Episode 246: Age of Doppelgangers feat Naomi Klein
Naomi Klein, author of The Shock Doctrine and the upcoming Doppelganger: A Trip Into Mirror World, joins us to talk about QAnon, "diagonalist politics", and why people keep confusing her with Naomi Wolf online.
Thanks for being a QAA subscriber!
Naomi Klein: https://twitter.com/NaomiAKlein / https://linktr.ee/naomiklein
Music by Pontus Berghe. Editing by Corey Klotz.
Comments (59)
Actually, if you're explaining the concept of "Querdenker" you need to basically also explain that it's connected to the term "Querfront" which historically describes a "red brown" type deal. Conscious or not, they were basically calling themselves "Beefsteak Nazis"
Calling it CPC style electronic surveillance is the classic racist american thing of pointing at a specific american phenomena that was invented and pioneered in america and saying "What are we? A bunch of Asians?"
Ty guys for this engaging chat with Naomi Klein & turning me on to her new book, which is fascinating. Highly recommend everyone give it a read - it's a fresh perspective I think we all need right now.
Rotigenous? Can somebody help me out? Google is not helping me with this one...
I missed that one. Do you have a context or timing?
I related *so* hard to "we're not depressed, we just have bad posture".
Loved this convo and planning on re-listening. I first encountered Naomi Wolf as a teenager hanging out in bookstores and could not understand her appeal or reputation at the time— such superficial analysis and so much navel gazing and personal anecdotes. But I am still baffled by all the people mistaking Naomi Klein for Wolf… how do these people grocery shop???
This is one of my favourite episodes. I actually started out as a Christian conspiracist in 2003/4. Back then I considered myself a lefty. I read the Bible, read about communism, and saw communism in the NT. Watching conspiracism shift from left to right to left to right, depending on the issue and who is in charge is fascinating.
Writers have an ability to see the uncomfortable and coax it out.
I wonder if the "haven't you heard of cellphones" response is because we were/are absolutely flabbergasted by those we thought were intelligent friends, family, neighbors, etc. suddenly getting upset about surveillance but in the wackiest way possible. We're pointing out, yeah, they are surveilling us and we've been complaining about it for years. The surveillance is mundane and ubiquitous (and it's still bad). The real story is just more boring than "vaccine microchips" (or whatever) so they didn't listen or care... so how DO we get people to care about the ACTUAL issues we all face and not the clown world fantasy mirror versions? Heck just a few days ago I heard someone talk about "Geoengineering" but I know they didn't mean Climate Change. We're both upset about the rise in extreme weather. But they subscribe to the clown world fantasy mirror version of the issue with no real solution. I'd suggest cutting back carbon emissions and they'd suggest arresting Bill Gates. There isn't really any common ground to be had and maybe that was the whole point of this co-option campaign by the right.
I've been saying this for years. At this point is it any wonder smart people are black pilled? The right has become a cult and no one seems to have any real answers on how you successfully deprogram people from a cult. Every podcast, this one included goes on an on about identifying the problem but has zero answers for how to actually address the problem. Personally I think it will just end in war. If a man sits on a stone with a blind fold on and his fingers in his ears screaming "THE SKY IS PURPLE!" the only way I can see to get him to stop is to hit him.
Recently was looking through my Kindle and did a double take that I had books by that “Naomi.” Turns out I made the exact mistake she talks about, and had just gotten them mixed up lol
I just found out that Naomi Wolfe is pilled in this podcast…i never would have believed it…the good news is I’ve discovered her doppelgänger, Naomi Klein lol
So happy Naomi wanted to join the show, she's a real treasure ☺️🌹
This episode was so unbelievably bad and misguided that I don't think I can continue subscribing. This is sad because you've been some of the only voices I've had of sane neutrality. The view that Sanders was our whole savior in the face of Biden in our current whole situation is short sited and doomerist to the point that you are feeding the narrative which serves a second trump term and worse. This episode disregards the huge wins that Biden has secured and shows that your view of complex geopolitical situations is extremely simple minded and that you are more interested in clicks than in research.
*sighted
Anyone familiar with Zozobra fest in Santa Fe? Coincidentally that is what burning man was based on. Zozobra fest involves burning a giant effigy called Old Man Gloom.
She really wraps up all the things QAA discusses nicely. Top 5 ep for sure
Awesome episode. Had to order Naomi’s book after this one. Fascinating.
omg excited for this. I really wouldn’t have thought *Naomi* was that uncommon a name before all this, but that’s something a Siobhan would say
dying to see Q reality Julian threatening to k-word Q reality Jake and then they both collapse in hysterical giggles 🥺
I'm a little disappointed that the "Cambridge analytica, Russians hypnotized voters with twitter" narrative is still being used without much push back after the great Anthony Mansuy episodes of QAA.
I take your point and I also really enjoyed the Cambridge Analytica eps which brilliantly deflated the boogeyman that CA represented to many. However, in context here, where Klein is talking about the scarier side of data collection writ large (grocery store loyalty cards, online quizzes, face altering apps) that are not thought of in such sinister framing, perhaps we can be more charitable. To be sure the Mercers et al. are awful and it would be naïve to entrust them with peoples’ personal data. Like the Trump Russia stuff in general, it’s dumb to think of it as an *ESPIONAGE* issue and better to think of it as a technological trap that we’re all slipping into, most without even realizing it! But…like you I definitely noticed when she said that and I pictured Julian (who I suspect might agree more with you) kind of twitching involuntarily at the mention of CA. Lol
Okay, I have to be THAT PERSON, but you’re just flat wrong that Bernie was ‘stabbed in the back’ by us icky Hillary-wine moms. Bernie lost because he entirely and utterly failed with Black people. Black women are the best and most loyal progressives and Bernie just completely shat on them and they rejected him. To his credit he recognized this and quickly conceded, which he didn’t do for the Wine Mom in 2016. If you want coalitions you need to be at least a little conciliatory to those of us who don’t like your favorite candidate.
disagree 🤷♂️
I love it how when everyone denies being black-pilled, Travis stays silent.
It's hilarious he had "she gets confused with Naomi Wolf" in the description, that's exactly what I did when I read the episode title.
incredible ep - often I’ll talk to people about conspiracy theories as starting off from a reasonable concern but flying off into the la-la land of antisemitism, etc. But I feel like you all gave a couple different, excellent ways of talking about it. And as someone currently invested in The Authoritarian Personality, the idea of doppelgängers as an evil force from within was perfect timing. Great work y’all 💖
I can hardly wait. For anyone interested in the type of "capitalism" the world practices today, Shock Doctrine is compulsory reading.
This was such a great episode I’m going to get my non-qaa-listening spouse to listen to it!
I struggle with this same creeping feeling. I probably have more in common with a convoy protestor than I do with a wealthy blue wave dem. I've been funneled into the online left because of my stance on social issues but sometimes I feel like we're satisfied with a snarky brand of performative obedience. The "wait until they find out about cell phones" meme is a good example. Even though I don't agree with the right on many things, sometimes I feel like they have more fight left in them than we do.
might be worth considering that the right wing is way over represented in media. not just main stream media, but also a lot of podcasts hyper focus on the dumb shit the right it doing there are a lot of people out there fighting for all kinds of left wing goals. Like against cop city, chico school board counter protests, abortion saftey volunteers, local weekly food and pantry events or even Elm Fork John Brown Gun Club and similar groups doing protection for events there nazis say theyre going to show up. it can be disheartening and blue wave dems suck want to diminish left wing protesting so it isn't very well covered. but it is out there!
Was so geeked to see this in my notifications - love Klein! Awesome episode that re-kindled just a little bit of that cautious hope from 2020. The doppelgänger concept posited here sure made me feel a lot less insane! Thanks guys!
This episode is fanfuckingtastic, I kept finding myself standing still, listening, and then when it was finished I immediately replayed it. And all this semiotics stuff was flooding back into my head and i was riding this despair/hopefulness speedball— consider me rallied!
brilliant crux-finder episode!
This was a great listen. Idk how this is the same podcast as "buckets of Bigfoot cum" but I'm glad to be along for the ride 🫡
Wow. This episode was really strong. Great guest and each host brought their specific perspective/strengths. Only thing missing: a little bit of Liv...
Liv luv ❤️
wish she didn't claim to care about poor, working, and oppressed people while talking about the pandemic in the past tense.
get a new bit
So, the core issue here is search algorithms, yes? These two are clearly the first- and second-most popular/notable “Naomi”s, yes?
And, yes, that’s basically it. Here are the current Naomi autocompletes from Google: Naomi Campbell (model), Naomi Osaka (Japanese tennis player), Naomi Watts (British actress), Naomi Girma (US soccer player), Naomi Klein (Canadian writer and social activist), Naomi Judd (American singer), Naomi Wolf (no qualifier). Looking forward to a book called “I, Naomi” about how the robots confused you with a “doppelgänger”.
On the left? She means liberalism though, right? Like she's absolutely not talking about real left opposition to capitalism.
That was my only real qualm about this. I’m sort of for “liberal-left” unity on some issues, but the two are very different.
I have not Amen’d any podcast ep so much in a long time. A highlight was when all 3 hosts immediately and earnestly protested when Naomi suggested she was depressing them. Really looking forward to reading her book! Way to turn the Wolf issue into a win Naomi
Y’all were spitting straight hot fire on this one 🔥
I read No Logo in the early 00's, (because of the "No Logo" logo in Kid A). It put so many things in perspective and I loved it, made me seek out more of her stuff and became a fan of her work. Flash forward a few years and I'm staring at my phone, wondering why Naomi is going nuts om Twitter...
So good! I've been a proponent of Naomi Klein's work for at least 15 years. She was a great conversation partner here. Thank you!
I love Naomi Klein!
Looking forward to listening to this. I've got the book on hold at my local library
Dang it’s not even listed on my library’s catalog yet!
Big get. Nice!
I got a doppleganger who writes gay erotica who is screwing up my SEO, I feel for Klein.
👎
Just wanna say I am getting very annoyed by the huge numbers of Sound of Freedom bus ads in East London right now.
OMG thanks for not making me feel lonely on this
Fangirling so hard over Naomi Klein right now!!!!!!
Needs more Brace.
no we don't
