fake.
When Taylor released 1989 Taylor's Version, she included a prologue with a statement about how she got tired of being accused of dating any man she was seen with. So she opted to only hang out with her female friends "because they couldn't possibly sexualize those relationships" only to find out "they could and they would." Which, IMO is the strongest refutation of the Gaylor rumors I've seen her make. And it also set off a Gaylor meltdown so huge that it bled over into the casual Swiftie space (which is how I learned about the whole Gaylor movement). These people still persist in their beliefs, and will twist reality in any way to prove themselves right. Sounds shockingly familiar.
The 1989 prologue is definitely an indirect refutation. The stuff that still doesn't sit right with me is her constant usage of LGBTQ imagery in music videos/tours/Instagram posts. She's gotta be the only straight girl who constantly posts the bisexual pride flag and wears it.
To think 20-30 years ago, stuff of this nature was just rumors and gossip and now it’s a fully baked and evolving system of bad myth making.
It's called a 'publationship' when two celebrities are in a relationship for PR. The more you know...
Did none of the boys understand Liv's "I heart TS" bit, they should be online more
I need Jake’s song, “Maroon” to drop on Spotify NOW! 😂
My brain is in pain at the Spade stuff. Like #orangemuffin levels of broke. Great ep.
DROP THE WHOLE TRACK
I kissed a girl and I liked it. SO gay.
Jake singing at the end? ❤️
Daw! So tender and vulnerable
Cancelled you need swiftie representation. I'm making a tiktok rn
THIS is the content I subscribe for lolol
Jalien fandom VINDICATED. Tralien heads IN SHAMBLES
I don't think my brain retained any of that.
(chuckle) I hope my brain did not
Damn it. Now I know this.
Lol, some days I feel like that's the unofficial motto of the whole podcast
Can Liv’s next episode be about the Kpop fans that think Jungkook is Princess Diana
What the fuck
Make the background music stop please oh ok it did
25:00, I died. glad that stupid jokes like that still land
It's a fairly obscure term but "89" actually means "Heil Ilyich" and it's Taylor's subtle way of signaling to other tankies.
as someone who grew up on tumblr in this era the idea of an anon with an emoji sign off was pretty common just because at that time there was a much bigger gap between BNFs and smaller bloggers and sending an ask off anon could lead to harassment if the BNF responded poorly (plus i think people just liked the intrigue of a secret admirer with a signature sign off). another thing about tumblr is that you can send asks to yourself on and off anon, so TTB wouldn’t have even needed a second account to send those asks & it would have been trivially easy to fake them. as for not having a guarantee they were all the same person this is true now but iirc in the very olden days of tumblr you could get anons’ ip addresses or could figure out their identity by blocking them from the ask box and then checking your blocked blogs, but these in particular might be old tumblrina’s tales since both the user base and site runners like lying about how anything on the internal side of tumblr works
The funniest part of this to me is that when they mentioned gaylor antisemitism I immediately thought of a completely separate prominent case that I actually can’t believe they didn’t include at least a little. A couple years ago a prominent gaylor blogger was outed as a Mormon girl from utah who had been pretending to be from a New York Jewish family in all her personal posts 😭 constantly posting about “my Jewish mother is begging me to date a Kushner she’s offered to give me Josh’s phone number so many times” etc for YEARS and just constantly posting about Jewish stereotypes in an “it’s okay I can make these jokes I’m Jewish” kind of way when she was fully mormon and not even from New York the entire time
this is so tumblr energy holy shit 😭😭
okay who wants a “Listener until never, may the Taylor(Gaylor?) Swift bless you and shake it off” mug?
so glad I persisted through Julian’s negativity for Jake’s beautiful Maroon cover ❤️ (I would also like to hear Jake remix Taylor Swift and Weezer, Pink Triangle perhaps?
Jake and Julian's couple name should be "Juke."
I would love an ep of Liv explaining Wendy Williams to the rest of the crew. I don't have a conspiracy/qanon angle on it, I just think "clap for someone always watching" is such a low level of Wendy derangement
Lol I agree. And I’m pretty sure there were conspiracy theories around Wendy’s health, and when she like fainted on the show??
https://img.gifglobe.com/grabs/brentcloud/S01E04/gif/t5umxK8Tca76.gif
Ahhh! The algorithm strikes again! I just listened to the episode and the second video on my Facebook feed this morning (after listening) was of T-Swift sitting court side with some girl. This is despite me not listening to a single Swift song since “You Belong to Me” when it played nonstop on the radio and I was forced to listen as a school bus passenger.
This is the crossover of two of my favorite things that I never expected to ever happen.
Joshua Tree hat mentioned 🥳
Wait why was the Maroon cover kinda good ..
Ps: I read the title as "gaylord" at first. For a moment I was brought back to 2004 chans. Weird times.
It can always get stranger. The "transvestigators" are weirder than the "gaylors". Always can count on right wingers to take headcannons to the extreme.
This might be my favorite episode.
I’ve been a Swiftie for a long time and could never fully put my finger on why the gaylor thing made me uncomfy, but this is definitely why. It’s the baking, the belief she’s sending them secret messages, that people are forcing her to stay closeted, etc. And yeah, Taylor loves to leave little clues around…but it’s pretty much exclusively related to things like album release dates, new singles, music videos. She’s not out there leaving bread crumbs for us to follow about her personal life. So yeah, the gaylor stuff has always been weird to me. But I had no idea how wild some of these theories actually are. Yikes.
what the fuck did i just listen to
I’m now a Gaylor
When the crew makes an enjoyable episode out of an interesting topic, I'm happy. When they make an enjoyable episode out of a shallow, vapid, pointless topic like this one, I'm impressed. Anybody can make something out of something worthwhile. It takes real talent to make something out of nothing.
"because you'd be eating so much of my cum?" Thanks dickheads, I drove off the road laughing
OK, this really bad clit lit.
I've never laughed so hard at an auto Q drop
This does seem a lot like the Johnlock episode in that both the Sherlock producers/writers and TS offer their fans some sort of engagement through clues/easter eggs. They can't be surprised that fans will take them in "unsanctioned" directions. The difference being the character of "Sherlock" is entirely fictional while the character of "TSwift" has a real person behind it.
I propose a new Patreon tier that grants access to Jake's unsanctioned acoustic TS cover album
1989 (Juliake’s Version)
never thought this day would come
the warmth of relief flooding my body when Liv tells Jakey we do NOT stan Joe Jonas in this house
Jake song 🫶
i love that y’all posted this episode as i’m on my flight back home from the eras tour
You flew to a Taylor Swift show?
Love how their song just ended up being a dashboard confessional joint lmao
Like qanon's inception, if only these poor souls were just taught it's ok enjoy dumb stuff and it's ok to to move on to new stuff if the old stuff ain't working no more, perhaps their panicked neurones would find solace and stimulation in greener pastures instead of being wasted threading these self-soothing spirals around their insecurities.
I’ve just had Covid TWICE in a month. Twice. Covid can get in the bin! Hope you’re both feeling better soon.
i can’t believe y’all covered this. THIS IS MY ROMAN EMPIRE
i knew you guys would do this one day
the rumor come out: does taylor swift is gay?
An important note is that the Ides of March is a big tumblr holiday, but also, I’ve absolutely been waiting for this episode because I’ve noticed the similarities between gaylors (ESPECIALLY that blogger) and Qanon.
Jake that was beautiful ♥️
seeing these comments in the first half of the ep - i wasn’t ready
I’m only 1/4 of the way thru and this is already the best QAA episode of all time
Wow beautiful song Jake
Liv-ing for this, as always
i love being a swiftie and i love qaa, full maroon cover when
Who sang that Maroon cover ?? That was lovely and I wanted it to keep going! They really adapted the lyrics to fit the acoustic form
I love the return of the Q voice
Just came down with covid as well, this blows way harder this time too. 102 fever for a few hours that made me writhe in my bed from hot to cold.
This is exactly how I described the first 24 hours of this, my second round of covid was. I was so so so miserable. Feel better soon. ❤️
The best is yet to come is a thing people say in church. Kind of a reminder to keep faith
The coded love song to Travis at the end was delightful. ❤️🩹
You misspelled Teddy!
A rare swing and a miss
I'm a man with a basically exclusively lesbian group of friends (idk why), and I have been shocked by how widespread Gaylor belief is. One of my friends said *most* of the women she'd dated were believers in this theory.
The Kimmel/Fallon confusion continues...
I appreciate their commitment to the bit.
OMG Travis Kelce is also secretly gay!! They're perfect for one another!
Style is a Taylor Swift song smh read the lore
"This one is gonna be an unhinged one".. As opposed to all other episodes..
yes i have been waiting for this topic for years!! qanon for white millenial queer women (me)
as a lite gaylor myself,,, not sure if i should be worried 🫣 but i’ve seen A LOT of this content and, having researched hydroxychloroquine extremism for nearly 4 years now, can confidently say that, like all ~theories~ there is an iceberg meme, from pretty reasonable to earths core rabbit hole. lookin forward to this ep!
I don't like that they focused on TTB and hardcore Gaylors. There's a bunch of other more interesting content that isn't full blown Q posting lol
Fully was on board w this for years after encountering the gaylor master post in 2017. Not anymore but it remains a very fun time in my life
holy shit. i was thinking about travis’ episode about sherlock fandom and how crazy it would be if the show covered gaylor just yesterday. i’m so excited!
god, i was not disappointed by the boys’ reactions to the kushner and mueller report connection. we live in the stupidest timeline.
I wish all could have heard the groan I made reading the episode description
if everyone is allowed one conspiracy theory, this is mine
just one, as a little treat
Perfect timing! Just finished the last one.
First
😄 but it takes longer for the podcast to reach me here in sweden
